Well, I got behind on writing reviews (which wasn't my fault, you drive 19 hours straight and find time to write a review), so I'm going to have to dig into my memory for the next few reviews here.
Ok, to start with, I've never read a Warhammer 40K book. I'm slightly interested in the deep grimdark lore of the setting, which is why I decided to pick up the "Warhammer Horror: Audiobook Collection" to keep my occupied as I drove through the Appalachians. So, this was my first dive into grimdark and Warhammer 40K, so I reserve the right to be entirely wrong in my review as I learn more later.
This was the first of the three books and was a "fun" delving into madness. The formalized structure of Warhammer 40K seemed to work really well with the very slow decent into madness, which at first I thought was going to be something like a 40K version of The Haunting of Hill House. I'm not sure it entirely ended that way, but it certainly wasn't crazy far off (pun now intended).
One of my favorite aspects of all three of these books, but this book in particular, was the subversive and non-corporeal nature of the horror which invades the protagonist's story. The story itself took a bit of time to get off the ground, laying a groundwork instead of jumping right into the deep end, but once it takes off it TAKES OFF. The reader (and, by virtue of seeing only through his eyes, the protagonist) has no idea what is real, what is illusion, or what is indeterminate. Did demons kill his friend in the basement? Did his wife kill herself? Numerous other questions regarding the evil, and you know what? The answer to every question is "maybe yes?" I could even see the answers of no and yes being both correct for several questions.
Which is to say the book can get frustrating. There's only so many times you can take a left turn only to find out you're going right until it gets monotonous. But, I feel like that too, is part of the story; by the time the end scene hits you just don't know what's true or false or indeterminate and you, like the protagonist, kinda just want it to end. So, the absolutely horrific end scene which in a vacuum would have anyone screaming "THIS IS STUPID THERE'S NO WAY HE'D DO THAT" you just sit there and, well, get it.
That said, both my wife (who was forced to listed to this with me) and I guessed the end of the story, and I felt that there was something just a bit off with it. Maybe off isn't even the right word, but missed? Either way I couldn't fully rate this a 5, so it ended with a 4 star.
4.3/5 stars
Recommend