What do you think?
Rate this book
Love in Limbo
Love in Limbo, Vol. 2
A poignant story of love and atonement in the afterworld.
Calen, the new reaper in Limbo, develops feelings for his purehearted caretaker, Makoto. But can love flourish in a place where even existence can be fleeting?
New reaper Calen has spent many a peaceful day with his friend and lover Makoto, protecting the people of Limbo. But one day, the time for Makoto’s father to be reincarnated arrives. Once he is gone, the power sustaining Makoto—who is nothing more than an animated clay doll—will cease to exist. Will his precious love’s dissolution looming, will Calen find a solution or be forced to watch as Makoto returns to dust?
Calen, the new reaper in Limbo, develops feelings for his purehearted caretaker, Makoto. But can love flourish in a place where even existence can be fleeting?
New reaper Calen has spent many a peaceful day with his friend and lover Makoto, protecting the people of Limbo. But one day, the time for Makoto’s father to be reincarnated arrives. Once he is gone, the power sustaining Makoto—who is nothing more than an animated clay doll—will cease to exist. Will his precious love’s dissolution looming, will Calen find a solution or be forced to watch as Makoto returns to dust?
186 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2018
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
December 31, 2023
El sentimiento tan profundo que me hizo pasar este volumen, no tiene precio.
En esta parte la historia se enfoca en Makoto, su historia es interesante y a la vez dolorosa (en el 1er volumen te explica que es un chico hecho de barro y que está unido al alma de su padre) pero cuando el padre le toca reencarnar, aquí viene los dolores.
En sí, me encanta los temas que se llegaron a tocar, la construcción del mundo es lo que más me gustó y todas esas criaturas que llegan a pecar en lo cuchi, me hizo la madrugada con todas esas ilustraciones.
Aquí encuentras un poco de todo; amor, amistad, tristeza, trabajo en equipo, sanación, dolor y un sinfín de emociones. Muy recomendado, es bastante corto y para pasar un buen rato.
En esta parte la historia se enfoca en Makoto, su historia es interesante y a la vez dolorosa (en el 1er volumen te explica que es un chico hecho de barro y que está unido al alma de su padre) pero cuando el padre le toca reencarnar, aquí viene los dolores.
En sí, me encanta los temas que se llegaron a tocar, la construcción del mundo es lo que más me gustó y todas esas criaturas que llegan a pecar en lo cuchi, me hizo la madrugada con todas esas ilustraciones.
Aquí encuentras un poco de todo; amor, amistad, tristeza, trabajo en equipo, sanación, dolor y un sinfín de emociones. Muy recomendado, es bastante corto y para pasar un buen rato.
September 22, 2025
cried some more
nose red
lots to think about
nose red
lots to think about
![Profile Image for 小さな N (.❛ ᴗ ❛.)⊃ [_|_] ♡.](https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/users/1611850887i/5476828._UX200_CR0,21,200,200_.jpg)
August 24, 2019
That was heartwrenching at times and I loved that. To be honest, I wouldn't even have said no to a sad ending but of course, I'm glad how it ended.
I really liked the world and the idea of the story.
Makoto was such a lovely character who cares for his friends deeply. He seems like a carefree character at first but he takes things very seriously. He also holds himself at fault for his father's grief and fate and feels like he has to be strong and accept his fate with dignity because of that. He's also very open and sincere in his love for Calen which was so nice to see.
Calen will always be a little mysterious. Although we know what he did before he came to Limbo I would've liked a deeper glimpse into Calen's life especially his personal surroundings (did he have friends, a lover? It seems like there was some kind of an important connection there because of the glimpse into his life during his first fight in Limbo). But I get why this wasn't possible in a two-volume series.
Calen is very serious about his work as the Reaper although he is quite skeptical at first. I think because of his military background he subconsciously knows how to react, takes responsibilities and grows with them. I love how he is with Makoto, because he is so loving and mindful of him.
Can I just say that I adored the long ears, too?
I have two negative points about the story.
I'm not sure how much weight I want to put on the last two points when it comes to my rating. But I think the story still deserves 5 stars as a whole.
I really liked the world and the idea of the story.
Makoto was such a lovely character who cares for his friends deeply. He seems like a carefree character at first but he takes things very seriously. He also holds himself at fault for his father's grief and fate and feels like he has to be strong and accept his fate with dignity because of that. He's also very open and sincere in his love for Calen which was so nice to see.
Calen will always be a little mysterious. Although we know what he did before he came to Limbo I would've liked a deeper glimpse into Calen's life especially his personal surroundings (did he have friends, a lover? It seems like there was some kind of an important connection there because of the glimpse into his life during his first fight in Limbo). But I get why this wasn't possible in a two-volume series.
Calen is very serious about his work as the Reaper although he is quite skeptical at first. I think because of his military background he subconsciously knows how to react, takes responsibilities and grows with them. I love how he is with Makoto, because he is so loving and mindful of him.
