What do you think?
Rate this book
Detective Finnegan Beck #1
Where She Lies
When a beautiful, local teenage girl is found strangled in the cold, dark woods a mile from town. The prime suspect is the seemingly-gentle drifter who found Tanya’s body.
Detective Finnegan Beck, recently demoted from his high-powered job in Dublin and relocated in disgrace to the small Irish town of Cross Beg, is the police officer in charge, and he seems to be the only person who can’t escape the feeling that Tanya wasn’t killed at random.
As he digs deeper into the shadows of Cross Beg, he begins to realise it isn’t the sleepy backwater he’d first believed. Everyone here has something to hide. Tanya had a boyfriend, whose name no one knew. A best friend with a loose relationship with the truth. And a habit she thought she’d kept hidden from everyone.
But, just as Beck believes he is making progress, the body of one of the suspects is found drowned in the river. Is the killer just getting started?
Everyone in the town seems to have something they would die to protect. But who has a secret they’d kill for?
This debut novel from a powerful new Irish voice is the first in a gripping series that will feature the brilliant, haunted Detective Finnegan Beck who won’t rest until justice is found. Perfect for fans of LJ Ross, Joy Ellis and Patricia Gibney.
Detective Finnegan Beck, recently demoted from his high-powered job in Dublin and relocated in disgrace to the small Irish town of Cross Beg, is the police officer in charge, and he seems to be the only person who can’t escape the feeling that Tanya wasn’t killed at random.
As he digs deeper into the shadows of Cross Beg, he begins to realise it isn’t the sleepy backwater he’d first believed. Everyone here has something to hide. Tanya had a boyfriend, whose name no one knew. A best friend with a loose relationship with the truth. And a habit she thought she’d kept hidden from everyone.
But, just as Beck believes he is making progress, the body of one of the suspects is found drowned in the river. Is the killer just getting started?
Everyone in the town seems to have something they would die to protect. But who has a secret they’d kill for?
This debut novel from a powerful new Irish voice is the first in a gripping series that will feature the brilliant, haunted Detective Finnegan Beck who won’t rest until justice is found. Perfect for fans of LJ Ross, Joy Ellis and Patricia Gibney.
281 pages, ebook
First published February 1, 2018
286 people are currently reading
435 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 108 reviews
February 10, 2019
A Gripping Thriller
In a town full of liars, No one is safe.
Where She Lies is the first book of the Detective Finnegan Beck series. Set in Ireland, this one is an exciting atmospheric thriller and an excellent debut for Detective Beck.
Detective Finnegan Beck is demoted from his high-powered job in Dublin and relocated in disgrace to the small & forgotten town of Cross Beg. Treated with disdain by his new superiors and ridiculed by his new colleagues, things couldn’t get any worse for him.
But when a teenage girl is found dead in the woods a mile from town, Beck has an instinct that someone with far darker motives is behind the crime. It seems that everyone in Cross Beg has something to hide though. Wading through layers and layers of lies, Beck believes he’s finally getting closer to the truth….. Until the killer strikes again.
As a story, Where She Lies pulls you in, from the very beginning right till the end. This is the debut of Irish crime novelist Michael Scanlon. (it’s hard to believe that this is a debut novel) He's an employee of the An Garda Siochana (the Irish police force), so his documenting of police procedure and the depiction of internal politics in the force is top notch. Michael Scanlon’s writing style and the pace is perfect for this type of story. The action moves along a brisk pace and the story flows smoothly, which makes it immensely readable (I breezed through the novel in a couple of days).
The setting of a small Irish town, the mystery that keeps you guessing till the end, the unrelenting pace of the story and the excellent writing are some the best things about the book. The needle of suspicion keeps moving from one suspect to another, till the reveal in the end. The characters, even the secondary ones are well written and have depth to them
Apart from the mystery, Where She Lies is as much the story of Finnegan Beck. Finnegan Beck reminds me a lot of Harry Bosch. A brilliant detective who has ability to crack even the most impossible cases but also has a broken personal life. Finn Beck is a likeable character even though he may appear a bit cold at times. He has his own troubles & his own nightmares to fight but he is determined to solve the case, which makes you root for him. We learn a lot about Beck's past as the story moves along and we will hopefully learn a lot more in the future instalments. Having said that, at no point the main mystery is over shadowed by Beck’s story.
Overall, Where She Lies is an impressive debut by Michael Scanlon, with lots of thrilling twists. If you loved the detective series of Harry Bosch or Cormoran Strike, you will enjoy this one. I hope to read a lot more of Finnegan Beck in the future.
Many thanks to the publishers Bookouture, the author Michael Scanlon and NetGalley for the ARC.
January 22, 2019
After Detective Finnegan Beck is demoted and forced to work in the quiet town of Cross Beg, his intention is to keep his head down until he can return to Dublin. However, after a teen girl is found dead, he’s thrust into a complicated investigation, with his experience pulling him to suspect the case is more complicated than it first appears. As he wades through closely guarded secrets and the deep social relationships that come with small town life, he feels on the cusp of cracking the case— and then there’s another murder.
Author Michael Scanlon has written a powerful mystery wrapped in a mystery. The first mystery resides in Finnegan Beck himself. He’s a complicated, sometimes gruff, man with plenty of shortcomings. As the book opens, it’s understood that he’s been demoted, but with no immediate explanation as to why. Withholding this information is a brilliant move, casting Beck as potentially unreliable. Who is he? What happened? And what is he hiding? Scanlon breaks with this information when it can move the story, expertly revealing Beck’s layers as the case goes deeper.
One of the most common tropes in thrillers is the brilliant yet tormented detective and, while Beck is both brilliant and tormented, Scanlon flips this on its head. Beck is brilliant despite his shortcomings, not because of them. There’s an underlying organization to his work and he actively shows remorse for his mistakes and attempts to navigate them in a healthy way. He just isn’t always successful, and watching these active failures creates a more interesting, powerful character. Yes, he might be erratic, but he knows what he’s doing.
However, it’s the mystery of the murder that pushes the book into remarkable territory. Scanlon knows how to weave police procedure and investigation into a compelling narrative. Part of this comes from providing Beck with a smart, curious partner in Claire Somers. She balances and grounds the pair in the intricate world of Cross Beg, and it’s thrilling reading about the two as they progress as a team on a case where everything seems to be working against them.
The murders, viewed from the perspective of the killer, are graphic. The descriptions are vivid and, honestly, repulsive. For some, they might be too extreme, but it’s a matter of reader comfortability, which makes sense for this type of novel. It isn’t gratuitous and provides an extreme sense of urgency for Beck and Somers to unmask the killer. For this reason, the final act, as everything comes together perfectly, is as riveting as it is surprising.
The Quiet Hours is a stunning debut with plenty of thrilling twists.
Note: I received a free ARC of this book through NetGalley.
Author Michael Scanlon has written a powerful mystery wrapped in a mystery. The first mystery resides in Finnegan Beck himself. He’s a complicated, sometimes gruff, man with plenty of shortcomings. As the book opens, it’s understood that he’s been demoted, but with no immediate explanation as to why. Withholding this information is a brilliant move, casting Beck as potentially unreliable. Who is he? What happened? And what is he hiding? Scanlon breaks with this information when it can move the story, expertly revealing Beck’s layers as the case goes deeper.
