What do you think?
Rate this book
Under Northern Skies #4
A Song of Joy
In Minnesota in 1911, Nilda Carlson is torn between society life in the city of Blackduck and spending time with her family back home on the farm. Her employer, Mrs. Schoenleber, gives her more and more responsibility and experience, including recommending new opportunities for her philanthropy. Still new to America herself, Nilda focuses on the area's immigrant community, but she'll have to fight to get her ideas accepted by the locals and donors alike.
In the meantime, one of her greatest joys is her weekly piano lesson with the handsome schoolteacher, Fritz. But just as Nilda is beginning to realize she has feelings for him, a stylish, affluent young woman moves to Blackduck and monopolizes Fritz's attention. With her humble background, how can Nilda hope to compete with such a sophisticated beauty?
In the meantime, one of her greatest joys is her weekly piano lesson with the handsome schoolteacher, Fritz. But just as Nilda is beginning to realize she has feelings for him, a stylish, affluent young woman moves to Blackduck and monopolizes Fritz's attention. With her humble background, how can Nilda hope to compete with such a sophisticated beauty?
333 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 6, 2019
221 people are currently reading
1752 people want to read
About the author
Lauraine Snelling
160 books2,049 followersAward-winning and bestselling author Lauraine Snelling has over 80 books published with sales of over 4.5 million. Her original dream was to write horse books for children. Today, she writes adult novels about real issues centered on forgiveness, loss, domestic violence and cancer in her inspirational contemporary women’s fiction titles and historical series, including the favorite, Blessing books about Ingeborg Bjorklund and family.
Lauraine enjoys helping others reach their writing dreams by teaching at writer’s conferences across the county. She and her husband Wayne have two grown sons, and a daughter in Heaven. They live in the Tehachapi Mountains with a Basset named Sir Winston ob de Mountains, Lapcat, and “The Girls” (three golden hens).
Lauraine enjoys helping others reach their writing dreams by teaching at writer’s conferences across the county. She and her husband Wayne have two grown sons, and a daughter in Heaven. They live in the Tehachapi Mountains with a Basset named Sir Winston ob de Mountains, Lapcat, and “The Girls” (three golden hens).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 85 reviews
March 12, 2021
I have read 25 books in this author's series set in the frontier of North Dakota and Minnesota. While I don't think the writing is outstanding by any means, I have liked the characters. I enjoyed getting to know them. I also learned historical facts and context that help me better understand a close Norwegian friend. It was easy to relate to the settings, especially the forests of northern Minnesota, where I was raised.
That said, it is time to move on to a new author!
That said, it is time to move on to a new author!
August 27, 2019
This is the continuing story of Nilda who has a hard time deciding between life in town or on the farm. She continues to get more responsibility from her employer, which includes building houses for the poorer people of town. She also gets interested in a beau and has to firmly discourage another man who doesn’t want to take no for an answer. Very interesting reading on how the times were in the early 1900’s.
June 17, 2019
Nilda Carlson is finding a new life away from the family farm. She is now working for Gertrude Schoenleber as her executive assistant. As such she is learning much about business and philanthropy. She and Mrs. Schoenleber are working out ways to help immigrants gain a foothold in their new country and new community. Their efforts to provide housing and jobs is something that is bringing satisfaction to both women.
But Nilda has other things that are going to bring her new joys and some angst. She has a suitor, one of the nephews of Mrs. Schoenleber. But this nephew is a wealthy socialite who has very little desire to work. Instead he wants everything done for him. He is drawn to Nilda, but he doesn't understand her a bit. She is a hard worker and not interested in living a life of leisure.
The story unfolds as Nilda learns and grows under the teaching of Mrs. Schoenleber and as she develops a strong work ethic and many benevolent concerns. She also does haver an interest in one of Mrs. Schoenleber's nephews, just not the one that is interested in her.
Throughout the story we see the Hand of God working to direct the steps of Nilda and all those associated with her. We see the faithfulness of God to those who love Him and strive to serve Him. We see the glory of God fulfilling the dreams and desires of those who seek after His heart.
I only gave the story 4 stars because I felt the beginning dragged a bit. But the last fourth of the book moved very quickly and made up for what seemed to be dragging earlier.
I enjoy all of Ms. Snelling's writings and enjoy reading about the lives of early immigrants from Norway.
Enjoy!
But Nilda has other things that are going to bring her new joys and some angst. She has a suitor, one of the nephews of Mrs. Schoenleber. But this nephew is a wealthy socialite who has very little desire to work. Instead he wants everything done for him. He is drawn to Nilda, but he doesn't understand her a bit. She is a hard worker and not interested in living a life of leisure.
The story unfolds as Nilda learns and grows under the teaching of Mrs. Schoenleber and as she develops a strong work ethic and many benevolent concerns. She also does haver an interest in one of Mrs. Schoenleber's nephews, just not the one that is interested in her.
Throughout the story we see the Hand of God working to direct the steps of Nilda and all those associated with her. We see the faithfulness of God to those who love Him and strive to serve Him. We see the glory of God fulfilling the dreams and desires of those who seek after His heart.
I only gave the story 4 stars because I felt the beginning dragged a bit. But the last fourth of the book moved very quickly and made up for what seemed to be dragging earlier.
I enjoy all of Ms. Snelling's writings and enjoy reading about the lives of early immigrants from Norway.
Enjoy!
