2020 ECPA Christian Book Award Finalist for Bible Resources. God's rottweiler or shepherd of the faithful?
There's no doubt about Benedict XVI's theological legacy. He's been at the center of every major theological controversy in the Catholic Church over the last fifty years. But he remains a polarizing figure, misunderstood by supporters and opponents alike.
A deeper understanding of Benedict's theology reveals a man dedicated to the life and faith of the church. In this collection of essays, prominent Protestant theologians examine and commend the work of the Pope Emeritus. Katherine Sonderegger, Kevin Vanhoozer, and Carl Trueman-among others-present a full picture of Benedict's theology, particularly his understanding of the relationship between faith and reason and his pursuit of truth for the church. The global Christian faith can learn from Benedict's insight into the modern church and his desire to safeguard the future of the church by leaning on the wisdom of the ancient church.
Tim Perry Ben Myers Katherine Sonderegger Gregg R. Allison Kevin J. Vanhoozer R. Lucas Stamps Christopher R. J. Holmes Fred Sanders Carl R. Trueman David Ney Peter J. Leithart Joey Royal Annette Brownlee Preston D. S. Parsons Jonathan Warren P. (Pagán)
Grundsätzlich ein guter Überblick über die theologischen Schwerpunkte Ratzingers.
Die Artikel variieren jedoch stark in ihrer Qualität. Während Vanhoozer und Trueman sich erkennbar auf das katholische Denken einlassen und Ratzinger im Kontext seiner Schriften und dem zweiten Vaticanum verstehen, beschreiben und bewerten, gleicht der Artikel von Holmes einer oberflächlichen, protestantischen Lesung von Ratzingers Werken. Was dazu führt, dass sich die Artikel stellenweise Widersprechen.
Wenn Holmes beispielsweise Ratzinger als „a kind of sola scriptura Catholic“ beschreibt, wird deutlich, dass er weder Ratzingers Schriftverständnis verstanden hat, noch die anderen Artikel berücksichtigt.
A collection of complimentary essays on Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI's theology as it pertains to Scripture, liturgy, ministry, witness, and other aspects of life in the Church. I became interested in theology during Benedict XVI's tenure as pope but aside from here-and-there articles, I've only read one book of his ("Christianity and the Crisis of Culture") so this read for me as a helpful introduction to the pope emeritus' thought which I would highly recommend. The contributors rarely critiqued Benedict though then again, this is a "Protestant appreciation" and the tone is warm and laudatory throughout and my own esteem for Benedict has grown through reading this book. The physical book itself is beautiful!
Matthew Levering ends "The Theology of Benedict XVI" with an afterword where he considers Benedict alongside the pope emeritus' friend, the liberal Catholic theologian Karl Rahner. Levering relates how many evangelical Protestants have responded with enthusiasm to Benedict's uncompromising theological orthodoxy on contested issues whereas little such ardor is expressed towards progressive Catholicism even though in some instances, progressive Catholicism might have affinities with evangelicalism. This is an interesting observation to make, though as a (fairly conservative) evangelical, I have been encouraged by some of the statements Pope Francis has made about permitting communion for the divorced and the potential for married priests. Perhaps we may one day see "The Theology of Pope Francis: A Protestant Appreciation?"
An enjoyable collection of essays. I did not know much about Benedict XVI before reading this, so it was nice getting to know this interesting figure through the lens of theologians I love and trust. Benedict XVI was most warmed to me, oddly enough, by Carl Trueman's article on Ratzinger's principled minimal ecumenism. Rather than striving for the "least common denominator" strategy of ecumenism so prevalent among Protestants and Roman Catholics post Vatican II, Trueman highlights Ratzinger's honest and realistic ecclesiology: it's not so simple as minimizing our differences, we disagree about what the Church is. That tells me Ratzinger is someone on the other side of the isle we can actually engage meaningfully. The differences between Protestants and Roman Catholics on major theological dogma has not decreased since the Reformation, but have increased.
The lineup for this collection of essays is also pretty outstanding. In addition to Trueman's essay, there are also some stellar contributions from the likes of Katherine Sonderegger, Gregg Allison, Kevin Vanhoozer, R. Lucas Stamps, Fred Sanders, Peter Leithart and more. It was a lively jaunt into Roman Catholic theology at its best. I was, however, unpersuaded by the end that extensive time in Ratzinger's works would be deeply enriching as a Protestant theologian. All the positive contributions he makes (i.e., the theological virtues, his fully functional Trinitarianism, his take on theological interpretation of Scripture) are encouraging to see from a former pope, but are points well-made by other Protestants who don't bring the baggage of Roman Catholic distortions of the gospel. Additionally, some of the essays seemed to be reaching pretty far to compliment, and to minimize the dogmatic differences (e.g., Mary, Eucharist).
Overall, I really enjoyed the book, but wasn't convinced by the end that getting more "Ratzinger" on my bookshelf is a pressing aspiration.
*I received a copy of this book from Lexham Press for an honest review.
This is a superb collection of essays, and a marvelous introduction to the theological contribution Benedict XVI has made, not only to the Catholic Church, but to all Christians. Clearly highlighted are Benedict's commitment to scriptural authority, the church's evangelical task, to the centrality of God's grace on offer in his son's death on the cross for the forgiveness of sinners, his ecumenical commitment to give expression to the Catholic faith in a way that removes many impediments to Protestant rapprochment, but at the same time affirming with clarity the Catholic understanding of the givenness of ecclesiological form as essential to the Gospel. I highly recommend this work.
This collection of essays is a helpful read for Protestants who have little understanding of the theologians in the Roman Catholic Church. The authors illustrate that despite being adamantly Roman Catholic, the Pope emeritus sought at times to be a man of the Scriptures. There seems to be a desire here for this work to demonstrate that Protestants and Catholics together, can lock hands in fight the culture war of secularism. An interesting read that is worth chewing on.