Can I just say that I adored the long ears, too?
I have two negative points about the story.
I'm not sure how much weight I want to put on the last two points when it comes to my rating. But I think the story still deserves 5 stars as a whole.
October 13, 2019
The real injustice here is that this is the last volume. Such a sweet story with incredible characters and a wonderful setting, I am so in love with everything from the art style to the interactions between characters. Gorgeous from start to finish.
September 6, 2020
This was a perfect conclusion to this series!
Really looking forward to reading more manga by Haji.
Really looking forward to reading more manga by Haji.
December 1, 2020
I found this to be a surprisingly enjoyable read. I appreciated the continued world building from the first volume. Some of the details could have been explained in a bit more depth, but with the volumes being fairly short, I thought the author did a good job.
I don't have much to add to this review that I didn't include for the first volume, but I will say that there were definitely some great, heartfelt, human moments in the story, and I loved those.
Overall, really interesting concept and a series I would definitely recommend!
I don't have much to add to this review that I didn't include for the first volume, but I will say that there were definitely some great, heartfelt, human moments in the story, and I loved those.
Overall, really interesting concept and a series I would definitely recommend!
May 19, 2021
I love the way Haji draws. She's capable of visually compelling, quiet, intimate scenes as well as dramatic action shots, and everything in between. While I'm not too partial to religiously-tinged supernatural stories, this one caught my attention.
It’s about Calen, a soldier whose record in battle seems to straddle that of a war hero and war criminal, has been banished to Limbo to earn a chance at redemption, and the love he finds there with Makoto, a boy brought back to life by his father in the form of a clay golem. We learn more about Seishin, Makoto’s father, who is also in Limbo for bringing Makoto back to life through the dark arts, as well as the creepy, amoral or immoral “angels” who seem to control Limbo.
There’s drama, action, sex, humor and a strong story supported by some darn good characterization in these pages. I'd love to see more by this artist, but there's not much available yet in English.
It’s about Calen, a soldier whose record in battle seems to straddle that of a war hero and war criminal, has been banished to Limbo to earn a chance at redemption, and the love he finds there with Makoto, a boy brought back to life by his father in the form of a clay golem. We learn more about Seishin, Makoto’s father, who is also in Limbo for bringing Makoto back to life through the dark arts, as well as the creepy, amoral or immoral “angels” who seem to control Limbo.
There’s drama, action, sex, humor and a strong story supported by some darn good characterization in these pages. I'd love to see more by this artist, but there's not much available yet in English.
October 24, 2023
This was a lovely end to a fluffy and lovely little story. The story went in an entirely different direction than I expected and honestly that's just fine. I'm actually pretty tickled that the author completely abandoned the storyline of Calen's amnesia and then even made fun of themselves for dropping what should have been a really serious story beat. Fair enough I suppose lol!
But what did happen in the story told a wonderful story of love and loss. It was very pretty, but I don't think it's one of those stories that will stick in your head for too long. I really enjoyed it because of how sweet it was, but overall it did leave me wanting something more. Not much more... Just a bit though. I did enjoy the Warden and MVP to the doctor. Yes, he caused himself and his son a lot of grief, but his story was so touching and beautiful and I am here for it.
Definitely recommend this one if you're in the mood for a quick, light-hearted story.
But what did happen in the story told a wonderful story of love and loss. It was very pretty, but I don't think it's one of those stories that will stick in your head for too long. I really enjoyed it because of how sweet it was, but overall it did leave me wanting something more. Not much more... Just a bit though. I did enjoy the Warden and MVP to the doctor. Yes, he caused himself and his son a lot of grief, but his story was so touching and beautiful and I am here for it.
Definitely recommend this one if you're in the mood for a quick, light-hearted story.
September 21, 2022
This volume was the sadder of the 2 with things mainly focusing on Makoto’s father, and Makoto’s unique situation as a doll living in Limbo. There were some heartfelt moments, tearful moments, a few tense moments, and lots of Makoto and Calen being in love.
Overall I wish there was another volume or 2 since some things were left unanswered, as well as, to give Makoto and Calen a little epilogue.
Overall I wish there was another volume or 2 since some things were left unanswered, as well as, to give Makoto and Calen a little epilogue.
Read
July 29, 2021***Thoughts after reading***
Strange how I really enjoyed the story but something about it fell flat for me. The art is gorgeous and there is actually a plot! I've loved stories with less.