August 22, 2019
A Song of Joy is the fourth novel in Under Northern Skies series. I recommend reading this series in order, though, the author does summarize what happened in the previous books. I thought A Song of Joy was well-written and it proceeds at a gentle pace. I would have liked a little peppier pace because I did feel the story dragged in places. We get to see what daily life is like for Nilda and for her family on the farm. While A Song of Joy focuses on Nilda, I like that we get to catch-up with the family. They are busy cutting trees, planting crops, taking care of the animals, and the numerous other daily chores on a farm. There are such wonderful, developed characters in the book, and I like the references to Ingeborg Bjorklund which has me looking forward to reading A Blessing to Cherish. The author captured the time period with the clothing, events, books and the new technology. Electricity, motorcars, and the typewriter are some of the new inventions mentioned in the book. Nilda also learns shorthand to help her take notes at the quarterly company meetings. I enjoyed watching Nilda grow over the course of the series and the ending left me happy. This is a clean Christian novel. We get to see how God plays into the lives of our characters. They pray for guidance to make the right decisions and have faith that God will lead them in the right direction. They are compassionate people who want to share their blessings. A Song of Joy is a heartwarming novel with rich characters.
September 18, 2019
I'm an admirer of the people who came first. They are the ones who truly deserve this place. More so than we do.
They did all the hard work, struggled to survive and pave the way for us so that we might preserve America in our way. Now, it's our turn!!
Nilda is a wonderful character. I can't imagine having to learn English like the immigrants did. How hard that must've been. I feel sort of lucky! I take for granted what they had to learn. But then again I think most of us do.
Lauraine has done a wonderful job with this story. The storyline flowed smoothly but there was one man whom I wished had a more prominent roll and that was the detective. It felt like he was just there and then gone!
The only thing I feared about the whole series was the pronouncimg of the names. They scared me cause I wasn't sure how they should go. This was the only thing that I didn't like about the story. Was the names. Forgein names.
Overall this whole series was very enjoyable. Good job Lauraine!!
My thanks to Netgalley for a copy of this book. NO compensations were received. All opinions are my own.
They did all the hard work, struggled to survive and pave the way for us so that we might preserve America in our way. Now, it's our turn!!
Nilda is a wonderful character. I can't imagine having to learn English like the immigrants did. How hard that must've been. I feel sort of lucky! I take for granted what they had to learn. But then again I think most of us do.
Lauraine has done a wonderful job with this story. The storyline flowed smoothly but there was one man whom I wished had a more prominent roll and that was the detective. It felt like he was just there and then gone!
The only thing I feared about the whole series was the pronouncimg of the names. They scared me cause I wasn't sure how they should go. This was the only thing that I didn't like about the story. Was the names. Forgein names.
Overall this whole series was very enjoyable. Good job Lauraine!!
My thanks to Netgalley for a copy of this book. NO compensations were received. All opinions are my own.
April 24, 2020
I always enjoy Lauraine Snelling's novels of Norwegian pioneer life in America, specifically in Minnesota in this series. This fourth book continues the story of Nilda Carlson, who is living in Black Duck with her sponsor, Mrs. Schoenleber. Nilda continues to learn new skills and meet new people, and at Mrs. Schoenleber's urging, finding new ways to use her sponsor's wealth to benefit immigrants. There is also some continuing drama as a Pinkerton detective turns up, investigating the death of Dreng Nigor. And Nilda is courted by a handsome, wealthy relative of Mrs. Schoenleber - but what exactly are his motives? And where does her heart really belong?
July 1, 2022
This is probably a 2.5. I usually enjoy her books - not a lot depth to them but enjoyable. I just never could get attached to any of the characters in this series.
August 21, 2019
A Song Of Joy is a return to 1911 Blackduck MN. I have greatly enjoyed reading about the Carlson family as I live about a 100 miles north of Blackduck and I often drive through on my way to Bemidji. I love the characters that Ms. Snelling has created. it is fascinating to read of the struggles of the Scandinavians who settled this area. Nilda Carlson is a strong Norwegian immigrant who is struggling to find her place in a new world. She is fortunate to have a sponsor in Mrs. Schoenleber, who has not only employed her, but has offered friendship as well. I highly recommend Ms. Snelling's Under Northern Skies series along with the Red River Valley series. So grab a cup of Coffee and a few ginger cookies then settle in for a great read!
I was given a copy of this book by NetGalley.com with no expectations. All thoughts are my own.
I was given a copy of this book by NetGalley.com with no expectations. All thoughts are my own.
June 19, 2025
I read other books in this Christian series years ago but somehow missed this one. At first, there was a lot of talk but not much action. As the book progressed, it got better and turned out to be rather good. A happy ending for all.
July 2, 2019
"A Song of Joy" is a Christian romance set in 1911 in Minnesota. This book is the fourth in a series and the third with Nilda as the main character. I didn't realize this was a continuation of her story, and I haven't read the previous books. The first few chapters "spoil" what happened in the previous books to get new readers up to speed on what she's gone through. Fritz hardly spent any scene-time with Nilda, but it was clear that Nilda and Fritz were attracted to each other and only each other. A rich, young man attempted to impress Nilda with his wealth so she'd marry him, but there wasn't much suspense about how the romance would turn out.
Much of the story was spent describing daily life for her family on the farm and for Nilda in town. Enjoyable historical details about farm life, manners, and such were woven into the story. Some suspense was created during Nilda's efforts to come up with ways to help the poor, local immigrants and gain support (and money) for her projects. Plus a detective clearly bent on causing trouble for Nilda kept popping up to question people about her or to say nasty things to her.
