A Knight’s tale about duty, duels, driving your sister crazy...all while trying to save the country from a secret that threatens to tear it apart.
When a seemingly harmless prank goes wrong, knight-in-training Per of Esterpike watches her sister Elena, famed hero and leader of Lions, murdered by a barbarian horde set on wiping Esterpike off the map. Together with Elena’s second-in-command Amelia, Per must impersonate her sister and travel to Unity’s capital to convince the Generals of each city-state to provide aid against the oncoming horde. But as Per moves forward on her quest, she comes upon a conspiracy that might just threaten Unity itself!
Join writer and illustrator C.R. Chua (Adventure Time Comics) and writer Paolo Chikiamco on Per’s grand adventure all about strength, swords, and sisterhood.
It's a good premise, with a grand general set to be elected between 4 medieval kingdoms. The execution is where I had problems. I had issues following what was happening in the story due to the unclear story and unfinished looking art. Having two sets of twins? (could have been just siblings?. Again it was unclear due to the art.) made it hard to tell who was who in the story. This could have been good if the storytelling was clearer.
Received a review copy from Boom and NetGalley. All thoughts are my own and in no way influenced by the aforementioned.
A few weeks ago I finished the last volume that is currently available for Fence and since then I have been kind of hopping around in the graphic novel world looking for a new long-running graphic novel series to take Fence's place in my reading rotation. The way I usually read is to have a physical book from my nightstand stack, a kindle book (which is usually an ebook ARC or a library borrow), an audiobook (either from Libby, Hoopla, or Audible), and then a graphic novel. I like to read the graphic novels in between novels or whenever I am starting to feel a little burnt out (and sometimes when I just need a quick brain break from work).
I have a few graphic novel series that are long-running that I keep the next issue on hand on my Kindle so whenever I am ready I can jump in and I know I will enjoy them and be able to relax! Every once in awhile I throw in a stand-alone graphic novel or something new but I usually stick with my long-running series until I am caught up. Some of the long running graphic novels I have had or currently have in the rotation are: Saga (I am sadly all caught up and constantly checking for when more will be out, check out the reviews for each volume), Giant Days (I am still reading this one but I learned just recently that it will be ending soon and I will cry a million rivers), Fence (I am all caught up on this one as well and eagerly awaiting the next volume), and The Woods (this one is a more recent addition but I am really enjoying it)! So since I am currently only reading two long-running graphic novel series I decided to pick up this stand-alone!
SPOILERS AHEAD
In this stand-alone graphic novel, we meet Per of Esterpike who has watched her sister, the famed hero, Elena die in battle. Per and Elena's second in command Amelia work together to help Per impersonate Elena and help her travel to the capital of Unity. Per needs to convince the generals to provide aid for an upcoming battle however, things definitely do not go as planned and Per discovers something she definitely should not. Along her journey, Per finds out about a conspiracy theory that will threaten the entire country! Per now has to stop this conspiracy and complete her journey all while impersonating her sister! Is she up for the task? Will anyone find out she is pretending to be her sister?
Overall, I enjoyed this graphic novel a lot! Like I said above I do not read stand-alone graphic novels often so this was a super nice change of pace and I really enjoyed what it brought to the table. However, there were parts of the story that were hard for me to get into and I think honestly that it was on me. I seem to struggle with the more fantasy-based graphic novels but I still enjoyed this one and found the art to be gorgeous! The colors were vibrant and the blue that was used repeatedly was so beautiful (like I would put it on my walls beautiful). I am giving this three and a half stars on Goodreads!
**I was given this ARC copy in exchange for an honest review from the publisher!
Christina Rose Chua and Paolo Chikiamco's A Sparrow's Roar is a graphic novel full of passion and heart. With their country near under attack from barbarians, when the leader of Esterpike is murdered, it falls upon her sister, Per, to impersonate her in order to convince the nearby Generals to join them in protecting her homeland and their own. But, with all the secrets and conspiracies, Per will soon realize that her journey and goal is a lot harder to achieve than she originally thought. An incredibly fun and emotional tale, this was a story I truly enjoyed reading.
