What do you think?
Rate this book
Maine Clambake Mystery #8
Sealed Off
Early October is “winding down” time in Busman’s Harbor, Maine, but there’s nothing relaxing about it for Julia Snowden. Between busloads of weekend leaf peepers at the Snowden Family Clambake and a gut renovation of the old mansion on Morrow Island, she’s keeping it all together with a potentially volatile skeleton crew—until one of them turns up dead under the firewood.
When the Russian demo team clearing out the mansion discovers a room that’s been sealed off for decades, Julia’s baffled as to its purpose and what secrets it might have held. Tensions are already simmering with the crew, but when one of the workers is found murdered, things come to a boil. With the discovery of another body—and a mysterious diary with Cyrillic text in the hidden room—the pressure’s on Julia to dig up a real killer fast. But she’ll have to sort through a pile of suspects, including ex-spouses, a spurned lover, and a recently released prisoner, to fish out one clammed-up killer.
When the Russian demo team clearing out the mansion discovers a room that’s been sealed off for decades, Julia’s baffled as to its purpose and what secrets it might have held. Tensions are already simmering with the crew, but when one of the workers is found murdered, things come to a boil. With the discovery of another body—and a mysterious diary with Cyrillic text in the hidden room—the pressure’s on Julia to dig up a real killer fast. But she’ll have to sort through a pile of suspects, including ex-spouses, a spurned lover, and a recently released prisoner, to fish out one clammed-up killer.
246 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published December 31, 2019
575 people are currently reading
2167 people want to read
About the author
Barbara Ross
39 books1,141 followersBarbara Ross is the author of twelve Maine Clambake Mystery novellas and six novellas. Her books have been nominated for multiple Agatha Awards for Best Contemporary Novel and have won the Maine Literary Award for Crime Fiction. Barbara and her husband live in Portland, Maine. Readers can visit her website at Maine Clambake Mysteries.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 237 reviews
November 13, 2021
Sealed Off is the 8th book in the Maine Clambake Mysteries written by Barbara Ross. I've read all the previous books in this series except for some of the shorter novellas, which are up next on my list. Once those are complete, I'll read the most recent full-length novel, and then I am fully caught up! It's been an exciting journey, and I'll be glad to finish all that have been written to date, but I will welcome the newest next year, too.
When Chris's brother is released from prison, Julia gives him a job. He begins fighting with another man who's interested in Emmy, possibly Terry's ex and mother of his child. Unfortunately, the other man ends up dead, and it looks like Terry is guilty. As Julia digs deep into the past, to understand why he went to prison in the first place, she discovers new leads, and a lot of drama between the couples working at her clambake. Meanwhile, her distant cousin comes back to Busman's Harbor to visit the house on Morrow Island she one stayed at when she was a child. During the renovations, a journal is found in a hidden room, and it ironically provides clues to the current murder.
I enjoyed this one a lot... probably 4.5 stars, and it made me miss Maine. I haven't been there in over 3 months, and I need to go back soon! Getting to know Julia's family more is always a treat, and understanding the past by reading diary entries is a fun way to explore history. The mystery was good, possibly a little too light and then a bit out of left field... still kept my interest and stands out from a lot of other series that get a bit tiresome. I always find myself eager to jump back into this one, and I'll be sad when I'm fully caught up. As is typical, the setting is brilliantly described, and I learned a lot about a different kind of life. Immersive. Reachable. Clever.
When Chris's brother is released from prison, Julia gives him a job. He begins fighting with another man who's interested in Emmy, possibly Terry's ex and mother of his child. Unfortunately, the other man ends up dead, and it looks like Terry is guilty. As Julia digs deep into the past, to understand why he went to prison in the first place, she discovers new leads, and a lot of drama between the couples working at her clambake. Meanwhile, her distant cousin comes back to Busman's Harbor to visit the house on Morrow Island she one stayed at when she was a child. During the renovations, a journal is found in a hidden room, and it ironically provides clues to the current murder.
I enjoyed this one a lot... probably 4.5 stars, and it made me miss Maine. I haven't been there in over 3 months, and I need to go back soon! Getting to know Julia's family more is always a treat, and understanding the past by reading diary entries is a fun way to explore history. The mystery was good, possibly a little too light and then a bit out of left field... still kept my interest and stands out from a lot of other series that get a bit tiresome. I always find myself eager to jump back into this one, and I'll be sad when I'm fully caught up. As is typical, the setting is brilliantly described, and I learned a lot about a different kind of life. Immersive. Reachable. Clever.
May 26, 2022
In this eighth book of Barbara Ross’s Maine Clambake series, Julia Snowden’s family is winding down the end of tourist season in Busman’s Harbor, Maine. They’re also dealing with some conflict among their employees—hard to avoid in a small town where everyone knows everyone, and you might have to work with your ex, who might now be dating the person you have to serve tables next to… ouch. Additionally, they are renovating the old mansion set on the island where they serve customers, and discover a hidden room in the mansion and a secret contained within. There were several mysteries to figure out in this novel—one set far in the past, one set a decade in the past involving Julia’s boyfriend’s brother, and one set in the present day involving a dead body that turns up. I always like the way that the mysteries in this series are very well crafted and teach me something about local Maine color. An excellent series.