There was no bad language or sex. Overall, I'd recommend this story to those who have read the previous novels and who will enjoy learning how things are working out for those characters or to people interested in what life was like for immigrants at this time.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
Much of the story was spent describing daily life for her family on the farm and for Nilda in town. Enjoyable historical details about farm life, manners, and such were woven into the story. Some suspense was created during Nilda's efforts to come up with ways to help the poor, local immigrants and gain support (and money) for her projects. Plus a detective clearly bent on causing trouble for Nilda kept popping up to question people about her or to say nasty things to her.
There was no bad language or sex. Overall, I'd recommend this story to those who have read the previous novels and who will enjoy learning how things are working out for those characters or to people interested in what life was like for immigrants at this time.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
June 17, 2019
First sentence: Life in America certainly wasn't like Nilda had dreamed.
Premise/plot: A Song of Joy is the fourth book in Lauraine Snelling's Under Northern Skies series. Though one could certainly start the series at any point, you'll get more enjoyment and satisfaction if you read the series in order.
Though there are many, many characters in A Song of Joy, the main character is Nilda Carlson. She's still working for Mrs. Gertrude Schoenleber as her assistant and secretary. She hasn't forgotten the traumatic event(s) of previous books--nor should she have.
Jeffrey Schmitz is pursuing a relationship with Nilda at the insistence of his father, Heinrik. Nilda can see through Jeffrey's advances. He's a self-centered snob who thinks Nilda should be grateful if Jeffrey stoops to say hello to her. He only talks of himself, and he's dismissive of just about anything and everything Nilda has to say. He's not too observant, or he'd never have proposed at a public ball! He reminds me a bit of Disney's Gaston.
Fritz Larsson is a teacher and a musician. He's known Nilda for several books now. She's been taking piano lessons from him. She's always liked him. Perhaps she's always liked-liked him. But does he like-like her? Does he love her? Does he want to marry her?
This one isn't just a romance. It's also a novel about compassion and giving back. Nilda and her employer are hard at work on a new project that will help new immigrants that arrive in Blackduck.
My thoughts: I had my issues with the third book, I won't lie. But I thoroughly enjoyed this latest book in the series. I'm so glad that I've read it. I don't know why I assumed they'd just be three books in the series!!!
I love Lauraine Snelling's novels. It's always a treat to spend time with her well-developed characters.
Premise/plot: A Song of Joy is the fourth book in Lauraine Snelling's Under Northern Skies series. Though one could certainly start the series at any point, you'll get more enjoyment and satisfaction if you read the series in order.
Though there are many, many characters in A Song of Joy, the main character is Nilda Carlson. She's still working for Mrs. Gertrude Schoenleber as her assistant and secretary. She hasn't forgotten the traumatic event(s) of previous books--nor should she have.
Jeffrey Schmitz is pursuing a relationship with Nilda at the insistence of his father, Heinrik. Nilda can see through Jeffrey's advances. He's a self-centered snob who thinks Nilda should be grateful if Jeffrey stoops to say hello to her. He only talks of himself, and he's dismissive of just about anything and everything Nilda has to say. He's not too observant, or he'd never have proposed at a public ball! He reminds me a bit of Disney's Gaston.
Fritz Larsson is a teacher and a musician. He's known Nilda for several books now. She's been taking piano lessons from him. She's always liked him. Perhaps she's always liked-liked him. But does he like-like her? Does he love her? Does he want to marry her?
This one isn't just a romance. It's also a novel about compassion and giving back. Nilda and her employer are hard at work on a new project that will help new immigrants that arrive in Blackduck.
My thoughts: I had my issues with the third book, I won't lie. But I thoroughly enjoyed this latest book in the series. I'm so glad that I've read it. I don't know why I assumed they'd just be three books in the series!!!
I love Lauraine Snelling's novels. It's always a treat to spend time with her well-developed characters.
August 31, 2022
I wanted to rate this higher because I’ve read some other Lauraine Snelling books and loved them, but this series was kind of a let down.
Everyone was perfect in the family, except for Knute, and his biggest fault was not wanting to go to school.
The conversations were terrible. Someone would be talking about something and then, without a pause or end of quotations marks, they would change the subject. Very confusing, very poor writing in my opinion. My only thought was that Norwegian people talk like that?
I wished the last book had more about the farm. I was bored by Nilda’s life in town. I also feel like the farm part of the story was left unfinished. For instance, is Rune going to go blind?
In all, I was tired of reading the series by the end and it seemed as if the author was tired of writing the series by the end.
Everyone was perfect in the family, except for Knute, and his biggest fault was not wanting to go to school.
The conversations were terrible. Someone would be talking about something and then, without a pause or end of quotations marks, they would change the subject. Very confusing, very poor writing in my opinion. My only thought was that Norwegian people talk like that?
I wished the last book had more about the farm. I was bored by Nilda’s life in town. I also feel like the farm part of the story was left unfinished. For instance, is Rune going to go blind?
In all, I was tired of reading the series by the end and it seemed as if the author was tired of writing the series by the end.
February 17, 2022
I'm on page 110 and wondering is there a plot? Or just more slow rambling about farm life? The author throws so many names into the story, I can't keep them straight. I've read all my life and this book is the first I'm not eager to pick up. I feel like I'm muddling through.
August 10, 2019
A Song of Joy is by far my favorite of Lauraine Snelling’s Under Northern Skies series. I adored this story and highly recommend it.
