I'm not leaving a star rating on this one.... if I did, it would probably be a 2 ** book for me. The reason I'm not leaving stars is because I realize I'm not the intended audience for this book, and I don't want to drive down the average rating for anyone who might benefit from this. The author mentions "type A" painters in a light-hearted manner at one point.... I'm definitely, absolutely, very firmly in the type A painters camp, so keep that in mind if you're reading this.
I like that the book starts out with basics... like swatching, doing washes, etc. Play with your paints! I'm not a fan of using my watercolor wet straight from the tube onto a plate. I think this personal preference but also maybe related to the type of paint she's recommending. Nice paint works great dry.... it's also nice if you want to take your palette with you and paint on the go. The author's method will leave you studio-bound which for me eliminates the big appeal of watercolor (like personally, if I'm staying in the studio, I'll do gouache or oil. My watercolor travels in my back pocket). My biggest gripe with the book is that it comes across as an advertisement for Reeves paint. Reeves is just about the worst paint you can waste money on. It's barely a step up from Crayola. The paint mixes she goes with are based not on color theory but the very limited Reeves palette. If you want to paint, don't start off learning bad habits. Yes, Reeves is cheap up front, but in the long run, every penny spent on it is a waste.
I would not recommend gifting this book to anyone just starting out in painting. There are some fun exercises to download so that goes in the plus column. I did get some inspiration flipping through the book, and even though I was mildly annoyed when I finished, I felt like painting, so also a plus. It is a very pretty, nicely laid out book with lots of little bits of encouragement. I liked the mix of cheerleading from the author and quotes (specifically the Van Gogh one about silencing the voice that says you cannot paint by painting). I also like that this book includes gouache (Guh'wash, folks) because almost no one I run into knows what it is. For the record, I think the world would be a much better place if we all played with gouache (think about the lovely backgrounds in the old Disney movies.... that's gouache). I think the title of the book is gimmicky since this isn't really a watercolor book. I guess the name having watercolor in it instead of "mixed media" is a marketing choice to grab people who have had no exposure to mixed media? Anyways.... if you've always wanted to paint and haven't, try gouache. You need 4 tubes and a brush to start. It's cheaper than therapy and less mess than murder. Back to this book... there's a section that talks about painting for yourself not for sales or social media. Bravo. Good message. I liked that part. ...However... I would have liked to see a little bit about what if you want to sell something. It seems like this book is aimed at people who have never painted.... so why not mention lightfastness and permanence? Even if you never ever plan to sell anything, if you paint (and you actually let anyone see your work), you will eventually sell something. Again, this might be related to the fact that this book is recommending really bad paint, but for anyone who doesn't know, not all watercolor colors are there for the long term. If you sell something and it fades over time, will that be a problem for you?
What I didn't like:
*student paints? Nah, fam. You don't need 24 colors of crap. Skip Reeves. For $20usd, you can start building a limited professional palette. For my first palette, I started with 6 carefully chosen 5-ml tubes of holbien. You can go with 3 colors and learn a ton. Do any professional brand. Using student materials is a great way to get frustrated. You do not need lots of super cheap colors.
*paynes grey from a tube? No, no, no! OK, I confess, I have paynes grey (used constantly in this book) and Davies grey... what can I say... I like to paint nerdy character art, and it's not bad for shadows on ninjas. But no, please don't recommend pre-mixed grey for painting flowers. Paynes grey is all over this book. It's lazy, and you won't get the results you want. There are better colors for botanicals, and I HATE mixing premixed paynes grey with anything else. Most brands use black in their paynes grey, which doesn't play nicely with a lot of colors (any colors. It hates every single paint you have). If you want to use paynes grey, mix it. It's yellow ochre, Prussian blue, and crimson.
Who this book is for:
*if you're completely brand new to painting and get anxiety looking at a blank page, this is a gentle introduction to painting, but beware the material recommendations and spend a few minutes on YouTube learning to mix whatever brand of paint you choose (please not Reeves).