What do you think?
Rate this book
True Colors #2
The Pink Bonnet
A Desperate Mother Searches for Her Child
Step into True Colors -- a new series of Historical Stories of Romance and American Crime
Widowed in Memphis during 1932, Cecile Dowd is struggling to provide for her three-year-old daughter. Unwittingly trusting a neighbor puts little Millie Mae into the clutches of Georgia Tann, corrupt Memphis Tennessee Children’s Home Society director suspected of the disappearance of hundreds of children. With the help of a sympathetic lawyer, the search for Millie uncovers a deep level of corruption that threatens their very lives.
How far will a mother go to find out what happened to her child?
Step into True Colors -- a new series of Historical Stories of Romance and American Crime
Widowed in Memphis during 1932, Cecile Dowd is struggling to provide for her three-year-old daughter. Unwittingly trusting a neighbor puts little Millie Mae into the clutches of Georgia Tann, corrupt Memphis Tennessee Children’s Home Society director suspected of the disappearance of hundreds of children. With the help of a sympathetic lawyer, the search for Millie uncovers a deep level of corruption that threatens their very lives.
How far will a mother go to find out what happened to her child?
256 pages, Paperback
First published June 1, 2019
32 people are currently reading
3672 people want to read
About the author
Liz Tolsma
41 books1,779 followersLiz Tolsma is the author of several WWII novels, romantic suspense novels, prairie romance novellas, and an Amish romance. She is a popular speaker and an editor and resides next to a Wisconsin farm field with her husband and their youngest daughter. Her son is a U.S. Marine, and her oldest daughter is a recent college graduate. Liz enjoys reading, walking, working in her large perennial garden, kayaking, and camping. Please visit her website at www.liztolsma.com and follow her on Facebook, Twitter (@LizTolsma), Instagram, YouTube, and Pinterest. She is also the host of the Christian Historical Fiction Talk podcast.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 29 of 300 reviews
April 16, 2019
This is the second in a series of historical romance/mystery books, with the first one I read being The White City. The Pink Bonnet is set in the time of The Depression 1932 and centers on a young widow Cecile and her three-year-old Millie Mae. Struggling to support them, Cecile leaves Millie with a neighbor while she looks for full-time employment, but when she returns to pick her up Millie is gone. She’s been taken to the Tennessee Children’s Home Society as some part of an adoption situation. When Cecile goes down to their office, she’s told she’s not a fit mother to raise her child, and that besides, she has already signed her rights away. Knowing this isn’t true, Cecile swears to get Millie back from them, no matter what it takes. Miss Tann tries to convince her that Millie is far better off, that she will be placed with a family that can provide the best of everything. Cecile, who has already lost her husband, screams at her that it’s her daughter and she’s not losing her too, and a mother’s love matters.
This is a good story for those who like reading about historical American crime stories. Follow the story as Cecile fights an increasingly difficult and nasty battle to find and regain her daughter. This is in the mystery romance and the Christian categories, but it’s not that heavy on the religion angle. I don’t recall it even coming in until about nearly halfway, too. So if that bothers you, it’s not that overwhelming. I found it surprisingly enjoyable, and I don’t go out of my way for Christian books, I’m more of a true crime fan on its own. I was fine with it. It was worth it to learn about this Tann woman who was scamming people, along with a judge and a politician, who were all involved in helping Tann cover up the adoptions for selling children to the highest bidder for thousands of children back then. It was an outrage that should never have been allowed to happen, but many were corrupt back then, or willing to turn a blind eye. Advance electronic review copy was provided by NetGalley, author Liz Tolsma, and the publisher.
My BookZone blog:
https://wordpress.com/post/bookblog20...
This is a good story for those who like reading about historical American crime stories. Follow the story as Cecile fights an increasingly difficult and nasty battle to find and regain her daughter. This is in the mystery romance and the Christian categories, but it’s not that heavy on the religion angle. I don’t recall it even coming in until about nearly halfway, too. So if that bothers you, it’s not that overwhelming. I found it surprisingly enjoyable, and I don’t go out of my way for Christian books, I’m more of a true crime fan on its own. I was fine with it. It was worth it to learn about this Tann woman who was scamming people, along with a judge and a politician, who were all involved in helping Tann cover up the adoptions for selling children to the highest bidder for thousands of children back then. It was an outrage that should never have been allowed to happen, but many were corrupt back then, or willing to turn a blind eye. Advance electronic review copy was provided by NetGalley, author Liz Tolsma, and the publisher.
My BookZone blog:
https://wordpress.com/post/bookblog20...
June 18, 2019
I wanted to push three stars. but as I sat here trying to think of why I liked it . . . I found few reasons somehow?
Don't get me wrong - it was a good book, as far as content goes. There wasn't really anything that should cause a lower rating. Except for the fact that I just . . . didn't really like it. I wanted to. I tried. But sometimes there's just those books that you can't like. This was one of them.
First of all, it never really caught my interest. But of course, being a review copy, I had to finish it. so I did. Am I glad I did? I guess. I wanted to know how it would all play out. The ending was suspenseful.
But that's pretty much the only thing that somewhat hooked me.
The whole book seemed to be about telling instead of showing.
Let's talk about the characters, shall we?
-Miss Tann. Oh boy. That woman made me so mad. Which, of course, was the intent, in which case, the author completely succeeded. She was a heartless villain. *shudders*
-Cecile Dowd. A loving mother. Stubborn. But her stubbornness made perfect sense. I mean, her baby was stolen, so of course she was going to be a mama bear and get her little girl back in any way possible. But there were like . . . no emotions. I mean, yeah, there was a boatload of tears, but they were all in the book, and not on my face. None of Cecile's tears pulled on my heartstrings. I might just be heartless, buuuuut I felt like all the emotions in this book were sorely lacking.
-Percy Vance. He was good. I liked him. But that's about it. It seemed like none of the characters really had any depth, or development. They cried. They fought. They got mad. They were all stubborn.
-R.D. Griggs. I was so confused by this guy. I was never really sure of his exact role . . . but maybe I just wasn't paying much attention.
-Millie. The only character I fell in love with. She was sooooo adorable!! I could envision her saying everything exactly the way a 3-yr-old would. Kudos to Ms. Liz for that!
Some of the elements in the story confused me. Like, there were some things that just seemed thrown in randomly. Like Griggs and Vance having grown up together? Um, that would've been something we should've been told before 3/4 of the way through the book. And Percy has a drawl? I guess that makes sense since they live in TN, but he was the only character mentioned to have an accent, and only THEN towards the end of the book.
The spiritual content was lacking. I mean, yeah, they prayed, but in between prayers, I forgot that they were even Christians. It wasn't because they were awful people, but simply because God didn't seem to be anything other than Someone to pray to when they needed help. The ending really made more mentions of God, though, so I was glad for that. And Mrs. Dowd's dialogue about heaven . . . um yesssss please! <3 <3
So lastly . . . the romance. It seemed so . . . so . . . disjointed? Well okay, the whole book seemed kinda disjointed. BUT the romance seemed just THROWN IN. Everything was either heat or electricity. "Her temperature rose at his words." "She touched his hand, and a spark passed between them." "Her leg rubbed against his, setting his limb on fire." Now, I'll admit, it wasn't nearly as heavy as it could've been, save for 2 (or maybe 3?) kisses, for which I was thankful. But AFTER HE'S KISSED HER and SAID 'I LOVE YOU', she's convinced that he doesn't really care that much. For which I wanted to knock her head. Kind of.
So, yeah. The book wasn't awful. I guess I kinda made it sound awful, but it wasn't. I just somehow couldn't bring myself to enjoy it.
I received a free e-copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review.
Don't get me wrong - it was a good book, as far as content goes. There wasn't really anything that should cause a lower rating. Except for the fact that I just . . . didn't really like it. I wanted to. I tried. But sometimes there's just those books that you can't like. This was one of them.
