I would give this book a 3.5 if it were possible. It's an interesting story about a woman sentenced to stoning for adultery, including the lead up and how she was subsequently found not guilty, however there was something about this book that just didn't sit comfortably with me and I wasn't sure why.
On further consideration, I think the reason why and in opposition to one of the other reviews on here, I didn't really see Safiya as much of a fighter. Perhaps it is purely a very cultural thing and I just don't understand it, however I have recently read "Infidel" which has some cultural similarities and she was definitely a fighter. Safiya, on the other hand in my opinion, let everyone else make the decisions and do the fighting and she just went along with it.
The part that really made this stand out to me was when Safiya commented on when the women in the village finally began showing their support for her, as up until that time, her conviction was just how things were - it was not questioned until the sentence gained international exposure. With that in mind, I was a little frustrated that this "thinking outside the square" didn't extend to her family or even Safiya herself, when it came to her fifth marriage proposal after her being found not guilty. Ok, so it appears that this marriage turned out to be sucessful, but after so much heartache and disappointment at the hands of men, particularly her previous husbands, why on earth would you just keep continuing to agree to marry men that you don't know!!!! I just can't fathom after everything Safiya had been through and acknowledging that the women in her village were no longer just blindly accepting whatever had always been so, that she would just passively go along with her father's recommendation that she marry someone who had heard about her and decided to write to her father requesting a marriage. But as she had her whole life, she let everyone else make the decisions and just went along with them.
The reason I'm giving this 4 stars instead of 3 is because it's an interesting insight into a different culture and an important story, however I think this book is more of a political statement than a story about an inspiring woman. However that's just my opinion.