It was OK. I didn't hate it, but it was so... flat, for lack of a better term. And formulaic, like the author was checking boxes. Rather underwhelming.
The plot. So much packed in, but at the same time, there's so much undeveloped. It was like the author was going down a checklist of "How to Write A College Sports Romance." Abusive ex? Check. Mean Girl ex? Check. Bad boy player with heart of gold, totally smitten over heroine? Check. Family drama? Check and double check. But nothing really got developed. The whole classroom set-up, which seems to be the direction the author's going to bring her "enemies" together? Never mentioned again. They are in a class together, the teacher hates her, they're picked as partners... and then nothing comes of it. Never even mentions going to class again (though she does mention skipping class to visit Ella). And Jase's jealousy? Completely unnecessary plot point. Why wasn't he just her friend? As it was, it made her even more into the "oh I'm so average, but all the super popular boys on campus want me" type of character that I hate. Even the Monday Night thing! It's the freakin' title, for crying out loud, but she only just takes over the Monday night shift at the beginning of the story, and there are only about 2 scenes in the cafe before they hook up - his Monday night routine literally has no point in the plot! Overall, the result was choppy and formulaic.
Usually one narrator, first person stories aren't a big deal for me, but this one did get to me. Maybe because I never felt connected to Addison, maybe because she felt very empty as a character, but I really wanted to hear another POV and get out of Addison's head. Would have loved to hear why Parker (and all these other guys) were so head over heels for her. It didn't help that she took the "klutzy awkward cute" stereotype to irritating levels. Seriously, in the first 1/4 of the book, she's run into someone 4 times, all to further the plot too! Using that plot device once, maybe twice, in a book is fine but 4 times in the first quarter?? Then there's the teaser description - "Bookworm Addison James has vowed to crush it in her second year in college." Except she's never depicted as a bookworm, other than physically carrying books and/or her bookbag, and (as mentioned) the whole going-to-class thing fell by the wayside. Instead, we see her getting blackout drunk and hopping from one high drama mess to the next. I know, I know - don't judge a book by it's blurb. But this one here seriously misrepresented both the plot and the main character.
All from Addison's 1st person POV. OW and OM drama with both exes and her sister's Mean Girl antics. While not cheating (Addison and Parker weren't together yet) he's bringing other girls to flirt with at the cafe while she's working, all because he loves her and wants her attention. Besides being a bit twisted, it comes preeeeeetty close to my tolerance level for cheating. Fairly clean - the characters have sex, but nothing explicit, mostly "behind closed doors." Rather choppy plot, undeveloped plot threads, and little character development. Fast and rather mindless NA romance. No cliffhangers. HEA, but no epilogue (so slightly less satisfying).
Would I read more from this author/series? Quite honestly, probably not.