I received this book through Goodreads First Reads, and am grateful for the opportunity.
A Chance Beginning, the first book of the Shadow’s Fire series, is very interesting to read. There are many interesting characters, and a vivid world. More than that, the book is an interesting twist on the usual conventions of a fantasy quest. There are not many monsters actually fought or magic used, though it is evident in the background. The true focus is on the three protagonists – Erik, Befel, and Bryon – and how they adapt to the world they are exploring. By the end of this first book, they have clearly grown and changed from their original selves.
However, I had a few issues with the book. First of all, the plot just seemed to be missing something. There wasn’t actually much action except for a couple of battles, and even the finale seemed anticlimactic. The book ends with the three relatives defeating the slavers, but it’s unclear where they, or the story, are headed.
Compounding this is the inclusion of many characters who just seem to fill the background without much continual effect on the story. Take for instance the gypsies; after the first slaver attack, they largely disappear from the plot except for one minor reappearance. I get the feeling that the different stories are connected, but they never end up coming together. I understand that this is the first book of the series, but there should be some degree of clarity by the end of the book.
Then there are a few lesser issues. A few times, the author ends up switching between different character viewpoints within a single section, such as in the conversation between Erik and Del Alzon; fortunately, he mostly remembers to keep characters points of view separated. Also, he occasionally used showing instead of telling; the recollection of another conversation with Del Alzon could be made more vivid if it was actually made into a conversation, with specific dialogue. Finally, the large and unique font at the start of the chapters is eye-catching, but it also makes the opening paragraph a little difficult to read. Compounding this, the font is the same size and design as the title, leading to further confusion.
This all said, I don’t think there is anything decidedly wrong with the novel. Some of my concerns, as with the matter of the plot’s direction, become a little less important if you see the story as not so much about a quest, but rather about the growing boys’ journey of discovery. The minor issues that remain only hinder the book slightly. I saw no grammatical issues either. Overall, this is a great fantasy story, and a remarkable achievement for a new author. I am not sure where Patterson plans to lead Shadow’s Fire, but I’m interested in finding out, and look forward to see how he improves in the future.