What do you think?
Rate this book
Backstage Romance #1
Love and Loathing
A spunky chorus girl. A hotshot movie star. An unforgettable stage kiss.
Beth Bennet can’t keep her mind off of Will Darcy--but only because he’s infuriatingly arrogant just like every other Hollywood type she’s known. It’s definitely not because he’s drop-dead gorgeous. If she didn’t need this job so badly, their choreography would be more like stage combat—toe-curling kiss notwithstanding. And since she swore to loathe him for all eternity, falling for him would be an extreme inconvenience.
Will Darcy is only doing this musical as a favor to a friend, and he certainly could do without the distraction from the sassy and spirited Beth Bennet—even if she invades his daydreams like an over-zealous photo bomber.
As sparks fly, riotous drama ensues when they can no longer fight the attraction on and off stage. But when the curtain falls and the lights dim, is their on-stage romance more than just a fantastic performance?
Love and Loathing is a clean romantic comedy and a standalone in the Backstage Romance Book Series.
If you like enemies to lovers chemistry, witty banter, and giggle-inducing humor, you’ll love Gigi Blume’s hilarious retelling of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice. Buy Love and Loathing today and enjoy the show.440 pages, ebook
First published February 18, 2019
241 people are currently reading
1307 people want to read
About the author
Gigi Blume
29 books502 followersGigi is a USA TODAY bestselling author and hopeless musical theatre nerd who has perfected the art of lollygagging.
Former professional wedding singer, Gigi lives in Southern California with her personal chef...er...husband and two weird and awesome teenagers.
When Gigi's not writing like a crazy woman, she likes to belt out showtunes, embarrass her kids, and spend all her free cash on books.
Former professional wedding singer, Gigi lives in Southern California with her personal chef...er...husband and two weird and awesome teenagers.
When Gigi's not writing like a crazy woman, she likes to belt out showtunes, embarrass her kids, and spend all her free cash on books.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 142 reviews
April 2, 2019
Love and Loathing is just a delightful modern re-telling of Pride and Prejudice with a hint of Cinderella mixed in. It particularly resonates for me because the setting is a professional theatre production of Pirates of Penzance, which my choir just performed a few months ago. Made it so easy for me to visualize and hear in my head!
This operetta is Beth Bennet's first big break in the acting business. She has the role of Edith, one of the Stanley sisters, and Will Darcy is the big screen action hero who is the surprising casting choice for The Pirate King. Beth's roommate Jane plays Mabel, the female lead, while Darcy's protege, Bing, plays opposite her as Frederic. The parallel to P&P is obvious, but there are plenty of surprises in the way the plot unfolds. I don't want to spoil any of them, though I have to say I love the addition of Dame Stella Gardiner. She isn't Beth's aunt here but instead has a role more akin to a fairy godmother.
The story, related in first person, shifts between Beth and Will. The author does a wonderful job making both of them believable. I really enjoy the various musical, movie and book references that pop up. Beth has an endearing aversion to cursing, and each day she substitutes iconic character names for the epithets she might otherwise unleash. This is one feisty lady who prefers blunt speaking to polite nothings. Naturally, Will finds himself fascinated by her, and the course of true love does not run smoothly.
This is clever and funny and clean. I can enthusiastically recommend it.
This operetta is Beth Bennet's first big break in the acting business. She has the role of Edith, one of the Stanley sisters, and Will Darcy is the big screen action hero who is the surprising casting choice for The Pirate King. Beth's roommate Jane plays Mabel, the female lead, while Darcy's protege, Bing, plays opposite her as Frederic. The parallel to P&P is obvious, but there are plenty of surprises in the way the plot unfolds. I don't want to spoil any of them, though I have to say I love the addition of Dame Stella Gardiner. She isn't Beth's aunt here but instead has a role more akin to a fairy godmother.
The story, related in first person, shifts between Beth and Will. The author does a wonderful job making both of them believable. I really enjoy the various musical, movie and book references that pop up. Beth has an endearing aversion to cursing, and each day she substitutes iconic character names for the epithets she might otherwise unleash. This is one feisty lady who prefers blunt speaking to polite nothings. Naturally, Will finds himself fascinated by her, and the course of true love does not run smoothly.
This is clever and funny and clean. I can enthusiastically recommend it.
March 2, 2019
A deliciously romantic,witty,dual perspective tale,a modern twist on P&P that is highly recommended!!!
April 19, 2020
5 stars ONLY because that is to top rating allowed by GR otherwise 10 no 15 stars. I loved this book! Admittedly I am not a fan of modern P&P versions but I am a fan of books set in Hollywood and the author combines the two and hits it out of the park.
Every character, except Kitty, makes an appearance in some form. Some are obvious others are less so. The dialogue is witty and snarky. The pop culture references fly fast and furious.
Lizzy Bennet is a musical theater actress who is cast in the role of Edith in Pirates of Penzance at the Gardiner theater in Los Angles. She is joined in the cast by her friend and roommate Jane, a young actress/dance Lydia, an up and coming actor Bing and established Hollywood action star Will Darcy who has a background in Musical Theater (thing Hugh Jackman), the musical director Fitz, the dance master Colin Hunsford and the director's nephew Denny and Caroline (she's back...)
Behind the scenes we have Jorge Wickham, set builder. Lizzy works as a waitress at Lucas Lodge, a quirky multi-theme Hollywood water hole with her Bestie and neighbor Charlotte, under the watchful eye of Charlotte's father.
Lizzy immediately hates Will when he calls her untalented. She things he is the spoiled child of Hollywood royalty and the star of unimpressive blockbuster action films. But of course these opinions will change by the end of the book.
The story is mostly clean, just some snogging. And almost foul language free as Lizzy curses using names and characters from musicals.
The book is just delightful
Every character, except Kitty, makes an appearance in some form. Some are obvious others are less so. The dialogue is witty and snarky. The pop culture references fly fast and furious.
Lizzy Bennet is a musical theater actress who is cast in the role of Edith in Pirates of Penzance at the Gardiner theater in Los Angles. She is joined in the cast by her friend and roommate Jane, a young actress/dance Lydia, an up and coming actor Bing and established Hollywood action star Will Darcy who has a background in Musical Theater (thing Hugh Jackman), the musical director Fitz, the dance master Colin Hunsford and the director's nephew Denny and Caroline (she's back...)
Behind the scenes we have Jorge Wickham, set builder. Lizzy works as a waitress at Lucas Lodge, a quirky multi-theme Hollywood water hole with her Bestie and neighbor Charlotte, under the watchful eye of Charlotte's father.
Lizzy immediately hates Will when he calls her untalented. She things he is the spoiled child of Hollywood royalty and the star of unimpressive blockbuster action films. But of course these opinions will change by the end of the book.
The story is mostly clean, just some snogging. And almost foul language free as Lizzy curses using names and characters from musicals.
The book is just delightful
February 22, 2019
This is a modern variation set in the world of theater. I think what I enjoyed most in reading this was how inventive (or creative) the author was in how she was able to use both the basic outline of canon and also Jane Austen's words although at times the latter are paraphrased. Yes, other authors have used JA's words but in a modern setting it was just a little more of a stretch to make them fit the time and the situation.
This Beth does not have four sisters. The one sister she does have is Mary who has an almost cameo role herein. But her roommate at the onset is Jane and, of course, with Jane comes Bing who is another actor at the beginning of his career. Later Beth rescues a fellow actress who is living out of her car...Lydia. Lydia has much the same behaviors as in canon, flirting and impulsive and naïve, but her fate in the modern world...well, I don't go there but know it reflects present day...sadly.
Later (and here I am smiling) Beth names her heart "Kitty" as she tells us how that organ is feeling about certain situations. Mrs. Bennet does apply some pressure for Elizabeth to find a husband the few times we read of Elizabeth visiting home but as E. doesn't live at home it is not a daily occurrence.