First of all, it never really caught my interest. But of course, being a review copy, I had to finish it. so I did. Am I glad I did? I guess. I wanted to know how it would all play out. The ending was suspenseful.
But that's pretty much the only thing that somewhat hooked me.
The whole book seemed to be about telling instead of showing.
Let's talk about the characters, shall we?
-Miss Tann. Oh boy. That woman made me so mad. Which, of course, was the intent, in which case, the author completely succeeded. She was a heartless villain. *shudders*
-Cecile Dowd. A loving mother. Stubborn. But her stubbornness made perfect sense. I mean, her baby was stolen, so of course she was going to be a mama bear and get her little girl back in any way possible. But there were like . . . no emotions. I mean, yeah, there was a boatload of tears, but they were all in the book, and not on my face. None of Cecile's tears pulled on my heartstrings. I might just be heartless, buuuuut I felt like all the emotions in this book were sorely lacking.
-Percy Vance. He was good. I liked him. But that's about it. It seemed like none of the characters really had any depth, or development. They cried. They fought. They got mad. They were all stubborn.
-R.D. Griggs. I was so confused by this guy. I was never really sure of his exact role . . . but maybe I just wasn't paying much attention.
-Millie. The only character I fell in love with. She was sooooo adorable!! I could envision her saying everything exactly the way a 3-yr-old would. Kudos to Ms. Liz for that!
Some of the elements in the story confused me. Like, there were some things that just seemed thrown in randomly. Like Griggs and Vance having grown up together? Um, that would've been something we should've been told before 3/4 of the way through the book. And Percy has a drawl? I guess that makes sense since they live in TN, but he was the only character mentioned to have an accent, and only THEN towards the end of the book.
The spiritual content was lacking. I mean, yeah, they prayed, but in between prayers, I forgot that they were even Christians. It wasn't because they were awful people, but simply because God didn't seem to be anything other than Someone to pray to when they needed help. The ending really made more mentions of God, though, so I was glad for that. And Mrs. Dowd's dialogue about heaven . . . um yesssss please! <3 <3
So lastly . . . the romance. It seemed so . . . so . . . disjointed? Well okay, the whole book seemed kinda disjointed. BUT the romance seemed just THROWN IN. Everything was either heat or electricity. "Her temperature rose at his words." "She touched his hand, and a spark passed between them." "Her leg rubbed against his, setting his limb on fire." Now, I'll admit, it wasn't nearly as heavy as it could've been, save for 2 (or maybe 3?) kisses, for which I was thankful. But AFTER HE'S KISSED HER and SAID 'I LOVE YOU', she's convinced that he doesn't really care that much. For which I wanted to knock her head. Kind of.
So, yeah. The book wasn't awful. I guess I kinda made it sound awful, but it wasn't. I just somehow couldn't bring myself to enjoy it.
I received a free e-copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review.
May 12, 2019
I love the premise of this series in basing stories upon true crimes. The Pink Bonnet is the second one in the series. I was previously exposed to the crimes of Georgia Tann through a novel by Lisa Wingate. Simply horrendous what happened to children and families at the hands of one woman over decades. While the crime itself is fascinating, I found some details of the fictional story line to not be fully plausible. Overall, it was a good novel and I look forward to the next in the series.
My gratitude to publisher Barbour for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and the opinions expressed are my own.
My gratitude to publisher Barbour for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and the opinions expressed are my own.
May 28, 2020
Settle in for a good emotional read!
This story was an incredible, amazing tale of a mother’s unrelenting love. Following Cecile’s journey was gut-wrenching at times, but there was always hope that she would succeed in rescuing her daughter from the grips of Georgia Tann.
Fans of Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate will adore this book. In fact, these two books would be a great pairing for book clubs, gifts, or just to enjoy on your own.
FTC Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley, but I also listened to the audio copy via the library. This review is my honest opinion.
This story was an incredible, amazing tale of a mother’s unrelenting love. Following Cecile’s journey was gut-wrenching at times, but there was always hope that she would succeed in rescuing her daughter from the grips of Georgia Tann.
Fans of Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate will adore this book. In fact, these two books would be a great pairing for book clubs, gifts, or just to enjoy on your own.
FTC Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley, but I also listened to the audio copy via the library. This review is my honest opinion.
July 11, 2019
What an incredible roller coaster ride this book was!
This book is part of a series Barbour Books has out called True Colors: Historical Stories of American Crime. All the stories are based on true crimes that have happened in the past.
Like I just said this book was a wild ride, it took my emotions all over the place.
A young mother down on her luck after her husband's death in the early 1930's may not have had a lot of money but she was rich on love for her daughter, her only child.
A busy body neighbor thinks the right thing to do is give the child to Memphis Tennessee Children’s Home Society director,Georgia Tann. She ran this place from 1924 to 1950.
She wasn't in it to help the children but to make money by kidnapping innocent children from loving homes and selling them. My mother's heart can not understand why. The pain you would inflict on the families with the children never being seen by them again and never knowing what happened. All I can say is this woman must have been horribly mistreated as a child to have no compassion or care what her actions caused.
I was riveted while reading this fast paced book, it was very hard to put down. I will be doing some research of my own into this subject online as it is fascinating!
I highly recommend this book!
Published June 1st 2019 by Barbour Books.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
This book is part of a series Barbour Books has out called True Colors: Historical Stories of American Crime. All the stories are based on true crimes that have happened in the past.
Like I just said this book was a wild ride, it took my emotions all over the place.
A young mother down on her luck after her husband's death in the early 1930's may not have had a lot of money but she was rich on love for her daughter, her only child.
A busy body neighbor thinks the right thing to do is give the child to Memphis Tennessee Children’s Home Society director,Georgia Tann. She ran this place from 1924 to 1950.
She wasn't in it to help the children but to make money by kidnapping innocent children from loving homes and selling them. My mother's heart can not understand why. The pain you would inflict on the families with the children never being seen by them again and never knowing what happened. All I can say is this woman must have been horribly mistreated as a child to have no compassion or care what her actions caused.
I was riveted while reading this fast paced book, it was very hard to put down. I will be doing some research of my own into this subject online as it is fascinating!
I highly recommend this book!
Published June 1st 2019 by Barbour Books.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
June 21, 2019
Cecile Dowd is a single mother, just trying to keep life together in 1933 for her and her three year old daughter Millie. Cecile is a widow and it's the great depression. Without her husband, it's difficult to always control Millie's behavior and make sure there is enough food on the table. Cecile decides she needs to get another job to help make things easier. While she goes out looking, she leaves Millie with a neighbor. When she returns to pick up Millie at the end of the day, Millie is gone. The neighbor says, that Cecile can't handle the child and has given her to someone who can help, Georgia Tann the head of the Tennessee Children's Home. They "help" parents find loving families for their children. But Cecile didn't ask for this and neither did a lot of other parents. Ms. Tann is taking children from parents she deems unfit and sending them to other families in the area. Ms. Tann has most of the Tennessee government in her back pocket and no matter who Cecile goes to for help, it's to no avail. Will she be able to find Millie before she's gone forever? With people trying to stop her at every turn, Cecile is determined, no matter what the cost.
Thank you to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for the opportunity to read and review this book.
This book is based on a true story. Georgia Tann was a real woman who really ran an adoption agency in Tennessee for over 25 years. During her tenure, it is believed that approximately 5,000 children were taken unwillingly from their parents and sold in adoptions to whoever would pay the highest price.
This book hit my heart hard. I can't imagine what I would do, if I left my child with a friend or neighbor for a little bit and then when I came back they had forged my name on documents to allow my child to be taken for adoption. Or if they were just snatched from the street on their way home from school. This was happening to hundreds of families during the depression. People were doing anything they could to make ends meet, but for Georgia Tann that didn't matter. One parent should be with the child at all times. That is the only way to show that you really love and are able to take care of the child.
