It's soon to be off-Season on Mackinac Island but first, the residents and some tourists are ready to have some Halloween fun with a charity zombie walk. Allie McMurphy is eager to participate in raising money for heart disease, a cause near and dear to her heart. Before Allie makes it to the walk, she discovers her cat Mella running out of the alley with bloody paws. A shriek from Sophie reveals another dead body. The case is complicated because everyone looks like a dead body and this one'a makeup is especially gruesome but Shane and the CSU are on the case to determine the difference. The victim, a young man named Anthony Vanderbilt was the son of Frances's best friend. There doesn't seem to be a motive until eagle eyes spot another, nearly identical zombie at the walk that night. Could the killing be a case of mistaken identity? Allie is determined to stay out of it this time. She has her hands full with renovating the McMurphy and trying to make new friends, but the seniors and other residents are counting on Allie to see justice done.
I didn't like the plot of this novel even though it kept me up late to find out what happened. There are so many wild and dark twists and turns. One made me gasp and broke my heart and one I wasn't surprised by. I only started to guess who the murderer was right before they revealed themselves! The killer is twisted and dangerous. The confrontation was pretty scary and my heart was in my throat for a minute.
This novel has too many odd points that don't add up, coming in the timeline before the Christmas novellas, too many details about renovating a historic building and too much fluff. I skipped most of the renovation and some of the fluff and still got a complete understanding of how the murder happened and why. The reveal was pretty shocking. A second subplot is Allie's love triangle. Her relationship with Rex is heating up while Trent is off-island. Allie still can't make up her mind. Allie never reveals why heart disease is a cause near and dear to her heart. Did Grandpa Liam have heart disease? I believe Grandma Alice died of illness.
Allie is so anxious in this novel. Since it's her first year on the island, she doesn't know what to expect for off-season. She's eager to bring the McMurphy back to its former glory before spring. All her friends are leaving one by one and encouraging her to leave too. That makes her sad. Is she being stubborn or can she make a go of it leaving the hotel open? I think a bit of both but she'll need Jenn to make it successful. Sandy may be leaving for another job and that adds another layer of worry on Allie's already heavy shoulders. At least she's trying to make friends her own age this time. She hangs out with Liz more and makes one new friend. I'm an introvert too and I understand her. She's happy with Mal and Mella but she does need more friends her own age on the island. The seniors leave the island too! I'm bored with the love triangle. Don't choose either of them. I was so annoyed with the people in her life stating that one day she'll marry and change her name so the hotel will pass out of the McMurphy family. WTH? This is the 21st century people! Allie can a)choose to have children without a husband and pass on her name that way or b)keep her last name and pass it on either alone or as a hyphen. McMurphy-Jessop would be a pretty powerful name on the island. McMurphy-Manning or Manning-McMurphy would be too. (I like that last one).
Mella has a larger role in this novel. This time she is the one who discovers the dead body and not Mal. Mal gets her time in the spotlight too. A subplot revolves around Allie's cat, Mella, who disappears for a time. I would be scared too if I were Allie but I find it hard to believe no one else knew what was going on. Some of the reason was my first guess! Mella is sweet for a cat. Mal is still my favorite. She likes to be held and love people but she's also a genius at finding things. This goofy puppy is so adorable she makes my heart melt.
Allie's only other good platonic friend is Liz. Liz may speak her mind and be a bit caustic but I like her a lot. She's grown on me. Liz loves her grandfather and is devoted to running his paper. She is devoted to the island and the people who live there. Liz is a good friend for Allie because she's so practical and as a reporter/editor, she knows everyone and everything. Rex loses some of his macho in order to be sweet to Allie when she needs it. I like seeing a softer side of him. Trent is spoiled, arrogant and doesn't understand Allie.
Allie makes a new friend, Haley Manx. Haley, a young woman a little older than Allie, is an artist. She works in clay making beautiful things out of pottery. Haley reaches out to Allie and is very kind to Allie and the seniors. Her husband, Rex, is not so nice. He seems kind of egotistical, at least in regards to construction work and has a hot temper. I don't think he's a good partner for the artistic Haley and he indicates their marriage is not ideal at the moment. Could it be because her husband lost his temper and killed someone?
Allie's closest friends are the seniors. They like her nosiness and her tenacity when searching for justice. She likes the seniors because they were her grandparents friends and don't judge her because she was raised off the island. The seniors are funny but it's hard to remember who is who. I wouldn't include Frances in that category but she thinks of herself as one of them.
The victim, Anthony Vanderbilt, sounds like a saint. He was universally loved and devoted to caring for his mother, presumably a widow. Maggs is very shaken up by his death. She seems to lose the will to live. Frances is very worried. Frances is a great friend but there's not much she can do but be there to support her friend. Anthony's friends seem more like typical twenty-somethings while Anthony sounded too good to be true. What about the zombie double? Could he have been the target? This man seems nice enough too. He's shown with a pregnant woman in the photos, hopefully his girlfriend or wife. He did have an altercation with a man though or was it Anthony? It's hard to tell from Liz's photos and Rex is having a tough time figuring this one out. Another body is found halfway into the book and unidentified for a time. This man did not deserve to die either. A final new character is Pastor Henry, a newcomer to a local parish in need of help. He seems like he was sent from God to help restore the church and the parish. He'll need a lot of financial help. Jenn should come back and help them fundraise but Allie is doing a good job on her own.
This novel has the best selection of fudge recipes! I am eager to try them out next Thanksgiving. I still have the ingredients or can make the ingredients for all the ones I want to try but then I'll just eat it all myself.