Five plus stars.
Five plus stars.
December 10, 2019
Usually love this author's writing, but this book was sluggish to get through.
March 25, 2021
I love how Snelling brings in the family on the farm, and the family in town, and ties them together. With mystery, intrigue, and clean romance, it's a story worth reading!
May 2, 2022
I don't know . . .these books just kept getting worse, but I kept reading them because . . . just to finish the series I guess? I don't think I'll be reading anything else by the author, to be honest. My biggest pet peeve with this one was that a private investigator showed up concerning Dreng Nygard's death. I was so over stupid rapist Dreng, and I just didn't understand why it had to be dragged out any further. I get that sexual assault was not taken as seriously back then as it is today, but even in 1911 a woman running screaming from the woods with a ripped dress and bruises is pretty cut and dry. And Dreng's cause of death was hypothermia. How do you murder someone via hypothermia? It's ridiculous. Plus, I couldn't understand why everyone kept talking to this investigator. He wasn't a police officer, and even if he was, he had no warrant or any way to legally make them talk to him. Nilda especially should never have spoken to him. Then, there was the woman he assaulted in the logging camp. All the sheriff had to do was send the investigator to the logging camp right off the bat to prove Dreng was a serial rapist. Or, I don't know, interview the multiple women he assaulted in Norway? Why was this even a thing?!!!!!
I also got confused by all the characters. Others have mentioned this as well. Nilda's mother's cousin started writing letters, and I get that this cousin was a character in a previous series by this author, but I just . . . didn't care. At all. Then, new characters were introduced in the high society of the twin cities, and I just was utterly confused. Especially when Jeffrey's brother ended up being named Jeremy, and I just couldn't keep straight who they were talking about.
Finally, the "romance" - which has never been very well done in this series - was just a snooze fest. I liked Fritz, he was sweet, but I just didn't get enough of him with Nilda to really invest in their relationship. I mainly just wanted her to choose Fritz to keep her away from the snobby, whiny Jeffrey. I felt even the thing with Jeffrey could have been better done. Make him a charmer, who while there are red flags, seems like someone who Nilda may legitimately fall for. Instead, he was so awful, you never for one second worried she would choose him. I think there could have been some sexual tension with Jeffrey, Nilda feeling confused by her warring attractions and emotions, just to raise the stakes and make Fritz fight for her.
Overall, I was just bored and frustrated with this entire book. I wrestled with whether to give this one or two stars, but since I actually finished it, I gave it two. And her writing was decent, not awful. So yeah, two stars. Probably more like one and a half, but that isn't an option.
I also got confused by all the characters. Others have mentioned this as well. Nilda's mother's cousin started writing letters, and I get that this cousin was a character in a previous series by this author, but I just . . . didn't care. At all. Then, new characters were introduced in the high society of the twin cities, and I just was utterly confused. Especially when Jeffrey's brother ended up being named Jeremy, and I just couldn't keep straight who they were talking about.
Finally, the "romance" - which has never been very well done in this series - was just a snooze fest. I liked Fritz, he was sweet, but I just didn't get enough of him with Nilda to really invest in their relationship. I mainly just wanted her to choose Fritz to keep her away from the snobby, whiny Jeffrey. I felt even the thing with Jeffrey could have been better done. Make him a charmer, who while there are red flags, seems like someone who Nilda may legitimately fall for. Instead, he was so awful, you never for one second worried she would choose him. I think there could have been some sexual tension with Jeffrey, Nilda feeling confused by her warring attractions and emotions, just to raise the stakes and make Fritz fight for her.
Overall, I was just bored and frustrated with this entire book. I wrestled with whether to give this one or two stars, but since I actually finished it, I gave it two. And her writing was decent, not awful. So yeah, two stars. Probably more like one and a half, but that isn't an option.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 7, 2020
"In His time, God will make it clear to you. Thank Him in advance for His answers.”
1911 What a joy to be back in Blackduck, Minnesota, with these special people again. We say this was a simpler time, but there was so much work in day to day things. Like using the telephone. We all have one on us these days. Back then, not all houses had one. You had to go into town to use one. People communicated by mail. Now I bet some do not even know what its like to receive a letter. Written in cursive.
A family of Norwegian immigrants, in a town made up of mostly that nationality. There is the farm where this family resides and grows, and they bring over family from Norway a little at a time. Hardworking, skilled people. And a wealthy widow in a nearby town who took in one of the girls to train and groom her as an assistant. I love how Lauraine brings in people from different generations, you learn about them, their likes and skills. It's fun to see potential and watch the young kids grow. Enriching to read. This is a year in the life of the lovely immigrant girl, Nilda, from Norway and how she settles in and learns from this wonderful woman, who has much to offer in loving kindness as well as money and prestige. This level of society and family money are not without responsibility or family struggle for control. Nilda is still shaking off the death of the man who harmed her in the previous book. God has a plan for her, which unfolds gracefully through the pages. A book that makes you feel warm all over inside - as Lauraine is so skilled at doing.
Quote
“You all work hard.” “That’s what it takes to survive out here. And we want to do more than survive.”
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from the publisher and NetGalley book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
#NetGalley #ASongOfJoy
1911 What a joy to be back in Blackduck, Minnesota, with these special people again. We say this was a simpler time, but there was so much work in day to day things. Like using the telephone. We all have one on us these days. Back then, not all houses had one. You had to go into town to use one. People communicated by mail. Now I bet some do not even know what its like to receive a letter. Written in cursive.