I would love to read more about this lady. I hope there was a warm seat in hell waiting for her and all her cohorts when she passed away. Throughout the story, you can feel the love for Millie that Cecile has and she risks her life and the lives of those that are helping her in order to get to her daughter. No matter what she does, though it never seems like enough, Millie is always just beyond her grasp.
If you like historical, true crime fiction, you will enjoy this book.
Thank you to NetGalley and Barbour Publishing for the opportunity to read and review this book.
This book is based on a true story. Georgia Tann was a real woman who really ran an adoption agency in Tennessee for over 25 years. During her tenure, it is believed that approximately 5,000 children were taken unwillingly from their parents and sold in adoptions to whoever would pay the highest price.
This book hit my heart hard. I can't imagine what I would do, if I left my child with a friend or neighbor for a little bit and then when I came back they had forged my name on documents to allow my child to be taken for adoption. Or if they were just snatched from the street on their way home from school. This was happening to hundreds of families during the depression. People were doing anything they could to make ends meet, but for Georgia Tann that didn't matter. One parent should be with the child at all times. That is the only way to show that you really love and are able to take care of the child.
I would love to read more about this lady. I hope there was a warm seat in hell waiting for her and all her cohorts when she passed away. Throughout the story, you can feel the love for Millie that Cecile has and she risks her life and the lives of those that are helping her in order to get to her daughter. No matter what she does, though it never seems like enough, Millie is always just beyond her grasp.
If you like historical, true crime fiction, you will enjoy this book.
May 21, 2020
3.5 stars
The best part of this story is how well it taps into Cecile's heartbreak over losing her little girl. The emotions portrayed in the book are so well done that it added another star; you feel what the characters are feeling. Though it wasn't exactly fun to identify with them because of the pain Cecile is going through, and the angst adoptive mothers Darcy and Gladys face in their private lives, it's well done.
The men in the book (mostly Vance and Griggs) aren't as well developed and honestly it came as a chock to discover late in the book that they had known each other as kids. They get the job done and serve a purpose, but I really didn't feel like I knew either of them super well.
I listened to a library copy audiobook, and the narrator honestly wasn't one of my favorites. She spoke often with a heavy Southern accent but then ignored some traditional Southern pronunciations, which really confused my mind (if you're from the deep South and you don't call bologna "baloney" at all times, are you really Southern?)
There were several places where the plot rather fell apart and I didn't think it was believable all the way through, but it's one of the more enjoyable ones from this series.
Thanks to the publisher for a free reading copy. A favorable review was not required.
The best part of this story is how well it taps into Cecile's heartbreak over losing her little girl. The emotions portrayed in the book are so well done that it added another star; you feel what the characters are feeling. Though it wasn't exactly fun to identify with them because of the pain Cecile is going through, and the angst adoptive mothers Darcy and Gladys face in their private lives, it's well done.
The men in the book (mostly Vance and Griggs) aren't as well developed and honestly it came as a chock to discover late in the book that they had known each other as kids. They get the job done and serve a purpose, but I really didn't feel like I knew either of them super well.
I listened to a library copy audiobook, and the narrator honestly wasn't one of my favorites. She spoke often with a heavy Southern accent but then ignored some traditional Southern pronunciations, which really confused my mind (if you're from the deep South and you don't call bologna "baloney" at all times, are you really Southern?)
There were several places where the plot rather fell apart and I didn't think it was believable all the way through, but it's one of the more enjoyable ones from this series.
Thanks to the publisher for a free reading copy. A favorable review was not required.
June 22, 2019
Reviewed at The Power of Words: https://bit.ly/31Rq1a7
Liz Tolsma has written an impressive novel in the True Colors: Historical Stories of American Crime series. I have read some, but not all, of Tolsma’s previous books because they have dealt with the Holocaust. While she is an excellent writer and handles that subject in a compelling way, I just have a hard time reading stories in that setting, so I was excited to try this one. Although still not a subject easy to read about, Tolsma has written a fascinating page turner that combines fiction with real-life events. I was engaged emotionally from page one of this action-packed story and could hardly put it down.
The Pink Bonnet reads like a wonderful suspense thriller, until it sinks in that it is based on historical true crime – the story of Georgia Tann, who ran a Memphis adoption agency from 1924 to 1950; then it becomes chilling and haunting. Children she perceived to be from inadequate homes or parenting situations were literally stolen and given to families who could pay well. Even those who were supposed to care – politicians and others in authoritative positions – were corrupt and easily bribed to turn a blind eye. That this could go on for 25 years is horrifying.
Into this backdrop we meet Cecile Dowd, a young widow with the odds stacked against her, struggling to care for her three- year-old daughter Millie. Cecile is a loving mother and making things work out, when suddenly she is betrayed by a “concerned” neighbor and Millie falls into the hands of Georgia Tann. Cecile and Millie are characters every reader will be drawn to, so easy to connect with. And then there’s Percy, a lawyer working with Tann, who begins to suspect that all is not right with this adoption agency. I loved the connection between Cecile and Percy, a sweet and growing relationship in an otherwise dark story. I also appreciated the spiritual overtones of God’s unrelenting seeking for us.
The Pink Bonnet is a riveting, suspense-filled story that drove me to do some online research into this crime. I look forward to much more of Liz Tolsma’s writing. Recommended.
I received a copy of this book through Celebrate Lit. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Liz Tolsma has written an impressive novel in the True Colors: Historical Stories of American Crime series. I have read some, but not all, of Tolsma’s previous books because they have dealt with the Holocaust. While she is an excellent writer and handles that subject in a compelling way, I just have a hard time reading stories in that setting, so I was excited to try this one. Although still not a subject easy to read about, Tolsma has written a fascinating page turner that combines fiction with real-life events. I was engaged emotionally from page one of this action-packed story and could hardly put it down.
The Pink Bonnet reads like a wonderful suspense thriller, until it sinks in that it is based on historical true crime – the story of Georgia Tann, who ran a Memphis adoption agency from 1924 to 1950; then it becomes chilling and haunting. Children she perceived to be from inadequate homes or parenting situations were literally stolen and given to families who could pay well. Even those who were supposed to care – politicians and others in authoritative positions – were corrupt and easily bribed to turn a blind eye. That this could go on for 25 years is horrifying.
Into this backdrop we meet Cecile Dowd, a young widow with the odds stacked against her, struggling to care for her three- year-old daughter Millie. Cecile is a loving mother and making things work out, when suddenly she is betrayed by a “concerned” neighbor and Millie falls into the hands of Georgia Tann. Cecile and Millie are characters every reader will be drawn to, so easy to connect with. And then there’s Percy, a lawyer working with Tann, who begins to suspect that all is not right with this adoption agency. I loved the connection between Cecile and Percy, a sweet and growing relationship in an otherwise dark story. I also appreciated the spiritual overtones of God’s unrelenting seeking for us.
The Pink Bonnet is a riveting, suspense-filled story that drove me to do some online research into this crime. I look forward to much more of Liz Tolsma’s writing. Recommended.
I received a copy of this book through Celebrate Lit. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
March 27, 2020
If you’ve read Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate, you are aware of Georgia Tann and the Tennessee Children’s Home Society historic scandal. Liz Tolsma’s The Pink Bonnet, the second True Colors novel, again revisits this tragic history, but from the perspective of a mother in search of her child.
Cecile Dowd is a young widow, and though she loves her Millie Mae very much, most days it is a struggle to provide for her. After a neighbor allows Millie Mae to be taken by Tann, Cecile has no choice but to find her. Her desperate search leads to startling, heartbreaking revelations, especially when Tann’s lawyer Percy Vance sees the truth.