***Read for the Manga Olympics Reading Challenge***
Runs from Friday July 23 to Sunday August 8
The person responsible for this challenge is Christy Lou on YouTube . They announced this challenge in their Manga Olympics Reading Challenge! | Announcement video. They have made a lovely bingo board which you can find on their Twitter
CHALLENGES
Complete 5 Challenges for a Bronze Medal
Complete 8 Challenges for a Silver Medal
Complete all 17 Challenges for a Gold Medal
I’ll try to read a different manga for every prompt but I don’t know how successful I’ll be. I’ve read this manga for the prompt:
1. Triathlon: Read a whole Series
Love in Limbo by Haji, vol.1
Strange how I really enjoyed the story but something about it fell flat for me. The art is gorgeous and there is actually a plot! I've loved stories with less.
***Read for the Manga Olympics Reading Challenge***
Runs from Friday July 23 to Sunday August 8
The person responsible for this challenge is Christy Lou on YouTube . They announced this challenge in their Manga Olympics Reading Challenge! | Announcement video. They have made a lovely bingo board which you can find on their Twitter
CHALLENGES
Complete 5 Challenges for a Bronze Medal
Complete 8 Challenges for a Silver Medal
Complete all 17 Challenges for a Gold Medal
I’ll try to read a different manga for every prompt but I don’t know how successful I’ll be. I’ve read this manga for the prompt:
1. Triathlon: Read a whole Series
Love in Limbo by Haji, vol.1
2. Swimming: Read a Sports manga
High School Debut (3-in-1 Edition), Vol. 1 by Kawahara, Kazune
3. Track & Field: Read a Short series (4 vols or less!)
Escape Journey, Vol. 1 by Ogeretsu, Tanaka, Escape Journey, Vol. 2 by Ogeretsu, Tanaka, and Escape Journey, Vol. 3 by Ogeretsu, Tanaka
4. Sailing: A manga that gives you summer vibes
Love Hina, Vol. 01 by Akamatsu, Ken
5. Gymnastics: Read a manga with a female main character
BL Metamorphosis, Vol. 1 by Tsurutani, Kaori
6. Taekwondo: Read an Action Manga
Fullmetal Alchemist: Fullmetal Edition, Vol. 7 by Arakawa, Hiromu
7. Tokyo 2020: Read a manga set in Tokyo
Manga to come
8. Skateboarding: Read a new release
BL Metamorphosis, Vol. 3 by Tsurutani, Kaori. Published in December 2020 and I’m counting a half year as a ‘new release’.
9. Fencing: Read a fantasy manga
Revolutionary Girl Utena Complete Deluxe Box Set, second volume by Saitō Chiho
10. Table Tennis: Read a manga recommended by a Manga content creator
Spy x Family, Vol. 1. I needed an easy recommendation and it just so happened the moment I was looking for one the YouTuber Swiss Bohemian recommended this series in their I like 'em, those japanese comics! (manga collection video tour 4K) video. So I’ll just re-read this volume for this challenge.
11. Shooting: Read something outside your comfort zone
Chobits 20th Anniversary Edition, vol. 1 by CLAMP
12. Rugby: Read a Shonen/Seinen
Love Hina, Vol. 02 by Akamatsu, Ken
13. Cycling: Read a Shojo/Josei
Kimi ni Todoke: From Me to You, Vol. 1 by Shiina, Karuho
14. Volleyball: Read a manga you've been excited for
Don't Call Me Dirty by Kanbe, Gorou
15. Archery: Read an underrated Manga
BL Metamorphosis, Vol. 2 by Tsurutani, Kaori
16. Weightlifting: Read the manga that's been on your TBR the longest
Princess Ai: Ultimate Edition by Kujiradō, Misaho
17. Softball: A manga that features an ensemble cast
Wotakoi: Love is Hard for Otaku, Vol 2 by Fujita
August 29, 2025
Rated 1 star lower than my review of volume 1, just because once you realize they’re setting up for the big conflict resolution it becomes kinda obvious that the conflict will be resolved. Redundant to say I know, but the ultimate tragedy of potentially losing your partner is undercut a little bit by this setup that happens like midway through this volume. This had the potential to move me to tears but it didn’t because I kinda figured it would all work out.
That being said… im SO glad it all worked out. I love these two so much. Author got me thinking about their future and shit, and what will happen once Calen’s soul is ready to reincarnate. And what is the cost Makoto has to pay in order to turn down reincarnation? The ultimate tragedy is not prevented, simply delayed. Or maybe they can somehow stay in purgatory together forever, which is insanely doubtful since it was established that this comes at a high cost. I guess that is the beauty of love, that it is finite no matter the context, and we still choose to love in spite of that.
This is why I want more slice of life bl, because I could fully have read an entire third volume of them just living the rest of their lives in purgatory, even if it’s relatively conflict free and they don’t do much of anything at all.
Anyways. Lemme go pontificate or something now.
That being said… im SO glad it all worked out. I love these two so much. Author got me thinking about their future and shit, and what will happen once Calen’s soul is ready to reincarnate. And what is the cost Makoto has to pay in order to turn down reincarnation? The ultimate tragedy is not prevented, simply delayed. Or maybe they can somehow stay in purgatory together forever, which is insanely doubtful since it was established that this comes at a high cost. I guess that is the beauty of love, that it is finite no matter the context, and we still choose to love in spite of that.