A family of Norwegian immigrants, in a town made up of mostly that nationality. There is the farm where this family resides and grows, and they bring over family from Norway a little at a time. Hardworking, skilled people. And a wealthy widow in a nearby town who took in one of the girls to train and groom her as an assistant. I love how Lauraine brings in people from different generations, you learn about them, their likes and skills. It's fun to see potential and watch the young kids grow. Enriching to read. This is a year in the life of the lovely immigrant girl, Nilda, from Norway and how she settles in and learns from this wonderful woman, who has much to offer in loving kindness as well as money and prestige. This level of society and family money are not without responsibility or family struggle for control. Nilda is still shaking off the death of the man who harmed her in the previous book. God has a plan for her, which unfolds gracefully through the pages. A book that makes you feel warm all over inside - as Lauraine is so skilled at doing.
Quote
“You all work hard.” “That’s what it takes to survive out here. And we want to do more than survive.”
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from the publisher and NetGalley book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
#NetGalley #ASongOfJoy
November 25, 2021
The fourth in the series with the main character Nilda, a young immigrant from Norway that takes place in the early 1900's. Nilda is working for a wealthy woman, Gertrude Schoenleber in a small town in Minnesota. Gertrude is the eldest sibling and only female in the family. Her father became very wealthy from hard work and being a very astute businessman. Gertrude is the only one who has chosen to live in a smaller town, her brothers all live in a bigger city and enjoy the finer lives that it has to offer. Gertrude believes in being a philanthropist just like her father while her brothers seem to have forgotten how important that work really is. She has taken Nilda under her wing and has trained her to be her assistant and given her the challenge on discovering what would really benefit the town they now live in. How can they make life better for new immigrants?
It seems suddenly, Jeffery, one of Gertrude's brothers sons has become interested in Nilda but is there an ulterior motive. Jeffery loves to talk about himself and enjoys the finer things life has to offer, playing tennis, going to the symphony etc. He seems slow to understand Nilda has no interest in him!
Nilda enjoys spending time with Gertrude's other nephew, Fritz and school teacher and talented piano player. Fritz is not afraid of hard work very unlike Gertrude's brother's sons.
Nilda loves being able to take time off to spend with her mother and two brothers on the farm where they are now living. While the conditions are much better than when they lived in Norway, all of them still miss their homeland.
I find it quite interesting to learn how life was for those people during that time period; how the women worked hard from dawn to dusk, keeping up with the laundry, cooking the meals, churning the butter, tending and preserving the garden. I've vowed to try to can potatoes next year just like they did just to see how they taste.
It seems suddenly, Jeffery, one of Gertrude's brothers sons has become interested in Nilda but is there an ulterior motive. Jeffery loves to talk about himself and enjoys the finer things life has to offer, playing tennis, going to the symphony etc. He seems slow to understand Nilda has no interest in him!
Nilda enjoys spending time with Gertrude's other nephew, Fritz and school teacher and talented piano player. Fritz is not afraid of hard work very unlike Gertrude's brother's sons.
Nilda loves being able to take time off to spend with her mother and two brothers on the farm where they are now living. While the conditions are much better than when they lived in Norway, all of them still miss their homeland.
I find it quite interesting to learn how life was for those people during that time period; how the women worked hard from dawn to dusk, keeping up with the laundry, cooking the meals, churning the butter, tending and preserving the garden. I've vowed to try to can potatoes next year just like they did just to see how they taste.
September 4, 2019
A Song of Joy by Lauraine Snelling is a delightful story. Nilda Carlson, an immigrant from Norway, has for some months, worked as personal assistant to the wealthy Mrs. Schoenleber. She is grateful for all that she has learned and accomplished since being mentored by her generous employer. She has mastered English is learning the ropes in a large family corporation and fits in whether it is in the boardroom or on the family's farm. She is remarkably bright and it is her wish to give back so others who are new to the country can have some of the opportunities she has had. When she shares her ideas to her philanthropic boss, she is met with surprising enthusiasm that eventually leads to a whole community's involvement to help the newcomers.
I liked this book not just for the good story, but because it reminds me of how many of my ancestors came to America. Someone came first, checked out the opportunity and sent tickets home for others to follow either one by one or in a group. Some traveled by steerage and once they got to Minnesota, they settled together and worked hard. My father's family spoke mostly German at home. He went to school until the eighth grade, like Nilda's nephews did in A Song of Joy. I admire how hard these immigrants worked the land or in other industries to support their families while building a new life in our country. Their resilience, similar to the Carlson family, is what settled the midwest, and eventually, the western states. I wasn't aware this was the fourth book in the Under the Northern Skies series but A Song of Joy can be read as a standalone. I recommend this book as the story is engaging with good old fashioned characters!
I liked this book not just for the good story, but because it reminds me of how many of my ancestors came to America. Someone came first, checked out the opportunity and sent tickets home for others to follow either one by one or in a group. Some traveled by steerage and once they got to Minnesota, they settled together and worked hard. My father's family spoke mostly German at home. He went to school until the eighth grade, like Nilda's nephews did in A Song of Joy. I admire how hard these immigrants worked the land or in other industries to support their families while building a new life in our country. Their resilience, similar to the Carlson family, is what settled the midwest, and eventually, the western states. I wasn't aware this was the fourth book in the Under the Northern Skies series but A Song of Joy can be read as a standalone. I recommend this book as the story is engaging with good old fashioned characters!