One of the most common tropes in thrillers is the brilliant yet tormented detective and, while Beck is both brilliant and tormented, Scanlon flips this on its head. Beck is brilliant despite his shortcomings, not because of them. There’s an underlying organization to his work and he actively shows remorse for his mistakes and attempts to navigate them in a healthy way. He just isn’t always successful, and watching these active failures creates a more interesting, powerful character. Yes, he might be erratic, but he knows what he’s doing.
However, it’s the mystery of the murder that pushes the book into remarkable territory. Scanlon knows how to weave police procedure and investigation into a compelling narrative. Part of this comes from providing Beck with a smart, curious partner in Claire Somers. She balances and grounds the pair in the intricate world of Cross Beg, and it’s thrilling reading about the two as they progress as a team on a case where everything seems to be working against them.
The murders, viewed from the perspective of the killer, are graphic. The descriptions are vivid and, honestly, repulsive. For some, they might be too extreme, but it’s a matter of reader comfortability, which makes sense for this type of novel. It isn’t gratuitous and provides an extreme sense of urgency for Beck and Somers to unmask the killer. For this reason, the final act, as everything comes together perfectly, is as riveting as it is surprising.
The Quiet Hours is a stunning debut with plenty of thrilling twists.
Note: I received a free ARC of this book through NetGalley.
February 8, 2019
Where She Lies, previously entitled The Quiet Hours, is the first book in the DS Finnegan Beck series, and it's a great read. There are plenty of surprises with the perpetrator kept well hidden from view for the majority of the novel, and the killer's monologues allow you to see events from their perspective. It's well written, perfectly paced and although there are many familiar genre tropes on show here, the damaged, flawed detective, to name one, the author puts a fresh spin on things. He crafts a wonderful debut novel which held my attention the whole way through.
The cast of characters are well fleshed out, and I particularly enjoyed getting to know DS Beck who is an astute investigator despite having the customary issues with alcohol and women. I look forward to learning more about him and his colleagues. The author knows how to provide the intense excitement the reader craves, and I'm already anticipating the next instalment.
Many thanks to Bookouture for an ARC.
You can also find my reviews posted here on my blog.
The cast of characters are well fleshed out, and I particularly enjoyed getting to know DS Beck who is an astute investigator despite having the customary issues with alcohol and women. I look forward to learning more about him and his colleagues. The author knows how to provide the intense excitement the reader craves, and I'm already anticipating the next instalment.
Many thanks to Bookouture for an ARC.
You can also find my reviews posted here on my blog.
August 19, 2019
Mini review: a random selection from my TBR pile that came up aces. I really enjoyed this police procedural set in Ireland. The MC has a bit of a cliched background but his personality makes him interesting.
After being sent to what he perceives as "the sticks", Finnegan Beck just wants to keep his head down until he can reclaim his previous more prestigious position. He may be grouchy & antisocial but is a true detective at heart & can't abide a poorly run investigation. The plot is layered & well paced, keeping the reader guessing as to the identity of the killer. Loved the setting & look forward to book #2.
After being sent to what he perceives as "the sticks", Finnegan Beck just wants to keep his head down until he can reclaim his previous more prestigious position. He may be grouchy & antisocial but is a true detective at heart & can't abide a poorly run investigation. The plot is layered & well paced, keeping the reader guessing as to the identity of the killer. Loved the setting & look forward to book #2.
January 10, 2019
4.5 stars!
One small town. One crazed killer. One devastating secret.
I have a weak spot for broken male characters with issues - I prefer them being cops *blush* - who are not perfect but who are able with their smart-ass-personality, their loyalty and sensibility to captivate you within no time at all.
Detective Finnegan Beck has a potential to become one of my favorite underdogs.
With his impressive debut novel The Quiet Hours Michael Scanlon cast a spell over me. I hope for more of Finnegan Beck in the future.
If you like Harry Hole Series by Jo Nesbø, you shouldn't miss this one. Finnegan Beck reminds me a lot of Harry Hole, not only because of his brilliant detective skills, his personal attitudes and his affinity to act on his own, but also because of hisabuse of alcohol complicated relationship to alcohol.
A very impressive debut novel. Everything in this novel is just right: the characters, even the secondary ones are really good developed, the setting (a small Irish coast town), the mystery, the pace of the story, the writing, the balance between the gripping moments and humor.
I don't want to give a lot away. The blurb gives you everything you have to know to decide if you want to give it a go.
I can't recommend this book highly enough!
***ARC provided kindly by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.***
One small town. One crazed killer. One devastating secret.
I have a weak spot for broken male characters with issues - I prefer them being cops *blush* - who are not perfect but who are able with their smart-ass-personality, their loyalty and sensibility to captivate you within no time at all.
Detective Finnegan Beck has a potential to become one of my favorite underdogs.
With his impressive debut novel The Quiet Hours Michael Scanlon cast a spell over me. I hope for more of Finnegan Beck in the future.
If you like Harry Hole Series by Jo Nesbø, you shouldn't miss this one. Finnegan Beck reminds me a lot of Harry Hole, not only because of his brilliant detective skills, his personal attitudes and his affinity to act on his own, but also because of his
A very impressive debut novel. Everything in this novel is just right: the characters, even the secondary ones are really good developed, the setting (a small Irish coast town), the mystery, the pace of the story, the writing, the balance between the gripping moments and humor.
I don't want to give a lot away. The blurb gives you everything you have to know to decide if you want to give it a go.
I can't recommend this book highly enough!
***ARC provided kindly by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.***
August 21, 2019
Where She Lies, previously entitled The Quiet Hours, is the first book in the DS Finnegan Beck series.
DS Beck has been demoted from his Supervisor position in Dublin and relocated in disgrace to a very small Irish town, where he mainly wants to drink and try to sleep without the nightmares. His supervisors have no respect for him, but Beck is the police officer in charge and when a teenage girl is found in the woods, strangled to death, it is up to him to locate the killer.
He's learning that living in a small town means that almost everyone knows the other, and they all have secrets and things to hide.
But this isn't the only body that will be discovered....
One small town. One crazed killer. One devastating secret.
This is a debut novel filled with memorable characters. Beck may be flawed, but he's a brilliant detective who is like a bull dog when it comes to finding justice for the victims. it's well written, nicely paced, with lots of action.
Many thanks to the author / Bookouture / Netgalley for the digital copy of this crime fiction. Read and reviewed voluntarily, opinions expressed here are unbiased and entirely my own.
February 13, 2019
Where She Lies is the first instalment in a brand-new Irish crime series featuring Detective Finnegan Beck. A former inspector, Beck finds himself demoted to Sergeant in the small Irish town of Cross Beg. His main objective is to return to Dublin and not get too involved in whatever goes on in Cross Beg. But when a young girl is found murdered in the woods, Beck can’t help digging deeper.
Cross Beg isn’t exactly what Beck imagined it to be. For a town so small, where everyone seems to know everyone else’s business, there are a lot of secrets and skeletons in the closets and everyone seems to have something to hide. The murdered girl too was up to all sorts. She may have had a boyfriend but nobody knows who it is. Is he responsible for her murder? Police zero in on a suspect but when this person is found dead as well, does this mean the case is closed or is it merely the start of something far more sinister?