I found this story to be a page-turner even though I knew where we were headed. As in canon we have that insult and Beth overhears it. Loved her in-your-face retort to him...“Mr. Darcy, you dropped something. Oh, it’s just your tact. Never mind.” I won't relate all the parts similar to canon which gave me pleasure in this variation but know that I do recommend this story. The author also gives you a free book to download even if you are borrowing this from KU.
Darcy keeps calling Beth a pixie due to her petite size and she wows him with her stage performances. Will has already made a name for himself in films while Beth is just starting out. She waits tables for a steady income as she is not as assured that her acting career will take off. We do have a Wickham so that is also nothing new.
Beth makes a habit of using names or songs or words from movies or plays as her substitutions for curse words. That was interesting although there are some movies or plays with which I was not familiar.
There is a short epilogue but it doesn't go far into the future.
This Beth does not have four sisters. The one sister she does have is Mary who has an almost cameo role herein. But her roommate at the onset is Jane and, of course, with Jane comes Bing who is another actor at the beginning of his career. Later Beth rescues a fellow actress who is living out of her car...Lydia. Lydia has much the same behaviors as in canon, flirting and impulsive and naïve, but her fate in the modern world...well, I don't go there but know it reflects present day...sadly.
Later (and here I am smiling) Beth names her heart "Kitty" as she tells us how that organ is feeling about certain situations. Mrs. Bennet does apply some pressure for Elizabeth to find a husband the few times we read of Elizabeth visiting home but as E. doesn't live at home it is not a daily occurrence.
I found this story to be a page-turner even though I knew where we were headed. As in canon we have that insult and Beth overhears it. Loved her in-your-face retort to him...“Mr. Darcy, you dropped something. Oh, it’s just your tact. Never mind.” I won't relate all the parts similar to canon which gave me pleasure in this variation but know that I do recommend this story. The author also gives you a free book to download even if you are borrowing this from KU.
Darcy keeps calling Beth a pixie due to her petite size and she wows him with her stage performances. Will has already made a name for himself in films while Beth is just starting out. She waits tables for a steady income as she is not as assured that her acting career will take off. We do have a Wickham so that is also nothing new.
Beth makes a habit of using names or songs or words from movies or plays as her substitutions for curse words. That was interesting although there are some movies or plays with which I was not familiar.
There is a short epilogue but it doesn't go far into the future.
February 23, 2019
This is a modern day retelling of Pride and Prejudice, full of fantastic fun and humour. Elizabeth is a struggling actress who lands a part in Pirates of Penzance, alongside famous Hollywood actor Will Darcy.
The story very much follows Pride and Prejudice and it was interesting to see how the same plot could happen in modern times. There are some real laugh out loud moments - Elizabeth is a complex character she's funny but it masks vulnerability and insecurity in her. Will is also an amazing character - as we get to know him more we can appreciate his difficulties and why he manages to get things spectacularly wrong with Elizabeth. Normally Lydia's character is one I almost always struggle to like... not here... she is a really likeable, funny character but who is also reckless and impulsive.
I enjoyed this book - it's witty, funny and kept me interested. It is a long book and I really loved the last half of the book which, on reflection, made the first part seem a bit long. When Will and Elizabeth start working things out I just loved it. It was a shame the reader doesn't spend more time with them in the romance part of the story... it was definitely my favourite part.
The book is written so we see the different perspectives of Will and Elizabeth - I just loved seeing how his feelings were so different to hers and how completely clueless he was at knowing what to do with her. The inner voices of both characters are hilarious. They are both quite self deprecating but this makes for good fun as they can laugh at themselves. It also helps the reader truly get to know these characters. I really liked them both.
Due to the book being set in a theatre, there are lots of film and theatre references which I didn't truly appreciate as I'm not hugely interested in film and theatre but I enjoyed the book all the same.
Usually, I'm not a fan of the Epilogue... this book has a short one that just rounded this story off perfectly. It was really cute and lovely!
I got an Advance Reader Copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest review.
The story very much follows Pride and Prejudice and it was interesting to see how the same plot could happen in modern times. There are some real laugh out loud moments - Elizabeth is a complex character she's funny but it masks vulnerability and insecurity in her. Will is also an amazing character - as we get to know him more we can appreciate his difficulties and why he manages to get things spectacularly wrong with Elizabeth. Normally Lydia's character is one I almost always struggle to like... not here... she is a really likeable, funny character but who is also reckless and impulsive.
I enjoyed this book - it's witty, funny and kept me interested. It is a long book and I really loved the last half of the book which, on reflection, made the first part seem a bit long. When Will and Elizabeth start working things out I just loved it. It was a shame the reader doesn't spend more time with them in the romance part of the story... it was definitely my favourite part.
The book is written so we see the different perspectives of Will and Elizabeth - I just loved seeing how his feelings were so different to hers and how completely clueless he was at knowing what to do with her. The inner voices of both characters are hilarious. They are both quite self deprecating but this makes for good fun as they can laugh at themselves. It also helps the reader truly get to know these characters. I really liked them both.
Due to the book being set in a theatre, there are lots of film and theatre references which I didn't truly appreciate as I'm not hugely interested in film and theatre but I enjoyed the book all the same.
Usually, I'm not a fan of the Epilogue... this book has a short one that just rounded this story off perfectly. It was really cute and lovely!
I got an Advance Reader Copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest review.
September 26, 2021
The core idea of this was great - modern retelling of P&P set in a theatre world. Characters were sympathetic for the most part, and there is a sense of humor threaded throughout, with some funny scenes, especially at the Lodge.
However, it was twice as long as it needed to be and just riddled with badly structured sentences/paragraphs and misused words - in dire need of a professional edit.
Some examples:
-Vice grip when it should be vise grip (multiple times, there was quite a bit of arm grabbing)
-An outer-body experience when it should be an out-of-body experience
-Our gazes met and the tension was palatable …it should be palpable!
-Characters were described as refraining themselves from doing things - should be restraining themselves i guess, although the number of times this was used, probably should come up with some other ways to say this
-He looked deep inside her eyes….just look into them, he is not an eye doctor!
-She relinquished a smirk…..just no, that is so awkward….just have the character smirk
…literally hundreds more examples i could give, nearly every page.
Descriptive set ups were too lengthy. There would be a sentence describing something, a character’s expression, for example. Then another sentence about it, saying a similar thing, just worded differently, maybe awkwardly. Then another sentence, with more adjectives and misused words…then maybe a fourth. Then maybe a snarky thought by the POV character. Then a humorous comment or hip reference or musical theater reference.
A good edit would trim the excess descriptive sentences down, make the tone more consistent throughout, and clean up all the misused words and awkward sentences. Result would be a shorter book, a much better reading experience, and fewer DNFs.
However, it was twice as long as it needed to be and just riddled with badly structured sentences/paragraphs and misused words - in dire need of a professional edit.
Some examples:
-Vice grip when it should be vise grip (multiple times, there was quite a bit of arm grabbing)
-An outer-body experience when it should be an out-of-body experience
-Our gazes met and the tension was palatable …it should be palpable!
-Characters were described as refraining themselves from doing things - should be restraining themselves i guess, although the number of times this was used, probably should come up with some other ways to say this
-He looked deep inside her eyes….just look into them, he is not an eye doctor!
-She relinquished a smirk…..just no, that is so awkward….just have the character smirk
…literally hundreds more examples i could give, nearly every page.
Descriptive set ups were too lengthy. There would be a sentence describing something, a character’s expression, for example. Then another sentence about it, saying a similar thing, just worded differently, maybe awkwardly. Then another sentence, with more adjectives and misused words…then maybe a fourth. Then maybe a snarky thought by the POV character. Then a humorous comment or hip reference or musical theater reference.
A good edit would trim the excess descriptive sentences down, make the tone more consistent throughout, and clean up all the misused words and awkward sentences. Result would be a shorter book, a much better reading experience, and fewer DNFs.
February 19, 2019
This was fantastic. It contained 3 of my favourite things. 1 a different spin on Elizabeth Bennett 2 stage production of Prirates of Penzance and 3 one liners from movies that will leave you giggling. This is so well written and will keep you turning pages to find out what’s going to happen next.
I received this as an arc and I am giving my honest review voluntarily
I received this as an arc and I am giving my honest review voluntarily
June 1, 2019
Definitely one of the funniest and most inventive P&P retellings. The author's take on Mr. Collins had me in stitches (even Fordyce's Sermons made an appearance in an unexpected way) while being quite sweet at the same time. This goes to my 'comfort read' shelf.
February 20, 2019
Set in present day Los Angeles, California, this book could be described as Pride and Prejudice meets musical theatre. Instead of wealthy Regency landowner Fitzwilliam Darcy, we get Hollywood action superstar Will Darcy who also has a penchant for stage musicals. Elizabeth is Beth Bennet who is about to work in her first professional stage role in Gilbert and Sullivan's The Pirates of Penzance at the Stella Gardiner Theatre.
The story follows canon pretty closely in a beautifully comic yet romantic way. Beth in particular has a unique approach to the curse words she uses, which had me laughing out loud on more than one occasion. The equivalent to Jane's and Elizabeth's stay at Netherfield Park is particularly inventive! Even before turning your first page, just the chapter titles will let you know you're in for an interesting time. We hear POVs from both Beth and Will during the course of the story; Will has about a third of the chapters to Beth's two thirds. Will gets the task of the "Two Years Later" epilogue which will make you sigh in a most contented manner.
I had no idea what to expect from from this book when I started reading but I absolutely adored it! OK, some of the musical theatre references were a little out of my sphere of knowledge, but it barely detracted from the experience of the story as a whole. I was especially fond of the occasional sci-fi references that popped up from time to time.
It'd be lovely to see more from Ms. Blume, especially if she could weave some of Jane Austen's other works into a similar background. Although there are some romantic scenes during the story, there's nothing remotely approaching explicit and it could be read by anyone.
I received a pre-publication ARC from the author and this is my honest opinion of it.
The story follows canon pretty closely in a beautifully comic yet romantic way. Beth in particular has a unique approach to the curse words she uses, which had me laughing out loud on more than one occasion. The equivalent to Jane's and Elizabeth's stay at Netherfield Park is particularly inventive! Even before turning your first page, just the chapter titles will let you know you're in for an interesting time. We hear POVs from both Beth and Will during the course of the story; Will has about a third of the chapters to Beth's two thirds. Will gets the task of the "Two Years Later" epilogue which will make you sigh in a most contented manner.
I had no idea what to expect from from this book when I started reading but I absolutely adored it! OK, some of the musical theatre references were a little out of my sphere of knowledge, but it barely detracted from the experience of the story as a whole. I was especially fond of the occasional sci-fi references that popped up from time to time.
It'd be lovely to see more from Ms. Blume, especially if she could weave some of Jane Austen's other works into a similar background. Although there are some romantic scenes during the story, there's nothing remotely approaching explicit and it could be read by anyone.
I received a pre-publication ARC from the author and this is my honest opinion of it.
May 27, 2022
WOW this book majorly sucked
I'm sorry, but I was ready to drop this book 100 pages in. I forced myself to finish so that I could see if it gets better but it didn't.
The author's writings style felt forced, she stripped Darcy and Elizabeth of most of their best features, also the Darcy character (Will) basically forced a kiss on the Elizabeth character (Beth) twice?? But it was okay because he's hot as Beth reminds you OVER AND OVER AGAIN - yeesh man we get it. Will has a POV which I thought was great until it kinda completely destroyed any character development that he had from the OG book. Also the racism in this book was actually sickening - I had to stop reading and just take a deep breath several times. The fact that Will just assumed that the Wickham character (Jorge) was on drugs and Beth just accepted it?? With like no other reasoning other than his behavior changed so he must being using. UM.
Also! Beth celebrates Hanukah as well as Christmas because she likes presents :)))
I was so excited for this book and for the rest of the books but I can't. It's too much and I just won't put myself through that again. The author continually pushed for sequels by adding in weird details that didn't serve *this* story's plot at all, there were weird details scattered across the whole book (at one point, Beth calls her heart Kitty - just to add in a reference to the OG) (also Bing and Jane decide to get married near the end right after they reunite and then it's not really addressed) UGH I'm sorry y'all this was a mess of a book and was about 300 pages more than it needed to be.
I'm sorry, but I was ready to drop this book 100 pages in. I forced myself to finish so that I could see if it gets better but it didn't.
The author's writings style felt forced, she stripped Darcy and Elizabeth of most of their best features, also the Darcy character (Will) basically forced a kiss on the Elizabeth character (Beth) twice?? But it was okay because he's hot as Beth reminds you OVER AND OVER AGAIN - yeesh man we get it. Will has a POV which I thought was great until it kinda completely destroyed any character development that he had from the OG book. Also the racism in this book was actually sickening - I had to stop reading and just take a deep breath several times. The fact that Will just assumed that the Wickham character (Jorge) was on drugs and Beth just accepted it?? With like no other reasoning other than his behavior changed so he must being using. UM.
Also! Beth celebrates Hanukah as well as Christmas because she likes presents :)))
I was so excited for this book and for the rest of the books but I can't. It's too much and I just won't put myself through that again. The author continually pushed for sequels by adding in weird details that didn't serve *this* story's plot at all, there were weird details scattered across the whole book (at one point, Beth calls her heart Kitty - just to add in a reference to the OG) (also Bing and Jane decide to get married near the end right after they reunite and then it's not really addressed) UGH I'm sorry y'all this was a mess of a book and was about 300 pages more than it needed to be.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 29, 2019
I loved Confessions of a Hollywood Matchmaker, but this one took me a bit to warm up to. I did like the last half of the book though!
February 19, 2019
That book was fantastic! I enjoyed reading it ever so much. Pride and Prejudice has been one of my favorites rereads since high school. And musical theater was my life for four years. The combination of the two was sheer delight. I giggled loudly at several parts. Fortunately, my family is used to this and politely ignored me.
It was so fun to read along seeing how different aspects of P&P played out in a contemporary setting and trying to guess how and when certain iconic scenes would be portrayed. I was not disappointed with the characters, dialogue, or plot at all.
That epilogue was one of my favorite ever! I had to contain my high pitched 'squeeee' as my husband was sleeping next to me and it may or may not have been close to 2 in the morning.
It was so fun to read along seeing how different aspects of P&P played out in a contemporary setting and trying to guess how and when certain iconic scenes would be portrayed. I was not disappointed with the characters, dialogue, or plot at all.
That epilogue was one of my favorite ever! I had to contain my high pitched 'squeeee' as my husband was sleeping next to me and it may or may not have been close to 2 in the morning.
December 19, 2022
This book made me create a new shelf. One and done. For when I nope out of a series.
I greatly enjoyed this book until about 1/2 way through. Then I realized EVERY SINGLE CHARACTER SOUNDED THE SAME.
Yes, there was fun humor but see above, it got old.
Also there is NO WAY a rich, famous movie star like Darcy’s father would get taken for every penny by a second wife! California has been a community property state since 1850.
The worst villains were POC. Jorge Wickham, really?!
I greatly enjoyed this book until about 1/2 way through. Then I realized EVERY SINGLE CHARACTER SOUNDED THE SAME.
Yes, there was fun humor but see above, it got old.
Also there is NO WAY a rich, famous movie star like Darcy’s father would get taken for every penny by a second wife! California has been a community property state since 1850.
The worst villains were POC. Jorge Wickham, really?!