November 28, 2019
The Snowden Family Clambake business is wrapping up the busy tourist season in Busman's Harbor, Maine. When an employee is murdered, everyone immediately suspects Julia's boyfriend's ex-con brother. He swears he is innocent and Julia agrees to help him clear his name. Meanwhile, renovations are starting in the family's Island home and a secret diary is discovered in a hidden room from 1898. It tells the sad story of a young woman and the Snowden family is determined to find out what really happened to her.
I really enjoyed this delightful installment in the Maine Clambake Mysteries. It is well-written with realistic characters, a lovely seaside town setting, and two intriguing mysteries. The murder mystery has enough twists, turns, and suspects to keep readers engaged throughout the entire story. The historical mystery is very enjoyable. I love genealogy so I was very invested in the mysterious secret room and wanted to find answers. Overall, I found the conclusion of both mysteries to be very satisfying. I have read a few books in this series and enjoyed every one of them. I will definitely be reading more by Barbara Ross.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I really enjoyed this delightful installment in the Maine Clambake Mysteries. It is well-written with realistic characters, a lovely seaside town setting, and two intriguing mysteries. The murder mystery has enough twists, turns, and suspects to keep readers engaged throughout the entire story. The historical mystery is very enjoyable. I love genealogy so I was very invested in the mysterious secret room and wanted to find answers. Overall, I found the conclusion of both mysteries to be very satisfying. I have read a few books in this series and enjoyed every one of them. I will definitely be reading more by Barbara Ross.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
November 14, 2019
It's mid-October and the end of the Snowden family's Clambake season, set in Busman's Harbor, Maine. A crew of workers have been hired to restore the family home on Morrow Island. One of the workers is killed and Julia's boyfriend's ex-con brother becomes the main suspect. During the renovations, they also find an enclosed room on her family's island where a mystery woman wrote a diary a hundred years ago, they wonder what became of her. Julia is determined to find out who killed Jason, even if she puts herself in danger once again.
I really enjoy this series but I admit, this installment was not one of my favorites. Neither plot was particularly compelling. I am wondering where the relationship between Julia and Chris is going or if they are just going to continue dating with no commitment. I'd like to see it take a more definite direction.
Thanks to NetGalley and Kensington for an ARC. My review is voluntary.
I really enjoy this series but I admit, this installment was not one of my favorites. Neither plot was particularly compelling. I am wondering where the relationship between Julia and Chris is going or if they are just going to continue dating with no commitment. I'd like to see it take a more definite direction.
Thanks to NetGalley and Kensington for an ARC. My review is voluntary.
December 24, 2019
The clambake that Julia Snowden and her family run on their family’s island is just running on weekends through Columbus Day. Unfortunately, tension among the staff seems to be reaching the boiling point. Romances among the staff have been causing issues all season, but Julia was hoping they could make it until the end of the season, and those issues would resolve themselves before the clambake starts up again in the spring. A fist fight as the guests and crew were leaving one days brings things to a head, and leaves Julia in the unfortunate position of firing her boyfriend’s brother. However, a dead body on the island the next morning only makes the situation worse.
There is a strong sub-plot, almost a second full mystery, in this book involving a room that has been sealed off since the 1890’s in the family mansion on the island. Between the two stories, this book moves forward at a constant pace, and the pages flew by. I never wanted to put the book down until I reached the satisfying end. Once again, I was left in awe of how the clues were woven into the story. Several series arcs were advanced here, and the chances for character development were put to full use. The new characters are just as strong as the series regulars, which is no surprise to anyone who has read the series. Those looking for recipes will be pleased with the five we get at the end of the story. There is not one wasted word in this story, and I set it down completely satisfied. Well, almost satisfied. As is always the case, I was left wanting to visit Julia and her family and friends again as soon as possible. Fans of the series will be delighted with this book. If you haven’t started this series yet, you need to fix that as soon as possible.
NOTE: I received an ARC of this book.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
There is a strong sub-plot, almost a second full mystery, in this book involving a room that has been sealed off since the 1890’s in the family mansion on the island. Between the two stories, this book moves forward at a constant pace, and the pages flew by. I never wanted to put the book down until I reached the satisfying end. Once again, I was left in awe of how the clues were woven into the story. Several series arcs were advanced here, and the chances for character development were put to full use. The new characters are just as strong as the series regulars, which is no surprise to anyone who has read the series. Those looking for recipes will be pleased with the five we get at the end of the story. There is not one wasted word in this story, and I set it down completely satisfied. Well, almost satisfied. As is always the case, I was left wanting to visit Julia and her family and friends again as soon as possible. Fans of the series will be delighted with this book. If you haven’t started this series yet, you need to fix that as soon as possible.
NOTE: I received an ARC of this book.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
January 2, 2021
Another terrific entry in one of my favorite series. I'm particularly impressed with the way author Barbara Ross ties together the three plot lines -- a murder on Morrow Island, where the Snowden family runs their clam bakes, the secrets of a closed-off room discovered in the historic mansion on the island, and the unanswered questions surrounding Chris's brother. Julia is once again strong and capable, loyal and determined, but Ross isn't afraid to show Julia's vulnerabilities as well. I've written about the tensions inherent in running a family business myself, and Ross plays them out nicely. One of my favorite reads of 2020.
