Few personalities in the history of literature have aroused so much interest as that of Oscar Wilde, yet the essentials of his nature are still not recognized and we are left to catch glimpses of the real man in the scattered reminiscences of the period. Here, at last, is the whole life of the man who was probably the most delightful and witty conversationalist the world has ever seen. Hesketh Pearson has succeeded in presenting Oscar Wilde as he was at the Café Royale in London, and in making the reader see him as the darling of the drawing rooms, the conversationalist, not the convict. But this is not a hero-worshipping book—Pearson shows Wilde's shortcomings and gives instances when Wilde was over-dramatic and when he failed to come off as a writer and a talker. This is a remarkable recreation of a genius set sharply in contrast to a period that battened on his wit, persecuted him, failed to understand him. Some of Wilde's stories make their first appearance in this book as do some of the conversational original s of several witticisms in his plays. "The most true, the most sensible and the fairest book which has yet been written about Oscar Wilde."—Harold Nicholson in The Observer Illustrated with 15 gravure plates.
Edward Hesketh Gibbons Pearson was an English actor, theatre director and writer. He is known mainly for his biographies; they made him the leading British biographer of his time, in terms of commercial success.
Note from the future: I've since changed my opinions on Alfred Douglas, but I'll leave the review as is, as it expresses my honest opinions from when I read and just after I read this book.
I finished this book last night, so it had some time to brew in my mind before I began writing this review. This was something it needed, as I’m still unsure what to rate this book or how to feel about it. I liked the length of the book, what the chapters were titled and what they focused on, the way the book was organized, the prose, the font-size, and the type-print. All positives there. But there are a couple general points of contention I have. No, three, now that I think of it. (After editing this review the next day, many more points of contention popped up, but the three still generally conceptualize my primary annoyances with this book.)
Firstly, Pearson is a bit of a misogynist. Not that he ever blatantly says, “Women are inferior to men, and are mentally defective, and I hate them,” but the way he talks about women is a bit condescending, and oftentimes he seems to try to overemphasize how popular Oscar Wilde was with women, as if to make him appear to be “more of a man”. He also makes some jokes that would only be funny to (chauvinist) men, like saying that men have been trying to figure out for eternity how to balance drugs, drink, and women, in reference to a man he discusses who crosses Wilde’s path. Here’s another example, an example quotation now: “But he still had not completely vindicated his masculinity, and one evening at a club several youths suggested a round of brothels. Wilde was perfectly game, and proved that he could take his women, as he had taken his whisky, like a man.” (54) Makes me want to vomit the way this is phrased. There may be a touch of sarcasm there, or he may be deliberately phrasing it as the men who were “testing” Wilde thought of it, but it’s nonetheless very distasteful all-around. The part concerning Wilde, on the other hand, couldn’t be more intellectually dishonest and unnecessary. I understand the author admires Wilde, but that doesn’t mean he should be toeing the line of actually making things up and fabricating to “redeem” his name.
Back to the misogyny, though: This misogyny can also be shown in the way Pearson talks about Constance Wilde, Wilde’s wife. Pearson says that she was always uncomfortable in the fashionable clothes Wilde apparently made her wear, and that he liked exploring new and unconventional styles and forced her to clothe herself in unpopular and modern dresses that didn’t fit the era, but in Vyvyan Wilde’s memoirs, he, a far more trustworthy and credible source, being the son of this woman, says that she actually enjoyed it, took considerable pleasure in it, and didn’t just do as Wilde told her to do but happily followed his suggestion and made it her own. Pearson, in the text, seems to be playing up on certain qualities of hers, describing in a very thinly-veiled way how hesitant, feminine, submissive, unintelligent in comparison to the brilliant Mr. Wilde, and unoriginal she was, and it’s utterly obnoxious. He says, “She was uncomfortably aware that her clothes had to be as unconventional as her husband’s conversation”, “For his sake she posed in . . . [different] attires, and she did not like it a bit”, “She smiled bravely; but, if she looked lovely, she felt miserable”, etc (103). Pearson is certainly trying to forward his viewpoint, reading things into the past which were not there.
See, finding these quotes is reminding me how annoying the tone Pearson writes with is.
