I have many feelings about Always, but I’ll start by saying it’s a worthy conclusion to Felix’s life. Not something easy to do, when each of the books of his life have deeply moved me in their own ways.
Always evokes heart-rending emotion and touches on terrible themes: racism, hatred, bigotry writ current in the 21st century. The overall themes and messages of this book were appropriately done, because as Soon also covered: reality means evil is never fully vanquished with the heroes living a happily ever after. Humanity is never so simple.
This book explores how despite the terrible cost of WWII, people are starting to forget the lessons of the past. That there are those who lived during periods of horror, and choose to frame their lives in its shadow and in a destructive way. That apathy, indifference, and corruption still live on in new generations.
It also touches on greed, hope and love. I enjoy how the memory of Zelda was woven throughout Always, and how the treasure was far more priceless than money. Yes it’s cliche, but fitting for this series.
There is also a healthy dose of ‘fan service’ for lack of a better term, with the most references to previous characters in Always than ever before. On one hand it was exciting to have those references sprinkled in, and I think the way the plot relied on them was done tastefully. On the other hand, I think there was more use of past characters as ‘things’ to move the plot with very little exploration on discovering new things about these earlier characters, and fleshing them out in that way. Without giving any spoilers, it makes sense due to the time, however I think exploring the spirit of earlier characters could have strengthened the novel.
However, this book didn’t make it to 5 stars because of two things:
1) I felt it was a little lengthy in some places. This is noticeably the longest novel in the series. Always follows a more classic storyline, in that there is an (apparently) clear goal the ‘heroes’ are racing towards, and they need to defeat the ‘villains’. There is nothing wrong with this narrative, and there were many thoughtful and touching moments throughout. However, the Once series hasn’t so obviously relied on this kind of narrative arc in the past, and I’ve found the subtle arcs of the other novels adds to their strength.
2) Point 1 links into how Always is reflective of a shift of the series to a more….cartoonish slant? I’m not quite sure how to define it, but I definitely noticed in Maybe that there was a much clearer element of break from reality/deus ex machina incorporated into the books where things didn’t reallyyyyyy make sense but things would work out mostly happily at the end for our heroes. There is still tragedy along the way, but there is really a sense that in the small scale of our heroes lives, they will triumph. Always continues this trend, although it was done more gracefully than Maybe (from memory, I haven’t read it recently, there was one very sudden jarring reality-lapse in Maybe).
This sense of a last minute rescue/solution wasn’t the case in Once, Then and After, and I suppose that reflects the particular nature of wartime that those novels are set within. However, I find it removes some of the nuance of the stories, and simplifies the messages.
***
To sum up, Always is a beautiful read with some subtle, but not hugely noticeable weak spots. I’m very sad to say goodbye to Felix, but happy to lay his life, in all its terribly beautiful glory, to rest. May those of us who read these books Always hold his messages of hope and love in our hearts.