January 25, 2020
Dollycas Thoughts
We are back in Busman’s Harbor, Maine in the final days of the clambake season. Julia is so excited because when the clambakes end the demolition of the inside of the island mansion, Windsholme, can really get going. Hopes are to get as much done as possible before the weather shuts work down. The really cool thing is a Morrow relative that spent summers in the mansion has come to take a final look. Marguerite remembers her time there as a child and wanted to see the place one more time before the renovations. While not necessary for Marguerite to approve their plans Julia and her mother feel that it would nice to have her blessing. A surprising discovery is made right before Marguerite’s visit that sends the family on a quest to get answers. Another find may answer some of their questions.
With Snowden Family Clambake working with a skeleton crew to finish out the year there is clear there is some tension between two members of the team. The tension escalates to a fistfight that is broken up only to find one of them dead the next day under the woodpile of the island. Later Julia finds another body. Why is all this happening on her family’s island? Could the deaths be related to the discovery in the mansion or is there something else going on?
______
I really loved this story. The historic part was fascinating and it comes with its own mystery. The family mansion has been vacant since 1929, so it was wonderful to hear an account of a family member from her little girl’s perspective. A discovery that has been Sealed Off in the mansion opens the door to another piece of history dating back to the late 1800s. I was completely captivated by this part of the book. The descriptions of the mansion are always very detailed, With each book in the series, the images in my mind become more vivid. I really am looking forward to reading more about the incredible renovation.
The current murders are a second mystery to solve. Julia has a vested interest because they took place on her family’s island and the prime suspect is not only her employee but the brother of her boyfriend Chris who has checkered past. It is a mystery full of red herrings. Julia found other suspects and works her way through the plethora of twists and turns. But by the end of the book, while the known mysteries are wrapped up, the author throws another one at readers leading to the next book.
Ms. Ross is a stellar storyteller. She has created characters that are easy to get invested in. The recurring characters continue to grow and the new characters get fleshed out quickly and have a true purpose to the story. Every time I open a book by Barbara Ross I know I am in for a real treat and that is just what Sealed Off was. Autumn in Busman’s Harbor was absolutely delightful. Leaf peepers and murder went together nicely but the history portions were my absolute favorite.
We are back in Busman’s Harbor, Maine in the final days of the clambake season. Julia is so excited because when the clambakes end the demolition of the inside of the island mansion, Windsholme, can really get going. Hopes are to get as much done as possible before the weather shuts work down. The really cool thing is a Morrow relative that spent summers in the mansion has come to take a final look. Marguerite remembers her time there as a child and wanted to see the place one more time before the renovations. While not necessary for Marguerite to approve their plans Julia and her mother feel that it would nice to have her blessing. A surprising discovery is made right before Marguerite’s visit that sends the family on a quest to get answers. Another find may answer some of their questions.
With Snowden Family Clambake working with a skeleton crew to finish out the year there is clear there is some tension between two members of the team. The tension escalates to a fistfight that is broken up only to find one of them dead the next day under the woodpile of the island. Later Julia finds another body. Why is all this happening on her family’s island? Could the deaths be related to the discovery in the mansion or is there something else going on?
______
I really loved this story. The historic part was fascinating and it comes with its own mystery. The family mansion has been vacant since 1929, so it was wonderful to hear an account of a family member from her little girl’s perspective. A discovery that has been Sealed Off in the mansion opens the door to another piece of history dating back to the late 1800s. I was completely captivated by this part of the book. The descriptions of the mansion are always very detailed, With each book in the series, the images in my mind become more vivid. I really am looking forward to reading more about the incredible renovation.
The current murders are a second mystery to solve. Julia has a vested interest because they took place on her family’s island and the prime suspect is not only her employee but the brother of her boyfriend Chris who has checkered past. It is a mystery full of red herrings. Julia found other suspects and works her way through the plethora of twists and turns. But by the end of the book, while the known mysteries are wrapped up, the author throws another one at readers leading to the next book.
Ms. Ross is a stellar storyteller. She has created characters that are easy to get invested in. The recurring characters continue to grow and the new characters get fleshed out quickly and have a true purpose to the story. Every time I open a book by Barbara Ross I know I am in for a real treat and that is just what Sealed Off was. Autumn in Busman’s Harbor was absolutely delightful. Leaf peepers and murder went together nicely but the history portions were my absolute favorite.
January 11, 2020
An excellent entry in one of my favorite cozy mystery series. It's neither silly nor scary, and the characters feel like real people with real problems. Busman's Harbor, Maine, is painted so clearly I feel as though I've visited many times.
January 25, 2020
Julia is busy working at the family’s clambake and doing a total redo of the mansion. The Russian crew working on it finds a room sealed off that no one knew about. They also find a journal, which no one sits down and read right away something I would do and it always bothers me in books how they put off reading old journals. A member of the crew is murdered and Julia has to find the killer fast, she also wants to solve the mystery of the sealed room.
June 18, 2023
Bel libro, con due diversi mistery. Uno è un cold case, per così dire, con un finale soddisfacente. L'altro è un omicidio contemporaneo e la soluzione non mi ha sorpreso più di tanto, sebbene all'inizio non sapessi dove andare a cercare il colpevole, poi ho iniziato a pensare che colui che sembrava il colpevole più probabile fosse in realtà qualcosa di diverso da come appariva (ci avevo visto giusto).
