Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Melissa Craig #9

Murder at Benbury Brook

Rate this book
A babbling brook runs alongside a wooded glade, surrounded by autumn light and birdsong. But next to the stream a young woman lies dead, her once bright blonde hair now limp and lifeless…

Melissa Craig has settled into a new job in the charming Cotswolds village of Upper Benbury. She is teaching French to several of the local teenagers, which gives her a fascinating insight into the young people’s lives. Material for a new novel perhaps…

Her quiet life is interrupted when she sees her new neighbour running out of the woods in a blind panic. Melissa rushes to help him, but what she finds leaves her breathless: the body of young woman is lying on the bank of the river.

When suspicion falls on Melissa’s neighbour, a man with a difficult past trying to make a new start, Melissa feels determined to prove his innocence. With the village in turmoil, and the police sure they’ve got their man, she must act quickly.

As she interviews the local residents, she realises there are several sinister characters lurking inside those charming Cotswold cottages… Could one of them have hurt Cissie? Was it the strange old man with a cottage near the river? Or the ailing ex-choirmaster with quite an eye for the ladies?

When Melissa Craig decides to get her teeth into a case, she doesn’t let go – nothing will stop her from solving this murder. Can she prove the innocence of her new friend? And will she unearth the culprit before another young life is taken?

An absolutely unputdownable murder mystery for fans of Faith Martin, Joy Ellis and P.D. James that will have you hooked right from the start.

What readers are saying about Betty Rowlands:
Hooked from the first pages… wonderful… fascinating, full of twists and turns kept me guessing till the end.’ Goodreads reviewer, 5 stars

Brilliant I read this book in one sitting and could not put it down. I would highly recommend this book to anyone.’ NetGalley Reviewer, 5 stars

An absolutely addictive, wonderful story. Loved it from start to finish. Great pace and a delightful setting, colourful characters and thrilling mystery. This was a brilliant story and I cannot wait for more!’ Renita D’Silva, author of The Forgotten Daughter, 5 stars

Perfect for lovers of COZY CRIME!... I loved this book… This is an easily read book but it will keep you on your toes.’ Goodreads reviewer, 5 stars

Once I started reading I couldn't put it down as it was entertaining and enthralling… The mystery was interesting and it kept me guessing till the endHighly recommended!Scrapping and Playing, 5 stars

The quintessential cozy mystery… the storyline is fast-paced and engaging… builds to an adrenaline fuelled ending, full of action and powerful imagery. An enjoyable, escapist read that I suspect may become my secret addiction.

236 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 1, 2000

1066 people are currently reading
217 people want to read

About the author

Betty Rowlands

47 books142 followers
Betty Rowlands is an member of the Crime Writers' Association and appears on panels at writers' conferences.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
453 (44%)
4 stars
379 (36%)
3 stars
151 (14%)
2 stars
37 (3%)
1 star
8 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews
Profile Image for Helga چـو ایـران نباشد تن من مـباد.
1,394 reviews487 followers
January 28, 2019
An engaging and fast-paced mystery!

The body of a teenager is found near a stream in the woods. Did she slip, fell in the water and drowned? If it was an accident then who pulled the body out of the water? What was the girl doing in the woods and who was she running from?
When Melissa Craig finds out that her new neighbor, whom she believes to be innocent, is implicated because of his finding the body and his presence at the time of the incident, she is determined to find out what exactly happened and help clear the man’s name.

Thanks to the author, Bookouture and the NetGalley for an advanced copy.
Profile Image for 8stitches 9lives.
2,853 reviews1,724 followers
February 16, 2019
Murder at Benbury Brook, the ninth novel in the Melissa Craig Cozy Mystery series, uses the beautiful Cotswolds setting as one of the central aspects of the story and reminds me a lot of the chocolate-box villages portrayed in Midsomer Murders. It's a story that is full of charm and works well as a standalone - it certainly isn't necessary to have read the previous instalments. The author is adept at moulding interesting characters that you really care about, an intriguing plot and the twists and turns throughout make for a satisfying tale. We also get more development of main protagonist Melissa which is exciting to see and book nine is just as exciting as the rest of the series.