Also, on page 105, he relates a story where Constance, at one of Wilde’s receptions, interrupts him when he’s being witty to ask him if he’s called for Cyril’s boots, Cyril being their eldest son, a story which apparently shows what a nag and dumb female she was. (Pearson doesn’t say it, but it’s definitely implied.) In Vyvyan Wilde’s memoir, he explains this story was made up to insult his mother. Sure sounds like it to me.
Finally, in regard to the misogyny charge, on page 323, Pearson says, “What [Wilde] missed most was his audience: the pretty fashionable women who had thronged to hear him talk and whose appreciation had inspired his plays.” (This is to explain why he stopped writing after his exile to France.) Now, this just reads as Pearson’s imagination. There is no evidence that this was what Wilde really thought, and it seems this is what Pearson imagines he would miss the most if he were in Wilde’s place. He provides a quotation by Wilde afterwards to justify this interpretation, which says something along the lines of, when you’ve been at the top, it’s no longer fun anymore when you’re at the bottom, but this is completely different and lacks any mention of pretty women! It almost sounds like Pearson is trying to…defend Wilde by making him seem more heterosexual by saying he missed the pretty women? Ha! How stupid and obnoxious.
Anyway, reason number two I was annoyed: Pearson is writing in the age of the sexologists, and it’s very obvious. At least, I’m pretty damn sure of it, because he starts to talk about homosexuality as a congenital sickness and tries to fit Wilde into what the sexologists thought was the prototypical homosexual mold. It was annoying, and it made me feel I couldn’t trust much of what he said about Wilde, because he discarded the information that didn’t fit into his theory; for example, he spends a lot of time in the beginning of the book talking about how incredibly un-athletic Wilde was, and how he hated all physical sports, sucked at them, only tried them out because one of his teachers recommended it, etc. Whereas, in Vyvyan Wilde’s autobiography, he spends a lot of time rebutting this accusation and describing how Wilde loved to golf, and at Oxford, he went boating and did many sports and was physically hearty, not because he felt like he had to, but because he genuinely liked it. Now, there is that one myth in Vyvyan’s memoir, that Wilde easily beat up three men (and threw them about) who were going to try to jump him, but otherwise, Vyvyan seems to be more on the nose than Pearson.
In reality, the truth probably lies somewhre in between the two perspectives, as likely Vyvyan was, to a certain extent, trying to defend his father against the accusation of effeminacy and accepted some tales that may have been untrue, but the way Pearson handles the matter really annoyed me.
On a similar vein, he talks in this book so often about how Wilde was “emotionally undeveloped”—he constantly goes over that refrain, and, to illustrate his point, he talks about how Wilde dramatized everything when he didn’t really mean it, and how he had this imaginative fancy that he was going through the same trials as Jesus Christ and changed his behavior when it didn’t fit the trials of Christ. On page 290, he makes up this half-baked theory about Wilde unjustly (hah??) blaming Douglas for his imprisonment and casting him as the “villain” because he was so entrenched in his delusion of himself as Jesus that he needed to cast the role of Judas and ultimately picked Douglas. I don’t even know what to say about that…It’s ridiculous. First of all, Douglas was not an innocent lamb, and their relationship was a fucking mess, according to all the sources I’ve read from so far, especially after Wilde went to jail, (at that point there was basically no relationship left), no matter what lies Pearson makes up about them being on friendly terms to the end of Wilde’s life. Second of all, I think Pearson is picking and choosing behaviors Wilde displayed and magnifying them beyond all proportion. The Jesus Christ thing wasn’t this significant. And his being angry with Douglas was not some delusion about needing a Judas to his Christ, for God’s sake! Pearson says such insulting misrepresentations of the truth—it makes me so angry. Crazy, considering this is just over a historical matter considering a literary personage.
At least he didn’t explicitly castigate Wilde for his homosexuality; he seemed to accept it (...to a certain extent) and mentioned how, nowadays (in the time he was writing the book), it’s considered generally normal and wouldn’t be the cause of so much attack.
