What do you think?
Rate this book


325 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2017
Simply put, one does not. It is one thing to write a biography without interviewing the subject when the subject is a person from history. Secondary sources are the only options in that case. However, writing about a living legend without ever interviewing the subject is like trying to describe color to a blind person or the act of sex to a virgin. Either David Roberts did not try hard enough to interview Stills, or the subject had a reason to decline the interview. Either way, I am skeptical at best of author David Roberts' bona fides in this instance; it makes me discredit the cites and quotes that Roberts has imported and attributed to other players.
There is very little (and I mean VERY little) information contained in this book that has not been published elsewhere.
If the reader desires further information about Stills, one must look to the autobiographies of David Crosby, Graham Nash, or Neil Young.
Perhaps Stephen Stills' position is that he actually intends to let his music do all of his speaking for him.
It is for certain sure that David Roberts has not added anything on Stills' behalf.
My rating: 6/10 (because this book is not a bad summation of Stills' career; it just adds nothing to the body of knowledge), finished 3/25/20 (3431).