It's an engaging mystery with a menacing undertone and chilling atmosphere running through it. Importantly for a cozy there is no profanity, sexual liaisons or blood and gore, and the conclusion was unexpected and satisfying. Previously published as The Man at the Window, fans of Agatha Christie and MC Beaton should enjoy this as well as those who love to read cozies. A superb and highly entertaining addition to an already popular series, and a perfect read for those dark, chilly nights.

Many thanks to Bookouture for an ARC.

You can also find my reviews posted here on my blog.
Profile Image for Laura Butler.
7 reviews3 followers
December 11, 2020
I usually enjoy this author’s books and while I understand that they were written in the late 90’s/ early 2000’s I was a bit perturbed by the attitudes towards the moral issues in the story such as describing a 14 year old girl as a “Randy little baggage,” and considering her partly responsible for being the targeted sexually by a middle aged man. I found it detracted from the story.
Profile Image for Els .
2,271 reviews52 followers
February 25, 2019
Again a great story by this author. We see some ‘old’ characters again, but some have left and new ones are being introduced. It’s always a bit sad to have to say goodbye to them and I missed them, but the author filled the void with quite interesting ones.

In this book we get less information about the private life of Melissa. There is more focus on the case itself and she really excels. Maybe because she had more time on her hands due to the changes in her personal life?

Either way it was a truely enjoyable read and I love the connection between Melissa and Bruce. They work well together and have become friends.

The author has a nice writing style and I am looking forward to book 10. I wonder what Melissa will have to untangle next and how her (love) life is going to develop. 5 stars.

Thank you, Betty Rowlands, Bookouture and Netgalley.

https://bforbookreview.wordpress.com
Profile Image for Vicky D..
131 reviews2 followers
November 1, 2022
I found this book in the Melissa Craig series extremely disappointing. I think a lot of that is due to fact the plot had such potential. Three suspects that kept you guessing only find out in the final pages that 2 of them just gratified themselves in the same room to kiddy porn. These were old men. I just can't put into words how odd it was. You don't expect a book to necessarily be believable but this was too far out there.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Hedi.
654 reviews30 followers
September 23, 2024
Mõnus muhekiri, millest ei puudu haarav põnevus. Külakese elu pööratakse pahupeale, kui noore tüdruku laip leitakse metsast jõe äärest. Kui aga kahtlused langevad Melissa uuele naabrile, siis naine on koheselt asjade ajamise enda peale võtnud, sest ta ei taha mitte kuidagi uskuda, et naabrimees võiks süüdi olla. Küll aga on mehe südamel mured, mis on jäänud tema minevikku, ent nüüd jälle päevavalgusele tulnud.
Soovitan kergema krimi armastajatele.
Profile Image for Heatherinblack .
741 reviews9 followers
April 11, 2019
felt like a gateway book

iris and boyfriend are gone. must establish new friends and habits. not a bad mystery (though a sad one) didn’t keep me enthralled. took like a week to finish it.
Profile Image for K.J. Sweeney.
Author 1 book47 followers
February 1, 2019
Another great book from Betty Rowlands in the Melissa Craig series. I did wonder how she would fare now that Iris, her next door neighbour and close friend had left for France. The arrival of a new neighbour to live, at least for the time being in Iris's cottage soon throws Mel into the midst of another mystery and it isn't long before she finds herself involved in a little sleuthing.

With the changes that happened in the last book, I knew that we were likely to be without a few of the supporting characters from previous books. Although I have always enjoyed reading about them, they weren't really missed her and Mel still had a couple of friendly faces to rely upon.