The highest of stakes.
Honestly, I didn't realize how emotional I would feel about this graphic novel when I first went into it. It's the sort of story that doesn't really ever give you a moment of rest. From one moment to the next, you're always worried about what is going to happen. And then, when the worst does seem to happen, you're upset about it. And though this is a story about a young woman, Per, coming into her own, it remains fraught with moments of grief.
With her sister's death and her country on the line, Per has a lot to face along her journey. And she just might discover herself along the way.
Graphics.
I loved the illustrations in this book. Honestly, it was a huge selling point for me in the beginning and remains one long after I read it. The colors are so vibrant, the characters incredible. You can't help feeling a part of the story with the way it all drags you in. I think, above all else, the graphics were the piece of this novel that I loved the most.
All in all, this was a pretty great book and I'm incredibly happy to have read it.
I was provided a free copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
How could a night so bright... ...scar my soul with such darkness.
If you're looking for a quick and compelling read to catch up on your Goodreads challenge, look no further!
A Sparrow's Roar is easily one of the best graphic novels I've read in 2020. I picked it up on a whim and it hooked me from the very first page! The story follows Per as she, after witnessing her sister's death, tries to stop a conspiracy that can destroy everything they've worked for. Underlying is a tale about familial bond, loyalty, and finding yourself. It's a very engaging and fast-paced read—everything happens within three days with flashbacks here and there as the conspiracy unfolds. It's actually a lot more poignant than I expected, too. As for the art, it's absolutely gorgeous! From the soft color palette to C.R. Chua's fun, lively art style, it ticks all the boxes when it comes to what I like to see in graphic novels. Overall, if you like political intrigue, sisterly love, and warrior women being badass, this graphic novel is for you!
eARC provided by BOOM! Studios via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review!
This was a fantastic graphic novel. I loved every second of it and I would highly recommend it to anyone. This story is about Per and her sister Elena. Elena is the leader of the Lions and a badass with a bow. After something goes horribly wrong, Per watches as Elena is killed on the battlefield. Per assumes Elena's identity as this rapidly spiral out of control. Will Per be able to keep her home safe? Will she get revenge on Elena's killer? You'll have to check this out and find out for yourself!
This was a really great graphic novel and I would highly recommend it. If you like badass ladies doing badass things then this one will be right up your alley.
This is a really great story about family and courage. While some of the art made it difficult to tell certain characters apart, that did play into a twist which was well done. This book set up great motivations for the characters and leaves room for more books in the story world, while still bringing this story to a satisfying conclusion.
Based on the cover art, I had thought this was about a middle school character. It isn't, and that becomes more apparent as the story goes on. Instead, it is about young adults, trying to protect and lead while living up to family legacies.
I have provided an honest review after having received an ecopy of the book through Netgalley.
A straightforward story that tried to keep from being too straightforward by playing with the timeline a bit... But ended up being a bit muddied as a result. Would've been better if a bit more time was spent building relationships to give the events meaning, but it was a fun yarn regardless
Very punchy and effective. A short political thriller, revenge tale, and coming of age all wrapped up in a pseudo renaissance pastiche world. Would love to see another adventure in this world.
Disclaimer: I received a free ecopy via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The idea of this book sounded really exciting to me. Who doesn't love stories about knights and political intrigue? And Per's story is good. She fights with her sister, struggles to be the best knight she can be, and gets into some shenanigans as leaders of surrounding nations jockey for power.
There are a couple things that didn't work for me though. The characters didn't feel distinct for a good portion of the book. I had a hard time distinguishing between Per, her sister, and some of the other characters toward the beginning. Going back and reading it again might have helped alleviate that problem. Some of the better moments in the book didn't have quite the impact on me as they should have because of that confusion.
The structure of the political balance is cool. It plays a big part in the conflicts of the story. The way that Per gets involved and the impact it has on her lends to some of the strength of this book. This story felt aimed at a younger audience, and I think someone in their teens would get a lot out of reading Per's story.