A solid historical story with a bit of romance, The Pink Bonnet has great moments of suspense. I enjoyed reading it and look forward to more from the True Colors series.
This review is also posted on Hallie Reads.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and the opportunity to provide an honest review. I was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions I have expressed are my own.
Cecile Dowd is a young widow, and though she loves her Millie Mae very much, most days it is a struggle to provide for her. After a neighbor allows Millie Mae to be taken by Tann, Cecile has no choice but to find her. Her desperate search leads to startling, heartbreaking revelations, especially when Tann’s lawyer Percy Vance sees the truth.
A solid historical story with a bit of romance, The Pink Bonnet has great moments of suspense. I enjoyed reading it and look forward to more from the True Colors series.
This review is also posted on Hallie Reads.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and the opportunity to provide an honest review. I was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions I have expressed are my own.
June 12, 2019
In Memphis Tennessee, during 1933, Cecile has already suffered great loss and is struggling to stay afloat. A nightmare begins as she loses what is most precious to her, 3 year old Millie. As she tries to locate and reclaim Millie, she uncovers an evil network of epic proportions. The currency in this evil network is stolen children.
The director of an adoption agency, Georgia Tann, enjoys the power she has over others and is always busy making others miserable. Pretty sure she has liquid evil running through her veins instead of blood. Miss Tann fed her evil soul with corruption and the manipulation of others. Most people who confront and disobey her run the very real risk of personal ruin or even worse. She becomes a formidable opponent to anyone who dares to stand in her way.
As Cecile decides to take steps to find Millie, she enlists the help of others. As they dig deeper and investigate, they find themselves threatened and in grave danger. Nothing is off limits for Miss Tann and her band of thugs.
At the same time, a mother’s love knows no bounds. Ever protective, ever determined and fierce, Cecile refused to give up. Along her fierce and determined journey, she forms a special bond with an ally, and that bond holds much sweet promise. This bond becomes a bright and guiding light through a long, dark tunnel.
True, unconditional love is breathtaking. Once found, it needs to be treasured, embraced, valued and clung to. And, even though a dark path, lined with sorrow causes many tears to be shed, it can lead to light and joy.
A well done and satisfying reading experience.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and I was under no obligation to post a review.
The director of an adoption agency, Georgia Tann, enjoys the power she has over others and is always busy making others miserable. Pretty sure she has liquid evil running through her veins instead of blood. Miss Tann fed her evil soul with corruption and the manipulation of others. Most people who confront and disobey her run the very real risk of personal ruin or even worse. She becomes a formidable opponent to anyone who dares to stand in her way.
As Cecile decides to take steps to find Millie, she enlists the help of others. As they dig deeper and investigate, they find themselves threatened and in grave danger. Nothing is off limits for Miss Tann and her band of thugs.
At the same time, a mother’s love knows no bounds. Ever protective, ever determined and fierce, Cecile refused to give up. Along her fierce and determined journey, she forms a special bond with an ally, and that bond holds much sweet promise. This bond becomes a bright and guiding light through a long, dark tunnel.
True, unconditional love is breathtaking. Once found, it needs to be treasured, embraced, valued and clung to. And, even though a dark path, lined with sorrow causes many tears to be shed, it can lead to light and joy.
A well done and satisfying reading experience.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and I was under no obligation to post a review.
September 15, 2021
As the terrifying, tragic story unfolds, my heart breaks for the mothers who lost children during this kidnapping adoption scheme. How could that have happened in the United States? How does evil happen anywhere? That element lurking in man’s capable soul is real if not defeated.
Liz Tolsma masters the role of storyteller while guarding the truth. Even when the truth is horrifying. Well done.
Liz Tolsma masters the role of storyteller while guarding the truth. Even when the truth is horrifying. Well done.
June 16, 2019
Having read Lisa Wingate's book, Before We Were Yours, I was familiar with the abhorrent story of Georgia Tann and the Tennessee Children's Home Society. This story is written from the perspective of one mother whose child was taken and who is fighting to find her child. I read this story in a long, late night because I couldn't put it down. It is very much a plot-driven book. Cecile and Percy, a lawyer for Georgia Tann who definitely feels there is something rotten in Denmark, join forces to find out what has happened to find Millie.
Percy has been duped into working for Georgia who is connected or has bribed every official in the state of Tennessee. He senses the evil, but continues to look the other way until it touches his heart when he sees Millie taken away on only a neighbor's word. He made choices that would be difficult for anyone to make knowing full well that he was probably going to lose everything he had worked hard for in his life. Cecile, on the other hand, had nothing to lose and everything to gain by digging until she found what had happened to Millie.
With twists and turns at each corner, with villains popping up everywhere they turned, persistance paid off in the end. Liz Tolsma's historical research is evident on every page, and her exposing of this little known piece of history should make us all aware that adoption agencies should be very carefully researched as Tann even managed to dupe some very well known people including the actress, Joan Crawford. Tann spread her web both wide and deep for almost 20 years.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Books through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
Percy has been duped into working for Georgia who is connected or has bribed every official in the state of Tennessee. He senses the evil, but continues to look the other way until it touches his heart when he sees Millie taken away on only a neighbor's word. He made choices that would be difficult for anyone to make knowing full well that he was probably going to lose everything he had worked hard for in his life. Cecile, on the other hand, had nothing to lose and everything to gain by digging until she found what had happened to Millie.
With twists and turns at each corner, with villains popping up everywhere they turned, persistance paid off in the end. Liz Tolsma's historical research is evident on every page, and her exposing of this little known piece of history should make us all aware that adoption agencies should be very carefully researched as Tann even managed to dupe some very well known people including the actress, Joan Crawford. Tann spread her web both wide and deep for almost 20 years.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Books through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
May 30, 2019
This book is part of the True Colors series of Historical Crimes written by different authors. This is the story of Georgia Tann, the Director of the Tennessee Children's Home Society in the 1930s. I had previous read a book about this despicable time and crime, but this was a very different story. In this book, three year old Millie Dowd is signed over to Georgia Tann by a neighbour who is babysitting her while her mother is out looking for a better job. Cecile is a single mom, barely making ends meet after the death of her husband. When she realizes that her daughter has been stolen from her, she refuses to give up looking for her. Gaining some support from a couple of lawyers, she follows the clues.
I really liked the character of Cecile. She could have easily given up, but Millie was the only thing she had left from her husband. She uses whatever she can to find information about Millie. When she is able to convince a lawyer who works for Tann to help her, he risks losing his job, his home and even his life to right this wrong. This book is an historical mystery romance based on true events. It is also Christian fiction, but a bit lighter than others I have read. This is a very sad story, sadder still because it is based on real events and real corrupt officials who stole children and sold them to line their pockets, not caring what kind of home they ended up in. Once I started this story, I could not put it down. I wanted to find out if Cecile found her daughter or not and I will not spoil the story by telling you the answer to this question. There were a few niggles for me: I found the characters of Percy Vance and R.D. Griggs about face pretty quick. I am glad they did, but it was a bit unrealistic. The instalove between Cecile and Percy is another thing that I am not a fan of, but it does work in the story. Overall, this was an enjoyable story about a terrible tragedy in Tennessee history. Make sure to read the author's notes following the story where the author shares some of her actual research and experiences with legal adoption. The publisher generously provided me with a copy of this book upon my request and participation in a book tour by Celebrate Lit Publicity. The rating, ideas and opinions shared are my own.