This time the mystery focuses on the death of a girl was it an accident, or something more sinister? There is also something decidedly seedy going on in the village. It becomes pretty clear what's going on, although there are no graphic descriptions, just enough hints to make it clear what certain characters have been doing. I've said before that I feel that these books are more 'classic mysteries' than cosy mysteries. Although things aren't spelt out as such, I think that the crimes do make these more classic than cosy, but perhaps that's because I tend to be a little dismissive of the term 'cosy' and see it as twee and insubstantial, which these novels certainly aren't.

One of the joys of this series is the way that village life is depicted. I don't know if it's because I grew up in an English village and I relate to this picture, or just because it's so well written, a little of both perhaps? I suppose that there is a little nostalgia too, with these books being set (and written) twenty years or so ago now. That doesn't detract from the enjoyment though, these are great mysteries and a good read, even if the world has moved on a little.

The more of this series I read, the more I enjoy them. I can't wait to see what the next book has in store for Mel.

I received a complimentary copy of this book through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
240 reviews1 follower
March 2, 2019
Another wonderful book!

These are always a joy to read and find out what mischief Melissa will end up in. This time there were circumstances that almost destroyed a mans life, and ended his life. It just so sad what a few rumors about someone can do to destroy a reputation, and drive that person to utter despair. I enjoyed this book very much, except it seemed so different from the past books I didn't give it five stars. Perhaps it was the missing characters of Iris her good friend and neighbor, and Ken, Melissa's former lover and DCI. I know he retired and went into PI work but did he have to move to New York?? I was hoping she might find a connection with Kens former Sargent, Matt, who's now a DI. At least I believe he's a DI. Its hard to keep up with the British form of law enforcement monickers!! Then there's Joe her agent for her books. He's okay, but he's never been a favorite character of mine. I was so happy when she finally got romantically involved with Ken, but that seems to have been done away with. My second pick would be Matt! Also it seems Bruce as done a complete turn around and has settled down. Which is great for him but he isn't that wild reporter anymore that got her into deep trouble with the bad guys, & with the police. Let's see what is it the British call them, the old Bill? I'll have to double check that to make sure it the right word. All in all this is a good book, just not as fast paced or exciting as some of her other adventures. I'm looking forward to seeing what comes up next in Mel's crime fighting escapades!! Maybe shell go see Simon, her son, in New York, & hook up with Ken again!! He changed at the end of the previous book, perhaps he'll be back to his old self, or better yet, Matt will come around and have the guts to ask her out! He's always had a crush on her I could tell!! Can't tell about Iris though, she was always a bit weird. Mel needs another really good friend to give her advice! Matt maybe!! Hahahaha! Yes I've always liked his character!!
Profile Image for Lizzie Hayes.
586 reviews32 followers
October 31, 2023
When Graham Shipley secures a teaching position at St Monica's Preparatory School in a Cotswold village, he feels that his exile is over and that he can begin his life again.

For Melissa Craig, best selling writer of crime fiction, returning from visiting friends in London, the sight of her home Hawthorne Cottage brings its usual feeling of thankfulness. Only tempered with thoughts of nostalgia for the days when her friend Iris Ash lived in the adjoining cottage and would be waiting to hear her news. Since Iris had married and moved away the cottage had been let to a succession of tenants. Almost immediately she meets the new tenant Graham Shipley, he makes it clear that he wishes to keep his distance. However, in a village like Upper Benbury, that is not always easy, and a reluctant Graham finds himself roped in to help with the local rounders match at a village fund raising event, where he meets the village inhabitants and many of his soon to be pupils.

Some days later returning from a shopping trip Melissa Craig sees an agitated Graham Shipley. Investigating, she finds the body of one of the local schoolgirls lying at the edge of the lake.

As the Police investigate things look bleak for Graham Shipley. Melissa discovers that all is not quite what it seems on the surface and sets out to discover the truth about Graham Shipley which may have direct bearing on the death of the young girl.

