What do you think?
Rate this book


433 pages, Paperback
First published June 14, 2018
Below, she could see miles and miles of unconquered woodland spreading in every direction: the Wild. Strange. Threatening. The very sight of it chilled her, and in the dark it was all too easy to imagine it growing, reaching out to engulf the road-born who dwelled on its perimeter.
She couldn't imagine living so close to death. How do they sleep down there? She wondered. How do they bear it?



Well that was disappointing.
It feels like Newman went from refreshingly new to a run of the mill plot that doesn't try remotely hard to engage.
*Cries in bought this book at full price*
🖤
So this book. *🥁🥁* Immortal beings squabbling.
Which sounds really cool and totally isn't an unwelcome plot. But with this book, felt like reading about children arguing. Everyone wants to write about political scheming without the finesse that such a plot would require.
The plot was clumsy, contrived and ill-befitting of being referred to as anything but subpar.
I don't know if it's just me, but I feel like if I'm going to read about beings that are for all intents and purposes, immortal, then they should, for the love of God, be smart and calculating.
There is a sense that Newman wants this book to go one way and one way only, 'family member feel slighted and betrays the rest of the family'. There is no nuance to this book.
🖤🖤
For an author that wrote a book carried on the back of an extraordinary mute character, the characters' Newman presents in this book move between mediocre and just plain weird.
Pari, Chandni, Nidari and the rest are just your typical run of the mill fantasy immortal characters, lacking everything that would make their exploits stay with you.
for no reason at all and it was just not something that the author was able to fully sell to me as plausible, Infact I don't think Newman explained how that could have happened.
A sizeable part of this book takes place in the Wild but little of the Wild's workings is explained especially as it seems this lack of explanation is used to ensure the survival of the main characters.
🖤🖤🖤
All in all, there's definitely huge potential with this story and the end does pick up but Newman doesn't seem to be able to prop up the story as a whole successfully. Leaving you with the kind of book where neither the characters' nor the plot stays with you long after you're done.
⭐⭐ disappointing stars 
“Hunt well and thorough.”
“I am a student of silence, and the things that can be found on its edges.”
"Things are not well in the home of your lover. Loyal friends are posted elsewhere. Strangers walk the halls, sharpening knives while they wait for his return. He needs help. He needs you. Come now. Come carefully."