The investigation is a frustrating one. There are no clues to speak of so where does one even begin to look for a killer? With a lot of the town residents acting shifty and suspiciously, I had no idea whatsoever as to who was responsible or why. I must admit that I didn’t particularly connect to any of these characters. Yet Michael Scanlon managed to hold my attention because he gives very little away and I felt compelled to keep reading until the truth was revealed.
Finnegan Beck stands out from the crowd with an intriguing backstory as to why he ended up in this town in the first place. Beck is damaged, flawed and has a drinking problem. But he also has that fascinating copper’s nose and is immensely perceptive. I think he might be one of those characters that will get increasingly more interesting when the reader gets to know him better.
All in all a solid start to a new series and it’ll be interesting to see where Michael Scanlon takes Beck next.
Cross Beg isn’t exactly what Beck imagined it to be. For a town so small, where everyone seems to know everyone else’s business, there are a lot of secrets and skeletons in the closets and everyone seems to have something to hide. The murdered girl too was up to all sorts. She may have had a boyfriend but nobody knows who it is. Is he responsible for her murder? Police zero in on a suspect but when this person is found dead as well, does this mean the case is closed or is it merely the start of something far more sinister?
The investigation is a frustrating one. There are no clues to speak of so where does one even begin to look for a killer? With a lot of the town residents acting shifty and suspiciously, I had no idea whatsoever as to who was responsible or why. I must admit that I didn’t particularly connect to any of these characters. Yet Michael Scanlon managed to hold my attention because he gives very little away and I felt compelled to keep reading until the truth was revealed.
Finnegan Beck stands out from the crowd with an intriguing backstory as to why he ended up in this town in the first place. Beck is damaged, flawed and has a drinking problem. But he also has that fascinating copper’s nose and is immensely perceptive. I think he might be one of those characters that will get increasingly more interesting when the reader gets to know him better.
All in all a solid start to a new series and it’ll be interesting to see where Michael Scanlon takes Beck next.
February 23, 2019
Where She Lies, previously titled The Quiet Hours, is an impressive police procedural novel set in Galway, Ireland, by a first time author, featuring a damaged alcoholic detective with an odd name tracking a serial killer. Yes, you’ve read it all before, but the points of difference are the small town Irish rather than British or American setting, and the evocative writing.
Finnegan Beck, demoted from Inspector and exiled to the run-down town of Cross Beg after a Garda operation in Dublin went horribly wrong, doesn’t really want to get involved when a teenager is strangled in the woods, but his instincts that the lonely alcoholic who found her body can’t be the murderer mean he can’t help himself. When the body count starts rising rapidly, and the victims get closer to home, Beck will need all his wits to defeat the killer.
I enjoyed this and while I suspected who the killer was as soon as they were introduced, I did not work out the twist or their motives. Beck is not a likeable hero and I had hoped for more explanation of the demons that plague him, which I suspect will come in later books. I liked his partner Clare and there were some intriguing minor characters, and enough suspects to keep me interested.
I do have a few quibbles: at one point the detectives are given a suspect through the evidence, but we are not told who - to me this is cheating, we should get the name when they do, it wouldn’t have altered the plot. There is a stomach-churning but fortunately brief scene of animal brutality towards a dog (tbh had it been a cat I would’ve abandoned it there and then), which is then referenced again, purely for ick factor. There’s mention of historical torture of a cat but it’s not described, and another scene where a character threatens to assault their dog. Somehow I don’t think the author likes animals much, as while there is violence towards humans, it’s not described anywhere as graphically. Finally another body is discovered, that has been buried for years, completely coincidentally, just when the killer is escalating: this is lazy writing but I’m more forgiving with a first time author.
Despite these, which I fully acknowledge are my particular bugbears and probably wouldn’t bother most readers, I would be keen to continue this series and find out what happens. My thanks to NetGalley for the arc in exchange for an honest review, and my apologies that it is late. Where She Lies is available now.
Finnegan Beck, demoted from Inspector and exiled to the run-down town of Cross Beg after a Garda operation in Dublin went horribly wrong, doesn’t really want to get involved when a teenager is strangled in the woods, but his instincts that the lonely alcoholic who found her body can’t be the murderer mean he can’t help himself. When the body count starts rising rapidly, and the victims get closer to home, Beck will need all his wits to defeat the killer.
I enjoyed this and while I suspected who the killer was as soon as they were introduced, I did not work out the twist or their motives. Beck is not a likeable hero and I had hoped for more explanation of the demons that plague him, which I suspect will come in later books. I liked his partner Clare and there were some intriguing minor characters, and enough suspects to keep me interested.
I do have a few quibbles: at one point the detectives are given a suspect through the evidence, but we are not told who - to me this is cheating, we should get the name when they do, it wouldn’t have altered the plot. There is a stomach-churning but fortunately brief scene of animal brutality towards a dog (tbh had it been a cat I would’ve abandoned it there and then), which is then referenced again, purely for ick factor. There’s mention of historical torture of a cat but it’s not described, and another scene where a character threatens to assault their dog. Somehow I don’t think the author likes animals much, as while there is violence towards humans, it’s not described anywhere as graphically. Finally another body is discovered, that has been buried for years, completely coincidentally, just when the killer is escalating: this is lazy writing but I’m more forgiving with a first time author.
Despite these, which I fully acknowledge are my particular bugbears and probably wouldn’t bother most readers, I would be keen to continue this series and find out what happens. My thanks to NetGalley for the arc in exchange for an honest review, and my apologies that it is late. Where She Lies is available now.
April 3, 2019
"To follow the crow one must first become a hawk."
Detective Finnegan Beck has been demoted to Sergeant in the Garda pending an investigation up at his former precinct in Dublin. Sent to Cross Beg to lick his wounds, Beck feels out of place and out of time in the tiny town in South Galway. He soon finds himself in the middle of an extremely complicated case involving a series of murders. Partnered with newlywed Detective Garda Claire Somers, the pair start looking a bit closer into the townspeople, especially those connected to the first victim, 15-year-old Tanya Frazzali. Her body was found in Cool Wood; she'd been strangled, had recent sexual intercourse, and was rumored to have a secret, much older boyfriend. Beck and Somers try to get going on the investigation but are hampered because of Beck's disgrace and he is kept away from the case. No matter, he is good at what he does, and he's going to find a work around. Make no mistake, there's evil roaming the streets and alleys of Cross Beg and Beck is on the job. NO SPOILERS.
I enjoyed this first of a new series featuring Beck though he is indeed another messed up tortured detective who is prone to depression and the bottle without much to redeem him except that he happens to be good at his job. Policing is what he does, he lives alone, and doesn't suffer fools. It will be interesting to see how and if he grows and changes in the next books. The only "off" note to me was the constant dream sequences -- I'm not a fan. We do hear the voice of the killer in italics narration interspersed through the chapters, but really only get vague suggestions of what caused his psychopathy -- severe as it was. It was an interesting plot with a lingering tease as the author doled out clues and hints. I am a fan of a good police procedural and look forward to reading more.
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for this e-book ARC to read and review. The title on mine was different -- THE QUIET HOURS -- and actually, I prefer that to the new one. Though actually neither really fits the book plot. The cover is great!