This is the ninth in the series featuring Melissa Craig and delves into the murky waters of student and teacher relationship. A thought-provoking book dealing with the consequences to both student and teacher once accusations are made.
-------
Reviewer: Lizzie Hayes
Profile Image for Anna.
648 reviews
February 13, 2019
Thank you NetGalley and Bookouture for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

It was an absolute treat to spend time with Melissa Craig once again in Upper Benbury. Much has changed in her life since we last saw her. Her best friend Iris has married and moved to the South of France. Her boyfriend Ken Harris is in America working as a PI.

In addition to writing books Melissa is now tutoring one of the local teenagers in French. She learns a lot from what she learns from her.

Iris has rented out her cottage to a teacher that will be starting in the fall term. He's very private and not overly friendly. Melissa tries to engage him in conversation on several occasions but he doesn't seem to want to talk.

One day she finds him running from the woods after finding the body of Cissie, a teenager from the village. Did he find her or did he kill her? It's not Melissa's job to figure this out but she just can't help getting involved (again). She's sure that the police are wrong in suspecting her new neighbour but she feels if she doesn't get to the bottom of things, he will be sent to prison for something that he didn't do.

There are several interesting characters that live in Upper Benbury....an old hermit who's up to shady things, a former choirmaster that left his post under hushed up circumstances.

A wonderful mystery that has Melissa working hard to prove just who killed Cissie and why.





Profile Image for Lorraine.
1,403 reviews42 followers
March 14, 2019
In this ninth book in the series, Melissa Clark is missing her next door neighbour, Iris. She has a new renter next door in Elder Cottage, a young man who's been hired to teach at a local private school. Graham Stripley is a shy young man, but Mel makes friends with him. Then one day she's driving home, and Graham comes running out of the woods towards her. Together they go to Benbury Brook and find the drowned body of sixteen year old Cissy, a pretty girl who worked at the local shop. Graham insists he "didn't touch her", and Mel believes him, but the police take him away from questioning. Graham's past is revealed by Bruce, the newspaperman. At Graham's previous school, a young girl falsely accused him of making a pass at her, and although he had not been arrested, the stress caused him a breakdown and broke up his marriage.

Mel is determined to find out what happened to Cissy. She had been to the dilapidated cottage of elderly Tommy Judd to deliver some eggs - why had she left the path and plunged into the woods, and then fallen to her death in the brook?

Melissa Craig is a great character. She is writing a novel while investigating, and writes up her notes and hands them off to the police. She visits various people in the village, poking into their lives, while her son and her publisher advise her to leave things alone. I was afraid she would come to grief in this book. Can't wait to read some more!
Profile Image for Tracy Wood.
1,272 reviews28 followers
January 20, 2019
The nineth book in this series is the first without two of the main protagonists but still works on all levels. The stock characters visible in any village tale are well written and their various foibles lovingly created to make you smile, cheer or rant in equal measure.

There is a new neighbour for Melissa, a teacher who has a new job to go to at the end of the summer holidays. Never one to hide away, Mel is friendly in the face of his reluctance and soon becomes his main ally as it seems his world is about to come crashing down.

The storyline this time leads Mel and the police into areas neither expected while investigating an unexplained death and although this is something dealt with in many different literary genres I felt that its prevalence in a small village was very well handled. I worked out some of the issues in this story but as is usual with Betty Rowland's books there are twists and turns which surprise right to the end.

I was able to read an advanced copy of this book thanks to Netgalley and the publishers and would recommend it to anyone who is reading the series in order, you won't be disappointed, or to anyone who enjoys a cosy mystery with a little bit more bite than some.
Profile Image for Cozy Reviews.
2,050 reviews5 followers
February 27, 2019
This is the 9th book in this well loved popular series . I find this series fascinating and always enjoy returning to the small charming Cotswold's village to solve a new mysterious crime. Part of the great joy of reading this series is experiencing the village through the author's eyes. This series can be read out of order if one likes. The author has in every book described the setting and previous charcters for every new reader to understand. The charcters are richly drawn by the author and the investigation is well crafted whodone it to a most pleasing end.