October 26, 2019
Lauraine Snelling has done it again. This is the fourth book in Under the Northern Skies series and I loved it just like I loved the other three books.
The whole series takes a look at the Carlson family that has immigrated close to Blackduck, Minnesota. Starting with the Rune and his wife Signe and their children in the first book and then on to Rune's brother Ivar and sister Nilda and finally, their mother also making the trip to Minnesota.
In this book, Nilda is busy working for Mrs. Schoenleber in Blackduck, MN and they have the needs of other immigrants on their minds and hearts. The book is full of their plans to help the loggers and their families and is quite satisfying to read about. Nilda is an amazing woman and while there is a part of me that wonders if so much could be done in such a short time, I find the storyline fascinating. I also find Nilda's love of work and her desire not to be an upper society snob also refreshing.
There is a tiny bit of romance in this book, the book does end with a wedding, but it's very understated and even humorous at times. It doesn't pervade the whole book. You aren't even sure if anything will even happen in that regard until towards the end.
I just really enjoyed reading this series and would recommend it to anyone else who enjoys a good story. It's a feel-good story yes and yet it feels so real-to-life. It's not all happiness and roses, especially not in the first book or so. It's just a good refreshing read.
I received this book from Bethany House via NetGalley and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
The whole series takes a look at the Carlson family that has immigrated close to Blackduck, Minnesota. Starting with the Rune and his wife Signe and their children in the first book and then on to Rune's brother Ivar and sister Nilda and finally, their mother also making the trip to Minnesota.
In this book, Nilda is busy working for Mrs. Schoenleber in Blackduck, MN and they have the needs of other immigrants on their minds and hearts. The book is full of their plans to help the loggers and their families and is quite satisfying to read about. Nilda is an amazing woman and while there is a part of me that wonders if so much could be done in such a short time, I find the storyline fascinating. I also find Nilda's love of work and her desire not to be an upper society snob also refreshing.
There is a tiny bit of romance in this book, the book does end with a wedding, but it's very understated and even humorous at times. It doesn't pervade the whole book. You aren't even sure if anything will even happen in that regard until towards the end.
I just really enjoyed reading this series and would recommend it to anyone else who enjoys a good story. It's a feel-good story yes and yet it feels so real-to-life. It's not all happiness and roses, especially not in the first book or so. It's just a good refreshing read.
I received this book from Bethany House via NetGalley and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
September 10, 2019
In the Song of Joy, we follow a Norwegian farm girl, named Nilda Carlson. who has recently moved to America in the mid- 1910s. She is working as a secretary for a woman named Mrs. Schoenleber. Two men are trying to pursue Nilda. Jeffery and Fritz are both nephews of Mrs. Schoenleber. However, Jeffery might be not be genuine in his advances toward Nilda, nor understands her heart-felt compassion. Fritz on the other hand can understand Nilda and her passion for helping other immigrants like her self. Nevertheless, who will Nilda choose?
Caught between her farm life and trying to adapt to her new way of life, Nilda longs to help the immigrants that come to the area have an easier start. Although the task is difficult for her to accomplish on her own, she comes up with a plan to help not only others but also her family, too. Which man will genuinely agree with her dreams, Jeffery or Fritz? Will her family still be her number one support system and accept the new person she is becoming or will becoming a part of the society change their opinion of young Nilda? You have to grab a copy for yourself to see.
This was my second Lauraine Snelling book. Although it was good and I jumped right in again, the book had some parts that just lost my interest and it became hard to read. It must be something with the writing style Ms. Snelling uses. However, I enjoyed the book because it was different than some of the others I’ve been reading. I enjoyed the story about immigrants making their way in this country in the early 1900s. I hope that you will enjoy the book, too.
Caught between her farm life and trying to adapt to her new way of life, Nilda longs to help the immigrants that come to the area have an easier start. Although the task is difficult for her to accomplish on her own, she comes up with a plan to help not only others but also her family, too. Which man will genuinely agree with her dreams, Jeffery or Fritz? Will her family still be her number one support system and accept the new person she is becoming or will becoming a part of the society change their opinion of young Nilda? You have to grab a copy for yourself to see.
This was my second Lauraine Snelling book. Although it was good and I jumped right in again, the book had some parts that just lost my interest and it became hard to read. It must be something with the writing style Ms. Snelling uses. However, I enjoyed the book because it was different than some of the others I’ve been reading. I enjoyed the story about immigrants making their way in this country in the early 1900s. I hope that you will enjoy the book, too.
August 27, 2019
A Song of Joy, by Lauraine Snelling was an absolute delight to read. I always enjoy Ms. Snelling’s books for their gentle and easy flow, the characters who I just want to invite to tea and a good chat, and the lovely settings she brings to my imagination.
Nilda Carlson works for a wealthy lady in Blackduck, Minnesota. Being an immigrant herself, she has a heart for Norwegians moving to the area in need of help. Along with her employer, they begin a building project to house and feed the families of those working in the lumber industry. Nilda is a woman of high character, but there is someone lurking around, digging up the past and trying to ruin Nilda’s reputation. Add to that a man who seems determined to marry her, even though he doesn’t love her, and another man who loves her but is holding back, and Nilda has a lot to keep up with.
I really enjoyed this book. Nilda is such an endearing character, and I rooted for her the whole time. She is full of determination and gumption, and above all, love for those around her. It was exciting to watch her love life unfold. The characters back on the family farm were also delightful to read about. A Song of Joy is an all around fantastic book, and I highly recommend it.