January 27, 2020
This is one of my favorite series — every time I finish a book in the series, I want to visit Maine. This is my favorite of the series so far. I didn’t figure out who the guilty party was until the end of the book. I also liked the mystery within the mystery involving Julia’s family and Morrow Island. I highly recommend the series and this book!
January 6, 2020
Sealed Off by Barbara Ross is the eighth A Maine Clambake Mystery. It can be read on its own for those who have just discovered this series. Julia Snowden has her hands full in Sealed Off between running the family business, getting ready for the opening of the winter restaurant she runs with Chris, the renovations at Windsholme, the murder of an employee, visiting relatives and the hidden room. Marguerite is an elderly relative who lived at Windsholme when she was a child and is visiting Busman’s Harbor with her granddaughter, Tallulah. She is arriving to take a last look at the house before the renovations begin. I like that she can describe what the once stately summer home looked like when it was at its prime. I enjoyed Marguerite’s readings of the diary. I admit that I found the story of the nanny more compelling than the modern day whodunit. I just loved the descriptions of the room’s furnishing and the beautiful clothing the governess left behind. I was a little disappointed with the outcome (but that is just me). Jason Caraway and Terry Durand bickering about Emmy Bailey was unprofessional and I was surprised that Julia let it go on as long as she did (I know it is fiction—but I thought it odd). No one has bothered to tell Emmy that her daughter could be Terry’s child and that Huntington’s runs in the family. I was happy that this particular storyline is put to bed by the end of the novel. The death of Jason Caraway along with what happened to the missing demo crew worker was not a head scratcher. There was a lack of suspects plus obvious clues that made this puzzle a snap to solve. There were some exciting suspenseful moments that I relished. I would like to see Julia and Chris’s relationship progress. They are happy, but I wonder what the future holds for them especially regarding children. Sealed Off is a good story, but it is not my favorite in the series. I am, though, looking forward to the next A Maine Clambake Mystery. This is a series that I enjoy reading with its charming town and engaging characters. Sealed Off has demolition drama, squabbling suitors, a recondite room, a discovered diary, and fine food.
January 2, 2020
Sealed Off by Barbara Ross is the 8th book in A Maine Clambake Mystery, and a great addition. Julia Snowden and her family are busy finishing up the Snowden Family Clambakes Company season, and starting to redo the families mansion. Worker's from Russia are doing the demolition on the place, when a hidden room is found. When a murder take place, the sleuthing begins. There are a lot of twists and turns in this book, which Julia is determined to solve. Ms. Ross's books just seem to get better and better. Reading about all the fresh seafood, makes me droll. I highly recommend this book and the whole series, you won't be disappointed.
I reviewed a digital arc provided by NetGalley and Kensington Publishing. Thank you.
I reviewed a digital arc provided by NetGalley and Kensington Publishing. Thank you.
November 8, 2019
The first mystery is a hidden room from 1898 sealed away with everything in it intact. The second is a murder. All of this happens on a small, family owned island with a severely damaged Victorian home and currently part of a tourist attraction. Lots of twists and red herrings complete with state cops, an old diary, odd behaviors by main characters, and other peculiarities. I loved it!
I requested and received a free ebook copy from Kensington Books via NetGalley. Thank you!
I requested and received a free ebook copy from Kensington Books via NetGalley. Thank you!
November 23, 2019
I received a copy of this book from Netgalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Another winner in the Barbara Ross Clambake mystery series!
This one involves a murdered rapscallion and a sealed off room in a renovated mansion!
Another winner in the Barbara Ross Clambake mystery series!
This one involves a murdered rapscallion and a sealed off room in a renovated mansion!
February 2, 2020
I fell in love with this series during book one so when I see a new one of course I have get my hands on it. This one is a fabulous addition. Julia is gearing up for the end of the season for the family clambake as well as a family visit. Windsholme is finally being worked on as well which adds some workmen into the mix. Things get interesting when two employees have a fight and one of them turns up dead on the island the very next day. Since her boyfriends brother is the one still alive from the fight Julia finds herself having to investigate but I bet she never would have predicted all the things she managed to undercover when it was all said and done. A fantastically written cozy mystery that you will be unable to put down once you pick it up. I totally loved it so I give it 5/5 stars.
January 7, 2020
It's close to the end of the season for Julia Snowden's family clambake, but tensions are rising between several of the employees, so much so that Julia isn't sure they will make it through the 6 final meals without a blowup. When two of them come to blows, that's only the precursor for finding one of them dead the next morning. Promising her boyfriend to find out the truth and hopefully exonerate his brother, she looks into the murder. Meanwhile during the renovations of the.manor house on the island, they discover a perfectly preserved hidden room....total sealed off. Among the items found was a diary of a young governess and discovering the truth about what happened to her at the turn of the century. Both stories are interesting and well played off of each other. I love this series and enjoyed this book, may even more that the last couple. Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read the book in exchange for an honest review.
January 2, 2020
It’s only a week until the end of the Maine clambaking season when a worker with the Snowden Family Clambake is found dead under a wood pile. Julia is running the clambake and also directing the renovation of the old family mansion, vacant since 1929, on Morrow Island. When the contractors find a hidden room complete with a diary from 1898, Julia decides to investigate both mysteries in Sealed Off.