The art in this book is absolutely stunning. I'd never heard of the title or author/artist before, so it was the cover and a quick scan of the inner pages that convinced me to check out this graphic novel on an impulse. I didn't even read the summary on the back beforehand, but I fell in love with the vibes of this fantasy world nevertheless.
"A Sparrow's Roar" is a relatively short read, consisting of only four chapters, so there isn't the space for dense world-building. But the countries are easy to keep track of, since they're color-coded, not just in their flags and banners, but also in their architecture and rooftops. The fashion, too, caught my eye instantly, because it blends traits that I associate with masculinity and femininity. Most of the characters are young women with short hair, who might look butch except for the fact that they mostly wear dresses when they're not in their armor. The archery outfits especially stand out to me, and I appreciate how the artist designed everything. The armor isn't made to accentuate the characters' chests; it's practical and not sculpted out like a bra. Additionally, Chua does not shy away from giving the female characters pronounced muscles and broad shoulders, which is always refreshing to see.
My biggest reservation with this graphic novel, in terms of, "I don't quite know how to feel about this yet," is the disabled representation. (WARNING: MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD.) The main villain has a wooden right arm, and at first, this serves to endear him to the characters and readers, as a point of sympathy and humanity. But then, we learn that he didn't lose his arm gallantly in battle, as many people assumed. Instead, he asked his brother to cut it off for him during the war, to support a lie that would help him gain access to his goal and trust from those in power.
I am all for seeing disabled characters in fiction, and I don't think that it's necessarily wrong to have a villain who is disabled. But when that villain is the only disabled character in the story, I grow suspicious. And when that villain's disability is directly linked to their villainy, I feel hurt and betrayed, by the storytellers more than by the character. It's not his fault he was written like that! The wooden arm feels unnecessary to me, like the only thing making this character disabled accomplishes is vilifying disability in the first place. "You thought that you could trust this man, since he has a disability," the narrative seems to say. "But little did you know, he brought this disability upon himself, and it is an indelible mark of his evil!"
Besides this discomfiting detail, I genuinely enjoyed "A Sparrow's Roar." I like the emphasis on sibling relationships and the Shakespearean trope of siblings switching places, sometimes against their will and other times to execute a clever plan. The story feels cohesive due to this overarching theme, and I enjoy the parallels between the two good sisters and the two evil brothers. That one line Per says about relating to the villain's brother, because he's about to become an only child... That hit hard!
And the art was fantastic, in terms of both sharp, bold lines and in beautiful, satisfying colors. I cannot stress the beauty of the style enough. It's impressive how much story and emotion Chua can generate through a relatively small amount of space, too. I grew to love these characters, especially Per, whom I had just met, and each battle had emotional depth and high stakes. The way that flashbacks are interwoven into the current drama is excellent, and each page truly is a work of art.
I would recommend this story to anyone who loves graphic novels, gender non-conforming women (at least, in the context of our world), and fantasy settings. It's worth mentioning that there isn't any romance to speak of in "A Sparrow's Roar." That's part of what I love, to be honest: that the highest emphasis is on family and friendship, rather than sex and romance. I was briefly afraid that one of the sisters might develop a romance with one of the brothers, but thankfully, that did not happen, and the story was all the stronger for it, in my opinion.
A Sparrow's Roar by C.R. Chua & Paolo Chikiamco • This is a really great graphic novel that I didn't even know was being released internationally until a bunch of my friends tweeted about it! 😅 It's quite a popular comic since it's indie days, but I wasn't as active a local comic book reader then so this was my first time to go through the story and be WOW-ed by its entirety.
The story follows Per of Esterpike as she presents herself as her late sister to meet with leaders and officials of their country and ask for aid and protection from the horde of enemies dead set on disrupting the peace.
It is wonderfully done and I appreciate including at least one reference to a historical and cultural thing that I recognized immediately. :) The plot is not very complex, but it isn't too simple either. It's in that sweet spot between excitedly knowing what ~might be coming next bec of familiar themes, and still compels me as a reader to not put the book down at any point.