Thank you to the publisher and to Net Galley for the ARC for review. My personal opinion is my own.

Melissa is a savvy adept protagonist who happens to be a crime writer. Her investigation into murders is primary to her writing career. In this next installment a new neighbor adds to the mystery as she begins to solve another murder using her sharp investigative skills. . As the mystery deepens clues abound and soon Melissa is on the right track of solving another murder.

I highly recommend this most entertaining cozy mystery. This is the perfect mystery to read on a cold day curled up with a cuppa .
Profile Image for Fiona Wilson.
Author 2 books57 followers
January 27, 2019
This is the 9th book in the Melissa Craig series and for me it seems to have a different feel to it. I think it is down to the end of the story as it definitely turns out to be a somewhat unique outcome. Don’t get me wrong, I loved the story regardless. At its core it still has a well written mystery running throughout, and Melissa once again finds herself becoming involved in things far more than she means to.

Melissa is a brilliant character. Without even trying she is drawn into matters in her local area more deeply over time. Even without two of the core characters we have grown to love, she is such a strong woman. I still have in the back of my mind the cryptic message she received from Rachel, the gypsy woman in the previous book, that she should give her heart to her true love. I have my ideas of who that could be, yet I also feel that the author may throw a spanner in the works in the future.

I’m loving this series and can’t wait to read more. Many thanks to Bookouture and Netgalley for providing a copy.
Profile Image for Deborah Carr.
31 reviews15 followers
March 1, 2019
Melissa Craig is an author living in the beautiful Cotswolds. She returns home to find that she has a new neighbour, school teacher Graham Shipley. He is a little strange and defensive and when teenager Cissie is found dead suspicion falls on him. Melissa feels the need to prove the locals' suspicions of him are wrong and starts to investigate the murder to find the real culprit.

This is the first book that I've read in this series, but I didn't feel like that mattered. This mystery has an intriguing cast of characters with a glorious setting, which in some way makes the murder seem that much more shocking. I loved the twists and turns and unexpected ending and will definitely read more by Betty Rowlands.

My thanks to Netgalley and Bookouture for this arc copy of Betty Rowlands book.
Profile Image for Marianne.
237 reviews6 followers
January 29, 2019
I am pleased to see the series continues to evolve. Ex-boyfriend Ken Harris is in NYC being a PI, next door neighbor Iris Ash is married and living in the South of France. Graham Shipley, a fortyish teacher has moved into the cottage next door. Apparently he has suffered some type of a break down and is on medication for his nerves. Mel makes a few friendly overtures, but they are not received well.
This has been the darkest of the series, a teenager dies, and Graham is suspected as the murderer.
Another good entry in the series. As always, well drawn characters and strong sense of place.
Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for an electronic ARC, all opinions are my own.
Highly recommended.
Profile Image for Jane Hunt.
Author 3 books114 followers
February 25, 2019
It’s no secret that I love this series, but how can I not? The plots keep getting darker and more menacing, whilst still retaining the essentials of a cosy mystery.

Melissa is a complex protagonist, a crime writer, whose career and private life, often takes second place to her crime solving.

There are new characters to meet, for Melissa and because of the changes in her personal life, Melissa is even more driven to solve the crime that features in this story.

The picturesque Cotswold setting, realistic characters and an interesting twisty plot makes this story an atmospheric, interactive crime-solving mystery.

I received a copy of this book from Bookouture via NetGalley in return for an honest review
Profile Image for Lel Budge.
1,367 reviews31 followers
April 28, 2019
Book #9 by the Marvellous Betty Rowlands in the Melissa Craig series.

Melissa Craig has a new neighbour, now that the artistic Iris has moved to France….I’ll miss her as she is one of my favourite characters, acerbic but with a soft heart really.