I really liked the character of Cecile. She could have easily given up, but Millie was the only thing she had left from her husband. She uses whatever she can to find information about Millie. When she is able to convince a lawyer who works for Tann to help her, he risks losing his job, his home and even his life to right this wrong. This book is an historical mystery romance based on true events. It is also Christian fiction, but a bit lighter than others I have read. This is a very sad story, sadder still because it is based on real events and real corrupt officials who stole children and sold them to line their pockets, not caring what kind of home they ended up in. Once I started this story, I could not put it down. I wanted to find out if Cecile found her daughter or not and I will not spoil the story by telling you the answer to this question. There were a few niggles for me: I found the characters of Percy Vance and R.D. Griggs about face pretty quick. I am glad they did, but it was a bit unrealistic. The instalove between Cecile and Percy is another thing that I am not a fan of, but it does work in the story. Overall, this was an enjoyable story about a terrible tragedy in Tennessee history. Make sure to read the author's notes following the story where the author shares some of her actual research and experiences with legal adoption. The publisher generously provided me with a copy of this book upon my request and participation in a book tour by Celebrate Lit Publicity. The rating, ideas and opinions shared are my own.
March 17, 2020
This was a book that brought to life a very difficult time in Memphis, with evil cruising the streets, no child was safe. I have read books about the Memphis Children's Society before, but never one that brings it to quite so personal of a level.
The story is about young widow, Cecile Dawd, and her three-year-old daughter, Millie Mae. When times get tough for Cecile she goes looking for work leaving her daughter in the care of an elderly neighbor. Never did it occur to her that her neighbor would call Georgia Tann and give her daughter away. Cecile does not give up and is determined to find her daughter, no matter what. When she meets Tann's legal assistant, Percy, she is more than outraged that he helped take her child, but then he realizes that what he did was wrong and helps Cecile try to find Millie Mae. Their attempts are great, but it seems Tann is always one step ahead of them, and hinders Cecile from finding her daughter.
This was a book that brought the time of the Memphis Children's Society to a more personal level, especially being a mother. The emotions, the roadblocks, the feeling of defeat in not having or being able to find your child. And to think there were so many that could not find their children.
I am loving this new mystery series and cannot wait to read the next.
The story is about young widow, Cecile Dawd, and her three-year-old daughter, Millie Mae. When times get tough for Cecile she goes looking for work leaving her daughter in the care of an elderly neighbor. Never did it occur to her that her neighbor would call Georgia Tann and give her daughter away. Cecile does not give up and is determined to find her daughter, no matter what. When she meets Tann's legal assistant, Percy, she is more than outraged that he helped take her child, but then he realizes that what he did was wrong and helps Cecile try to find Millie Mae. Their attempts are great, but it seems Tann is always one step ahead of them, and hinders Cecile from finding her daughter.
This was a book that brought the time of the Memphis Children's Society to a more personal level, especially being a mother. The emotions, the roadblocks, the feeling of defeat in not having or being able to find your child. And to think there were so many that could not find their children.
I am loving this new mystery series and cannot wait to read the next.
March 5, 2023
Anyone who has read Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate knows the infamous history of Georgia Tann and the Tennessee Children's Home Society. You'd have to be completely heartless not to be affected by the stories that resulted from this place's dark history of black market adoptions and ruthless child kidnappings. Since I live in the area where this history took place, I am probably more fascinated with it than most. It's not that I enjoy reading the horrors of this time (because they are atrocious), but I am thankful that this woman and her unethical practices were finally brought to an end.
I have slowly been making my way through the True Colors series by Barbour Publishing, but did not realize that one of the books featured a fictional story amidst the very real history of the Tennessee Children's Home Society. From the very first chapter, it is a heartbreaking tale, and as a mom, I know that if placed in the same situation, I would move heaven and earth to get my children back. Such is the case with Cecile Dowd. Due to her persistence and the help of legal assistant, Percy Vance, they are on a mission to find Cecile's daughter and bring her home.
For those interested in separating fact from fiction, there are several mentions of actual Memphis landmarks and individuals that helped Georgia Tann continue her moneymaking scheme. There is also a very helpful author's note at the end.
It's also worth noting that this story is available as an audiobook. While I am normally a huge fan of this particular narrator, her accents and interpretation of the characters were a bit overdone for my taste. Memphis is a Southern city, but we don't all speak like a bunch of uneducated, backwoods hicks. There were a few instances where I got this impression from the narrator, and it tarnished my enjoyment of an otherwise great story.
I have slowly been making my way through the True Colors series by Barbour Publishing, but did not realize that one of the books featured a fictional story amidst the very real history of the Tennessee Children's Home Society. From the very first chapter, it is a heartbreaking tale, and as a mom, I know that if placed in the same situation, I would move heaven and earth to get my children back. Such is the case with Cecile Dowd. Due to her persistence and the help of legal assistant, Percy Vance, they are on a mission to find Cecile's daughter and bring her home.
For those interested in separating fact from fiction, there are several mentions of actual Memphis landmarks and individuals that helped Georgia Tann continue her moneymaking scheme. There is also a very helpful author's note at the end.
It's also worth noting that this story is available as an audiobook. While I am normally a huge fan of this particular narrator, her accents and interpretation of the characters were a bit overdone for my taste. Memphis is a Southern city, but we don't all speak like a bunch of uneducated, backwoods hicks. There were a few instances where I got this impression from the narrator, and it tarnished my enjoyment of an otherwise great story.
June 25, 2019
What Happens When You Explore the Ugly Side of “Adoption?”
Written with careful attention to historical detail, The Pink Bonnet does more than chronicle a young mother’s desperate search for her child. It also shows a subtle picture of God’s relentless pursuit of His own children, ready to rescue each one from Satan’s clutches.
If it sounds cruel to compare Georgia Tann to Satan, well… you’ve got to read the book.
Lord Acton’s words about absolute power corrupting absolutely shows in the way Tolsma portrays the director of the Tennessee Children’s Home Society. I believe in any other book written by any other author about any other person, the portrayal would have been over the top. Instead, Tolsma made me believe that I was watching the events play out on the screen.
Not going to lie. There were times I wanted to shake, smack, and otherwise do violent things to different characters. At first, I took that as a problem with Ms. Tolsma’s writing.
But I don’t think it is. I think her writing did exactly what it was supposed to. Since when does a panicked mother ever behave in logical, rational ways when the safety—rather, the life of her child—is at stake? That would have been unrealistic.
Look, I tend to be rather unruffleable. I just move along and do the next thing. Fix it. I’m a fixer. But when an airline moved my minor child to another airline that no one at LAX had ever heard of, you’d better believe I “ruffled.”
Sure, if you want to get nit-picky, there are tiny things. A couple of small anachronisms that most likely wouldn’t notice et cetera. But frankly, I didn’t even care.
From page one of The Pink Bonnet, I wanted Georgia Tann to get her comeuppance. I knew she wouldn’t—not really. I knew how her story ended and it was long after this book. Choosing this year instead of one closer to the end of the Memphis horrors? Brilliant. Leaving it open-ended like that only added to the suspense. And I think that’s pretty cool.
Who would like this book?
Lovers of suspense. Seriously, I think Liz Tolsma mentioned somewhere that this was her first suspense novel. It should not be her last. She managed to capture the momentum and keep it rolling. She got that “snowball” effect started and it crashed at the end of the book with a terrific bang. Well done.
Those who love spiritual truths woven into the story with subtlety and grace will love this. There were no deep theological discussions. You didn’t run across grandiose, spiritual epiphanies. Instead, the realistic clinging to prayer and the dual storyline layered over and under the main story—one of God’s care and provision, even in the dark ugliness of this world—proved rich and true.
Who might not care for it?
If you like your spiritual content overt and strong, you may not be satisfied.
Additionally, if emotional declarations of undying love aren’t your jam, be aware. There’s one near the end. It’s actually my only quibble, and not just because I’m not a big fan of sappy romance. Something about it felt forced—too clean and precise. As if the character read his lines from a playbook instead of speaking them from his heart.