I received a free copy of this book from the publishers for an honest review. The opinions are my own.
Nilda Carlson works for a wealthy lady in Blackduck, Minnesota. Being an immigrant herself, she has a heart for Norwegians moving to the area in need of help. Along with her employer, they begin a building project to house and feed the families of those working in the lumber industry. Nilda is a woman of high character, but there is someone lurking around, digging up the past and trying to ruin Nilda’s reputation. Add to that a man who seems determined to marry her, even though he doesn’t love her, and another man who loves her but is holding back, and Nilda has a lot to keep up with.
I really enjoyed this book. Nilda is such an endearing character, and I rooted for her the whole time. She is full of determination and gumption, and above all, love for those around her. It was exciting to watch her love life unfold. The characters back on the family farm were also delightful to read about. A Song of Joy is an all around fantastic book, and I highly recommend it.
I received a free copy of this book from the publishers for an honest review. The opinions are my own.
July 10, 2019
Lauraine Snelling has an affinity for books about the Scandanavian immigrant. Each story builds on a previous one and fills in a bit more about the characters. It makes the reader feel a part of the neighborhood.
Nilda Larsson works for Gertrude Schoenleber as her secretary and assistant. Gertrude's brother doesn't feel that Nilda belongs in the board meetings of the family logging business, so he gets his son to court Nilda as a way of neutralizing Nilda's affect on the business.
At the same time another nephew of Gertrude's, named Fritz, spends his time being Nilda's friend and quietly courting her without being obvious about it. One of the talents Fritz has is playing piano and Nilda looks forward to his every visit so that she can have another lesson.
This book is a quietly, even-paced novel with well-written characters and deeply thought out settings. The reappearing characters get more depth and focus while the main characters shine like stars. I loved the way the plot played out in such a satisfying way.
This is a five star book, with two thumbs up, and a good report on your next piano lesson.
I want to thank Bethany House and NetGalley.com for providing the galley I read.
Nilda Larsson works for Gertrude Schoenleber as her secretary and assistant. Gertrude's brother doesn't feel that Nilda belongs in the board meetings of the family logging business, so he gets his son to court Nilda as a way of neutralizing Nilda's affect on the business.
At the same time another nephew of Gertrude's, named Fritz, spends his time being Nilda's friend and quietly courting her without being obvious about it. One of the talents Fritz has is playing piano and Nilda looks forward to his every visit so that she can have another lesson.
This book is a quietly, even-paced novel with well-written characters and deeply thought out settings. The reappearing characters get more depth and focus while the main characters shine like stars. I loved the way the plot played out in such a satisfying way.
This is a five star book, with two thumbs up, and a good report on your next piano lesson.
I want to thank Bethany House and NetGalley.com for providing the galley I read.
August 22, 2019
A Song of Joy
by Lauraine Snelling
Bethany House
Bethany House Publishers
Christian
Pub Date 06 Aug 2019
I am reviewing a copy of A Song of Joy through Bethany House Publishers and Netgalley:
In this book we will be transported back to 1911 Minnesota. Nilda Carlson finds herself torn between society life in Blackduck and spending time with her family on the farm. She is employed by Mrs. Schoenleber who is giving her more and more responsibility and experience which includes recommending new opportunities for her philanthropy. Nilda who is still new to America herself focuses on the areas immigrant community. But she finds herself having to fight to get her ideas accepted by donors and locals alike.
One of her greatest joys at the time is her weekly piano lessons with handsome Schoolteacher Fritz. But just as Nilda is coming to the realization she has feelings for him, a young affluent, stylish woman moves to Blackburn monopolizing all of Fritz’s attention. Can Nilda hope to compete with such a Sophisticated beauty?
I give A Song of Joy five out of five stars!
Happy Reading!
by Lauraine Snelling
Bethany House
Bethany House Publishers
Christian
Pub Date 06 Aug 2019
I am reviewing a copy of A Song of Joy through Bethany House Publishers and Netgalley:
In this book we will be transported back to 1911 Minnesota. Nilda Carlson finds herself torn between society life in Blackduck and spending time with her family on the farm. She is employed by Mrs. Schoenleber who is giving her more and more responsibility and experience which includes recommending new opportunities for her philanthropy. Nilda who is still new to America herself focuses on the areas immigrant community. But she finds herself having to fight to get her ideas accepted by donors and locals alike.
One of her greatest joys at the time is her weekly piano lessons with handsome Schoolteacher Fritz. But just as Nilda is coming to the realization she has feelings for him, a young affluent, stylish woman moves to Blackburn monopolizing all of Fritz’s attention. Can Nilda hope to compete with such a Sophisticated beauty?
I give A Song of Joy five out of five stars!
Happy Reading!
October 3, 2019
This is the fourth book in the series Under Northern Skies. I did not realize this was a series book when I requested it through Netgalley. Even though it was the last of a series, it was still a good standalone book. It would have been more interesting if I had read the first three books, but it was still interesting.
I have always enjoyed books by Lauraine Snelling and this did not disappoint. It was slow in some spots, a lot of description at times but this did not detract from the story. The characters were well developed and the plot was an easy read. It had a little bit of suspense when Nilda was being investigated but not a true suspense novel. It is more a love story, sweet and simple.
The editing was well done. That can make or break a book in my opinion. I hate having to re-read things to figure out the wrong words or punctuation.
