Review: The Complete Works of Charles Dickens, Part 1
As a reader, I’ve always found Charles Dickens to be a challenging author to engage with. His dense prose, sprawling narratives, and the sheer number of characters can make even the most well-known works a bit of a hurdle. That said, I committed to reading the first part of his complete works and was pleasantly surprised by the variety of tones and themes throughout. Below are my impressions of each novel in the collection, based on readability, story, and character development.
A Tale of Two Cities — ★★½ / 5
This was, unfortunately, my least favourite of the collection. I found the plot and characters difficult to follow, which detracted from my overall enjoyment. The historical context is rich, but without supplemental materials like Coles Notes, I struggled to stay engaged. The complexity of the storyline often made it feel more like a chore than a compelling read.
Bleak House — ★★★★ / 5
This was a standout for me. Bleak House felt ahead of its time, blending social commentary with what could be seen as the early roots of the police procedural genre. The shifting perspectives and the depiction of the legal system added depth to the narrative, and I found myself genuinely invested in the characters and their fates.
Dombey and Son — ★★★★ / 5
A well-paced and emotionally satisfying novel, Dombey and Son follows the personal and professional trials of a prominent family. I enjoyed the way Dickens wove themes of pride, familial duty, and personal growth into the story. The balance between drama and romance made it a more approachable and rewarding read.
Nicholas Nickleby — ★★★★ / 5
A quintessential Dickensian tale of family hardship, personal resilience, and eventual triumph. While the narrative followed a somewhat predictable arc, the vivid cast of characters and moral undertones kept it engaging. A classic example of Dickens’ ability to mix dark themes with touches of humour and redemption.
The Mystery of Edwin Drood — ★★★ / 5
Though unfinished, Edwin Drood shows tremendous promise. It’s clear Dickens was leaning toward a darker, more suspenseful tone, and the setup for a murder mystery is intriguing. Unfortunately, we’ll never know how the story concludes, but the existing chapters offer an atmospheric and moody glimpse into what could have been a great whodunit.
The Old Curiosity Shop — ★★★★ / 5
This story was both easy to follow and emotionally affecting. Dickens tackles the devastating consequences of gambling addiction and its ripple effects on a family, all while weaving in themes of vulnerability and resilience. The tone is decidedly sombre, but the story is accessible and moving, especially in its portrayal of intergenerational hardship.
Martin Chuzzlewit — ★★★ / 5
While this novel has its moments, it didn’t resonate with me as strongly as others. The satirical take on selfishness and hypocrisy within families and society is clever, but the pacing felt uneven. Still, Dickens’ wit and social critique shine through.
Barnaby Rudge — ★★★ / 5
This novel stood out for its early and relatively sensitive depiction of a character with what we would now recognize as a developmental or cognitive disability. Barnaby is a compelling and unique figure in Dickens’ body of work, and his presence adds emotional weight to an otherwise uneven historical narrative.
Hard Times — ★★★ / 5
A stark and sombre novel, Hard Times is a critique of industrialization and utilitarianism. While the themes are important, the story felt especially grim and heavy. The characters serve the message more than they feel like real people, making it a less emotionally engaging experience for me.
Overall Impression so far:
While Dickens can be a difficult author to read, his ability to portray societal issues, emotional turmoil, and moral conflicts remains unmatched. Despite the ups and downs, this first part of his complete works has deepened my appreciation for his role in shaping the modern novel. With patience (and occasionally, a guidebook), the journey through these stories can be rewarding.
★★★★★ 4.5/5
The Pickwick Papers earns 4.5 stars for its humor, charm, and episodic storytelling that laid the groundwork for later classic duos like Wodehouse’s Wooster and Jeeves. This was easily the most comedic novel I've read so far—full of lighthearted adventures and quirky characters you can enjoy in small doses without needing to rush through. The dynamic between Pickwick and his clever servant Sam Weller is especially delightful. While Dickens’ prose can still feel overly wordy at times, the wit and warmth more than make up for it.
Currently working on Part 2 of the collection reading: David Copperfield