Seriously, though. We’re talking half a page at most. And it’s probably just me. I really liked The Pink Bonnet—almost loved it. I’ll be rereading it as soon as possible because I wonder if I wouldn’t have absolutely loved it if I hadn’t been interrupted so many times while reading it. I'm so glad I requested a review copy. Thankful it was provided by the publisher.
If so, I’ll be adjusting my review then. Meanwhile, I recommend it for anyone who loves suspense and can handle the reality of ugliness perpetrated on children and innocent families. The scenes aren’t graphic, but they are realistic and don’t shy away from the horrors inflicted on Memphis during these years.
Written with careful attention to historical detail, The Pink Bonnet does more than chronicle a young mother’s desperate search for her child. It also shows a subtle picture of God’s relentless pursuit of His own children, ready to rescue each one from Satan’s clutches.
If it sounds cruel to compare Georgia Tann to Satan, well… you’ve got to read the book.
Lord Acton’s words about absolute power corrupting absolutely shows in the way Tolsma portrays the director of the Tennessee Children’s Home Society. I believe in any other book written by any other author about any other person, the portrayal would have been over the top. Instead, Tolsma made me believe that I was watching the events play out on the screen.
Not going to lie. There were times I wanted to shake, smack, and otherwise do violent things to different characters. At first, I took that as a problem with Ms. Tolsma’s writing.
But I don’t think it is. I think her writing did exactly what it was supposed to. Since when does a panicked mother ever behave in logical, rational ways when the safety—rather, the life of her child—is at stake? That would have been unrealistic.
Look, I tend to be rather unruffleable. I just move along and do the next thing. Fix it. I’m a fixer. But when an airline moved my minor child to another airline that no one at LAX had ever heard of, you’d better believe I “ruffled.”
Sure, if you want to get nit-picky, there are tiny things. A couple of small anachronisms that most likely wouldn’t notice et cetera. But frankly, I didn’t even care.
From page one of The Pink Bonnet, I wanted Georgia Tann to get her comeuppance. I knew she wouldn’t—not really. I knew how her story ended and it was long after this book. Choosing this year instead of one closer to the end of the Memphis horrors? Brilliant. Leaving it open-ended like that only added to the suspense. And I think that’s pretty cool.
Who would like this book?
Lovers of suspense. Seriously, I think Liz Tolsma mentioned somewhere that this was her first suspense novel. It should not be her last. She managed to capture the momentum and keep it rolling. She got that “snowball” effect started and it crashed at the end of the book with a terrific bang. Well done.
Those who love spiritual truths woven into the story with subtlety and grace will love this. There were no deep theological discussions. You didn’t run across grandiose, spiritual epiphanies. Instead, the realistic clinging to prayer and the dual storyline layered over and under the main story—one of God’s care and provision, even in the dark ugliness of this world—proved rich and true.
Who might not care for it?
If you like your spiritual content overt and strong, you may not be satisfied.
Additionally, if emotional declarations of undying love aren’t your jam, be aware. There’s one near the end. It’s actually my only quibble, and not just because I’m not a big fan of sappy romance. Something about it felt forced—too clean and precise. As if the character read his lines from a playbook instead of speaking them from his heart.
Seriously, though. We’re talking half a page at most. And it’s probably just me. I really liked The Pink Bonnet—almost loved it. I’ll be rereading it as soon as possible because I wonder if I wouldn’t have absolutely loved it if I hadn’t been interrupted so many times while reading it. I'm so glad I requested a review copy. Thankful it was provided by the publisher.
If so, I’ll be adjusting my review then. Meanwhile, I recommend it for anyone who loves suspense and can handle the reality of ugliness perpetrated on children and innocent families. The scenes aren’t graphic, but they are realistic and don’t shy away from the horrors inflicted on Memphis during these years.
January 5, 2022
This was a brutal read! Speaking as a Mama, reading this book and picturing my daughter in this situation was heartbreaking. Especially since my daughter has special needs, and I can only imagine how that evil woman would have reacted to that! Knowing that this was based on ACTUAL events: WOWZA! Liz did a good job at constructing a compelling story and it flows well with lots of twists and turns. It's the subject matter itself that lowers my rating. This isn't a book I will likely reread because it truly makes my heart hurt.
I received this book from NetGalley and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts are my own.
I received this book from NetGalley and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts are my own.
July 3, 2019
This is the second book in the True Colors Series, put out by Barbour publishing, which focus on historical stories of American Crime. Although the books are in a series, they are not connected and can be read out of order. They are written by different authors.
The topic of this book really interested me and the fact that it's based on a true story is horrifying and sad. The story focuses on the kidnapping and sale of children to the highest bidder in Memphis Tennessee in 1933.
The author conveyed Cecile's anguish very well, I found myself feeling extremely frustrated as I read this book and my heart broke for not only the fictional character of Cecile but also for all the real parents and children that were affected by this awful occurrence.
All of the characters were richly developed and described in a way that I could easily picture them.
There were some very difficult scenes of abuse in this book that could be triggering for some. The story is gritty, frustrating, and sad but also an important read.
I definitely recommend this one!
I received this book from the publisher to review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
The topic of this book really interested me and the fact that it's based on a true story is horrifying and sad. The story focuses on the kidnapping and sale of children to the highest bidder in Memphis Tennessee in 1933.
The author conveyed Cecile's anguish very well, I found myself feeling extremely frustrated as I read this book and my heart broke for not only the fictional character of Cecile but also for all the real parents and children that were affected by this awful occurrence.
All of the characters were richly developed and described in a way that I could easily picture them.
There were some very difficult scenes of abuse in this book that could be triggering for some. The story is gritty, frustrating, and sad but also an important read.
I definitely recommend this one!
I received this book from the publisher to review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
June 17, 2019
Heartbreaking! Georgia Tann, corrupt Memphis Tennessee Children’s Home Society director, destroyed many families. This true crime is so shocking! Once you begin reading, you won't want to stop.
I borrowed a copy from my local library. All views expressed are my honest opinion.
I borrowed a copy from my local library. All views expressed are my honest opinion.
July 21, 2019
The Pink Bonnet by Liz Tolsma is part of Barbour Publishing’s True Colors series, fiction based on strange but true history.
Set in Memphis 1933, The Pink Bonnet tells the true story of Georgia Tann, the director of the Memphis Children’s Home Society, through the eyes of fictional character, Cecile Dowd, a recently widowed young mother.
The year 1933 was an exceptionally difficult year for many, people are starving, homeless, and begging for work. Cecile Dowd has managed to keep a small apartment in a run down building, providing housing for her young daughter. She works part time and a neighbor looks after her daughter. Upon her return home from work one afternoon, she finds her young daughter gone. Vanished.
Thus begins a young mother’s journey to learn where her daughter is, along with the children of other mothers she meets during her search. A search that will bring much danger to many, including Cecile, the children or anyone else who threatens Georgia Tann’s very corrupt business practices.
Georgia Tann was real, she was not fiction, no matter how much I and hundreds of others wish it could be so. The Pink Bonnet is a well written fictional account of how the parents of hundreds of children must of despaired of ever seeing their children again. Sounds strange perhaps, but I could almost hear Cecile Dowd’s young daughter crying for her mother.
Highly recommend.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and am under no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions therein are solely my own, and freely given.
Set in Memphis 1933, The Pink Bonnet tells the true story of Georgia Tann, the director of the Memphis Children’s Home Society, through the eyes of fictional character, Cecile Dowd, a recently widowed young mother.
The year 1933 was an exceptionally difficult year for many, people are starving, homeless, and begging for work. Cecile Dowd has managed to keep a small apartment in a run down building, providing housing for her young daughter. She works part time and a neighbor looks after her daughter. Upon her return home from work one afternoon, she finds her young daughter gone. Vanished.
Thus begins a young mother’s journey to learn where her daughter is, along with the children of other mothers she meets during her search. A search that will bring much danger to many, including Cecile, the children or anyone else who threatens Georgia Tann’s very corrupt business practices.
