I read enough Anita Stansfield books as a youth to pretty much know how this book was going to go: two people meet and fall in love; one has a "past"; one, usually the guy, struggles with his faith, and one, usually the girl, is insurmountably patient; a tragic event happens about halfway through the book, which causes one or more people to change miraculously; and everyone lives happily ever after. After that you can expect a sequel, which takes place a few blissful years later, which involves conflicts and tragic events that jeopardize all things warm and fuzzy, and a lot of times it is some of Stansfield's other characters (from other books) that give individuals the perspective they need to overcome and move on. And so on and so forth.
This was my first time reading an Anita Stansfield novel as an adult though; I simply wanted to escape into someone else's world for a while, even if it was inside a badly edited Covenant book, and for 5 hours I read and forgot about my own troubles for a time.
Stansfield doesn't seem to spend a lot of time of characterization and description; I had a hard time picturing Alex--all I had to go on was that he was handsome--and most of the other characters were just blank faces to me. As for the places/settings, Stansfield seems to assume that her audience has already been to these places, and doesn't need to describe them further. I think this tactic works though, because I'm guessing that most of Stansfield's audience comprises women from Utah.
Most of the book is composed of dialogue--both external and internal--not a lot of stuff actually happens. And despite Alex's change at the end, I found the character development overall lacking. But apparently this tactic works too, because Stansfield has a lot of fans.
I couldn't help but feel a sense of familiarity with this book, however, something I've felt for all of her books. I swear I've had half of these conversations before. I know what it feels like to be surrounded by family as the shock of losing a loved one settles in. I know what it's like to watch friends and family make poor choices, and I know the joy that comes from watching them get back on track. And within all of the predictable events of the novel is pearls of gospel wisdom that, despite the cheese factor, find a way to reach me in ways that scriptures and speeches wouldn't normally be able to.
I went looking for a book that started with "once upon a time" and ended with "happily ever after," and I got it. And even though I make fun of people who read "substance-less" books like these, sometimes it's just soothing to the soul to get lost in a book that is trivial and distracting.