The addition of a historic mystery in Sealed Off makes it a compelling read. Both mysteries are intriguing and well-written. There are plenty of suspects and red herrings to sort out. It also contains five recipes cooked by characters in the book for:
• Greek Style Lamb Chops Sous Vide (which means sealed off like the title)
• Halibut Pizzaiola
• Slow Cooker Cioppino
• Olga’s Brownies (which sound deliciously homemade)
• Ma’s Pot Roast
Sealed Off is the eighth book in the Maine Clambake Mystery series. However, it can be read as a standalone. It is recommended for the realistic characters, timeliness of its plot, and the well-researched historic topics. 4 stars!
Thanks to Kensington Books and NetGalley for a copy in exchange for my honest review.
The addition of a historic mystery in Sealed Off makes it a compelling read. Both mysteries are intriguing and well-written. There are plenty of suspects and red herrings to sort out. It also contains five recipes cooked by characters in the book for:
• Greek Style Lamb Chops Sous Vide (which means sealed off like the title)
• Halibut Pizzaiola
• Slow Cooker Cioppino
• Olga’s Brownies (which sound deliciously homemade)
• Ma’s Pot Roast
Sealed Off is the eighth book in the Maine Clambake Mystery series. However, it can be read as a standalone. It is recommended for the realistic characters, timeliness of its plot, and the well-researched historic topics. 4 stars!
Thanks to Kensington Books and NetGalley for a copy in exchange for my honest review.
July 13, 2020
This book was un-put-down-able, and once again Barbara Ross excels and exceeds herself, with another better than ever story happening at the Snowden Family Clambake. And again I could not even guess at solving the mystery - well, I DID try to guess, but boy was I wrong, and when the answer was finally revealed, I never saw it coming.
I also enjoyed that, as usual, there’s more than one story happening - it’s not just about the murder. An elderly relative who may hold a clue to a secret room, various employees who disappear, lobstermen who don’t do their work well but are suddenly rich, and more intriguing and delightful interactions with relatives, neighbours and townspeople.
And - Julia Snowden, the protagonist, and I share a trait. No, and although I am the type who likes to help solve people’s problems, I don’t get involved in murders!
It’s that Julia is forever pouring herself a cup of coffee - at her place, at Gus’s cafe, at her mom’s - and as a fellow coffee addict, whenever I read that I want to do the same!
This series is wonderful and while I recommend reading them all, each book does fine as a stand-alone too.
I also enjoyed that, as usual, there’s more than one story happening - it’s not just about the murder. An elderly relative who may hold a clue to a secret room, various employees who disappear, lobstermen who don’t do their work well but are suddenly rich, and more intriguing and delightful interactions with relatives, neighbours and townspeople.
And - Julia Snowden, the protagonist, and I share a trait. No, and although I am the type who likes to help solve people’s problems, I don’t get involved in murders!
It’s that Julia is forever pouring herself a cup of coffee - at her place, at Gus’s cafe, at her mom’s - and as a fellow coffee addict, whenever I read that I want to do the same!
This series is wonderful and while I recommend reading them all, each book does fine as a stand-alone too.
February 1, 2020
I always enjoy this series and I anticipate what Barbara Ross will come up with next. One of the things I really enjoy about this series is that there is a secondary mystery in the books beyond the murder that is being solved. This book is not exception. The season is winding down and as winter is approaching, Julia is hoping that the demolition of Winsholme will be finished in time. Julia is also dealing with the return of her boyfriend Chris's brother. He has been released from prison and she hires him to help out at the Snowden Family Clambake. When one of their employees ends up dead, they have to shut everything down as no one is allowed on the island. The secondary mystery involves a hidden room uncovered by the Russian demo crew. Finding the room intact with clothes, personal items and a journal, Julia and her mother, cousin and great aunt try to figure out why the room was closed up and what happened to the woman who had lived in it.
I love my visits to Busman Harbor, Maine. I enjoy this series with it's well-written story, great well-developed characters, beautiful setting and interesting mysteries. The murder mystery has several twists, and enough suspects to keep readers engaged. There are several red herrings that threw me off. I thought I had it all figured out, but was wrong on several accounts. There is a second murder that ties into the first and added another dimension to the story. The secondary, historical mystery was also enjoyable and intriguing. I love how this mystery is what gave the book it's title. I was very invested in the mysterious secret room and wanted to find answers. As things started to happen, and the demolition continued, Julia found another clue that finally threw open the doors to solve both murders. I found the conclusion of both mysteries to be very satisfying and interesting. I continue to enjoy this series and can hardly wait for my next trip back to Busman's Harbor.
I listened to the audiobook narrated by Dara Rosenberg. She is a wonderful narrator. Her voice fit Julia perfectly and her narration made the story come alive for me. I could easily distinguish between all the different characters including the male voices which were well done. I have listened to other audiobooks by Dara Rosenberg, and will listen to more by this talented voice actress. The publisher generously provided me with a copy of this book upon my request. The rating, ideas and opinions shared are my own.
