3.5 stars (rounded to 3 stars)
First of all, I’m a huge Robert Bryndza fan and can hardly wait every time I find out he is about to release a new book. Note the present tense—I AM a huge fan, and I CAN hardly wait for book 6 in the Erika Foster series. Book 5, however, was a little disappointing to me.
Now before you Bryndza fans (and there are certainly a lot of you!) get all excited, let me say the number one problem I encountered with Cold Blood was triggered by a quirk of my own. Man, I just did not like the Nina/Max arc at all. Every time I began a Nina/Max chapter I groaned. Not because the writing was bad. Mr. Bryndza is a fine writer. It was because I have a real issue with the type of story that arc was telling. I have no desire whatsoever to read that kind of story. But I had to here, as I was dying to get back to the part featuring Erika and her colleagues. Again, that was my main issue with the book. Most crime fiction lovers will sail through the Nina/Max arc and in all liklihood love it.
I came upon some other issues, which were not so bad, but still were there for me. Gosh, Rob, couldn’t you cut Erika a break? She has a pretty bleak time in this installment and it was kind of painful to see. Also, we do continue to learn more about Erika and also Marsh, but what about Moss, McGorry and Crane. Could we get these guys featured more? I would love to learn more about them. Finally, there were a few occurrences that hit the believability wall for me. I may have passed over these if the rest of the book had been perfect, but I was feeling grumpy and the ability to suspend the believability issue disappeared on me.
I feel like a real meanie now. Forgive me, Rob. I love you and Erika, I do. There was a lot of good in the story. The plot, getting to know Erika and Marsh better, the interaction of Nina with the humans near the end of the book. I liked seeing that in the worst criminals, there can be some good, however too little or too late it is.
Sigh. I always rate by how a book makes me feel. So, Rob, when you look at these measly 3 stars, know that it’s really 3.5 stars and know that this crappy rating is primarily due to my abhorrence of having to watch how evil Max treated formerly sweet Nina. I still declare the Detective Erika Foster series to be part of the cream of the crop of crime fiction, and I encourage all crime fiction fans to read it. Best start at the beginning with The Girl in The Ice in order to watch the characters develop.
I will say it again. I can hardly wait till the next Erika Foster book arrives on my kindle. Bring it, Rob!
Many thanks to Net Galley, Bookouture, and Robert Bryndza for gifting me an ARC of this book. Opinions are mine alone and are not biased in any way.