Anne-Marie Meyer books are always pleasant, feel-good reads. I liked this story and the characters a lot and I give it 4 stars because it was well written and had a nice plot. I'm looking forward to reading the rest of the series.
However, I have some issues with some writing decisions:
1. Everything started with a J. I get that all the siblings had J names, but the son, Beth's mom, the other city.
2. The other city and the son had the same name: Jordan. Why?? Bullet points 1 & 2 made this a difficult read for a dyslexic to follow.
3. At least 3 of the following phrases/actions were mentioned approximately 5 times a chapter: pinched her/his lips, tucked her hair behind her ear, making his/her/their way [somewhere], sheepish look, honest with himself/herself, wink, chewed her lip, sorry (seriously, it was annoying how frequently Beth apologized), gaze flicked, touched her elbow........Anne-Marie Meyer, please use some different phrases, especially for "making their way somewhere". Every time I read it, I just start singing the opening line from A Thousand Miles by Vanessa Carlton...so I sing it about 40 times per book! Yes, it's in every book.
And my last comment is a spoiler so don't read further unless you want the ending to be given away. Seriously, the next line will spoil it, so you've been warned. The mom should have died in her last scene. Not that I like death, but it was where the character was going the entire book, and then suddenly the prognosis changed and the book ends with everyone happy. It just seemed out of place. The death would have been a good opportunity for character development and for Beth and Josh to grow closer. The hopeful prognosis just shifted the vibe right at the end and it felt weird and unnatural.