Detective Finnegan Beck has been demoted to Sergeant in the Garda pending an investigation up at his former precinct in Dublin. Sent to Cross Beg to lick his wounds, Beck feels out of place and out of time in the tiny town in South Galway. He soon finds himself in the middle of an extremely complicated case involving a series of murders. Partnered with newlywed Detective Garda Claire Somers, the pair start looking a bit closer into the townspeople, especially those connected to the first victim, 15-year-old Tanya Frazzali. Her body was found in Cool Wood; she'd been strangled, had recent sexual intercourse, and was rumored to have a secret, much older boyfriend. Beck and Somers try to get going on the investigation but are hampered because of Beck's disgrace and he is kept away from the case. No matter, he is good at what he does, and he's going to find a work around. Make no mistake, there's evil roaming the streets and alleys of Cross Beg and Beck is on the job. NO SPOILERS.
I enjoyed this first of a new series featuring Beck though he is indeed another messed up tortured detective who is prone to depression and the bottle without much to redeem him except that he happens to be good at his job. Policing is what he does, he lives alone, and doesn't suffer fools. It will be interesting to see how and if he grows and changes in the next books. The only "off" note to me was the constant dream sequences -- I'm not a fan. We do hear the voice of the killer in italics narration interspersed through the chapters, but really only get vague suggestions of what caused his psychopathy -- severe as it was. It was an interesting plot with a lingering tease as the author doled out clues and hints. I am a fan of a good police procedural and look forward to reading more.
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for this e-book ARC to read and review. The title on mine was different -- THE QUIET HOURS -- and actually, I prefer that to the new one. Though actually neither really fits the book plot. The cover is great!
March 10, 2019
This review was originally posted on Between My Lines
Well when I heard that Where She Lies by Michael Scanlon was the start of new gripping Irish Detective series, I knew that was a blog tour I HAD to join. Thanks Bookouture for making my wish happen.
First Line of Where She Lies by Michael Scanlon
“She cursed herself for having agreed to meet him in the forest.”
My Thoughts on Where She Lies by Michael Scanlon
I thought this was a cracking debut novel, with lots of potential for further development of the characters. Beck has been shuttled off from a busy Dublin Garda Station, to a small town station and demoted a few rungs on the ladder too. Then, we left hanging on for the reason why, which made me tear through the pages as I was intrigued.
I will say that Beck represents a detective we have seen in many other books and films. Quirky, clever, fond of a drink, murky past, willing to bend the rules to get his man. But I still attached quickly to him, and enjoyed watching him trying to resist getting involved in the murder investigation, but being pulled in anyway.
The death count mounts quickly in this sleepy town and while I thought I knew whodunnit it. I wasn’t even close! And I love when an author catches me out like. The atmosphere was dark and gristly, with some scenes causing shivers to run up and down by back.
Overall I really enjoyed it, and look forward to more in this police procedural series. And more time with Beck.
Who Should read Where She Lies by Michael Scanlon?
I’d recommend this to fans of psychological thrillers with gripping plots, or if you like Irish settings and to those who like to be kept guessing. Fans of With Our Blessing by Jo Spain and Can Anybody Help Me by Sinead Crowley should also enjoy.
Thanks to Bookouture for giving me for giving me a copy of this book for review consideration. As always, no matter what the source of the book, you get my honest, unbiased opinion.
Well when I heard that Where She Lies by Michael Scanlon was the start of new gripping Irish Detective series, I knew that was a blog tour I HAD to join. Thanks Bookouture for making my wish happen.
First Line of Where She Lies by Michael Scanlon
“She cursed herself for having agreed to meet him in the forest.”
My Thoughts on Where She Lies by Michael Scanlon
I thought this was a cracking debut novel, with lots of potential for further development of the characters. Beck has been shuttled off from a busy Dublin Garda Station, to a small town station and demoted a few rungs on the ladder too. Then, we left hanging on for the reason why, which made me tear through the pages as I was intrigued.
I will say that Beck represents a detective we have seen in many other books and films. Quirky, clever, fond of a drink, murky past, willing to bend the rules to get his man. But I still attached quickly to him, and enjoyed watching him trying to resist getting involved in the murder investigation, but being pulled in anyway.
The death count mounts quickly in this sleepy town and while I thought I knew whodunnit it. I wasn’t even close! And I love when an author catches me out like. The atmosphere was dark and gristly, with some scenes causing shivers to run up and down by back.
Overall I really enjoyed it, and look forward to more in this police procedural series. And more time with Beck.
Who Should read Where She Lies by Michael Scanlon?
I’d recommend this to fans of psychological thrillers with gripping plots, or if you like Irish settings and to those who like to be kept guessing. Fans of With Our Blessing by Jo Spain and Can Anybody Help Me by Sinead Crowley should also enjoy.
Thanks to Bookouture for giving me for giving me a copy of this book for review consideration. As always, no matter what the source of the book, you get my honest, unbiased opinion.
December 1, 2019
4.5 Stars, very good.
December 25, 2018
What begins as an investigation into the murder of a teenage schoolgirl escalates swiftly into the hunt for a devious killer who may have gone unnoticed for decades. Set in the fictional rural Irish town of Cross Beg, the story opens with the discovery of the girl's body, found strangled in woods close to the town. Detective Finnegan ("Finn" for short) Beck has been demoted from his job as a detective inspector in Dublin and sent to Cross Beg, in Galway, where he believes he will die from boredom. The death of the young girl changes all that.
Suspicion falls on an unemployed local who called the police after, he claims, he found the dead girl's body and Finn's instincts tell him the man is telling the truth. Beck is a heavy drinker who suffers terrible nightmares and has a messy personal life. He is partnered with a younger female detective, Claire and the two uncover a series of secrets which turn the case on its head. Then, there's another murder and bodies start to turn up all over the place - 3 random killings inside a week seems excessive, especially for this backwater town.
Despite being constantly hindered and reprimanded by his bosses, Beck continues his maverick-style investigation and discovers that some of Cross Beg's seemingly respectable citizens are hiding secrets - some personal, some criminal - which will have a disastrous effect on many people's lives. His direct methods upset his superiors but, each time he's proved right, they relent and allow him to carry on.
We learn a lot about Beck's background, which includes a broken marriage and the reason for him losing his high-powered police post in Dublin. There are only sketchy details about the other main characters, but, as this is the first of a trilogy featuring Finnegan Beck, it's possible we'll learn more about them in future stories. Every few chapters, we get an insight into the thoughts of the killer who has a tendency to philosophise about his actions. Similarly, at various points in the story, we are given details of Beck's nightmares.
Meanwhile, the latter's interview of a long retired police sergeant brings some startling revelations about past crimes and misdemeanours in the town.
This is the debut of Irish crime novelist Michael Scanlon. He's a civilian employee of the An Garda Siochana (the Irish police force), so his documenting of police procedure in Beck & Claire's investigation and the work of crime scene staff and pathologists, is first rate. The action moves along at a brisk pace and his use of the killer's thoughts serves to advance the story relatively smoothly. Finn Beck is a likeable character even if, at times, he can seem a bit smug. This is great crime thriller - fine work from a first time crime writer - and I look forward to reading more about Finn Beck.
My thanks to the publishers, Bookouture, and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in return for an unbiased review.
Suspicion falls on an unemployed local who called the police after, he claims, he found the dead girl's body and Finn's instincts tell him the man is telling the truth. Beck is a heavy drinker who suffers terrible nightmares and has a messy personal life. He is partnered with a younger female detective, Claire and the two uncover a series of secrets which turn the case on its head. Then, there's another murder and bodies start to turn up all over the place - 3 random killings inside a week seems excessive, especially for this backwater town.