Georgia Tann was real, she was not fiction, no matter how much I and hundreds of others wish it could be so. The Pink Bonnet is a well written fictional account of how the parents of hundreds of children must of despaired of ever seeing their children again. Sounds strange perhaps, but I could almost hear Cecile Dowd’s young daughter crying for her mother.
Highly recommend.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and am under no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions therein are solely my own, and freely given.
June 19, 2019
4.5 stars
When I first heard about this series, True Colors: Historical Stories of American Crime, I was intrigued. When I started reading The Pink Bonnet, I was immediately captivated by this riveting story of the ugly crime that affected so many families for so many years. While Cecile Down and Percy Vance are fictional characters, their story reflects the heartache that was inflicted by Georgia Vance and the corrupt politicians that were complicit with the Tennessee Children's Home Society. Vance is thought to have been involved with the disappearance of thousands of children. The reader needs to realize this is a fictional story that revolves around this horrendous crime.
This is my favorite book by Liz Tolsma to date. She expertly draws her readers into the story from the very first page. Her attention to historic detail, expert pacing in an action-packed, emotionally charged story will keep her readers glued to the page.
One of my favorite quotes:
"...there was nothing like a mother's love, other than God's love for His own children. Fierce. Determined. Protective."
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
When I first heard about this series, True Colors: Historical Stories of American Crime, I was intrigued. When I started reading The Pink Bonnet, I was immediately captivated by this riveting story of the ugly crime that affected so many families for so many years. While Cecile Down and Percy Vance are fictional characters, their story reflects the heartache that was inflicted by Georgia Vance and the corrupt politicians that were complicit with the Tennessee Children's Home Society. Vance is thought to have been involved with the disappearance of thousands of children. The reader needs to realize this is a fictional story that revolves around this horrendous crime.
This is my favorite book by Liz Tolsma to date. She expertly draws her readers into the story from the very first page. Her attention to historic detail, expert pacing in an action-packed, emotionally charged story will keep her readers glued to the page.
One of my favorite quotes:
"...there was nothing like a mother's love, other than God's love for His own children. Fierce. Determined. Protective."
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
September 11, 2019
meh. good story, but the writing didn't captivate me. they made the women seem like damsels in distress and only really talked about how beautiful they were. I feel like a lot more plot could've been added if the author didn't feel the need to comment on every woman's appearance before having her speak.
June 20, 2019
The Pink Bonnet is a riveting novel of faith that grabbed me from the first page and held my attention throughout. It is based on a real woman who plotted crimes similar to those in this tale. It is at once heartbreaking and intriguing, most characters are appealing, and the type of crimes committed part of a terrible crime spree spanning almost 30 years of the early 1900’s in and around Memphis, Tennessee. I appreciate the author sharing some of the historical background and who the real-life characters were.
Cecile has been widowed for about a year in the summer of 1933. Disowned by her family when she married her late husband, she has only her beloved three-year-old, Millie Mae. She has been looking for a full-time position in lieu of the part time one she has in a nursery school, but jobs are few and far between in the Great Depression. Mrs. Ward, the senior who lived in the apartment underneath hers, suggested that Cecile take her daughter to the Tennessee Children’s Home Society. She said Georgia Tann did remarkable things for children, and when Cecile is better on her feet and able to handle the precocious Millie, she could bring her home again. Horrified, Cecile refuses to give up her precious child.
One day when going out on job search, Cecile left Millie with Mrs. Ward. When she returned for Millie, she learned that. Mrs. Ward contacted Georgia Tann, who came and took Millie away. Later she learned that her signature was forged on the forms to relinquish her daughter. Cecile met Miss Tann and was told she was an unfit parent with an unfit home. Miss Tann would find a home for Millie where she could be given all that her mother couldn’t, and Cecile would never see her again.
Percy Vance is the legal assistant to Miss Tann. He came from poverty and now enjoys the things his wealth accumulates. He talked to Miss Tann about Cecile’s case and wonders about the situation. Percy contacted Cecile to meet with her about her daughter. He then begins to help her find Millie, who was last seen wearing the pink bonnet Cecile bought when pregnant with her.
This slice of history is well-written and an excellent novel in Barbour’s series, True Colors: Historical Stories of American Crime. The suspense builds throughout, making it difficult to put down. Many of the children stolen would never be traced. Some went to homes where they were genuinely loved and cared for, while others were abused. The more Cecile and Percy close in on Georgia Tann, the more their lives, and the life of Millie, are at risk. Tann clearly did not take these children out of love and concern for them; instead, she took them to further her own lifestyle and agenda. The depth of corruption in Memphis at that time spreads further than the kidnappings into many layers of society. I very much appreciated the demonstration of faith in the Lord and demonstrating how He can change even those whose lives are built on the shifting sand of wealth. I highly recommend it!
From a thankful heart: I received an e-ARC of this novel from CelebrateLit and NetGalley, a positive review was not required.
Cecile has been widowed for about a year in the summer of 1933. Disowned by her family when she married her late husband, she has only her beloved three-year-old, Millie Mae. She has been looking for a full-time position in lieu of the part time one she has in a nursery school, but jobs are few and far between in the Great Depression. Mrs. Ward, the senior who lived in the apartment underneath hers, suggested that Cecile take her daughter to the Tennessee Children’s Home Society. She said Georgia Tann did remarkable things for children, and when Cecile is better on her feet and able to handle the precocious Millie, she could bring her home again. Horrified, Cecile refuses to give up her precious child.
One day when going out on job search, Cecile left Millie with Mrs. Ward. When she returned for Millie, she learned that. Mrs. Ward contacted Georgia Tann, who came and took Millie away. Later she learned that her signature was forged on the forms to relinquish her daughter. Cecile met Miss Tann and was told she was an unfit parent with an unfit home. Miss Tann would find a home for Millie where she could be given all that her mother couldn’t, and Cecile would never see her again.
Percy Vance is the legal assistant to Miss Tann. He came from poverty and now enjoys the things his wealth accumulates. He talked to Miss Tann about Cecile’s case and wonders about the situation. Percy contacted Cecile to meet with her about her daughter. He then begins to help her find Millie, who was last seen wearing the pink bonnet Cecile bought when pregnant with her.
This slice of history is well-written and an excellent novel in Barbour’s series, True Colors: Historical Stories of American Crime. The suspense builds throughout, making it difficult to put down. Many of the children stolen would never be traced. Some went to homes where they were genuinely loved and cared for, while others were abused. The more Cecile and Percy close in on Georgia Tann, the more their lives, and the life of Millie, are at risk. Tann clearly did not take these children out of love and concern for them; instead, she took them to further her own lifestyle and agenda. The depth of corruption in Memphis at that time spreads further than the kidnappings into many layers of society. I very much appreciated the demonstration of faith in the Lord and demonstrating how He can change even those whose lives are built on the shifting sand of wealth. I highly recommend it!
From a thankful heart: I received an e-ARC of this novel from CelebrateLit and NetGalley, a positive review was not required.
June 22, 2019
WARNING: there is a hint of a spoiler in this review, but not enough to check the box. You have been warned!!
This book was really good, but not perfect. I really liked the premise of it - a young widowed mother is having a rough time with her three year old daughter. She leaves the daughter with a neighbor for a few hours to look for full-time employment - and her neighbor forges her signature and gives the daughter to the infamous Georgia Tann, the woman that ran the Tennessee Children's Home Society. As was made clear a few years ago in a Lisa Wingate novel, Tann kidnapped over 5,000 children and sold them to people that could afford to pay her fees (regardless of what kind of parents they would be). She stashed them in orphanages around Memphis, Tenn., where they were abused, tortured, or killed outright before being sold. She had several people in highly ranked positions that aided and abetted her doing this, including a judge, a former mayor, and several policemen. She died three days before charges were filed against the agency.