I love my visits to Busman Harbor, Maine. I enjoy this series with it's well-written story, great well-developed characters, beautiful setting and interesting mysteries. The murder mystery has several twists, and enough suspects to keep readers engaged. There are several red herrings that threw me off. I thought I had it all figured out, but was wrong on several accounts. There is a second murder that ties into the first and added another dimension to the story. The secondary, historical mystery was also enjoyable and intriguing. I love how this mystery is what gave the book it's title. I was very invested in the mysterious secret room and wanted to find answers. As things started to happen, and the demolition continued, Julia found another clue that finally threw open the doors to solve both murders. I found the conclusion of both mysteries to be very satisfying and interesting. I continue to enjoy this series and can hardly wait for my next trip back to Busman's Harbor.
I listened to the audiobook narrated by Dara Rosenberg. She is a wonderful narrator. Her voice fit Julia perfectly and her narration made the story come alive for me. I could easily distinguish between all the different characters including the male voices which were well done. I have listened to other audiobooks by Dara Rosenberg, and will listen to more by this talented voice actress. The publisher generously provided me with a copy of this book upon my request. The rating, ideas and opinions shared are my own.
Read
February 15, 2020“Sealed Off“ is the 8th instalment in the lA Maine Clambake Mysteries” by Barbara Ross. It can be read as a stand alone but I do recommend reading from the beginning.
Early October is “winding down” time in Busman’s Harbor, Maine, but there’s nothing relaxing about it for Julia Snowden. Between busloads of weekend leaf peepers at the Snowden Family Clambake and a gut renovation of the old mansion on Morrow Island, she’s keeping it all together with a potentially volatile skeleton crew—until one of them turns up dead under the firewood.
When the Russian demo team clearing out the mansion discovers a room that’s been sealed off for decades, Julia’s baffled as to its purpose and what secrets it might have held. Tensions are already simmering with the crew, but when one of the workers is found murdered, things come to a boil. With the discovery of another body—and a mysterious diary with Cyrillic text in the hidden room—the pressure’s on Julia to dig up a real killer fast. But she’ll have to sort through a pile of suspects, including ex-spouses, a spurned lover, and a recently released prisoner, to fish out one clammed-up killer.
I really enjoyed this story, being the first one I have read in the series I didn’t know what to expect. I really liked the main characters of Julia, Chris and the rest of the Snowden family. The setting of Busman Harbor, Maine was enchanting and made me want to visit the coast of Maine even more than I did. The island with the big summer mansion intrigued me and the history, I like how there was 2 mysteries going on in the story the murder but also one from the past.
There were plenty of twists and turns throughout and I was kept guessing right till the end. I highly recommend this series and can’t wait to find out some answers in the next instalment. With that said I do own a few of the early books but I now plan on completing the set so I can binge read the first seven books.
I requested and received an Advanced Readers Copy from Kensington Books and NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Early October is “winding down” time in Busman’s Harbor, Maine, but there’s nothing relaxing about it for Julia Snowden. Between busloads of weekend leaf peepers at the Snowden Family Clambake and a gut renovation of the old mansion on Morrow Island, she’s keeping it all together with a potentially volatile skeleton crew—until one of them turns up dead under the firewood.
When the Russian demo team clearing out the mansion discovers a room that’s been sealed off for decades, Julia’s baffled as to its purpose and what secrets it might have held. Tensions are already simmering with the crew, but when one of the workers is found murdered, things come to a boil. With the discovery of another body—and a mysterious diary with Cyrillic text in the hidden room—the pressure’s on Julia to dig up a real killer fast. But she’ll have to sort through a pile of suspects, including ex-spouses, a spurned lover, and a recently released prisoner, to fish out one clammed-up killer.
I really enjoyed this story, being the first one I have read in the series I didn’t know what to expect. I really liked the main characters of Julia, Chris and the rest of the Snowden family. The setting of Busman Harbor, Maine was enchanting and made me want to visit the coast of Maine even more than I did. The island with the big summer mansion intrigued me and the history, I like how there was 2 mysteries going on in the story the murder but also one from the past.
There were plenty of twists and turns throughout and I was kept guessing right till the end. I highly recommend this series and can’t wait to find out some answers in the next instalment. With that said I do own a few of the early books but I now plan on completing the set so I can binge read the first seven books.
I requested and received an Advanced Readers Copy from Kensington Books and NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
January 7, 2020
Sealed Off is the eighth book in the A Maine Clambake Mystery series.
It’s early October in Busman’s Harbor and the end of the clambake season is about over for the Snowden Family Clambake business. When Julia Snowden goes to Morrow Island for that day’s clambake and soon finds out that Jason Caraway is missing from his fire pit duties. A search is begun and Julia finds him buried in a woodpile. Suspicion soon falls on Terry Durand, her boyfriend Chris’s, brother, who has recently been released from prison. Terry becomes the prime suspect based on his record and that he and Jason had recently been fighting. Julia and Chris set off to see if they can clear Terry’s name and soon find there is no shortage of other suspects.
In a subplot, a Russian demolition crew has begun on Windsholme, the family home on Morrow Island, to ready it for renovation in the coming Spring. Much to the family’s surprise, a hidden room is found. When Julia’s 96-year-old distant cousin, Marguerite, arrives for a visit, they hope she will be able to shed some light about the room. As Julia is looking through the mystery room she comes across a hidden journal. With the help of Marguerite, they believe that the journal belonged to the nanny, Lillian. The family hopes they will be able to learn where Lillian might have gone and why the room was sealed off.