Despite being constantly hindered and reprimanded by his bosses, Beck continues his maverick-style investigation and discovers that some of Cross Beg's seemingly respectable citizens are hiding secrets - some personal, some criminal - which will have a disastrous effect on many people's lives. His direct methods upset his superiors but, each time he's proved right, they relent and allow him to carry on.
We learn a lot about Beck's background, which includes a broken marriage and the reason for him losing his high-powered police post in Dublin. There are only sketchy details about the other main characters, but, as this is the first of a trilogy featuring Finnegan Beck, it's possible we'll learn more about them in future stories. Every few chapters, we get an insight into the thoughts of the killer who has a tendency to philosophise about his actions. Similarly, at various points in the story, we are given details of Beck's nightmares.
Meanwhile, the latter's interview of a long retired police sergeant brings some startling revelations about past crimes and misdemeanours in the town.
This is the debut of Irish crime novelist Michael Scanlon. He's a civilian employee of the An Garda Siochana (the Irish police force), so his documenting of police procedure in Beck & Claire's investigation and the work of crime scene staff and pathologists, is first rate. The action moves along at a brisk pace and his use of the killer's thoughts serves to advance the story relatively smoothly. Finn Beck is a likeable character even if, at times, he can seem a bit smug. This is great crime thriller - fine work from a first time crime writer - and I look forward to reading more about Finn Beck.
My thanks to the publishers, Bookouture, and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in return for an unbiased review.
February 8, 2019
It’s nice reading series, because every new book is like meeting up with ‘friends’, but I also like first parts of series and when they are debuts moreover, it gives a special touch.
Apart from trying to figure out who the culprits are, I also have to get to know the team. Finn Beck is the main character and the author certainly does a good job in keeping me guessing why he ended up here. Little by little he feeds us bits of information about his background without letting us forget about the crime that is going on.
I like the way the story was structured and I was as curieus about the person Finn Beck as I was about the exposure of the murderer. The author also gives us a glimpse in the head of the criminal.
In my opinion it was a good debut that formed a perfect base to build upon and turn the series into must reads. 4 stars.
Thank you, Michael Scanlon, Bookouture and Netgalley for providing a review copy.
https://bforbookreview.wordpress.com
Apart from trying to figure out who the culprits are, I also have to get to know the team. Finn Beck is the main character and the author certainly does a good job in keeping me guessing why he ended up here. Little by little he feeds us bits of information about his background without letting us forget about the crime that is going on.
I like the way the story was structured and I was as curieus about the person Finn Beck as I was about the exposure of the murderer. The author also gives us a glimpse in the head of the criminal.
In my opinion it was a good debut that formed a perfect base to build upon and turn the series into must reads. 4 stars.
Thank you, Michael Scanlon, Bookouture and Netgalley for providing a review copy.
https://bforbookreview.wordpress.com
December 27, 2018
In a town full of liars, no one is safe.
When Detective Finnegan Beck is demoted from his high-powered job in Dublin and relocated in disgrace to the small Irish town of Cross Beg, he predicts boredom will be his biggest threat.
It’s a sleepy backwater, a forgotten town of narrow alleyways that lead from the cathedral down to the river, and towards the bogland beyond. It’s a place where seemingly nothing – good nor bad – has happened. Not for a long time.
But when a teenage girl is found dead in the woods a mile from town, and a seemingly-harmless local drifter is arrested, Beck has an instinct that someone with far darker motives is behind the crime.
It seems that everyone in Cross Beg has something to hide though. Wading through layers and layers of lies, and generations upon generations of secrets, he believes he’s finally getting closer to the truth.
That is, until the killer strikes again…
This debut novel from a powerful new Irish voice is the first in a gripping series that will feature his charismatic detective, Finnegan Beck.
My thoughts
rating 4 stars
Great start to a new series as will to a new author , as soon as I read what was on the cover the cover in town full of lairs no one is safe I knew had to see if i could get it to read, and what can i say i actually likes it way better then I thought I was going to , I loved how the main character at times reminded my of Hercule Poirot's and that he had flaws that he knew about and that he wasn't going to let them stop him, I also liked that one of the characters has a hand in the LGBTQIA , and I can't wait to read more by this author or from this series. With this said I would like to thank Netgalley for letting me read and review it in a change for my honest opinion
When Detective Finnegan Beck is demoted from his high-powered job in Dublin and relocated in disgrace to the small Irish town of Cross Beg, he predicts boredom will be his biggest threat.
It’s a sleepy backwater, a forgotten town of narrow alleyways that lead from the cathedral down to the river, and towards the bogland beyond. It’s a place where seemingly nothing – good nor bad – has happened. Not for a long time.
But when a teenage girl is found dead in the woods a mile from town, and a seemingly-harmless local drifter is arrested, Beck has an instinct that someone with far darker motives is behind the crime.
It seems that everyone in Cross Beg has something to hide though. Wading through layers and layers of lies, and generations upon generations of secrets, he believes he’s finally getting closer to the truth.
That is, until the killer strikes again…
This debut novel from a powerful new Irish voice is the first in a gripping series that will feature his charismatic detective, Finnegan Beck.
My thoughts
rating 4 stars
Great start to a new series as will to a new author , as soon as I read what was on the cover the cover in town full of lairs no one is safe I knew had to see if i could get it to read, and what can i say i actually likes it way better then I thought I was going to , I loved how the main character at times reminded my of Hercule Poirot's and that he had flaws that he knew about and that he wasn't going to let them stop him, I also liked that one of the characters has a hand in the LGBTQIA , and I can't wait to read more by this author or from this series. With this said I would like to thank Netgalley for letting me read and review it in a change for my honest opinion
January 28, 2019
For a debut novel .... not bad! The beginning was a little slow and I found myself having a hard time connecting to the characters. I continued on and I'm glad I did. About 2/3 of the way through, I found that I couldn't put it down and had to see how it ended. The ending did not disappoint. I will definitley give book 2 in this series (if there is one) a chance.
Thank you#netgalley and #bookoutore for the eARC.
Thank you#netgalley and #bookoutore for the eARC.
February 28, 2019
WHERE SHE LIES in the first in a brand new Irish crime series by Michael Scanlon. It was previously published as THE QUIET HOURS.
A former inspector in Dublin, Detective Finnegan Beck finds himself not only demoted back to Detective Sergeant but transferred to a sleepy backwater town called Cross Beg situated in County Galway. His main objective? To do his job, keep his head down and not get too involved in whatever goes on in the village. The less involved he is, the quicker he can return to Dublin and his life there.
But then 15 year old Tanya Frazzali is found dead in the woods and Beck cannot sit back and watch his superiors lay the crime at the feet of an innocent man. Beck instinctively believes that there are darker motives at play and it isn't long before more deaths follow - despite their differing methods. However, police politics dictate that Beck must tow the line and refer to his superiors with regard to the case, who look down on him with somewhat distaste. However, Beck finds an ally in his detective constable Claire Somers as they question the Frazzali family and possible suspects.
Beck also has somewhat of an ally in forensic pathologist Dr Gumbell, and together they seem to spend several nights in one of the town's many pubs. This was the part I grew weary of. So many police prodeural mysteries see cops drinking themselves into oblivion most nights, and for me it isn't an integral part of the story. I get tired of it and it could well do without it.
