John Piper is my favorite author, Bible teacher, and preacher. By the grace of God, I have learned much from his rigorous yet clear Bible exposition, his systematizing of truths, and his way of thinking and teaching. I thank God for him in my life.
And I think that when you read Piper’s books, so many stand out as unique, clear, well-written argumentation. Almost all his major works have this outstanding quality about them. His most well-known books like *Desiring God*, *Pleasures…*, *Let the Nations Be Glad*, fit in this category, but so do books like *Brothers, We Are Not Professionals*, *What Jesus Demands…*, *This Momentary Marriage*, *A Hunger for God*, *Don’t Waste…*, *God is the Gospel*, and even the recent *A Peculiar Glory* trilogy and *Why I Love the Apostle Paul*. These (and more!) all are brilliant, well organized, well written.
I say all that as a backdrop because, I have to admit, that then there’s this second tier level of Piper’s works. Now, to be clear, it is second tier *not* because the logic, thoughts, insights are not great. It rather just seems like they weren’t as edited, polished, or well organized. In this category, I’d put his *Living in the Light*, *A Holy Ambition*, and now, this book.
Did I enjoy reading it? Absolutely. But it was jarring how (for lack of better term) sort of thrown together it felt. I have listened to his 10 sermon series the books were based off—I even had the privilege of visiting Bethlehem for his sovereignty sermon in the series—but the actual chapters were jumbled and didn’t seem like a book (nor even a sermon).
Rather, each chapter, as you can see by just skimming the chapters if you’d like, is mainly 4 reasons here, 10 reasons there, etc. In this way, there is good argumentation and exegesis, but it clearly isn’t as organized nor edited to be a cohesive whole.
Still, as I said above, there was some great content. I especially loved the final four chapters, only because they are less talked about in other places in Piper’s works and it was great having them in print. But overall, it felt jumbled and lacking.
Overall, as someone who has read all of Piper’s works, I was disappointed—but even that word can be mistaken, it was still excellent content, it just was missing editing, organization, cohesiveness.
But if the book was given more time, editing, and pasting together—changing it from a book of lists to a book more like his others—I think it could be incredible.
In fact, that would be my recommendation (for whatever it’s worth). The 10 truths are as world-shattering as he says they are; moreover, in his ministry as a whole *Piper* is the one who teaches these 10 truths uniquely, in a compelling and convicting way; and even furthermore, a book about these 10 truths could become a true classic and something that could be memorial for who Piper was. But honestly, this work here, with its poor editing and poor cohesiveness and list-focus, wasn’t it unfortunately.
Nevertheless, I’m still glad I read it. And the content was good and still, being Piper, a world different than most other Christian books—hence, the 4 star rating. I just wish it was more like his others in clarity, creativity, and cohesiveness.