Kosciuszko

by Nick Brodie

A riveting story of one of Australia’s forgotten mysteries.

Kosciuszko is more than just our highest mountain – unbidden, it forms part of our national sense of self. So when in 1928 two men went missing high on its perilous slopes, the mystery of their disappearance gripped the country. Focusing on the mountain, Australians united in purpose.

Evan Hayes typified the best of old and new Australia – a country boy and son of a unionist, made good in Sydney and skiing the Snowies; Laurie Seaman, a well travelled American newly married to an Australian; both were members of the Millions Club, an ambitious push to reach one million people in Sydney, underscoring Australia’s place in a changing world.

Their excursion to Kosciuszko – the country’s newly popular winter playground, yet also one of its most inhospitable wildernesses – revealed a young Commonwealth coming of age. As we journey alongside the search parties, and the puzzle of their disappearance is explored, we are shown an almost-forgotten Australia between wars, straddling a crucial turning point in world history.

Evan and Laurie’s story of misadventure tangibly shows us the spirit of their age, and of our nation.

Genres: Nonfiction, History

200 pages, Kindle Edition

Published March 1, 2019

Reviews

[Sophie · Rating 2 out of 5]

The only part I enjoyed in this book was the description of events surrounding the two skiers going missing. I thought the whole book would be about this but it is really only about half. The rest is random historical events that don’t seem to have much relevance and were quite boring.
The author seems to have taken every time “Kosciusko” was mentioned ever (in letters, newspapers etc), and included that in this book as proof that it is some iconic Australian cultural phenomenon. In reality, I think I only know about Kosciusko because of maybe a brief mention in school and because I happen to have skied on it many times. I completely disagree that it forms some sort of Australian identity. My native Australian partner didn’t even know for sure that the mountain was in Australia. I think the whole premise of the book is a bit of a stretch and would have been rated 1 Star if not for the slight mystery element.

[Troy · Rating 5 out of 5]

Mount Kosciuszko holds a place close to that of Uluru in the consciousness of the Australian people, both the Indigenous Australians and those who came after. Every year thousands of people make the trek up its not too difficult slopes in summer to reach the summit. But in winter the mountain can be a deadly place. Back in 1928 Australia learnt that lesson when two men went missing while climbing to the summit during a blizzard. Nick Brodie tells the tale of the disappearance and the efforts to find the men. But he also tells the story of both men and the story of the mountain before and after they were there. This is a brilliant book, a really riveting read and a great piece of forgotten Australian history.

[David Vernon · Rating 3 out of 5]

When Nick focussed on the missing skiers and the attempts to find them, the book was engaging. However, too much of the text was trying to 'prove' that Kosciuszko has some deep cultural meaning to Australians. I think this is overblown and no matter how many examples he threw up in trying to persuade me that we have some huge reverence for this particular mountain, the arguments were unconvincing. Kosciuszko is no Uluru. I've climbed it many times and yeah, it's fantastic but that's because of the surrounding scenery, not because of the mountain (you'd barely know you were on the peak). The highlight for me was reading why Seaman's Hut is named such. I spent my buck's night in Seaman's hut and now knowing its history, this experience has been enhanced for me!

[Garrett Fitzgerald · Rating 3 out of 5]

A novel about a historical event which seems to be based almost entirely on newspaper based research.

Did the author try to contact relatives of the people involved? Interview experts or guides who work there today? Find old radio or even early TV/films? A very limited research base.

[chloe · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.25 stars. A poignant story on tragedy and the Australian character.

[Nikki Balzer · Rating 1 out of 5]

Not for me - just couldn't get into it.