I've bought this after watching a litrpg podcast review on youtube. I really liked the premise of it, you know? Dark survival fantasy in a post apocalyptic world where no one is absolutely safe. The mood was dark, solemn, and full of anger and rage.
Dave Willmarth really designed characters like Meg, Sam, Nancy and Chloe well. Even the childlike innocence of Chloe was highlighted well. The main character was a brat but acted appropriately and took logical decisions. You could sense the tension in the air and to be honest I really really liked that. There was good character interaction and development between the first group of survivors.
At least, until Helen and Fuzzy showed up and the mc turned into a dude bro.
The mc was always a bit childish but he made appropriate decisions for a post apocalyptic survival novel in the first half of the book. I repeat but I really liked the solemn death filled numb kind of mood.
But then the author, made the mc into a smart-ass who spews weird jokes and cheesy one lines (in the middle of a danger zone) and starts describing various cute interaction between the mc and Helen (like Helen making weird pout faces....). And this continued on and on. The Survivalist dark atmosphere was gone and the story took a nosedive and turned into some kind of lame joke filled slice of life. I like slice of life and this story was supposed to be a grim dark slice of life, not the exact opposite. If first half of the book when someone died everyone was mourning and crying. They didn't see the dead as heroes, they saw them as unfairly murdered. In the second half of the book people were still busy cheering and high-fiving. The dead were brushed away as 'heroic' and that's that. :( This whole charade continues, not to mention the airbase people and the Cheyenne folks.
I feel in the 2nd half of the book the author threw character interaction out of the window. No deep development like in the first half.
But all of this isn't even my biggest gripe against the series.
So, a little bit of spoiler here. Be warned.
In the airbase, they were cleaning mobs when they came across locked doors and such. they were cautiously opening the doors in case a mob inside slams it open to injure someone. This reminded the mc of a scene of a character named 'X' in a book called War Aeternus that was tragically killed by a trapped tavern door.
X because i am hiding the character name here but the author certainly named a character.
And I was like... did the author just spoil a book for me in my reading list that I have yet to read???? I bought the War Aetenrus book series but haven't gotten to read it yet. I don't know if the 'X' is one of the characters in book 1 who died, or if 'X' was a character who was there till book 4 as a major character, or if he just appeared for 5 pages and got off'ed. I don't know that. BUT, now I know how he died and that he had indeed died. I just stared at the page for a few seconds there and kept wondering, WHAT THE FUCK????
*sighs*
Ok that was a long rant. I don't know if I am going to read War Aeternus now because even a minor spoiler kind of ruins whole books for me (I quit reading Tom Sawyer because someone told me what happened to Huckleberry Fin). I already have book 2 of Shadow Sun but now I only imagine I will read it for the base building. There is no tension or solemness left that was present in fist half of book 1.