We have a Winter season, so I wanted to immerse myself into a cozy story, full of wonder and adventures, set up in Winter. This is how I found the Sky Song by Abi Elphinstone.
By looking at my rating, you can imagine how much fun I had with this story.
The Sky Song takes place in a magical world called Erkenwald. In this world live three human tribes, who were friends with each other and believed in magic, until an evil appeared in the name of the Ice Queen. The witch's goal is to take over the Erkenwald and become immortal. To do so, she had to consume all the voices of Erkenwald's human residents. She manages to kidnapp all the adults, but not children. At least not all of them. One of the child captures is Eska, our heroine, who's trapped in a music box. When she meets Flint, a boy who came to save his mother, they run away from the Ice Queen's castle and go into an adventure to stop her reign over Erkenwald and to save all the adults.
I think that the Sky Song could be an enjoyable adventure for a child, but NOT for a sharp and observant one. The questions like who, how and why would NEVER stop incoming (before anyone asks: NO, I don't have a child and NO, I haven't read this to a child - I am not a child either, but I had A LOT of questions like these when I read the book).
The amount of conveniences this story has should be illegal. If ANY trouble arrives in our heroes' journey, be sure that a VERY convenient thing IMMEDIATELY happens. So the heroes are never really in any danger and the story gets boring pretty quickly.
I could praise this book for its' messages like 'friendship is valuable' or 'nothing's impossible if only you believe in', but, to be honest, when it comes to the Sky Song, these messages don't feel as powerful as they should be. There is no real friendship in this story. We are told over and over how the heroes are friends and how they need each other, but what you need to know is that everything and everyone created in this story only exists to help our VERY, VERY SPECIAL heroine to her victory over the evil. And since the heroine is so VERY, VERY SPECIAL, you know immediately that she will succeed, because nothing is impossible for her.
Now the villain. The Ice Queen of Sky Song is definitely one of the most incompetent villains that were ever created. She was supposed to be so powerful and scary, but ended up being quite pathetic. How such powerful witch couldn't find two non-magical children, like seriously, how hard could this be? (and when she finally found them, she had let them go, because... uh... they were faster? I don't know.)
Anyways, my search for some nice Winter stories continues. If any of my friends (or non-friends) is reading this review and have some recommendations, please send me some! ;)