But I digress. The book told the story of a mother and daughter separated by Tann and the many, many people who helped solve the mystery of what happened. I have no problems with the mystery; the part I have an issue with is the "love story" aspect of the book. I think it moved far, far too fast and therefore came off as unrealistic and a tiny bit ridiculous. So that's why a star is getting knocked off my review. Otherwise this book is the perfect way to spend an afternoon. Read and enjoy!
This book was really good, but not perfect. I really liked the premise of it - a young widowed mother is having a rough time with her three year old daughter. She leaves the daughter with a neighbor for a few hours to look for full-time employment - and her neighbor forges her signature and gives the daughter to the infamous Georgia Tann, the woman that ran the Tennessee Children's Home Society. As was made clear a few years ago in a Lisa Wingate novel, Tann kidnapped over 5,000 children and sold them to people that could afford to pay her fees (regardless of what kind of parents they would be). She stashed them in orphanages around Memphis, Tenn., where they were abused, tortured, or killed outright before being sold. She had several people in highly ranked positions that aided and abetted her doing this, including a judge, a former mayor, and several policemen. She died three days before charges were filed against the agency.
But I digress. The book told the story of a mother and daughter separated by Tann and the many, many people who helped solve the mystery of what happened. I have no problems with the mystery; the part I have an issue with is the "love story" aspect of the book. I think it moved far, far too fast and therefore came off as unrealistic and a tiny bit ridiculous. So that's why a star is getting knocked off my review. Otherwise this book is the perfect way to spend an afternoon. Read and enjoy!
May 12, 2019
The Pink Bonnet by Liz Tolsma is the second book in the series True Colors, Historical Stories of American Crime by Barbour Publishing.
Liz Tolsma has captured the flavor of 1933 Memphis, Tennessee and has built a story around the scandal that rocked many people’s lives. She has brought to life the despicable acts of the infamous Georgia Tann of the Tennessee Children’s Home Society.
This book is like watching an old black and white Film Noir, complete with a shiny black Cadillac limousine and a chauffeur with a nasty pistol. There are many tense moments for our hero and heroine. Ms. Tolsma has us rooting for them as they try to get the stolen children back. An emphasis is put on the spiritual condition of the characters and the reliance on God by the hero and heroine.
Get caught up in a bygone era and learn the history of a child adoption conspiracy that was far reaching in political circles.
I thought it especially interesting that the author has three adopted children. She wrote that she didn’t want to discourage anyone from adopting. In fact she encourages us all to ponder the plight of the many children who are in need.
*I received a complimentary ARC copy of this book from the author. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
Liz Tolsma has captured the flavor of 1933 Memphis, Tennessee and has built a story around the scandal that rocked many people’s lives. She has brought to life the despicable acts of the infamous Georgia Tann of the Tennessee Children’s Home Society.
This book is like watching an old black and white Film Noir, complete with a shiny black Cadillac limousine and a chauffeur with a nasty pistol. There are many tense moments for our hero and heroine. Ms. Tolsma has us rooting for them as they try to get the stolen children back. An emphasis is put on the spiritual condition of the characters and the reliance on God by the hero and heroine.
Get caught up in a bygone era and learn the history of a child adoption conspiracy that was far reaching in political circles.
I thought it especially interesting that the author has three adopted children. She wrote that she didn’t want to discourage anyone from adopting. In fact she encourages us all to ponder the plight of the many children who are in need.
*I received a complimentary ARC copy of this book from the author. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
July 29, 2019
This was a difficult book to read and took me a while to get through, not because of the writing, but the subject matter. Based on the true events of Georgia Tann who trafficked children via adoption, this mommy's heart could not deal with the horrible situation the moms and children had to face.
Some children (like Pearl) was lucky to be adopted into a loving family. Other children, like Fanny, was not so lucky - I had to skip the chapters about Fanny on the farm because I could just not deal with that detail.
"...there was nothing like a mother’s love, other than God’s love for His own children. Fierce. Determined. Protective." Cecile was like a fierce lioness in her search for her daughter.
The first half of the story I found a bit slow and took very long to get through. But at the 50% mark the suspense picked up and I found myself trying to find time to get back to the story and reading way past my bedtime to finish it to see what will happen.
I will not recommend this story to sensitive readers (I'm not a sensitive reader and found some parts disturbing, especially knowing it is based on factual events), but if you enjoy suspense and historical fiction, you would like this book.
*I received a complimentary copy from Barbour Publisher via Netgalley. All opinions expressed are my own.*
Some children (like Pearl) was lucky to be adopted into a loving family. Other children, like Fanny, was not so lucky - I had to skip the chapters about Fanny on the farm because I could just not deal with that detail.
"...there was nothing like a mother’s love, other than God’s love for His own children. Fierce. Determined. Protective." Cecile was like a fierce lioness in her search for her daughter.
The first half of the story I found a bit slow and took very long to get through. But at the 50% mark the suspense picked up and I found myself trying to find time to get back to the story and reading way past my bedtime to finish it to see what will happen.
I will not recommend this story to sensitive readers (I'm not a sensitive reader and found some parts disturbing, especially knowing it is based on factual events), but if you enjoy suspense and historical fiction, you would like this book.
*I received a complimentary copy from Barbour Publisher via Netgalley. All opinions expressed are my own.*
February 26, 2020
The single best thing about this book? It has a unique historical backdrop, one I haven't read about in fiction yet (let alone even heard of the whole affair before). It kept me pleasantly surprised as the story unfolded, as I had no clue whatsoever what was going to happen next. (A piece of history I don't know about? That's a bonus for me!)
Georgia Tann, director of a Memphis-based children's home, is snatching children right off the street, to sell them. Whoa! This is true stuff, people. Now, this particular story takes place in 1932. Cecile Dowd is now a single mom with a daughter, Millie Mae. Little three-year-old Millie Mae is taken... and just like that, Cecile goes on a manhunt to track down who took her daughter. Cecile enlists the help of the man who aids Georgia Tann in her kid-snatching endeavors. He's turning a new leaf it would seem, and he has access to the information.
The writing style is fairly good. The setting is super intriguing to me. Plus, it's true crime fictionalized AND falls under the Christian fiction genre? Yep, I just had to pick it up.
Georgia Tann, director of a Memphis-based children's home, is snatching children right off the street, to sell them. Whoa! This is true stuff, people. Now, this particular story takes place in 1932. Cecile Dowd is now a single mom with a daughter, Millie Mae. Little three-year-old Millie Mae is taken... and just like that, Cecile goes on a manhunt to track down who took her daughter. Cecile enlists the help of the man who aids Georgia Tann in her kid-snatching endeavors. He's turning a new leaf it would seem, and he has access to the information.
The writing style is fairly good. The setting is super intriguing to me. Plus, it's true crime fictionalized AND falls under the Christian fiction genre? Yep, I just had to pick it up.
July 5, 2023
Insipid. I had to read it because it’s based around the Tennessee Children’s Home and Georgia Tann, but it’s routine barely-historical fiction that cares more about a romantic story line than general facts- the characters use a phone book (50 years before they were first printed) and talk about having a cardiac arrest.
November 27, 2019
After having read "Before We Were Yours" by Lisa Wingate, I became fascinated by the scandal created by Georgia Tann and the Tennessee Children's Home Society in the early to mid 20th century, so I was naturally drawn to this book. While this book put a different spin on things as it was from the perspective of a parent whose child was taken by Tann, the details were still interesting. The story line was good and it was good to see the account from a parent's point of view. However, I did find parts of the book a bit unbelievable and the romance thread had me rolling my eyes a bit (though I admit romance is generally not my genre of choice). With a moving story line and good characters, though, I would still recommend this one to fans of historical romance.
Displaying 1 - 29 of 300 reviews