This is why I want more slice of life bl, because I could fully have read an entire third volume of them just living the rest of their lives in purgatory, even if it’s relatively conflict free and they don’t do much of anything at all.
Anyways. Lemme go pontificate or something now.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 26, 2020
(5 Stars)
I’m sad Love in Limbo was only two volumes but I absolutely adored this last instalment.
I liked seeing the question of morality when it comes to life and death, and the question of how far one will go to save the person they love and if the price to pay is worth it in the end.
I would’ve liked to have seen more of the other caretakers though as I found them to be interesting characters and wished there were a couple volumes exploring the world of limbo a bit more and the dynamics with its residents.
I’m sad Love in Limbo was only two volumes but I absolutely adored this last instalment.
I liked seeing the question of morality when it comes to life and death, and the question of how far one will go to save the person they love and if the price to pay is worth it in the end.
I would’ve liked to have seen more of the other caretakers though as I found them to be interesting characters and wished there were a couple volumes exploring the world of limbo a bit more and the dynamics with its residents.
December 23, 2022
[rating = B-]
This was a good conclusion to the twosome's struggle for love and for their souls. After discovering that Makoto is made of clay, a golem, Calen (the reaper) must find a way to save him, so his soul doesn't disappear when/if his father (and creator) reincarnates. A touching and sweet second volume. It would be fun to have another chapter or two, but it might be more filler, so, it's best that it ends here.
This was a good conclusion to the twosome's struggle for love and for their souls. After discovering that Makoto is made of clay, a golem, Calen (the reaper) must find a way to save him, so his soul doesn't disappear when/if his father (and creator) reincarnates. A touching and sweet second volume. It would be fun to have another chapter or two, but it might be more filler, so, it's best that it ends here.
May 12, 2021
Cute story. I was bracing myself for when it’d get dark, but it never happened thank god. It’s surprisingly wholesome for a story that takes place in the underworld. I like the romance, but I must say that the relationship between Makoto and his father got to me more. There was some excess moisture in my eyes, but it must have been sweat. It was a bit hot at the moment. Yes, that must be it.
Read
November 23, 2022I can’t finish this nor can I rate it. I do read a lot. And I mean A LOT. That causes me to get storylines mixed and even parts forgotten. I don’t remember reading book 1 of this. At all. That’s says something. This second volume was also chock full of exposition that I really didn’t want. I have only gotten rid of 1 or 2 yaoi series out of my collection but this will be one of them.
April 22, 2020
Es una injusticia que solo sean 2 volúmenes de esta historia, deberían ser por lo menos unos 10.
En este volumen hay más drama, hasta llore en alguna parte de la trama, pero el manga y el dibujo es espectacular.
¡Es un gran manga!
En este volumen hay más drama, hasta llore en alguna parte de la trama, pero el manga y el dibujo es espectacular.
¡Es un gran manga!
May 18, 2020
Ahh, I loved it! Good ending, Makoto remains adorable, the boss angel was fun... I would easily have read a 10 volume expansion of this plot, but it worked really well with the focus on the Reaper, Golem and his dad as it was. Definitely happy I bought this and want more from the author.
August 8, 2020
It makes me very sad that this was the very last volume, but I’m glad I picked it up. I loved that there was a plot intermingled with with the smut. It was a very beautiful romance and it ended so wonderfully.
April 18, 2023
This was unreal !! The twist !! The sacrifice!! The love !! It pulled at my heartstrings good !! The entire series was well paced start to finish and just did such a good job telling this love stories !! Truly a series I would buy for my shelf !!
April 5, 2019
Tears! So emotional and sweet. A good ending. Proof you can have a HEA and still be dead.
August 9, 2019
Thanks to Edelweiss for the e-arc!
Calen and Makoto are still sweet idiots in love. A few supernatural hijinks but mostly just fluff to end this series.
Calen and Makoto are still sweet idiots in love. A few supernatural hijinks but mostly just fluff to end this series.
August 22, 2019
4.75 stars
poignant questions and hea ending ;))
poignant questions and hea ending ;))
December 6, 2019
This volume had a lot packed into it, so sometimes the transitions were quite brisk. A cute enough conclusion for our protagonists though.
April 22, 2021
I rate this pretty much right in the middle. Just okay, could have been better. I see a lot of people suggest this one but it wouldnt be one Id suggest first.
June 6, 2021
Satisfying conclusion.
March 31, 2022
3.5 stars.
June 26, 2022
It was fine, and wrapped up well. Just not really much to write home about.
July 6, 2022
I just adored this series all around. highly highly recommend to anyone who wants a good story with romance!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews