Another instance when I wish I could award half stars to a book. My 25 Years in Provence definitely is worthy of at least 2-1/2 stars. In good conscience, I could not quite go up to three.
At times, I was drawn into Mayle's recollections of his many years living in Provence. But those few times didn't go far enough to compel me to really like this memoir of 179 pages. He obviously loved his adopted country, Provence in particular. But he just didn't go deep enough into why he was ready to bid adieu to his native England -- other than the weather. Was that the only reason he and his wife settled somewhere sunnier and more laid back? Perhaps. People move for all kinds of reasons. Still, I would have liked more.
Two aspects of this book really bothered me.
The first was that this move was a joint venture. His wife, though present a few times within the pages, doesn't exist at all in the stories. Was she present for anything that he experienced? Was she a factor in his finding happiness in Provence? Were they merely two separate people living parallel lives, living in the same house but only to co-exist? I suppose this book was about Mayle's memories and recollections of his 25 years in Provence (he passed away last year), but how could his wife not be a part of his memories to share while living there?
Second, there were a few -- scant as they were -- smatterings of French phrases that Mayle threw into his stories that he does not translate. That was frustrating. French is not a universal language, and it would have been nice to know what message he was trying to get across. (There were instances when he did share the translation. Thankfully. But why not always?)
Now that I have gotten my two main gripes about My 25 Years in Provence out of the way, there were two minor grumbles I had with this book that I'd like to share.
The first pertains to the chapter about Ridley Scott taking one of Mayle's stories, and turning it into the quiet, charming "A Good Year", starring Russell Crowe. French actress Marion Cotillard was in the film, and Mayle credits Scott with turning the noted actress into "a major star" (Mayle's words, not mine), aka on the level of Brad Pitt, who Scott cast in "Thelma & Louise". I've seen Cotillard in other productions. She is a good actress, but in no way, shape or form is she on the same level as someone of Pitt's stature. This is an instance of when Mayle blows a story out of proportion. I'm just saying -- let's keep things in perspective.
The second pertains to Mayle being awarded the the Legion d'Honneur Medal, a highly esteemed honor to be bestowed upon an individual. Mayle's good friend, mayor of Menerbes, nominated Mayle for the prestigious award. But why??? Mayle never shares that piece of information with his readers. I am not saying -- nor inferring -- that Mayle wasn't deserving. It just would have been nice to know why his good friend thought he was worthy of one of France's highest honors.
Small grievances, perhaps. But they bugged me.
All in all, My 25 Years in Provence was charming. I certainly do not regret reading this book. It is a memoir, after all, and memoirs oftentimes can leave the reader wanting...
Happy Reading! :-)