I love this series and this another exciting and wonderful addition to the series. The book is well-written and plotted with a wonderful cast of believable characters.
Delicious sounding recipes are also included in the book.
I will be looking forward to the next book in this exciting series.
It’s early October in Busman’s Harbor and the end of the clambake season is about over for the Snowden Family Clambake business. When Julia Snowden goes to Morrow Island for that day’s clambake and soon finds out that Jason Caraway is missing from his fire pit duties. A search is begun and Julia finds him buried in a woodpile. Suspicion soon falls on Terry Durand, her boyfriend Chris’s, brother, who has recently been released from prison. Terry becomes the prime suspect based on his record and that he and Jason had recently been fighting. Julia and Chris set off to see if they can clear Terry’s name and soon find there is no shortage of other suspects.
In a subplot, a Russian demolition crew has begun on Windsholme, the family home on Morrow Island, to ready it for renovation in the coming Spring. Much to the family’s surprise, a hidden room is found. When Julia’s 96-year-old distant cousin, Marguerite, arrives for a visit, they hope she will be able to shed some light about the room. As Julia is looking through the mystery room she comes across a hidden journal. With the help of Marguerite, they believe that the journal belonged to the nanny, Lillian. The family hopes they will be able to learn where Lillian might have gone and why the room was sealed off.
I love this series and this another exciting and wonderful addition to the series. The book is well-written and plotted with a wonderful cast of believable characters.
Delicious sounding recipes are also included in the book.
I will be looking forward to the next book in this exciting series.
December 28, 2019
The Clambake season is coming to end
in Busman’s Harbor, Maine as it is
mid-October.
Restorations on the Morrow Island
family home will bring a surprise to
Julia Snowden and her family.
When Julia and her brother-in-law
arrive on Morrow Island to prepare
for the last clambake, the dead body
of one of the longtime employees is
found.
The brother of Julia’s boyfriend who
is an ex-con and who had a fist fight
with the deceased is an immediate
suspect. Julia plunges into the
investigation to prove his innocence.
Meanwhile the Morrow House reveals
a hidden sealed off room that surprised
everyone. The contents of the sealed off
room were that of a governess for the
child a hundred years ago. Why was the
room sealed off? What became of the
woman who resided in that room??
Come join the feisty Julie as she tackles
both the complex murder mystery and
the mystery of the hidden room and the
disappearance of the woman who stayed
there!!! Add in good food, the beautiful
seaside setting of Busman’s Harbor and
a group of colorful, vivid, well fleshed out
characters for an enjoyable, fast paced
read. Recipes included at the end of the
book
This is book # 8 in the Maine Clambake
Mysteries series. It can be read as a stand
alone.
The author weaves the past and present
together effortlessly making the reader
right at home on this scenic Maine adventure.
I volunteered to read Sealed Off. Thanks to
NetGallery and the publisher, Kensington
Books for the opportunity.
My opinion is voluntary and my own.
in Busman’s Harbor, Maine as it is
mid-October.
Restorations on the Morrow Island
family home will bring a surprise to
Julia Snowden and her family.
When Julia and her brother-in-law
arrive on Morrow Island to prepare
for the last clambake, the dead body
of one of the longtime employees is
found.
The brother of Julia’s boyfriend who
is an ex-con and who had a fist fight
with the deceased is an immediate
suspect. Julia plunges into the
investigation to prove his innocence.
Meanwhile the Morrow House reveals
a hidden sealed off room that surprised
everyone. The contents of the sealed off
room were that of a governess for the
child a hundred years ago. Why was the
room sealed off? What became of the
woman who resided in that room??
Come join the feisty Julie as she tackles
both the complex murder mystery and
the mystery of the hidden room and the
disappearance of the woman who stayed
there!!! Add in good food, the beautiful
seaside setting of Busman’s Harbor and
a group of colorful, vivid, well fleshed out
characters for an enjoyable, fast paced
read. Recipes included at the end of the
book
This is book # 8 in the Maine Clambake
Mysteries series. It can be read as a stand
alone.
The author weaves the past and present
together effortlessly making the reader
right at home on this scenic Maine adventure.
I volunteered to read Sealed Off. Thanks to
NetGallery and the publisher, Kensington
Books for the opportunity.
My opinion is voluntary and my own.
January 9, 2020
Another excellent Julia Snowden mystery!
I always look forward to a new addition to the Maine Clambake Mystery series, and book 9 does not disappoint. There is a nifty little side mystery from the past, as well as the main story involving the murder of one of Julia's clambake employees. I read it through last night when I should have been sleeping because I just did not want to stop reading. Excellent, strong characterization.
Can't wait for the next one!
I always look forward to a new addition to the Maine Clambake Mystery series, and book 9 does not disappoint. There is a nifty little side mystery from the past, as well as the main story involving the murder of one of Julia's clambake employees. I read it through last night when I should have been sleeping because I just did not want to stop reading. Excellent, strong characterization.
Can't wait for the next one!
January 23, 2020
This book in the series involves a mystery from the late 1800's and a current one too. More is developed about Julia's family and Chris's too. I enjoyed both mysteries. These books always make me want to visit Maine and go to a clambake. I highly recommend this book.
