Since there's not a 3.5 stars option, I'll round up.
Over all, I found this to be a solid compilation of research-supported instructional strategies for reading. I got especially jazzed while reading the chapters on vocabulary instruction. I'd knock off a half a star (if goodreads would let me) because many of the sample lesson plans don't effectively account for group size, varying ability levels, or, you know, the amount of classroom time that teachers actually have at their disposal (a ten-page lesson plan is too long, folks). That's a common enough failing of many of these types of sourcebooks, though. My main reason for reading this was to preview it for a grad course for new teachers. And it seems like it will be especially useful for that purpose.
In general, it's a decent reference to keep on your bookshelf.