WHERE SHE LIES moves along at a relatively good pace - not fast but not slow either. Just enough to keep you interested and reading for more. The suspect pool changes along the way as suspicion moves from one to another...until the reveal in the end.
Apart from the mystery, WHERE SHE LIES is as much about Beck and his story, as we learn pieces of information about him along the way. He has his own troubles but it doesn't stop his ability to solve the case. He is rather likeable as is his DC Claire Somers. They work well together and are a likeable team.
WHERE SHE LIES is an enjoyable debut with lots of thrills and twists. I definitely recommend it though I cannot compare it to any other series as to me, Finnegan Beck is one of a kind. I certainly hope to read more of him in the future.
I would like to thank #MichaelScanlon, #NetGalley and #Bookouture for an ARC of #WhereSheLies in exchange for an honest review.
This review appears on my blog at https://stinathebookaholic.blogspot.com/.
A former inspector in Dublin, Detective Finnegan Beck finds himself not only demoted back to Detective Sergeant but transferred to a sleepy backwater town called Cross Beg situated in County Galway. His main objective? To do his job, keep his head down and not get too involved in whatever goes on in the village. The less involved he is, the quicker he can return to Dublin and his life there.
But then 15 year old Tanya Frazzali is found dead in the woods and Beck cannot sit back and watch his superiors lay the crime at the feet of an innocent man. Beck instinctively believes that there are darker motives at play and it isn't long before more deaths follow - despite their differing methods. However, police politics dictate that Beck must tow the line and refer to his superiors with regard to the case, who look down on him with somewhat distaste. However, Beck finds an ally in his detective constable Claire Somers as they question the Frazzali family and possible suspects.
Beck also has somewhat of an ally in forensic pathologist Dr Gumbell, and together they seem to spend several nights in one of the town's many pubs. This was the part I grew weary of. So many police prodeural mysteries see cops drinking themselves into oblivion most nights, and for me it isn't an integral part of the story. I get tired of it and it could well do without it.
WHERE SHE LIES moves along at a relatively good pace - not fast but not slow either. Just enough to keep you interested and reading for more. The suspect pool changes along the way as suspicion moves from one to another...until the reveal in the end.
Apart from the mystery, WHERE SHE LIES is as much about Beck and his story, as we learn pieces of information about him along the way. He has his own troubles but it doesn't stop his ability to solve the case. He is rather likeable as is his DC Claire Somers. They work well together and are a likeable team.
WHERE SHE LIES is an enjoyable debut with lots of thrills and twists. I definitely recommend it though I cannot compare it to any other series as to me, Finnegan Beck is one of a kind. I certainly hope to read more of him in the future.
I would like to thank #MichaelScanlon, #NetGalley and #Bookouture for an ARC of #WhereSheLies in exchange for an honest review.
This review appears on my blog at https://stinathebookaholic.blogspot.com/.
January 12, 2023
I added this one to my TBR shelf a few years ago. Something about it obviously intrigued me at the time and not sure how I even cam across it. Undoubtedly I was drawn to the blurb about the main character, Detective Finnegan Beck, disgraced, demoted and relocated from Dublin to the Irish town of Cross Beg. Damaged detectives draw me in - I find the characterisation of these characters really intriguing - there’s something about the vulnerability of humanity that engrosses me. Finnegan Beck is no exception and I relished getting to know him a little in this tale - “Where She Lies” by Irish author, Michael Scanlon.
“Where she lies” is a story that hovers between a thriller and a good murder mystery. It leans slightly more to the thriller side which interests me less as opposed to the mystery element and characterisation and description of place. But there were enough of those two elements to keep me intrigued and certainly keen to read the next two instalments of this series.
Essentially, Beck (not quite Martin Beck of Scandi Noir fame) finds himself in a small Irish town following his relocation from Dublin and quickly becomes embroiled in a serial murder investigation that seems to ricochet all over the place. The plot takes a number of twists and turns with the usual red herrings and overall is a great read and an extremely commendable debut novel from Scanlon. I’ll be back for more of this Irish Beck. 4 stars.
“Where she lies” is a story that hovers between a thriller and a good murder mystery. It leans slightly more to the thriller side which interests me less as opposed to the mystery element and characterisation and description of place. But there were enough of those two elements to keep me intrigued and certainly keen to read the next two instalments of this series.
Essentially, Beck (not quite Martin Beck of Scandi Noir fame) finds himself in a small Irish town following his relocation from Dublin and quickly becomes embroiled in a serial murder investigation that seems to ricochet all over the place. The plot takes a number of twists and turns with the usual red herrings and overall is a great read and an extremely commendable debut novel from Scanlon. I’ll be back for more of this Irish Beck. 4 stars.
December 30, 2018
I got this as a e book from Net Galley. I enjoyed reading it. It had a good story to it. I liked the variety of characters in it. It is my first book read by this author. I hope to read more books by this author.
January 7, 2019
I would like to thank Netgalley and Bookouture for an advance copy of The Quiet Hours, the first novel to feature DS Finnegan Beck, set in the rural Irish town of Cross Beg.
Beck has been demoted and transferred from Pease Street, the busiest station in Dublin, to rural Cross Beg where nothing happens. His plan is to keep his head down, not get involved and wait out his disgrace and he sticks to it until a teenage girl is murdered when Inspector O’Reilly’s ineptitude forces him to take an interest.
I enjoyed The Quiet Hours which has a well concealed perpetrator and therefore is a good whodunnit. There is nothing particularly new in the premise with a deranged perpetrator, revealed as deranged through various italicised monologues throughout the novel, being hunted by a troubled detective, a high body count and various suspects but, as ever, the author puts his own spin on it and has produced a very acceptable, readable debut. Surprisingly, given the events, but perhaps in keeping with the title it is quite a muted read and doesn’t have the high octane impact of similar novels. I enjoyed the sedateness which gives the reader time to reflect on the investigation and have a few guesses (all wrong in my case).
Finnegan Beck is a character whom I’m sure I will come to love as the series develops. As it stands he’s a bit of a cliché with both drink and commitment issues and the mysterious demotion. The demotion is explained over the course of the novel and doesn’t quite ring true (surely An Garda Síochána would wait for the results of an enquiry before acting) but it allows for an exploration of rural living but the reason for his other tics isn’t so more to anticipate in the sequel. On the other hand he is a smart investigator and Mr Scanlon creates a good, believable scenario with the inept locals resenting the skills of the big city detective.
The Quiet Hours is a good read which I have no hesitation in recommending.
Beck has been demoted and transferred from Pease Street, the busiest station in Dublin, to rural Cross Beg where nothing happens. His plan is to keep his head down, not get involved and wait out his disgrace and he sticks to it until a teenage girl is murdered when Inspector O’Reilly’s ineptitude forces him to take an interest.
I enjoyed The Quiet Hours which has a well concealed perpetrator and therefore is a good whodunnit. There is nothing particularly new in the premise with a deranged perpetrator, revealed as deranged through various italicised monologues throughout the novel, being hunted by a troubled detective, a high body count and various suspects but, as ever, the author puts his own spin on it and has produced a very acceptable, readable debut. Surprisingly, given the events, but perhaps in keeping with the title it is quite a muted read and doesn’t have the high octane impact of similar novels. I enjoyed the sedateness which gives the reader time to reflect on the investigation and have a few guesses (all wrong in my case).
