Let me first say this: I am a huge Captain Marvel fan. Carol Danvers is my second favorite heroine in the Marvel Universe. I also knew what I was getting into when I picked up this book.
When your epitaph for your novel includes "and a misogynist's worse nightmare" you know that you are in for senseless political agenda pushing. A real shame really, as Ms. Sharpe shows that she does have a talent for intriguing characters and isn't that bad of a writer. Let me first state that I'm not done with the book yet. I'm a little over two-thirds of the way through, and I wanted to wait until finishing the book but I just can't keep mum about how certain elements in the book just grind my gears. First, I shall start off with the pros.
pros
- Rhi. I found Rhi to be a rather interesting character, if a little predictable and 2D at times. I don't blame Ms. Sharpe for this, but rather the box that Marvel put her in to write the novel. I feel that if Ms. Sharpe had amble room to fully develop Rhi, I would like her a whole lot more. Regardless, Rhi carries the novel and is the heart and soul of it.
- Carol. I have to say Ms. Sharpe really does understand character. As there are moments when Carol is not just the typical phallic female. Ms. Sharpe does offer a feminine side to Carol, one with emotional depth that hasn't been seen in her character since Brian Reed's run on Ms. Marvel back in the mid 2000s. It's a bit of a breath of fresh air.
- Carol and Rhi's bonding. I think Carol sees a lot of herself within Rhi. Carol's father was emotionally abusive (read Stohl's The Life of Captain Marvel to understand why), and Carol grew up in a time when women weren't expected to do anything that marry well and have children. And it's not like Carol doesn't want those things, she even admits that she wants to get married and have kids — but she has shit to do first. I think Rhi's situation, reminds Carol a lot of her own past and there is a strong sisterly bond between them. One of my favorite moments is when Carol tells Rhi about her older brother Stevie, and how a flood washed away his dog tags. Rhi "finds" the dog tags and returns them to Carol. It's a very touching moment and really shows Ms. Sharpe's ability to craft engaging characters.
cons
Oh boy where do I begin. There is so much in this book that just vexed me because it's all a bunch of feminist hogwash. Luckily, I wrote a list down of things that irked me as I read.
- Caricatures of men. Besides Scott Lang and Amadeaus Cho (and probably the other heroes), men are treated as grotesque caricatures of Zeus (to put it nicely). The bar scene in the beginning was a key moment. I've been to a bar. I got drunk at a bar. There were a lot of men at the bar. And yes, I was with friends (one man and one woman) and nobody came up to be lewd or anything. In fact, the bartender even gave me water after I had three drinks (cause I was clearly tipsy). The fact that the guy at the bar wasn't getting the girl's hints AND that the bar tender did nothing to stop it is inane. This is why bars have bouncers. So if a bartender sees a man coming on to a girl, despite her saying fuck off, he can single to the bouncer to make said creep leave. Men don't act like sexed crazed fiends. I was in the Navy, I was around Marines fresh from basic training. Yes, I got hit on a few times — I even lied and said I was married and the Marine replied the ring comes off when you're away — and it ended at that. 1. I didn't reply. 2. I walked away. 3. His friends lead him away. Are there predatory men? Absolutely, but to broadbrush all men as these chauvinistic pigs is unjustice.
- Aslen is a clear allagory for Trump. Not surprising considering this book was published in February 2019. While, I haven't gotten to his final showdown within the novel, and there isn't a clear discription of him. I would not be surprised if Aslen was an allagory for Trump. It's frankly idioitc. Aslen is a cookie cutter bad guy. He's doing bad because the plot I guess. There is no rhyme nor reason for his motives other than Hahahaha I Am the Big Bad and I Am Evil. It's contrite. I honestly, do not care if the heroes win because I know they are going to. Aslen doesn't pose any challenge or sense of dread. Even his Inhuman breeding program doesn't have the emotional impact the plot wants it to have, because Aslen isn't scary.