This is a Christian book though not preachy. It does show the importance of depending on God. It is mostly a clean, no sexual content, love story. I freely give my review it is my own opinion and not forced in any way. I recommend this book and I give it 4 out of 5 stars.
I have always enjoyed books by Lauraine Snelling and this did not disappoint. It was slow in some spots, a lot of description at times but this did not detract from the story. The characters were well developed and the plot was an easy read. It had a little bit of suspense when Nilda was being investigated but not a true suspense novel. It is more a love story, sweet and simple.
The editing was well done. That can make or break a book in my opinion. I hate having to re-read things to figure out the wrong words or punctuation.
This is a Christian book though not preachy. It does show the importance of depending on God. It is mostly a clean, no sexual content, love story. I freely give my review it is my own opinion and not forced in any way. I recommend this book and I give it 4 out of 5 stars.
June 19, 2019
(4 stars) - A song of joy from Zephaniah 3:14-20
This is book 4 of a series. I was unaware & so have not read the previous books yet, so I can attest that the book stood on its own just fine; however, because it's a family saga, it most likely would be contextually richer to read them in order.
The hero and heroine's story is written so "real" & is so sweet that it makes me smile every time I think about it. I loved the historical detail, especially the new inventions of their time & how it affected them.
The story was incredibly realistic & immersive. I also really appreciated that the villains of the story, for the most part, didn't follow any of the common tropes.
There were some points where it felt like it didn't need to be quite so detailed, but that may well have been my eagerness for the happy couple to finally admit their love to each other. 😉
Clean romance level: sweet kisses
Religion: explicitly Christian, characters are protestant, but Christianity is relatively generic
This is book 4 of a series. I was unaware & so have not read the previous books yet, so I can attest that the book stood on its own just fine; however, because it's a family saga, it most likely would be contextually richer to read them in order.
The hero and heroine's story is written so "real" & is so sweet that it makes me smile every time I think about it. I loved the historical detail, especially the new inventions of their time & how it affected them.
The story was incredibly realistic & immersive. I also really appreciated that the villains of the story, for the most part, didn't follow any of the common tropes.
There were some points where it felt like it didn't need to be quite so detailed, but that may well have been my eagerness for the happy couple to finally admit their love to each other. 😉
Clean romance level: sweet kisses
Religion: explicitly Christian, characters are protestant, but Christianity is relatively generic
August 6, 2019
A Song of Joy is the fourth book in Lauraine Snelling's Under Northern Skies series about a Norwegian family that immigrated to Minnesota. This book continues the story of Nilda Carlson in the year of 1911. The best part of this wonderful story is its reminder of the pure enjoyment one can received from the simplest of blessings: time with friends and family, fresh produce, a bird's song, and a cool breeze on a clear summer's night. Since reading this book I have purposefully been making myself attend to these types of blessings rather than allowing them to slip by unnoticed. The pervasive theme of the joys of giving and serving are also treasures in A Song of Joy. I thank Lauraine Snelling for reminding us of these joys, and to whom we owe our thanks. She allows God to use her gifting as a storyteller to both entertain and minister.
I am grateful to have received a copy of this book from Bethany House via NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion. I was under no obligation to provide a positive review and received no monetary compensation.
I am grateful to have received a copy of this book from Bethany House via NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion. I was under no obligation to provide a positive review and received no monetary compensation.
December 23, 2025
A Song of Joy is the fourth book in Lauraine Snelling's Under Northern Skies series. It can be read as a stand alone, but I think it is a more enjoyable to read the other three first, to become acquainted with the characters.
In this book Nilda Carlson continues to work with Gertrude Schoenleber, as her assistant and secretary. They work on a new project that will help new immigrants arriving in Blackduck, MN. She is torn between life on the farm with her family, and her work in the city. There is also a romance line in the story. Nilda has been taking piano lessons from a teacher and musician, Fritz Larsson, who also happens to be the nephew of her employer Mrs Schoenleber. Nilda likes him, but is not sure he feels the same. Jeffrey Schmitz also has eyes for Nilda at the insistence of his parents who want him to marry her. She has absolutely no interest in the self- centered young man.
The novel features a love story, exploring the complexities of relationships and choosing a partner based on character and shared values rather than wealth or social standing.
In this book Nilda Carlson continues to work with Gertrude Schoenleber, as her assistant and secretary. They work on a new project that will help new immigrants arriving in Blackduck, MN. She is torn between life on the farm with her family, and her work in the city. There is also a romance line in the story. Nilda has been taking piano lessons from a teacher and musician, Fritz Larsson, who also happens to be the nephew of her employer Mrs Schoenleber. Nilda likes him, but is not sure he feels the same. Jeffrey Schmitz also has eyes for Nilda at the insistence of his parents who want him to marry her. She has absolutely no interest in the self- centered young man.
The novel features a love story, exploring the complexities of relationships and choosing a partner based on character and shared values rather than wealth or social standing.
September 15, 2019
I have enjoyed this series by Lauraine Snelling, and this story follows my two favorite characters, Fritz and Nilda. I have loved seeing Nilda’s character develop throughout these books and I’ve appreciated that the author has allowed her character to retain her deep love of family, but also develop the unique gifts she has to take her a different direction than some of the other characters. Many of the other characters make an appearance, too, and we get to see how they have settled in to their new life in America. I’d recommend this whole series, as it’s wonderful Christian historical fiction. The author has done some great research as the background for her story, and I appreciated the faith of the characters all throughout the books.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 85 reviews