It’s not long before Melissa is caught up in another mystery, after the body of a young woman is found In the woods…..was it an accident or something more sinister? What has Mel got herself mixed up in again?

I really enjoy these gentle mysteries, nothing too graphic but enough to keep you entertained while enjoying a nice hot cup of tea….brilliant engaging writing as always by Betty Rowlands.

I would like to thank the Author/the Publishers/NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book for free in exchange for a fair and honest review
Profile Image for Abbie .
613 reviews3 followers
July 28, 2019
Indecent

Mel Craig true so hard to enjoy the quiet country life in the Cotswolds but murder and mayhem keep her on the hit for murderers. This novel includes nubile teens, illicit magazines and the death of a pretty young girl.
Betty Rowlands keeps the pages flipping because of the stellar writing. The scenes, dialogue and characters all combine to breathe life into the books 52nd make you care about the characters.

No spoilers here. For the best reading experience, start with book one. They are good stand alone novels but a series really packs a bigger punch. Happy reading 📚.
Profile Image for Beachcomber.
893 reviews30 followers
April 9, 2019
I received a copy of this book from NetGalley and Bookouture in return for an impartial review.

As the series progresses, the plot topics do seem to be getting slightly darker, as someone else pointed out. That makes a welcome change from some of the fluffier cosy mysteries - Rowlands doesn’t shy away from things. Nor does she feel the need to keep the characters all the same, which is refreshing - here, Iris has moved to France (Ken having left before), and so new characters means fresh blood. Overall, a positive addition to the series.
5 reviews
March 10, 2019
Easy reads that stay with you

A heroine in her fifties who, despite great success, still struggles with her identity in a man’s world/-and she solves crimes. How could anyone not love Mel Craig? There are 12 books in this series. I anxiously await the last two. The writer makes a quick lunch interesting. Her characters are amazing. And although the crimes aren’t real, Mel’s problems are those of every woman.
967 reviews27 followers
February 7, 2019
I liked Mel's new neighbor and once again a mystery I wasn't able to figure out. The characters are interesting and engaging. I like the setting as well. Ms. Rolands has added a few new characters into the mix.

I thank the publisher and NetGalley for my eARC in exchange for my honest review. - This is a very good series and I highly recommend it.
Profile Image for Leyla Johnson.
1,357 reviews16 followers
February 17, 2019
Another Melissa Craig book, and a lot has changed in her neighborhood, and in her life, which make this series come to life in another way.
I enjoyed this book, different, but still familiar in many ways - the story is good and with a surprise ending, a mystery not what it seems.
A good read, a little cozy but with bite.
Profile Image for Tracey.
Author 15 books17 followers
July 23, 2020
Murder at Benbury Brook

Melissa finds herself involved in another mystery when the man who is leasing Iris' cottage is arrested on suspicion of murder.
I really do love the Melissa Craig books and this one is no exception. Betty Rowlands has written another page turner, full of twists and turns, not to mention red herrings.
Highly recommended.
Profile Image for Pauline Loweth.
5 reviews1 follower
March 1, 2019
Brilliant as always. Looking forward to the next great read from Betty Rowlands. Have really enjoyed all ooks in this serthe bies

always. Looking forward to the next great read from Betty Rowlands. Have really enjoyed all ooks in this series. Great stuff.
31 reviews
March 3, 2019
Another great read.

Another great read from Betty Rowlands. The gradual development of her heroine's personality and relationships over the book series make a captivating backdrop to the murders she helps solve. Definitely recommend to anyone who enjoys a good English mystery.
186 reviews
March 11, 2019
Really good read

I love these books they are really well written and enjoyable to read the characters are really well written too.I would recommend these books to anyone who enjoys cozy mysteries, I can't wait for the next one .
1,910 reviews18 followers
March 23, 2019
Another winner!

This series of cozy but adventurous mysteries is terrific! Each story moves quickly, has a great plot, contains interesting characters, and is a fast, enjoyable read!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.