Finnegan Beck is a character whom I’m sure I will come to love as the series develops. As it stands he’s a bit of a cliché with both drink and commitment issues and the mysterious demotion. The demotion is explained over the course of the novel and doesn’t quite ring true (surely An Garda Síochána would wait for the results of an enquiry before acting) but it allows for an exploration of rural living but the reason for his other tics isn’t so more to anticipate in the sequel. On the other hand he is a smart investigator and Mr Scanlon creates a good, believable scenario with the inept locals resenting the skills of the big city detective.
The Quiet Hours is a good read which I have no hesitation in recommending.
February 8, 2019
This is a great start to a new crime series.
I really liked the character of Detective Beck and whilst he has his flaws, his heart is in the right place.
Beck is sent to Cross Beg following an incident with his old team.
Soon the body of a teenage girl is found and a murder investigation is underway.
As Beck and Claire investigate the murder secrets of the small village become apparent and send shock waves through the village.
His superiors don’t make Beck’s life easy but he just gets on with job, and I admired his resilience.
Soon other bodies are found and they have to work out what the link is and who is carrying out these crimes.
Whilst the investigation is underway Beck is called back to Dublin and gets news about the incident he was involved in.
He returns to Cross Beg to discover another body and then things start to spiral out of control in the small village.
This is a brilliant new series and I look forward to reading the next book.
Thanks to Bookouture and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book.
I really liked the character of Detective Beck and whilst he has his flaws, his heart is in the right place.
Beck is sent to Cross Beg following an incident with his old team.
Soon the body of a teenage girl is found and a murder investigation is underway.
As Beck and Claire investigate the murder secrets of the small village become apparent and send shock waves through the village.
His superiors don’t make Beck’s life easy but he just gets on with job, and I admired his resilience.
Soon other bodies are found and they have to work out what the link is and who is carrying out these crimes.
Whilst the investigation is underway Beck is called back to Dublin and gets news about the incident he was involved in.
He returns to Cross Beg to discover another body and then things start to spiral out of control in the small village.
This is a brilliant new series and I look forward to reading the next book.
Thanks to Bookouture and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book.
February 2, 2019
Inspector Finnegan Beck has been demoted and sent to Cross Beg, where nothing really happens. He reckons he'd find it easy to stay out of trouble here until the body of a young girl us discovered.
An interesting crime thriller that didn't give away any clues till the very end. A page turner if you like this genre.
Thank you Netgalley and the publishers for the review copy of this book
An interesting crime thriller that didn't give away any clues till the very end. A page turner if you like this genre.
Thank you Netgalley and the publishers for the review copy of this book
March 3, 2019
In this novel set in Ireland, the teen is found strangled in the woods, but is this a random kill, or is there more to it? What ensues is a gritty, atmospheric story that focuses on the lead investigator, Finnegan Beck. Beck may be a brilliant detective but he is also a troubled man with quite a few personal demons and perhaps not enough courage, and/or not enough incentive, to try and slay them. The short chapters propel the story forwards, I once again suffered from the oh-just-one-more-little-chapter syndrome and at about 100 pages from the end I just wanted to cancel all the birthday plans I’d made so I could carry on reading ( for the record: I didn’t, but oh that dreaded social life 😉)
This was an enjoyable read emanating a rather dark vibe and featuring a very interesting protagonist. I’m looking forward to the next Beck novel.
Thanks to Michael Scanlon, Bookouture and NetGalley for allowing me to read an eARC for free in exchange for an honest and unbiassed review.
This was an enjoyable read emanating a rather dark vibe and featuring a very interesting protagonist. I’m looking forward to the next Beck novel.
Thanks to Michael Scanlon, Bookouture and NetGalley for allowing me to read an eARC for free in exchange for an honest and unbiassed review.
February 8, 2019
For full review - The Limit of Books Does Not Exist
I feel like I have read so many novels about detectives who are “disgraced” and have to move to a small town, where crime is non-existent. Once the new detective shows up, lo and behold there is a major crime.
The novel really picked up for me in the last 1/3. It got intense and I was surprised by who the killer was and their story. I wish that a lot of the other storylines (disgraced detective, drinking, flashbacks) were left out since they just added unnecessary details that weren’t helpful to the main story.
I enjoyed the novel and would recommend to those who like crime novels.
Thank you to Netgallery and Bookouture for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
I feel like I have read so many novels about detectives who are “disgraced” and have to move to a small town, where crime is non-existent. Once the new detective shows up, lo and behold there is a major crime.
The novel really picked up for me in the last 1/3. It got intense and I was surprised by who the killer was and their story. I wish that a lot of the other storylines (disgraced detective, drinking, flashbacks) were left out since they just added unnecessary details that weren’t helpful to the main story.
I enjoyed the novel and would recommend to those who like crime novels.
Thank you to Netgallery and Bookouture for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
September 9, 2023
It's been a long time since I've written a book review. Decades. I enter the challenge at this stage in my life not because I'm meeting a requirement, but rather to allow myself to continue growing. I'm grateful to my best friend for encouraging and inspiring me to reignite my love for reading again as an adult.
I'm not a literature nerd. (yet) I am, however, a self-proclaimed music nerd. I listen to music while driving, doing chores, cooking or just being. So, my natural approach here is to attempt to find music to match my reading ventures. To be clear, I do not listen to music while I read. I need to focus on these two pleasures separately. My goal is to pair music with the book I am reading in order to deepen my connection with both art forms.
While reading "Where She Lies" by Michael Scanlon, I found a piece titled "The Site of an Investigation" by Irish composer Jennifer Walshe. In my first listening, I recognized right away that the story told in the music is completely different than that of Scanlon's book. Being a singer, I immediately centered my thoughts and reflection on voice.
If polished Bel Canto singing is what you're in the mood for, this modern symphony for voice and orchestra might not be for you. If, however you're looking for a unique, highly expressive, and evocative vocal style, it might be. Walshe sings her own composition here. The range of emotion of the vocal and orchestral timbres represented in the piece keep you guessing and wanting to discover what's next. Her voice as a composer takes the listener on a ride. From feelings of the grandiose to the subdued; from playful to uneasy and sinister, "Investigation" is an aural page turner. The themes and moods of the symphony are short, change quickly, and demonstrate big, sudden shifts. They are all seamlessly woven together by Walshe's captivating voice; both as a composer and performer.
Scanlon's voice paints detailed pictures of his beautiful characters and the small town of Cross Beg where his story takes place. I love getting to know the characters in a story and want to feel like I know them. Empathize with them. He does just that. The author uncovers bits about his characters at just the right time in the story and continues to reveal more about them as you go. Finnegan Beck is flawed, empathetic, and a guy you want to root for. I can't wait to get to know him better in the next installments of this series.
Much like Walshe's symphony, Scanlon's short chapters (sometimes very short) take the reader on a fast-paced journey. Bouncing from scene to scene in an engaging and thrilling way. It kept me wanting to read:
"I can read one more chapter. It's only two pages long."
"Wait, the next one is only half a page?!"
After reading the Author's note at the end, I also have a better understanding of the source behind this well crafter page turner. Thank you for sharing yourself with the reader.