February 10, 2024
ריטלינג מודרני ל"גאווה ודעה קדומה" המתרחש בקליפורניה בעולם הבמה ומחזות הזמר. אליזבת' בנט היא שחקנית אלמונית, ויל דארסי הוא כוכב סרטי אקשן ידוע, ושניהם משתתפים בהפקה של המחזמר "הפיראטים מפנזאס". בגדול הסופרת לקחה את העלילה של "גאווה ודעה קדומה" והתאימה אותה כמעט אחד לאחד לעולם שבחרה. בחלק מהמקרים זה בסדר וסביר, ובחלק מהמקרים זה ממש מגוחך. בספר הזה דארסי הוא דמות מהממת, אליזבת' - ככה ככה. היא עושה רושם הרבה פחות אינטליגנטי מאליזבת' בנט המקורית, וזה מאכזב. ספר די חביב, אבל ממש לא חובה.
March 11, 2024
5++ stars. A seriously adorable retelling. Perfectly adapted to fit the period. The story is told in alternate POVs of Darcy and Elizabeth with many hilarious asides. Loved it.
March 30, 2022
Not my cup of tea.
I should start by saying that I already struggle with on-the-nose Austen remakes, but I felt like this book had far too many quirks. I LOVE quirky characters, plots, scenes, etc, but it has to be an offset for the rest of the book. This one feels like one jumbled mess of clichés, theatre quotes, and over-the-top goofiness... And that's saying a lot because I adore that special brand of comedy.
I should start by saying that I already struggle with on-the-nose Austen remakes, but I felt like this book had far too many quirks. I LOVE quirky characters, plots, scenes, etc, but it has to be an offset for the rest of the book. This one feels like one jumbled mess of clichés, theatre quotes, and over-the-top goofiness... And that's saying a lot because I adore that special brand of comedy.
May 18, 2022
There are many ways to translate Pride and Prejudice to modern day, and the set of Pirates of Penzance is certainly an interesting one! This novel handles some of the more difficult-to-modernize aspects of the original really well; and some of the names were very clever, such as Colin Hunsford and Cole Forster. The connection to Emma Woods from the author's modern Emma makes it fun (I have not read the books about Emma Woods).
The fact that the only minority character is Wickham bothered me immensely. Yes, Jorge is a more common name than George these days; but someone else could have been a minority as well (besides a handful of very, very minor characters who speak very little if at all).
Something that makes no sense to me is the almost total Kitty erasure. It was like the author forgot about Kitty until nearly the end, and then decided to make her a sort of personification of Elizabeth's emotions. Lydia has a sister who would have made more sense as Mary, and then Elizabeth's teenaged sister could have been Kitty or some other variation of Catherine. Instead, Elizabeth's little sister is Mary, and Lydia's sister is Norah?? (Jane, Elizabeth, and Lydia are stage sisters and roommates, not related at all.)
It earns only 3 stars because it was much more suggestive than I'd expect from a "clean" romance. There's nothing explicit, but it's not as clean as I prefer. Still a fun read, but I don't know if I'll read this author's other modern Austen novels.
The fact that the only minority character is Wickham bothered me immensely. Yes, Jorge is a more common name than George these days; but someone else could have been a minority as well (besides a handful of very, very minor characters who speak very little if at all).
Something that makes no sense to me is the almost total Kitty erasure. It was like the author forgot about Kitty until nearly the end, and then decided to make her a sort of personification of Elizabeth's emotions. Lydia has a sister who would have made more sense as Mary, and then Elizabeth's teenaged sister could have been Kitty or some other variation of Catherine. Instead, Elizabeth's little sister is Mary, and Lydia's sister is Norah?? (Jane, Elizabeth, and Lydia are stage sisters and roommates, not related at all.)
It earns only 3 stars because it was much more suggestive than I'd expect from a "clean" romance. There's nothing explicit, but it's not as clean as I prefer. Still a fun read, but I don't know if I'll read this author's other modern Austen novels.
February 20, 2019
I liked this modern day rendition of Pride and Prejudice. It was set in LA. The characters were all cast members of a Pirates of Penzance theatre production. I liked Beth and her fake swear words. Will got better as the story progressed.
May 16, 2020
It is a truth universally acknowledged that a hotshot movie star must be off his rocker to do regional theater.
Rating: 3.5-4 stars
(In case you were wondering, this book contains some language, mentions of sexual assault and human trafficking, mentions of self-harm, alcohol use, innuendos, LGBT characters, some hashtags, slight Caroline-bashing, and a pirate ship's worth of musical references)
Okay, this is why you give books with generic covers and dumb-sounding premises a chance, because sometimes they'll surprise you and actually be good.
Before I get to the actual review, I'll preface this by saying I'm not a huge theater buff. I have soundtracks from some of the big musicals, but all I know about Pirates of Penzance comes from Act II, Scene I. Gigi Blume is uses her debut novel to prove to the world she is every bit the "hopeless musical theatre nerd" she claims to be and packs her book with enough musical references to make your head spin.
I've read my fair share of modern Pride and Prejudice, and this is one of the betters ones I've come across so far. When I'd read the book summary, I was expecting another arrogant hunk version of Darcy, but here we get socially awkward, spastic Darcy. He's not quite as shy as his namesake, but it's so refreshing to read Darcy's internal freak outs and bumbling attempts to act like a functioning human being around his crush. I mean, talk about #relatable.
In terms of plot, Love and Loathing stuck fairly close to canon while managing to offer an original and believable modern interpretation. The musical theater setting actually worked pretty well (minus the surprise duet which felt a little song-fic-y). In place of a sick Jane, we find the actors trapped in an underground vault of a costume room, and it somehow doesn't feel trope-y. The Netherfield debate about accomplished women turns into an argument about triple threats, Darcy and Lizzie bicker about the need for small talk during lift practice, and it all just works. Collins as the "most spectacular mixture of drill sergeant and drama queen" of a choreographer and the Bennet-Lucas matriarchs' one-upsmanship via annual/bi-annual family updates is gold.
The story is quirky and fun. My main complaint is that I don't feel like Lizzie's trust issues (stemming from baggage from an ex-, of course,) added much. Blume seems to have a good sense of humor, though there are a few instances when it feels like she's trying a little bit too hard ("he was a haughty hottie," really?). After a while, the deluge of musical theater and hipster-geek references start to reek of desperation (of the "I'm a cool mom" variety).
There are also some really cringe-worthy passages throughout. A leggy soprano, a Latin demigod carved from Quetazlcoati's hot chocolate, a ninja trained to make women swoon with his brooding glower are just some of the descriptions we get for the lovely cast. Lizzie, inexplicably, is "a hot little pixie." Love interests make Lizzie feel "gooey and soft" or like "an electric charge sparked and turned my innards into molten lava." (There are a few more food analogies, but I'll spare you). We also get some real gems including but not limited to:
"She squeezed Jane's arm, snapping a selfie. 'Hashtag Stanley Sisters.' She posted the photo immediately with the addition of #piratebootycall."
"my heart sped up just a little as he passed by me on the way to his seat. The molecules in my personal space were disrupted in the ripple he caused."
"This underacting action star looked at me like a vegan would look like a plate full of raw meat."
"I shrank into myself, flushed from the inferno he diffused from his infuriatingly brawny figure. His entire presence was imposing, invading my senses with whatever scent that was. It was unique to him and mingled provocatively with the minty freshness of his toothpaste. It was intoxicating and swoony."
Blume also has a strange penchant for the word "twitterpated" (maybe it was the word of the day when she was writing?) and an unfortunate habit of using bowels to describe things. Also, what is with the pervasive use of "magnetism" to describe Lizzie/Darcy's relationship? Is this part of a Jimmy Fallon challenge I don't know about? Is it some kind of buzzword agents are looking for that signifies a P&P retelling worth reading? Is it a condition universally required before modern Austen stories can be published? (Maybe the requirement is written in the same place that dictates Fitz has to be gay).
