When many people think of Christmas, they dream of snow-covered pine trees and a small cabin warmed by the wood fire on a cold December day. Since Maine was founded, people have written stories about the joys of Christmas in the state. In times of hardship and in times of wealth, Maine and her people have always put the value of Christmas in time shared with family and friends, connections with the natural world, rich traditions, and warm wood stoves. In a collection featuring essays, stories, and poetry, All is Calm is a look at the lives of Mainers during the holidays from the mid-1800s, to the Great Depression, to modern day. Spanning nearly 200 years, these stories show that while Christmas traditions and trends may be changing, the warmth, gratitude, and humility of the Maine spirit is evergreen.
I got this anthology of poems + essays on the “Maine” shelf in a Portland bookshop, and I’m so glad I got to read it on the porch of my Victorian B&B while looking out at the best mid-coastal Maine has to offer (The sea! Wildflowers! Trees!). Did I mention it was raining and the season is turning?! Literally cozy perfection ☕️🎄
I have a FOMO that’s hard to articulate—one that involves nostalgia for a place I’ve never seen and an unattainable longing to experience Christmas in Maine as a Mainer, with a family of Mainers. However, since generationally-rooted lived-experience is a non-option for me, I will have to instead live vicariously through the pages of this book to soak up the magic, charm, and sacredness of the season and its traditions.
[Yes, I know we haven’t even hit Labor Day yet, and yes, I am very excited for Christmas]
What a wonderful book of stories. How to describe the stories? Cozy, Picturesque, Warm, Christmas Card snapshots. All the stories by people who have lived in Maine and what comes through their telling of Christmases past is there no better place to celebrate Christmas than in Maine and they wouldn't want to be any place else. Whether you are from the mainland or one of the off islands they love the celebration in their state. So, if you are from Maine pick this book up and enjoy the memories because these authors did and you will be too.
P.S. My daughter lives in Maine and sent me this book.
All is Calm: A Maine Christmas Reader, edited by Shannon Butler, is a cozy collection written about the joys of Christmas in the state of Maine. This heartwarming collection includes essays, stories, and poetry from the mid-1800s through present day. My copy also included advertisements from the past as well as illustrations and photos.
I read All is Calm in December with the Cozy Cottage Book Club and really enjoyed it. Even though I live in the south, I enjoyed learning about Christmas in Maine at various time periods. We rarely have snow, so it was nice to read about Christmas adventures that involved snow and going into the woods to cut down Christmas trees. I loved the format of the collection. It made for a relaxing reading experience which I enjoyed during the hustle and bustle of the Christmas season.
I’m totally biased. Maine is the best place to be for Christmas, and this, the coziest Christmas reader you ever did see, only furthers my theory. The author dug up some impressive Maine writing through the last 100+ years that prove that Christmases past and Christmases present, though the wrap and bows may be different, still share many of the same qualities.
The format of this book is pleasant and very readable; just the kind of book to pick away at night after night by the lights of the Christmas tree.
This is, quite simply, a book that will evoke memories and make you—Mainers, especially—happy.
As with any anthology, there’s a great deal of variation in the quality of the entries. Many of them are small snippets of Maine’s past—loose newspaper articles, a smattering of poems, newsletter entries of charitable organizations during Christmas—but for the most part, they were charming. I’m generally a fan of ephemera, so I rather liked these bite sized bits from the past. Enjoyable reading right before bed.
I got this before Christmas from my son. We all love Maine and it was a wonderful book of essays about Christmas in Maine from many different people throughout the years. I found it delightful. Even in tough times, like during the depression, people always found a way to the Christmas spirit.
These readings were selected from Maine publications ranging in date from the 19th century though the 20th. There were some stunning descriptions of natural settings, and life in the various parts of the state. A worthwhile read for those interested in Mine life and history.
This cozy collection of Maine stories at Christmas makes a reader feel peaceful and reflective. It wasn’t what I expected - I expected some fictional tales interspersed, and some people’s stories were better and more captivating than others, but over all it was a pleasant read for the holidays!
Started reading today for the IAH book club. So far, I really like the book. It's a quick read. I'm reading it on a Kindle/Fire. Some of the stories are true which I really like. I like that they stories are written all around Maine. I liked all the short stories and poems in this book. It put me into the holiday mood so much that we went out and cut down a Christmas tree yesterday and I decorated the tree today! I'm so glad I took the time to read this book. I'm glad to see the Maine Seacoast Mission had a story in it and that Isle au Haut, and Stonington was mentioned in the book as well. A fun read for sure. I would recommend this book as a wonderful holiday read.
A good collection of Christmas stories but too much if reading straight through. It is better in small doses. Also, the overly christian viewpoint seems dated.