- Aslen not being scary leads me to my next point: over exaggeration of misogyny. I feel that the word misogyny has lost it's meaning. No longer was it a grave insult against a man, but now a term thrown around by prissy crybabies when you voice an opinion that is critical of ANY female lead. The book presents Earth — especially the United States — as being riddled with misogyny and that women skitter from street corner to street corner because *gasp* a half-drunk constructionworker catcalled her. O, the humanity. O, the tragedy. Goodnight. It's utter bullshit really. I've walked down city streets at night, with another woman, during a post night victory of some stupid football game. A bunch of people were drunk and we didn't even get glanced at. I've even walked down the streets of my own hometown at night after concerts and nothing uncooth happened to me. Hell, nothing uncooth happened to me in broad daylight either! Are there misogynists? Yes. But they are very, very rare these days.
- The world building is rather poor. The Damarians culture is built around Fire and the usage of fire. Which is kinda cool. Reminds me of the Fire Nation. But unlike the excellent worldbuilding in Avatar The Last Airbender, Ms. Sharpe fails to deliver anything interesting about the planet or its culture. I mean, their leader is called "president" (again, why I believe Aslen is an allagory for Trump). Why not call him "All Burning" or "All Fire". The leader of the Fire Nation was called the "Fire Lord" after and they even had snacks called "fire flakes" and according Aang they even had silly slang like "flamey-o". Where is that for Damara? Not there. It's a lifeless world. There is no culture. And the only culture present is this silly woman-hating schtick. I honestly can't think of any real world culture that treats women ... wait, yes I can. Islam. How Islam is practiced within certain countries of the Middle East (Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Sudan, Somalia), treat women with the same disregard as Damara. So, there, a real world culture.
- Carol apparently has a reluctance to work with men. And not just on this mission. I can get why she wouldn't want to bring someone like Tony Stark (who just treats everyone like shit, not just women). But Ms. Sharpe implies Carol hates working with men. Period. Which is totally idiotic as if anyone has read the comics they'll see that Carol has many team ups with men: Mar-Vell, Captain America, Spider-Man, Wonder Man, Iron Man. Carol never had a problem with men before or working with them. So this implication is frankly stupid and unnecessary.
- I can't remember where exactly, I came across this in the book, but they belittled female hobbies and that vexed me, because it implies that girls should only like "boy stuff". Which is stupid because girls can like girl stuff too. And by saying girls should only like boy stuff it... it's just wrong.
- Ah yes. You can't bring up misogyny without it's kissing-cousin homophobia. Which if you break down the word it means an irrational fear of homosexuals. And that my friends, is hilarious. Of course Damarians hate women and gays. Of course they want to "correct" the gays and make them not gay anymore — I'm surprised Ms. Sharpe hasn't mentioned conversation therapy or something similar happening on Damara. While yes, the LGBT community has had it rough, they are also much more accepted these days. For Mantis to say that the "present" isn't all that different from the past is complete and utter folly. The world has changed in the past 50 years, for the better. This victimhood mentality is so toxic and is crippling future generations. There is also no need to list "women and men and non-binary people". There are only two sexes: male and female. Now, there can be masculine women and feminine men, but there is no in-between. Intersex is an extremely rare condition (I think it's something like .1% of all live births are intersex). That line is just blatant pandering to the Twitter Mob (who don't even read the book or the comics and just want things to be done their way). That line alone dragged me right out of the story. Shall we list "lions and tigers and bears" (oh my) too?
In conclusion, while I haven't finished Liberation Run, it's shaping up to be a predictable read. With a weak plot and more political agenda pushing that you should honestly be forced to stomach. While there are some good character moments and when she doesn't let her politics (or the company's politics) get in the way, Ms. Sharpe can really deliver on emotional pay offs (see my note about Carol getting her brother's dog tags back). Alas, Ms. Sharpe spends too much time shouting about how every man is a misogynist and all straight men are gay-haters. Alas, I'm a masochist when it comes to characters I like, so I've been suffering through this novel since December.
Having finished it, I must say that the ending was tragically anticlimactic. There was no epic battle. No Carol zipping around Ansel and blasting him with her photon blasts. No sweet revenge. It felt hollow and unearned honestly. Tess Sharpe should've watched Stargate SG-1 S1E4. They did this entire plot better.
No, I would not recommend this to a friend or a fellow Carol fan. I should honestly give this book one star but two because the parts that do shine really do sparkle.