Still, if you're looking for a modern P&P retelling, you might want to give Love and Loathing a shot. Trust me, there's much worse out there.
Rating: 3.5-4 stars
(In case you were wondering, this book contains some language, mentions of sexual assault and human trafficking, mentions of self-harm, alcohol use, innuendos, LGBT characters, some hashtags, slight Caroline-bashing, and a pirate ship's worth of musical references)
Okay, this is why you give books with generic covers and dumb-sounding premises a chance, because sometimes they'll surprise you and actually be good.
Before I get to the actual review, I'll preface this by saying I'm not a huge theater buff. I have soundtracks from some of the big musicals, but all I know about Pirates of Penzance comes from Act II, Scene I. Gigi Blume is uses her debut novel to prove to the world she is every bit the "hopeless musical theatre nerd" she claims to be and packs her book with enough musical references to make your head spin.
I've read my fair share of modern Pride and Prejudice, and this is one of the betters ones I've come across so far. When I'd read the book summary, I was expecting another arrogant hunk version of Darcy, but here we get socially awkward, spastic Darcy. He's not quite as shy as his namesake, but it's so refreshing to read Darcy's internal freak outs and bumbling attempts to act like a functioning human being around his crush. I mean, talk about #relatable.
In terms of plot, Love and Loathing stuck fairly close to canon while managing to offer an original and believable modern interpretation. The musical theater setting actually worked pretty well (minus the surprise duet which felt a little song-fic-y). In place of a sick Jane, we find the actors trapped in an underground vault of a costume room, and it somehow doesn't feel trope-y. The Netherfield debate about accomplished women turns into an argument about triple threats, Darcy and Lizzie bicker about the need for small talk during lift practice, and it all just works. Collins as the "most spectacular mixture of drill sergeant and drama queen" of a choreographer and the Bennet-Lucas matriarchs' one-upsmanship via annual/bi-annual family updates is gold.
The story is quirky and fun. My main complaint is that I don't feel like Lizzie's trust issues (stemming from baggage from an ex-, of course,) added much. Blume seems to have a good sense of humor, though there are a few instances when it feels like she's trying a little bit too hard ("he was a haughty hottie," really?). After a while, the deluge of musical theater and hipster-geek references start to reek of desperation (of the "I'm a cool mom" variety).
There are also some really cringe-worthy passages throughout. A leggy soprano, a Latin demigod carved from Quetazlcoati's hot chocolate, a ninja trained to make women swoon with his brooding glower are just some of the descriptions we get for the lovely cast. Lizzie, inexplicably, is "a hot little pixie." Love interests make Lizzie feel "gooey and soft" or like "an electric charge sparked and turned my innards into molten lava." (There are a few more food analogies, but I'll spare you). We also get some real gems including but not limited to:
"She squeezed Jane's arm, snapping a selfie. 'Hashtag Stanley Sisters.' She posted the photo immediately with the addition of #piratebootycall."
"my heart sped up just a little as he passed by me on the way to his seat. The molecules in my personal space were disrupted in the ripple he caused."
"This underacting action star looked at me like a vegan would look like a plate full of raw meat."
"I shrank into myself, flushed from the inferno he diffused from his infuriatingly brawny figure. His entire presence was imposing, invading my senses with whatever scent that was. It was unique to him and mingled provocatively with the minty freshness of his toothpaste. It was intoxicating and swoony."
Blume also has a strange penchant for the word "twitterpated" (maybe it was the word of the day when she was writing?) and an unfortunate habit of using bowels to describe things. Also, what is with the pervasive use of "magnetism" to describe Lizzie/Darcy's relationship? Is this part of a Jimmy Fallon challenge I don't know about? Is it some kind of buzzword agents are looking for that signifies a P&P retelling worth reading? Is it a condition universally required before modern Austen stories can be published? (Maybe the requirement is written in the same place that dictates Fitz has to be gay).
Still, if you're looking for a modern P&P retelling, you might want to give Love and Loathing a shot. Trust me, there's much worse out there.
October 19, 2019
A modern, funny, showbiz P&P
Love and Loathing is a humorous love story set in the world of musical theatre, where the romance of the two main characters gives a very strong nod to Pride and Prejudice. William Martin Darcy is a famous movie star who is treading the boards for a change, at the behest of an old and dear friend and famous actress, Stella, and as a means of helping his friend, Bing, jumpstart his career.
Beth (short for Elizabeth, sometimes called Lizzy, but never Eliza) Bennet is a pocket-sized dynamo who hopes one day to sing and dance her way to bigger and better things, be they stage or screen. Family dynamics for Lizzy are different here: Jane is not her sister but her best friend, flaky Lydia is another friend and Mary is her only sister, who is not in showbiz but is still studying. There is no Kitty.
Sparks fly when Beth and Darcy first meet; she loathes him and writes him off as a second rate actor whose claim to fame is a series of very popular and lucrative action movies, and he barely acknowledges her friendly overtures, and is standoffish with all the ensemble, except Bing, the director and the musical director, Fitz Hanlon.
There are a lot of nods to different stage shows throughout, but often just referring to characters in said productions, and as I am not a mad, crazy stage show devotee, I was often at a loss to know what production was being spoken of. Beth, instead of cussing (or swearing as we Aussies say) would invoke the name of a character or show, a habit that confuses people who do not know her well.
This work, though thoroughly modern, is the closest to the original P&P as far as character personalities and storyline goes; there are many instances where the dialogue echoes some of the well known scenes that we all know and love.
Jorge Wickham and Catherine de Bourgh are present to provide villainy and overbearing self importance, and Caroline is a would-be femme fatale and an annoyance, mostly to Will, and she is not Bing's sister. Stella, a famous actress and septuagenarian and owner of the Gardiner (theatre), is a powerhouse of talent and vitality, and is, I gather, a nod to Mrs Gardiner, Lizzy's aunt in P&P. She is the matchmaker in this work rather than Mrs Bennet, but she is neither desperate, nor foolish; she just sees the chemistry between Beth and Will and she just wishes to help things along.
The book is long, and though that is a definite plus for me, I know there are people out there who prefer shorter works, it is set in Los Angeles, and though film is definitely LA's claim to fame, I gather that, though not Broadway, stage productions have their own niche in the City of Angels.
The book is well written with very few mistakes; a very easy to read, enjoyable story. Some of the Americanisms and stage show references went a little over my head and I found myself Googling several things, the story and Beth and Will kept me thoroughly entertained throughout.
Definitely recommend. Five stars. 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Love and Loathing is a humorous love story set in the world of musical theatre, where the romance of the two main characters gives a very strong nod to Pride and Prejudice. William Martin Darcy is a famous movie star who is treading the boards for a change, at the behest of an old and dear friend and famous actress, Stella, and as a means of helping his friend, Bing, jumpstart his career.
Beth (short for Elizabeth, sometimes called Lizzy, but never Eliza) Bennet is a pocket-sized dynamo who hopes one day to sing and dance her way to bigger and better things, be they stage or screen. Family dynamics for Lizzy are different here: Jane is not her sister but her best friend, flaky Lydia is another friend and Mary is her only sister, who is not in showbiz but is still studying. There is no Kitty.
Sparks fly when Beth and Darcy first meet; she loathes him and writes him off as a second rate actor whose claim to fame is a series of very popular and lucrative action movies, and he barely acknowledges her friendly overtures, and is standoffish with all the ensemble, except Bing, the director and the musical director, Fitz Hanlon.
There are a lot of nods to different stage shows throughout, but often just referring to characters in said productions, and as I am not a mad, crazy stage show devotee, I was often at a loss to know what production was being spoken of. Beth, instead of cussing (or swearing as we Aussies say) would invoke the name of a character or show, a habit that confuses people who do not know her well.
This work, though thoroughly modern, is the closest to the original P&P as far as character personalities and storyline goes; there are many instances where the dialogue echoes some of the well known scenes that we all know and love.
Jorge Wickham and Catherine de Bourgh are present to provide villainy and overbearing self importance, and Caroline is a would-be femme fatale and an annoyance, mostly to Will, and she is not Bing's sister. Stella, a famous actress and septuagenarian and owner of the Gardiner (theatre), is a powerhouse of talent and vitality, and is, I gather, a nod to Mrs Gardiner, Lizzy's aunt in P&P. She is the matchmaker in this work rather than Mrs Bennet, but she is neither desperate, nor foolish; she just sees the chemistry between Beth and Will and she just wishes to help things along.
The book is long, and though that is a definite plus for me, I know there are people out there who prefer shorter works, it is set in Los Angeles, and though film is definitely LA's claim to fame, I gather that, though not Broadway, stage productions have their own niche in the City of Angels.
The book is well written with very few mistakes; a very easy to read, enjoyable story. Some of the Americanisms and stage show references went a little over my head and I found myself Googling several things, the story and Beth and Will kept me thoroughly entertained throughout.
Definitely recommend. Five stars. 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
November 2, 2020
Modern day P&P variation
A wonderfully funny JAFF variation. Elizabeth and Darcy are both a part of a theater production of Pirates of Penzance. Darcy is an established action film star, doing the play as a favor to Stella Gardiner, famous namesake of Gardiner Theater. Many familiar names from P&P are woven into the story. The musical play is a comedy, and Elizabeth is a funny girl.
It's interesting and enchanting following the process of the cast and crew in performing the play. Since this is a P&P variation, it's required that Elizabeth "loathe" Darcy, as the title suggests, after first meeting him, even though they have some scenes together, including a kissing scene. The big villain in the book is Wickham, whose first name is Jorge in this version. He's a set designer, and not much is said about how he came to be working on this particular play. I kind of wondered about that when it later seemed that Stella Gardiner already knew that he wasn't a good person.
The book is written in the first person, alternating between Elizabeth's and Darcy's pov. This is an effective and enjoyable way to relate the story, but it seemed that most of the time it was Elizabeth's view. I would have liked a more even amount from both. Darcy's interest, and eventual feelings for Elizabeth were not given much attention, so I didn't feel the chemistry developing on his part. Suddenly he has strong feelings for her, and she's still is the loathing stage.
When an author is trying to transform the P&P storyline from a Regency era love story to the modern day, not all of the elements will translate smoothly. In this book, and some other modern variations I've read, the whole Lydia and Wickham debacle doesn't really work well, and feels forced. Lydia disappears with Wickham, and it's feared that she's in trouble. In this case, Lydia is just a co-worker of Elizabeth's, not a family member. The urgent involvement of Elizabeth and Darcy doesn't make sense. It's more annoying than anything that the author feels the need to conform to this facet of the original P&P. A modern day version has to bow to modern day dynamics, as far as how far friends and family get involved in each other's business.
The book is well written, wonderfully funny, and well edited. I recommend it.
A wonderfully funny JAFF variation. Elizabeth and Darcy are both a part of a theater production of Pirates of Penzance. Darcy is an established action film star, doing the play as a favor to Stella Gardiner, famous namesake of Gardiner Theater. Many familiar names from P&P are woven into the story. The musical play is a comedy, and Elizabeth is a funny girl.
It's interesting and enchanting following the process of the cast and crew in performing the play. Since this is a P&P variation, it's required that Elizabeth "loathe" Darcy, as the title suggests, after first meeting him, even though they have some scenes together, including a kissing scene. The big villain in the book is Wickham, whose first name is Jorge in this version. He's a set designer, and not much is said about how he came to be working on this particular play. I kind of wondered about that when it later seemed that Stella Gardiner already knew that he wasn't a good person.
The book is written in the first person, alternating between Elizabeth's and Darcy's pov. This is an effective and enjoyable way to relate the story, but it seemed that most of the time it was Elizabeth's view. I would have liked a more even amount from both. Darcy's interest, and eventual feelings for Elizabeth were not given much attention, so I didn't feel the chemistry developing on his part. Suddenly he has strong feelings for her, and she's still is the loathing stage.
When an author is trying to transform the P&P storyline from a Regency era love story to the modern day, not all of the elements will translate smoothly. In this book, and some other modern variations I've read, the whole Lydia and Wickham debacle doesn't really work well, and feels forced. Lydia disappears with Wickham, and it's feared that she's in trouble. In this case, Lydia is just a co-worker of Elizabeth's, not a family member. The urgent involvement of Elizabeth and Darcy doesn't make sense. It's more annoying than anything that the author feels the need to conform to this facet of the original P&P. A modern day version has to bow to modern day dynamics, as far as how far friends and family get involved in each other's business.
The book is well written, wonderfully funny, and well edited. I recommend it.
March 6, 2021
This was a cute retelling of Pride and Prejudice. I enjoyed many things about this novel but also disliked a few. I'll start with the things I didn't like and then on a positive note.
Things I didn't like:
1. I felt the novel was slow in places. There were scenes that could have been cut and/or shortened. Almost 450 pages was too long for this sort of book, in my opinion.
2. I didn't feel a connection between Beth and Will. They started as most enemies-to-lovers stories do with an attraction/pull while disliking each other. I didn't feel there was enough interaction between them to properly show their hate morphing into love; it seemed rather abrupt. Also, the summary of the book mentions "an unforgettable stage kiss" but I didn't feel that connection at all.
3. I wish the author had showed more of Bing and Jane's relationship. As written, they enjoyed making out a lot and their love at first sight felt more like lust at first sight.
4. Caroline's character went from being around Will constantly to not being in the story at all until the very end.
Things I liked:
1. The characters were well developed and different from one another. This was impressive as there were so many characters that it took a lot of imagination and character development to achieve this. I loved Colin's character because he was so unique.
2. There were a lot of great one-liners that made me chuckle.
3. The author is exceptional at creating similes and metaphors to enhance the scene and suck the reader in. The tone of these was a good balance of humorous and serious.
4. I loved the idea that these were all characters in theatre and they met/knew each other as a result of that relationship.
5. Will and Beth's character development as the story progressed was excellent. The author did an excellent job of showing their changes and growth.
I would definitely read another story by this author.
Things I didn't like:
1. I felt the novel was slow in places. There were scenes that could have been cut and/or shortened. Almost 450 pages was too long for this sort of book, in my opinion.
2. I didn't feel a connection between Beth and Will. They started as most enemies-to-lovers stories do with an attraction/pull while disliking each other. I didn't feel there was enough interaction between them to properly show their hate morphing into love; it seemed rather abrupt. Also, the summary of the book mentions "an unforgettable stage kiss" but I didn't feel that connection at all.
3. I wish the author had showed more of Bing and Jane's relationship. As written, they enjoyed making out a lot and their love at first sight felt more like lust at first sight.
4. Caroline's character went from being around Will constantly to not being in the story at all until the very end.
Things I liked:
1. The characters were well developed and different from one another. This was impressive as there were so many characters that it took a lot of imagination and character development to achieve this. I loved Colin's character because he was so unique.
2. There were a lot of great one-liners that made me chuckle.
3. The author is exceptional at creating similes and metaphors to enhance the scene and suck the reader in. The tone of these was a good balance of humorous and serious.
4. I loved the idea that these were all characters in theatre and they met/knew each other as a result of that relationship.
5. Will and Beth's character development as the story progressed was excellent. The author did an excellent job of showing their changes and growth.
I would definitely read another story by this author.
May 22, 2019
Wow! Great comedy!
I loved loved loved this story. I had read the prequel to this series a couple of months ago, which I loved so much as well. But sometimes you wonder is it just a fluke, can the author do it again? Well, she certainly did. The book exceeded my expectations.
First of all, the comedy part of it was spot on. The one liners, the film references, everything was just so funny. There were so many comedic scenes that I could picture vividly due to the funny descriptions given. I felt like a teenager giggling at some of the lighthearted comedy.
Second, I don’t think I have read a better modern adaptation of an Austen novel. Mind you I have read some really really good ones, but they have not gone into as much detail and stayed so true to the situations and comments of the original storyline as this book has. Reading this book was like me taking a “sick day” to binge watch the 5-1/2 hour BBC version of Pride and Prejudice. Yes it had the full story of details, only presented in with comedy in a truly endearing way.
Third, the romance aspect with Beth and Will falling in love was perfect. The carnival scenes, ooohhh, I just loved them. Their story was told in such a sweet way. I would call this a clean romance with a PG rating. Definitely family friendly.
I normally shy away from books this long because I prefer to binge read my books straight thru. This being that I firmly believe that in a good book there is no such thing as a good stopping point. Unfortunately I did have to stop many times in reading this book just to finish it. But it was a fantastic story. Very clever and unexpected. Just leaves one to wonder, what story will be next? Asking for a friend.....
I loved loved loved this story. I had read the prequel to this series a couple of months ago, which I loved so much as well. But sometimes you wonder is it just a fluke, can the author do it again? Well, she certainly did. The book exceeded my expectations.
First of all, the comedy part of it was spot on. The one liners, the film references, everything was just so funny. There were so many comedic scenes that I could picture vividly due to the funny descriptions given. I felt like a teenager giggling at some of the lighthearted comedy.
Second, I don’t think I have read a better modern adaptation of an Austen novel. Mind you I have read some really really good ones, but they have not gone into as much detail and stayed so true to the situations and comments of the original storyline as this book has. Reading this book was like me taking a “sick day” to binge watch the 5-1/2 hour BBC version of Pride and Prejudice. Yes it had the full story of details, only presented in with comedy in a truly endearing way.
Third, the romance aspect with Beth and Will falling in love was perfect. The carnival scenes, ooohhh, I just loved them. Their story was told in such a sweet way. I would call this a clean romance with a PG rating. Definitely family friendly.
I normally shy away from books this long because I prefer to binge read my books straight thru. This being that I firmly believe that in a good book there is no such thing as a good stopping point. Unfortunately I did have to stop many times in reading this book just to finish it. But it was a fantastic story. Very clever and unexpected. Just leaves one to wonder, what story will be next? Asking for a friend.....
January 24, 2024
OVERALL STAR RATING: 5/5
CLEAN RATING: 5/5
I have quite a few Austen-inspired novels sitting on my shelves, but this book right here is absolutely one of my all-time favorites now. If you’re a Pride & Prejudice fan and enjoy RomComs, then you MUST pick this one up!
I honestly don’t know how Gigi did it. Her writing felt so authentically Austen, while keeping it completely modern at the same time. The essence of each Pride & Prejudice character is so perfectly portrayed and represented in this book. And the sass is SERVED! Talk about “Obstinate, headstrong girl!” Woohoo! You will no doubt fall in love with Beth and Will Darcy. I was laughing my head off through the entire thing. The comparison of “Bing” to Mary Poppins is so practically perfect in every way.
I’ve honestly never read a book this full of incredible analogies and metaphors. It was a dream come true for me. Plus, references to 90210, Milli Vanilli, Grease, The Princess Bride, Depeche Mode, and Hello Kitty made this read feel like a warm hug!
I’m doing an awful lot of gushing here without saying much about the plot. Just to quickly sum it up - Beth Bennet has been cast to co-star in a theater production of Pirates of Penzance alongside mega famous Will Darcy. You will meet everyone in this story, from Jane, Lydia, Jorge Wickham, Charlotte to Colin (Mr. Collins). Packed full of Pride & Prejudice character references, yet still its own beautifully unique story. Austen characters in the era of social media is something I didn’t know I needed!
I’ve definitely got my eyes set on book two which features Emma.
For more reviews and bookish content, be sure to follow me on Instagram at: aliciasbooksanctuary
CLEAN RATING: 5/5
I have quite a few Austen-inspired novels sitting on my shelves, but this book right here is absolutely one of my all-time favorites now. If you’re a Pride & Prejudice fan and enjoy RomComs, then you MUST pick this one up!
I honestly don’t know how Gigi did it. Her writing felt so authentically Austen, while keeping it completely modern at the same time. The essence of each Pride & Prejudice character is so perfectly portrayed and represented in this book. And the sass is SERVED! Talk about “Obstinate, headstrong girl!” Woohoo! You will no doubt fall in love with Beth and Will Darcy. I was laughing my head off through the entire thing. The comparison of “Bing” to Mary Poppins is so practically perfect in every way.
I’ve honestly never read a book this full of incredible analogies and metaphors. It was a dream come true for me. Plus, references to 90210, Milli Vanilli, Grease, The Princess Bride, Depeche Mode, and Hello Kitty made this read feel like a warm hug!
I’m doing an awful lot of gushing here without saying much about the plot. Just to quickly sum it up - Beth Bennet has been cast to co-star in a theater production of Pirates of Penzance alongside mega famous Will Darcy. You will meet everyone in this story, from Jane, Lydia, Jorge Wickham, Charlotte to Colin (Mr. Collins). Packed full of Pride & Prejudice character references, yet still its own beautifully unique story. Austen characters in the era of social media is something I didn’t know I needed!
I’ve definitely got my eyes set on book two which features Emma.
For more reviews and bookish content, be sure to follow me on Instagram at: aliciasbooksanctuary
February 14, 2022
Title: Love and Loathing
Author: Gigi Blume
Year Published: 2020
Rating: 4/5
Who would like it/Who wouldn’t
like it:
If you enjoy Jane Austen and Pride and Prejudice retellings, I think you’ll like this one.
If you need spice in this book, this may be a skip for you.
REVIEW:
Pride and Prejudice is a must read for all fans of romance novels, historical romance novels, and historical romance novels that feature enemies to lovers. (I also think reading Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing, is another must, but I digress).
This story is a very cute, slightly cheesy in the best way, retelling of Pride and Prejudice. This book is set in a theater where Lizzie and Will are cast in the Pirates of Penzance, an amazing show, if you’ve never seen it. Much like in the original book most characters make an appearance, but one of my least favorite things that happens in the original is fixed here and I LOVE it. SOOOO much. I won’t spoil it, but I really enjoyed seeing a different take and interpretation on the classic.
I was a bit disappointed that Kitty didn’t make an appearance and that Mary is basically blink and you’ll miss it and in the brief time she’s mentioned she’s completely mocked and treated as if she deserves to be treated like crap because she’s annoying. I’ve always hated Mary’s treatment in this novel and so while this book maintains that terrible sentiment, I wish the author would’ve actually treated Mary with a bit more kindness. This is the reason I didn’t give this five stars, but that is a personal preference of mine, and not really a dig at the book overall.
TL;DR:
This is a delightful, funny, modern take on Pride and Prejudice that is quick and easy to read and stays very close to the original work.
Author: Gigi Blume
Year Published: 2020
Rating: 4/5
Who would like it/Who wouldn’t
like it:
If you enjoy Jane Austen and Pride and Prejudice retellings, I think you’ll like this one.
If you need spice in this book, this may be a skip for you.
REVIEW:
Pride and Prejudice is a must read for all fans of romance novels, historical romance novels, and historical romance novels that feature enemies to lovers. (I also think reading Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing, is another must, but I digress).
This story is a very cute, slightly cheesy in the best way, retelling of Pride and Prejudice. This book is set in a theater where Lizzie and Will are cast in the Pirates of Penzance, an amazing show, if you’ve never seen it. Much like in the original book most characters make an appearance, but one of my least favorite things that happens in the original is fixed here and I LOVE it. SOOOO much. I won’t spoil it, but I really enjoyed seeing a different take and interpretation on the classic.
I was a bit disappointed that Kitty didn’t make an appearance and that Mary is basically blink and you’ll miss it and in the brief time she’s mentioned she’s completely mocked and treated as if she deserves to be treated like crap because she’s annoying. I’ve always hated Mary’s treatment in this novel and so while this book maintains that terrible sentiment, I wish the author would’ve actually treated Mary with a bit more kindness. This is the reason I didn’t give this five stars, but that is a personal preference of mine, and not really a dig at the book overall.
TL;DR:
This is a delightful, funny, modern take on Pride and Prejudice that is quick and easy to read and stays very close to the original work.
February 12, 2023
It is a truth universally acknowledged that the world needs more Jane Austen and this book to be turned into a movie…well that’s my opinion anyway.
This book inspired by my favourite, Pride and Prejudice, was perfect. It was true to the original whilst bringing it right up to date.
I’m not going to give you a summary of the book as it’s likely a story we all know well. What I will say is that if you loved the original I think you will love this modern take.
Putting Mrs Bennet on Facebook was genius, what a perfect way for her to keep up with all the gossip.
Not having the Bennet sisters and still having each character in some way was a great change and the addition of Will’s dog Lady was a great way to showcase more of his softer side.
I always loved Mr Darcy and didn’t think you could really change and improve him but Gigi put him in pirate costume and made it so he can sing…well done 👏
Again, I loved the dual POV and the connection between the other Austen inspired books with Stella and the other main characters.
If you’ve been trying to convince someone to read the original but they are put off by the time period or more archaic language then this is the version to recommend.
🌟Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
✍️ Fave quote: “Yes, Officer. It was a crime of passion. Guilty on account of trying to function in society while twitterpated.”
There were so many one liners in this book that it was hard to pick one but I loved Will’s internal dialogue and the reference to Bambi was the icing on top.
November 5, 2022
Contains: kisses, mentions of human trafficking. I didn’t realize this was a Pride and Prejudice retelling when I got the book (I knew from the moment I read the first line, however). Here’s the dealio, I way overthink modern retellings of classics. The story takes place in a world where there is Shakespeare, Moulin Rouge, Leonardo DiCaprio, and all the existing musicals. So am I to believe that in this world Jane Austen doesn’t exist? Or does she exist, and Pride and Prejudice is an actual book in this world and there is just insane coincidences between these people’s lives and the fiction? I mean if a guy named Will Darcy was dating and Elizabeth (Beth) Bennett I’m sure most people would have noted how weird that is, unless there is no such thing as Pride and Prejudice in this world. Setting all that aside, the story was pretty entertaining even though I mostly knew what was going to happen (I prefer my retellings to be a little less “on-the-nose”). I did find that there were a few times when the author tried too hard to make the structure of things just like the original work which made our modern characters speak/write in an archaic or awkward way. I know it is based off another work but I still felt the characters went from acquaintances to being in love very quickly.
November 5, 2022
BRIEF SYNOPSIS: Beth Bennet has landed a role she’s excited about in a play at The Gardiner. The only problem? The obnoxious arrogant action hero Will Darcy who’s also in the play. Will is focused on his career and is not keen on the distraction that is Beth Bennet. Their days are spent avoiding each other and hurling sarcastic remarks at one another, until sparks start flying. Which makes them both wonder: is this love or loathing?
I read the prequel novella of this series, as well as another companion in this series and thought they were super cute. This whole series is modern retellings of Jane Austen classics, this one being a retelling of Pride and Prejudice. And it was so adorable. I loved the dynamic between Beth and Will and felt their chemistry was so apparent, even before they realized their true feelings for each other. It’s been a while since I’ve read Pride and Prejudice, so I can’t tell you just how closely it follows the original, but I think if you like Jane Austen novels (or even if you don’t…if you like enemies to lovers, clean romances, romances with great banter) you should try this. It’s a super quick read and I can’t wait to start book 2.
I was also so happy I read the prequel novella first, because I was dying when I realized just exactly where Emma gets her matchmaking scheming from (looking at you Stella Gardiner)
4⭐️
💗Clean Romance
I read the prequel novella of this series, as well as another companion in this series and thought they were super cute. This whole series is modern retellings of Jane Austen classics, this one being a retelling of Pride and Prejudice. And it was so adorable. I loved the dynamic between Beth and Will and felt their chemistry was so apparent, even before they realized their true feelings for each other. It’s been a while since I’ve read Pride and Prejudice, so I can’t tell you just how closely it follows the original, but I think if you like Jane Austen novels (or even if you don’t…if you like enemies to lovers, clean romances, romances with great banter) you should try this. It’s a super quick read and I can’t wait to start book 2.
I was also so happy I read the prequel novella first, because I was dying when I realized just exactly where Emma gets her matchmaking scheming from (looking at you Stella Gardiner)
4⭐️
💗Clean Romance
February 22, 2019
Long book, BUT TOTALLY WORTH IT! Stick with it because this writer hits it out of the park! Lots of great characters introduced in the first half and many of the scenes were LOL funny! Gigi has such a great writing style that is very relate-able. As a theater person myself, I was totally tracking with all the innuendos and musical knowledge - BONUS! I love the way this author took her time with the details in how Beth and Will feel and respond physically - OMG, especially when they finally connect! I could see every nuance created - every touch, every look. It was bliss. I wish that Beth and Will had some sort of hook-up/kiss/romantic moment in the first half of the book, but once I hit the middle, I couldn't put it down! And then there is that magical moment - my absolute favorite scene (probably in any romance I've ever read) that gave me all the feels and made me swoon when Beth and Will were across the stage from each other mouthing the words to the song on opening night. I had to reread that scene several times. Writing BRILLIANCE! GAH!!! I am not a Pride & Prejudice junkie like a lot of folks, but I loved this modern version. HIGHLY recommend. Look out world, a romance-author-star is born! BRAVO!
February 22, 2019
It is great! a fantastic modern adaptation
I loved this one, really loved it. I've read a ton of Jane Austen adaptations, particularly Pride and Prejudice, and this one is my favorite so far. It spoke directly to my theater nerd heart.
I really enjoyed the characters and how there were so many conversations that mirrored the original almost exactly, just in modern words, and modern settings, and about choreography of all things! Speaking of choreography, COLIN! He is a perfect Collins. He is just ridiculous and over the top and absurd, and perfect.
The further I got into the book, the more I enjoyed it. I like that the author took her time with the story and gave the needed time for real feelings to develop. The events of Pride and Prejudice did not transpire over a weekend, it was nearly a year! That is one of the things I most liked about it, and while this book is not a year, it is the running time of producing a play which is anywhere from 8 to 12 weeks, plus the additional time for Christmas and New Year... the point is, much like the original, the relationship and feelings took TIME, something missing from most romance novels, and something I really appreciate.
Loved it!
I loved this one, really loved it. I've read a ton of Jane Austen adaptations, particularly Pride and Prejudice, and this one is my favorite so far. It spoke directly to my theater nerd heart.
I really enjoyed the characters and how there were so many conversations that mirrored the original almost exactly, just in modern words, and modern settings, and about choreography of all things! Speaking of choreography, COLIN! He is a perfect Collins. He is just ridiculous and over the top and absurd, and perfect.
The further I got into the book, the more I enjoyed it. I like that the author took her time with the story and gave the needed time for real feelings to develop. The events of Pride and Prejudice did not transpire over a weekend, it was nearly a year! That is one of the things I most liked about it, and while this book is not a year, it is the running time of producing a play which is anywhere from 8 to 12 weeks, plus the additional time for Christmas and New Year... the point is, much like the original, the relationship and feelings took TIME, something missing from most romance novels, and something I really appreciate.
Loved it!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 142 reviews