There were time jumps and similarities of characters that kind of got me confused a little bit, but it didn't make it less interesting and entertaining. I did need to get over the intensity and action in one go first, and then reread for better comprehension, but that's on me. LOL.
And speaking of action, my gosh! I didn't really expect such intense war and battle scenes with the art style's seemingly fun, light and colorful delivery, but the fight scenes were done great! I also remember that this wasn't colored before this and mighty props to C.R. Chua bec I can imagine what a challenge that might've been. Well, the fact that it's rereleased in color and with such wide distribution now means they've pulled it off so well. • I highly recommend this to lovers of tales with knights, strong women and sisterhood. 4 of 5 stars. *I will also be getting a print version of this bec it'll look gorgeous in my shelves! • *I received this eARC from the publisher thru NetGalley for an honest review. Thank you!
The correct rating for A Sparrow's Roar would be more like 3.5 stars actually. I'm all for adventure comics where girls have to save the day and this was surely one of those. Per of Esterpike pranks her sister, who's the leader of Lions and a hero. The prank ends up in a barbarian horde destroying everything and Elena gets killed in the process and now the whole Esperpike land is in danger. Per has to pretend to be her sister and get aid to save the land, but there's treachery everywhere. Gladly she has help in the form of the second-in-command, Amelia. There's quite a lot of death in the comic, which actually works nicely. This is not a princess story, but a medieval knight story in a sense and still this isn't depressing, which was good. The plot is slightly hard to grasp at first and the sisters look almost the same, so it takes time to really get into the story. The parts of the amulet didn't really make all that much sense either.
The art looks slightly crude for my taste, since it makes it somewhat hard to follow the story too. I do like the colors and the facial expressions, which are the best part. The balance is off with the speech bubbles too at times, when they are too stuffed and the font isn't the best possible. Still, I do like a comic like this that has adventure in it and is still strong and even grave with its topic. A Sparrow's Roar is about growing up before you're ready and taking responsibility. It's about sisterhood, which is the greatest part, since comics with that at its center are quite scarce. Sadly so.
A story about a young warrior who has to step into her sister's big shoes, A Sparrow's Roar is simplistic, sweet and full of action. The story skips a bit back and forth (I was so glad to have read the synopsis first because the sisters' design is quite alike), but it tells of Per's older sister being invited to be one of the four Great Generals that govern the kingdom. When a prank of Per's leads to her sister being unprepared for an attack, she takes on her name and position to petition them to help her home, Esterpike, from being attacked again. While impersonating her larger-than-life sister is a bit challenging, the bigger difficulty comes in finding out the motives of one of the other Generals. By turns funny, and emotional, the story blends both drama and action into a fulfilling arc. I feel like Per's feelings could have been explored a bit more, as well as that of Amelia's (was she Elena's gf, too, I can't be sure but there were hints). The vibrant coloring and brilliant storyboard, complement the artwork style well, making it quite engaging to read. And hey, bonus - you get realistic girl warriors who are both buff and feminine!
Received an advance reader copy in exchange for a fair review from BOOM! Box, via Netgalley.
Per and his sister Elena, are opposed: the first's playful, impatient and especially bad with a weapon in hand, and the second's calm, respected and a war heroine, leader of the Lions. When Per goes to see his sister being murdered by a gang of barbarians, she will pretend to be her and try to protect her nation while avenging her sister.
This comic was a nice read, although it took me a while to get inside it. We slalom between plots and challenges, but some questions remain unanswered, which is a shame because it seems that this book hasn't a second book. The developed universe is interesting, but there are, as said above, elements that lack depth, while they have piqued my curiosity, and that I would have liked to develop.
I took a little time to dissociate the two sisters, who look alike like two drops of water and I, unfortunately, didn't particularly attach to the characters...