I wonder: If Michael Scanlon ever set his sights on the cinematic universe, would Walshe's musical style be considered for providing the score? Consider this excerpt from chapter 86 (p.295):
"There was a warmth in the air, the sky a canopy of blue stretching from one end of the world to the other. The weathered old buildings along the crooked streets in the centre of town, those stooped and grey buildings with their black slate roofs latticed in green moss, seemed to stretch before the yellow-washed sun."
and the section of Walshe's music from 30:50 to the end.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xm2yt...
You be the judge.
I'm not a literature nerd. (yet) I am, however, a self-proclaimed music nerd. I listen to music while driving, doing chores, cooking or just being. So, my natural approach here is to attempt to find music to match my reading ventures. To be clear, I do not listen to music while I read. I need to focus on these two pleasures separately. My goal is to pair music with the book I am reading in order to deepen my connection with both art forms.
While reading "Where She Lies" by Michael Scanlon, I found a piece titled "The Site of an Investigation" by Irish composer Jennifer Walshe. In my first listening, I recognized right away that the story told in the music is completely different than that of Scanlon's book. Being a singer, I immediately centered my thoughts and reflection on voice.
If polished Bel Canto singing is what you're in the mood for, this modern symphony for voice and orchestra might not be for you. If, however you're looking for a unique, highly expressive, and evocative vocal style, it might be. Walshe sings her own composition here. The range of emotion of the vocal and orchestral timbres represented in the piece keep you guessing and wanting to discover what's next. Her voice as a composer takes the listener on a ride. From feelings of the grandiose to the subdued; from playful to uneasy and sinister, "Investigation" is an aural page turner. The themes and moods of the symphony are short, change quickly, and demonstrate big, sudden shifts. They are all seamlessly woven together by Walshe's captivating voice; both as a composer and performer.
Scanlon's voice paints detailed pictures of his beautiful characters and the small town of Cross Beg where his story takes place. I love getting to know the characters in a story and want to feel like I know them. Empathize with them. He does just that. The author uncovers bits about his characters at just the right time in the story and continues to reveal more about them as you go. Finnegan Beck is flawed, empathetic, and a guy you want to root for. I can't wait to get to know him better in the next installments of this series.
Much like Walshe's symphony, Scanlon's short chapters (sometimes very short) take the reader on a fast-paced journey. Bouncing from scene to scene in an engaging and thrilling way. It kept me wanting to read:
"I can read one more chapter. It's only two pages long."
"Wait, the next one is only half a page?!"
After reading the Author's note at the end, I also have a better understanding of the source behind this well crafter page turner. Thank you for sharing yourself with the reader.
I wonder: If Michael Scanlon ever set his sights on the cinematic universe, would Walshe's musical style be considered for providing the score? Consider this excerpt from chapter 86 (p.295):
"There was a warmth in the air, the sky a canopy of blue stretching from one end of the world to the other. The weathered old buildings along the crooked streets in the centre of town, those stooped and grey buildings with their black slate roofs latticed in green moss, seemed to stretch before the yellow-washed sun."
and the section of Walshe's music from 30:50 to the end.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xm2yt...
You be the judge.
December 26, 2018
A big thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for the eARC of this excellent book.
I loved this mystery, it was definitely a superior one of this genre. Normally I am not that crazy about stories with serial killers, but somehow this was one I couldn't put down.
Detective 'Finn' Beck has been demoted from his job in Dublin and sent to Cross Beg, a fictional town in Ireland to join the Garda there.The
The murder of a young girl in the woods shocks the town and Finn, partnered with detective Claire, is determined to get the murderer even though he's told it's not his case by his superior, a nasty overinflated character who is determined to make Finn's life a misery.
Soon there's another death...the victim the man who originally found the girl's body is found drowned. Finn is sure it was murder, but his boss wants to close the case by determining the drowned man committed suicide out of guilt over murdering the young girl. More bodies like up; it looks like they have a serial killer in their patch.
Beck is a very sympathetic character; he's been through a lot and suffers from horrific nightmares. He also drinks too much, not making his life easier and endangering his job. There were many instances in which I empathized, understanding his feelings and his reactions to them. I also liked his relationship with Claire. All in all I thought it was a terrific book, hard to put down, with a jaw dropping denouement. Highly recommended and I for one can't wait for the next installment of Beck's trilogy.
I loved this mystery, it was definitely a superior one of this genre. Normally I am not that crazy about stories with serial killers, but somehow this was one I couldn't put down.
Detective 'Finn' Beck has been demoted from his job in Dublin and sent to Cross Beg, a fictional town in Ireland to join the Garda there.The
The murder of a young girl in the woods shocks the town and Finn, partnered with detective Claire, is determined to get the murderer even though he's told it's not his case by his superior, a nasty overinflated character who is determined to make Finn's life a misery.
Soon there's another death...the victim the man who originally found the girl's body is found drowned. Finn is sure it was murder, but his boss wants to close the case by determining the drowned man committed suicide out of guilt over murdering the young girl. More bodies like up; it looks like they have a serial killer in their patch.
Beck is a very sympathetic character; he's been through a lot and suffers from horrific nightmares. He also drinks too much, not making his life easier and endangering his job. There were many instances in which I empathized, understanding his feelings and his reactions to them. I also liked his relationship with Claire. All in all I thought it was a terrific book, hard to put down, with a jaw dropping denouement. Highly recommended and I for one can't wait for the next installment of Beck's trilogy.
February 2, 2019
Beck has been sent to a rural backwater, as punishment from his superiors. He thinks that nothing happens in Cross Beg - he is wrong.
A series of murders occur in Cross Beg and Beck does his best to solve them, despite issues with the drink, with ex partners and ex colleagues too. He is a man in crisis and the author does a good job of portraying him. It would be incredibly boring to read a police procedural such as this, if the main character was some perfect cop, to be honest.
I liked the character of Beck and the secondary characters too. There was a lot going on, after a bit of a slow start, and I am looking forward to reading other books by this author in the future.
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture.
4.5 stars from me.
A series of murders occur in Cross Beg and Beck does his best to solve them, despite issues with the drink, with ex partners and ex colleagues too. He is a man in crisis and the author does a good job of portraying him. It would be incredibly boring to read a police procedural such as this, if the main character was some perfect cop, to be honest.
I liked the character of Beck and the secondary characters too. There was a lot going on, after a bit of a slow start, and I am looking forward to reading other books by this author in the future.
Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture.
4.5 stars from me.
Want to read
January 16, 2019Well, this was a really enjoyable book. Honestly, in the beginning I struggled to get through the pages but it soon had me gripped and ended up being quite a page turner. The characters in this books were quite well created and I enjoyed getting to know them. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend this book and a big thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for giving me the chance to read this ARC in exchange of my honest review.
October 17, 2023
Bloody brilliant plot twist!!
August 15, 2024
If you are looking for a cozy, comfy crime mystery, this isn’t for you. Where She Lies features Detective Finnegan Beck who was demoted from an Inspector position in Dublin and pushed out to serve as a sargeant in a small town. He’s a miserable, heavy drinking cop, but he has to step up and get to work trying to catch a serial killer.
January 5, 2019
This is an action packed thriller with lots of twist and surprises. Beck is investigating the murder of a young girl and as the story progresses the author unveils the true face of the town. Very well written and the story unravels at an even pace that is easy to follow. An intriguing mystery.
Thank you Netgalley for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you Netgalley for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 108 reviews