To move onto my third point of contention: Pearson seems to really be trying to whitewash Alfred Douglas. I kind of mentioned that above, but I’ll expand on this. He places little to no blame on Douglas for the legal debacle Wilde got into, glibly explains away Wilde’s exclamations that Douglas ruined him, and glosses over all of Douglas’ negative traits. There’s one paragraph I remember in particular, that I’ll give as an example: He mentions how, while on vacation together, they both got the flu (or some influenza, can’t remember) and “nursed each other back to health” or something, which made their moods sour, but I know from the previous biographies (I think I’m thinking of Gide’s) of Wilde I read that, in actuality, Douglas got sick first, Wilde tenderly nursed him back to health, and then when Wilde got sick, Douglas left him in the hotel to go party all day, and Wilde had to tend to himself while he could barely pick himself off the ground. Here’s the quotation from Pearson, anyhow: “Each nursed the other through an attack of influenza, and tempers became a little frayed in the process.” (246) A complete misrepresentation of the truth. Also, Pearson mentions offhandedly many times that this, that, this, and that, are all lies—a lot of them made up by Robert Ross, apparently, because Ross was jealous of Douglas, but that reads false to me. I think the reverse is more likely to be true. Pearson is jealous of Ross, because Ross was Wilde’s closest friend, and Pearson never even met the man! Also, from the way Pearson sucks up to Douglas, you’d think Pearson is a Douglas fanboy. Or something. And he even praises Douglas’ autobiography and recommends it to the readers, when the previous biographies I’ve read of Wilde talk about how it’s full of lies! It feels very petty. And who is he to talk so much shit when he wasn’t even an acquaintance of Wilde?!!
There are many, many moments in this narrative that contradict what I’ve read before and say that what he’s saying is the actual truth, and I don’t know how to feel about that. Based on Pearson’s tone, though, and based on my own sense of reasoning and logic, and my truth-recognizing faculty, I’m inclined to distrust him.
Just to have a better idea of how to weigh all these conflicting opinions in my mind, I do want to read a more modern biography of Wilde and see what is accepted as the truth nowadays. I also should read that biography of Douglas from like 1970 and see what it says about his actions. Still, it’s very interesting how many conflicting perspectives there are!
One other thing I noticed in this book which was funny at first but then quickly became aggravating were the jabs at Frank Harris. They were present in Vyvyan Wilde’s memoir, and I wasn’t too surprised to see them here too. But they were extremely frequent. I knew from the segment by Bernard Shaw in the appendix of Harris’ two-volume biography of Wilde that Harris was a disliked figure, but I didn’t realize the extent! Pearson disputes a lot of what Harris said in his biography in this book. I am inclined to trust a good segment of what Pearson said, but not all of it, because a lot of it seems to be motivated by malice. But I definitely am less open to trusting unthinkingly what Harris said now.
A positive, before I wrap this review up: As Pearson said in the prologue/preface/intro, he wanted to focus more on Wilde’s wit than the drama of his life, and he succeeded in that. He included many quotations of Wilde’s and witty lines and stories he told, and several times they made me laugh aloud. I really enjoyed that aspect of the book; it definitely helped me further understand just how brilliant Wilde was, and what a beautiful speaker he was. This book really centered on Wilde’s mind—and what a wonderful mind! Wilde apparently also had a photographic memory, which is really impressive; he could flip through an entire book in three minutes and then answer any question on the book correctly and accurately, even quoting from it. Now, that is damn cool.
I guess I’ll stop here. My thoughts on this book are very, very confusing, and I still haven’t fully gathered them, even after writing this much. I suppose I’ll give this book three stars. For a little while, while reading the book, I thought about giving it two. That was when I was at the beginning of the first trial, as I noticed how scot-free Pearson left Douglas, which really annoyed me. But I think this book has enough positive points—it made me think, didn’t it?—that a three wouldn’t be a dishonest rating.
I changed my mind, after typing up the quotations I marked and going back and adding to the review. This definitely deserves a two. Or worse. God, Pearson makes me mad.
Finally, I’m not sure I’d recommend this book. If you’re interested in seeing another perspective on Wilde, sure. But if you haven’t read any old Wilde biographies and want a trustworthy source, no.
Quotations: (I have a lot more on a Google Document page, but they won't fit here ;-;)
The other old biography I had of Oscar Wilde, this is somewhat more important in that it is based largely on interviews with people who actually knew Wilde fairly well. It is also better than the previous biography in that it does not concentrate so largely on the scandals, but as the subtitle suggests gives many anecdotes about his witty conversations, as well as a bit more on his writings.
Miała swoje lepsze i gorsze momenty; widać, że jest to książka z "innej epoki" (opis kobiet jest tu hm... specyficzny). Trochę jednak bawi unikanie tematu seksualności w przypadku kogoś, kto został przez to skazany na więzienie. Myślę, że to dosyć istotny wątek, panie autorze lol