In short, a good read but with some minor flaws! ^^
Language: PG (6 swears, 0 “f”); Mature Content: G; Violence: PG13 Commander Elena is being recognized for her bravery and success by promotion to Great General, which will put her on the Council, but everything is thrown into chaos when they are attacked. With attacks seeming to come from every side, Elena’s sister, Per, finds herself playing a crucial role she never anticipated. I love the illustrations of Per’s story -- they are full of energy and dynamically show readers the actions and emotions of the events. Each panel feels alive. This short story is not lacking action nor intrigue, but I found that I did not enjoy those elements as much as I would have liked to because of the confusion I felt when first reading it. Clarity was an issue for much of the book as it switches between characters and time periods. I think Per’s story is a good one, but I found that the first half needs to be read twice for comprehension. Reviewed for https://kissthebook.blogspot.com/
Could be a really good duology - as it stands, this is too disjointed to get a feel for the characters or the world. There was a lot of jumping backwards and forwards in time - the times were labelled (i.e. 5 years ago) but it was weird trying to figure out the who, what and why - but if I look ahead 5 pages some of that will be explained! I also had a really hard time telling the difference between the characters, which is maybe kind of the point because nearly everyone is posing as someone else, but it should be clear to the reader so the story can be followed!
I think this story has potential - it needs to be expanded upon and re-edited for coherence. I do like who I think is the main character, as well as some of the side characters. I enjoyed the bits of this world's history and really (again) would like them to be expanded upon - I would love to see this as a duology where volume 1 is 'what happened' and vol 2 is 'what's happening now'.
I liked the concept of this story, but it took a little too much work to figure out.
When Per’s sister, the general Elena, dies in front of her, she takes her place so their enemies don’t find out. She ends up discovering secrets in the capital.
One thing that was confusing was that Per and Elena looked almost exactly the same. They had different coloured eyes but the same hair style. This was especially confusing when Per was impersonating Elena, so she was wearing Elena’s clothes. I also found that a lot of characters were putting on an act in front of others, so they weren’t saying what they meant. They said one thing but did something else, which made it difficult to understand the story.
Unfortunately this story didn’t work for me.
Thank you BOOM! Studios for providing a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Too scattered, underdeveloped, and kind of rushed. I had a hard time telling some of the key characters apart (are they all twins or not? cuz she acts like a much younger sibling but they look THE SAME), which made it hard to first of all figure out who died, and second of all tell what was going on and who did what in the flashbacks. The flashbacks themselves didn't help the story flow; it would have been easier to understand this very condensed and abbreviated-feeling story if told chronologically. In all the rush of cramming 2-3 volumes' worth of events into one fairly slim volume, I had no time to get to know any of the characters or catch much nuance in the worldbuilding or plot so, despite the sword fights and explosions, the story failed to keep my interest, and I caught myself skimming. Cannot recommend.
My only issue with "A Sparrow's Roar" is that it almost felt incomplete. The story is fun and I love the characters but I also want more. Based off my reading of it it feels like a one-shot and I just want a little more from it. Per and Elena have such a wonderful relationship and when you add in Amelia you really see what loyalty and leadership can look like. I"m always down for a strong female lead graphic novel and this one definitely delivers that. CR Chua's artwork add wonderfully to the narrative and really pulls the story they wrote with Paolo Chikiamco together. While there is sword violence, I would still feel fine with middle grade readers picking up the title. Hopefully we'll get some more from this team and see where Per's story takes her and more about the history of the medallion.
Giving this book a one star seems harsh, but I simply did not like this graphic novel. That's not to say it's bad, by any means. In fact, I think it had some great themes, and had characters and setting that a lot of people will really like... but it wasn't for me. I spent most of my reading experience really confused as to what was happening, and I'm beginning to realize that I am not a huge fan of constant sword-fighting or the kind of setting this book had.
Again, my rating reflects a ME problem, not at all a BOOK problem, so don't let my review deter you from reading this if you like graphic novels and the premise sounds intriguing!
Thank you Netgalley for providing me a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I must have seen this on some list of recommended GN, but it did not belong there.
There are a lot of characters and they mostly look the same. There is so much action that none of the characters take time to think. They are running all over the place and it's impossible to get to know them or care about them.
The illustrations were ok, aside from several different characters having doppelgangers. My library's copy was fairly new (actually, I just checked: it was brand new; mine was the first checkout) and the ink or glue had a foul odor, so I'm calling the publisher out on that one.
A Sparrows Roar is a fantastical and adventure-driven story. It's as well about family and courage.
Have you ever daydreamed of being a prince or a knight to defend your kingdom? Have you ever wanted to defeat evil and rescue those who you love? Between politics and good deeds, there's always time for that imagination to flare.
Wanting to be the best knight there is out there is a difficult task. One to take seriously and it's a responsibility. I think everyone should read to find out more if you're curious to become a knight. It can be fun!
Thanks to NetGalley for providing a copy in exchange for a review.
‘A Sparrow’s Roar’ by Cristina Rose Chua and Paolo Chikiamco is a graphic novel about taking sibling rivalry too far and a sister who has to make up for a mistake.
Two warring armies fighting over Esterpike, one army led by brothers, the other led by two women, with one, Per, impersonating her dead sister. Per must be the face of her city-state to negotiate for war support. While she is doing this, she uncovers a vile conspiracy.
I was lost for the first third of this story, as if there is a previous volume I was unaware of. The art is a fine manga style and the story eventually came together for me, but I’m nor sure many readers will stick with it.
First off, the art style of this graphic novel is so cute. I love the colors and the sometimes rough sketch aspect to panels.
Secondly, this graphic novel is short. I was able to finish it in what felt like no time at all and I enjoyed it. I liked the overwhelming presence of strong female characters and the story was both sad, but hopeful.
I will say that I felt a bit lost at the beginning because I couldn't tell what was current and what was past, but after I realized what was going on I fully enjoyed it.
I really liked this graphic novel! (I've been on a graphic novel kick and this one is so far my favorite!)
The story moves very fast but then it's a shorter graphic novel (I finished it in around an hour). Some things get lost in the fast pace, but I did feel that the story was well thought out and came to a satisfying conclusion. Of course, I'd love to read more in this world, including a more elaborate prequel, but it's enough for me to be entertained with this one novel.
A Sparrow's Roar gives us the story of a young warrior who, due to unfortunate circumstances has to fill in for her older sister. Per has to impersonate her sister and convince the Generals of the kingdom's city-states to help in the upcoming invasion. But what happens when during that quests, she realizes that the country is under a much larger threat?
A great tale filled with humor and bittersweet moments, A Sparrow's Roar is an ideal read for the fans of fiction and graphic novels.
An intriguing concept and world building, but needed much more breathing room, as the infodumps were distracting and distancing. I enjoyed the drawing style, which looked rather different, but had some difficulty distinguishing characters from one another. Had we had more time with our main cast and the world itself, I might’ve been more emotionally invested, which would have upped the tension in each new twist.
There are definitely some things to like here. The basic outline of the story is solid, and Per is a likable character. But the timeline gets muddled with in ways that make the story less clear, and something felt missing about the world building. There's also two sets of identical characters, with that identicalness being major plot points for both, and that's at least one set of identical characters too many.
A decent fantasy story with great art that is too short for its own good. As the lack of space (they basically fit a young adult fantasy novel into 4 issues) leads to a lot of rushing, which makes following the plot a bit difficult. I believe that it would have been better off being twice as long.
That said. It is still a fun fantasy story about political intrigue and a little sister needing to fit the shoes of her older sibling. The characters are fun and the world is interesting, with the art being quite beautiful.
Its just a shame that we don't have more pages to enjoy the characters, world, and art.
Thank you NetGalley for allowing me to read a digital copy of this book in exchange for a review. All opinions are my own.
I loved everything about this book! The characters, the world, the plot- it was all fantastic! The art style is lovely and totally makes me wish I could be a character in the book. Maybe I just need a fantasy adventure of my own...