What do you think?
Rate this book
ソウナンですか? / Are You Lost? #1
你遭難了嗎？1
鬼島譽、鈴森明日香、天谷睦和九條紫音四位女高中生坐的飛機發生空難，墜落到海裡，四人幸運存活並漂流到無人島上。但是她們必須在荒島上尋找避難處並尋找水與食物。幸好其中的譽因為受到軍人爸爸的野外求生教導，因此對野外求生的方式非常瞭解。她帶領另外三位少女去尋找水源、捉魚貝類，分辨能食能吃的植物、製做陷阱捉兔子。四名少女就此展開野外求生的生活…
176 pages, Paperback
First published August 4, 2017
16 people are currently reading
40 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews
June 21, 2024
Don’t judge a book by its cover. 🙊 Cast Away with highschool girls!
April 7, 2025
4 girls, one island, no help, will they survive?
I saw that this one was getting an anime and had to check it out. I just couldn't wait until the anime would arrive. And oh boy, this was just too much fun to read and I will definitely be watching the anime as well.
Meet our 4 girls, Homare who is the one who knows the most about survival and is the leader of our group (first nominated by herself and then the rest settled in with the idea as she knows the most). She is really kick-ass, when we first meet her she stabs a fish out of the air and then wrings it to get fluids... Then there is Asuka, who tries her best but is kind of useless most of the time. She gives up very easily and I was just rolling my eyes at her constant complaining. Yes, we get it, you are stranded, it isn't fun, but do you want to survive? Then work. We have Mutsu who is a bit timid but more than willing to try things out and learn from Homare. She is quite cute and also has plenty of knowledge that at times comes in handy. Lastly, Shion. I wasn't a fan of this girl. She is the rich girl and barely does anything to help out. Yes, she tries to make fire, SOS signs, but that is it. I hope she will learn to be more of a team player.
The chapters are pretty short and chronicle how the girls are surviving. We start with our trio finding Homare and then drifting to an island (with a chase scene). Then comes finding water, then food to finding a shelter to how to hunt (yep, the girls are planning to hunt as they have found out there are some tasty rabbits and squirrels around). I can imagine that the girls, well with the exception of Homare who just eats anything and everything, are hesitant to eat innards or bugs. But I am glad that they at least tried it, though I had quite a laugh at their faces. Then again, those would be my faces as well if I had to eat those things.
Many of the survival things are very nicely explained (though one comes with a warning to not do this thing unless in an emergency) and I have learned some new things about how to survive. No clue if they are all true, but they do seem pretty true given that I have done some google-fu to check. :P
Next to the grim survival there is plenty of humour and the girls trying to get along. I do like that humour is added and that things aren't all grim. Though now it feels as Yuru Camp x Survival x Uninhabited Island.
I do wonder why no one is looking for the girls given the plane had 100+ passengers. Or did they drift so far away from things that people are overlooking them? Then there is the other question, did anyone else survive the crash? Will we meet them?
The art is pretty good, I love the designs of the girls + I love the details on various things.
I would recommend this one if you are looking for a fun manga about survival and cute girls.
Review first posted at https://twirlingbookprincess.com/
I saw that this one was getting an anime and had to check it out. I just couldn't wait until the anime would arrive. And oh boy, this was just too much fun to read and I will definitely be watching the anime as well.
Meet our 4 girls, Homare who is the one who knows the most about survival and is the leader of our group (first nominated by herself and then the rest settled in with the idea as she knows the most). She is really kick-ass, when we first meet her she stabs a fish out of the air and then wrings it to get fluids... Then there is Asuka, who tries her best but is kind of useless most of the time. She gives up very easily and I was just rolling my eyes at her constant complaining. Yes, we get it, you are stranded, it isn't fun, but do you want to survive? Then work. We have Mutsu who is a bit timid but more than willing to try things out and learn from Homare. She is quite cute and also has plenty of knowledge that at times comes in handy. Lastly, Shion. I wasn't a fan of this girl. She is the rich girl and barely does anything to help out. Yes, she tries to make fire, SOS signs, but that is it. I hope she will learn to be more of a team player.
The chapters are pretty short and chronicle how the girls are surviving. We start with our trio finding Homare and then drifting to an island (with a chase scene). Then comes finding water, then food to finding a shelter to how to hunt (yep, the girls are planning to hunt as they have found out there are some tasty rabbits and squirrels around). I can imagine that the girls, well with the exception of Homare who just eats anything and everything, are hesitant to eat innards or bugs. But I am glad that they at least tried it, though I had quite a laugh at their faces. Then again, those would be my faces as well if I had to eat those things.
Many of the survival things are very nicely explained (though one comes with a warning to not do this thing unless in an emergency) and I have learned some new things about how to survive. No clue if they are all true, but they do seem pretty true given that I have done some google-fu to check. :P
Next to the grim survival there is plenty of humour and the girls trying to get along. I do like that humour is added and that things aren't all grim. Though now it feels as Yuru Camp x Survival x Uninhabited Island.
I do wonder why no one is looking for the girls given the plane had 100+ passengers. Or did they drift so far away from things that people are overlooking them? Then there is the other question, did anyone else survive the crash? Will we meet them?
The art is pretty good, I love the designs of the girls + I love the details on various things.
I would recommend this one if you are looking for a fun manga about survival and cute girls.
Review first posted at https://twirlingbookprincess.com/
April 25, 2024
An amusing take on the cozy slice of life manga. The characters easily slip into archetypes and the frames at time seem to focus to heavily on their femininity; but all in all it’s informative and entertaining without either side suffering. If you enjoy things like Days on Fes, Silver Spoon, or Laid-Back Camp you’ll likely enjoy this title.
May 28, 2020
3.5 stars.
December 26, 2020
Fanservice only, but at least the title always makes me giggle.
August 23, 2023
Loootta fanservice, but otherwise enjoyable survival story.
July 15, 2024
Some fan service, but some really interesting survival information as well.
July 7, 2019
While the storyline was good and I liked the characters, it definitely felt like I was reading a survivalist handbook
April 16, 2020
4 girls are standard on a desert island and must survive, you never learn how they actually get there. A plane crash is mentioned but there must be more to it than that, this was really interesting to start off with. But it kind of went downhill after it stopped with the interesting facts, basically one girl is a survivalist's and knows a bunch of ways to stay alive on a dessert island. It slowly turns into facts about different things that they can eat, food can be interesting but unless it's a cooking manga, I don't really need to know which bugs I can eat.
The survival facts where very good and interesting but after that nothing really happened, you don't care for any of the girls.
The survival facts where very good and interesting but after that nothing really happened, you don't care for any of the girls.
November 20, 2021
在動畫撥出時，第1集趁機限時免費
之前前1/3部分試閱的英文難度不高
之後提到各種生物就開始變得困難了一些
本書提到的signal mirror是用插在地上的Y字形樹枝協助對準目標
感覺精度較高，但是比起用手指比出Y麻煩不少
本書能把求生題材寫的有趣還真是不錯
4.5/5
之前前1/3部分試閱的英文難度不高
之後提到各種生物就開始變得困難了一些
本書提到的signal mirror是用插在地上的Y字形樹枝協助對準目標
感覺精度較高，但是比起用手指比出Y麻煩不少
本書能把求生題材寫的有趣還真是不錯
4.5/5
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews