I was delighted to see that although there might not be many reviews (33 as of March 2025) on GR for this collection they were almost all unstinting in their praise and, in many cases amazement, at discovering a writer of whom they knew nothing. James Purdy is the great unknown of 20th century American literature and although it is always said he was always ignored that isn't quite true. If you find original copies of his novels you will find their back covers full of praise from reviewers in prestigious publications and there were both hardback and popular paperback editions of all his novels. He was published, reviewed and read, what he was not was an accepted part of the 'canonical' literary tradition of the New York publishing world and the academic literary establishment at American universities never mind their 'creative writing' departments. No writer like Purdy has emerged from those factories of etiolated literary preciousness in Iowa or East Anglia. I can imagine that a writer like Purdy would be strangled at birth by those establishments.
Purdy is inimitable and probably is the sort of writer we will never see the like of again because writers today don't emerge from life and there is no longer a place for career writers in our world. That Purdy has any 'name recognition' today is because he categorized as a 'gay' writer but that is perhaps the saddest designation of all because it is a way of placing him in a literary cule-de-sac along with all those other talents who are acknowledged but belittled with ethnic tags like 'magic-realism'. These 'tags' are not praise but a way of marking them out, no matter their quality, as exotic exceptions, but not really part of the mainstream (see my footnote *1 below).
In Purdy's case the sobriquet 'gay' conceals that he created women characters, particularly in his later novels like Jeremy's Version, On Glories Course and Gertrude of Stoney Island Avenue (and many others), that are as good as anything in Tennessee Williams. But let us be honest 'gay' is a way of excluding, like all such tags.
The women in Purdy's stories, like his novels, are in these stories along with all the other acutely observed outsiders to the great American dream. Purdy is often described as a 'Southern Gothick' writer even though he spent no time in the South. He was formed by the great American mid-west. He was born in Findlay, Ohio a place I had the misfortune to spend some time as a teenager visiting my father and working to earn money for my University in Ireland. Purdy was not at any time before his death commemorated amongst the famous sons of Findlay although he is the greatest son of Findlay just as he was the last of the 20th century giants of the USA's post WWII literature's golden age to die. Long after I had left Findlay behind, except in nightmares, I discovered Purdy and recognised Findlay, unnamed in so much of his writing. The grotesque is most richly represented in America's most white-bread heartland.
This is a wonderful collection of stories by a unique writer. He will be read long after most of today's literary darlings are forgotten. If you can find time for the tripe written by the likes of Hanya Yanagihara (of A Little Life fame) then do yourself a favour and read Purdy and discover the truly great.
*1 I remember very clearly the way black athletes in the USA and UK (and probably in other white majority countries) were praised for their abilities but we were always reminded that their talent was not the result of the athletes hard work but advantages bestowed by their race (the adjective 'primitive' preceding race was unspoken but definitely implied) or historical antecedents like the 'breeding' of slaves. I use that comparison with great respect because it does sum up my loathing of the selection of certain people for praise which is no praise.