December 4, 2019
SEALED OFF, the eighth book in the Maine Clambake Mystery series by Barbara Ross, is another entertaining installment in an enduring series. It’s been a treat watching the protagonist, Julia Snowden, develop as a well-rounded character from the beginning of the series. She’s smart, she’s determined, and she has a kind heart to help those in need around her. Julia’s family’s clambake is wrapping up the season on their private island and ramping up the remodel on the decrepit family historical mansion. One of their longtime employees is found murdered on the island when Julia and her brother-in-law arrive to prepare for one of the last clambakes of the season. Despite how a lot of people feel about her boyfriend’s ex-con brother and despite his physical fight with the victim, Julia agrees to find the truth and see justice done. I admire Julia’s loyalty to her boyfriend, Chris, and by extension, to his down-on-his-luck, brother. I also enjoy the close relationship the protagonist has with her family and the closeness they share by working together and socializing together frequently. It adds a heartwarming thread throughout the story.
In addition to the murder mystery, Ms. Ross consistently adds a non-fiction thread through each story and I’ll admit, I always find them intriguing. It’s obvious she invests a lot of time researching so that the end result is believable and fits seamlessly into the tale. (Be sure to read the acknowledgements notating her research. This one is quite charming!) She also touches on social issues in this story that can’t help but make the reader give pause to think about the larger picture. Again Ms. Ross weaves these portions into the story without slowing down the plot which keeps the reader’s interest in turning the pages until the very suspenseful ending.
Julia’s family is known for delicious food served at their clambake along with the food served at their family gatherings. It’s not uncommon for friends to join their gatherings and bring scrumptious dishes to share. The author kindly provides several recipes at the back of the book for the reader to drool over.
I was provided an advance copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
In addition to the murder mystery, Ms. Ross consistently adds a non-fiction thread through each story and I’ll admit, I always find them intriguing. It’s obvious she invests a lot of time researching so that the end result is believable and fits seamlessly into the tale. (Be sure to read the acknowledgements notating her research. This one is quite charming!) She also touches on social issues in this story that can’t help but make the reader give pause to think about the larger picture. Again Ms. Ross weaves these portions into the story without slowing down the plot which keeps the reader’s interest in turning the pages until the very suspenseful ending.
Julia’s family is known for delicious food served at their clambake along with the food served at their family gatherings. It’s not uncommon for friends to join their gatherings and bring scrumptious dishes to share. The author kindly provides several recipes at the back of the book for the reader to drool over.
I was provided an advance copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
March 3, 2020
Sealed Off earns 5/5 Clambake Mysteries...Entertaining Fun!
Another Maine Clambake Mystery delight from Barbara Ross! It’s been a couple of year’s since Julia Snowden returned home to Busman’s Harbor to help run the family’s authentic clambake business, and butting heads with her brother-in-law never seems to let up. Currently it’s due to an employee “quadrangle” that interferes with the business operations. Jason is flirting with Emmy, Jason’s ex Prudence is not happy, then Terry, Julia’s boyfriend’s brother, seems to have a stake in the situation. Sonny wants Terry gone immediately, but Julia refuses to fire Terry suggesting instead they ride out the next two weeks when season ends for winter. Waiting, however, ends up murderous when Jason is found dead, and Terry, recently released from prison, is the prime suspect. Then if one (two) high-crimes isn’t enough, during renovations of the old Windsholme mansion a previously unknown “sealed” room is uncovered along with an intriguing diary from 1898 providing more angst than delight.
Brilliant! Barbara Ross’s eighth book is filled with mystery, mystery, and more mystery. Using a first-person narrative from Julia’s perspective gave me a vicarious role in the drama. Her vivid descriptions paint the beautiful northeast island setting along with characters’ looks and mannerisms; she also helps set tone and emotions, a bit of humor, and illustrate personalities with expressive dialogue. The mysteries and the family dramas are complicated keeping me engaged, guessing, and quickly turning the page for solutions. A pet peeve of mine is the expectation of realism, so I was pleased with character reactions, responses, and the role of law enforcement...I like that. There were dramas carried over from previous books, but it didn’t take long to catch up and enjoy the story. “Recipes Included” always gets me excited, and these easy-to-follow recipes are truly delicious, although chops and pot roast at a clambake? Enjoy Greek Style Lamb Chops Sous Vide, Halibut Pizzaiola, Slow Cooker Cioppino, Olga’s Brownies, and Ma’s Pot Roast. I love this series, and am eager to read more!
Disclosure: I received an ARC from Kensington thru NetGalley. My review is voluntary with honest insights and comments.
Another Maine Clambake Mystery delight from Barbara Ross! It’s been a couple of year’s since Julia Snowden returned home to Busman’s Harbor to help run the family’s authentic clambake business, and butting heads with her brother-in-law never seems to let up. Currently it’s due to an employee “quadrangle” that interferes with the business operations. Jason is flirting with Emmy, Jason’s ex Prudence is not happy, then Terry, Julia’s boyfriend’s brother, seems to have a stake in the situation. Sonny wants Terry gone immediately, but Julia refuses to fire Terry suggesting instead they ride out the next two weeks when season ends for winter. Waiting, however, ends up murderous when Jason is found dead, and Terry, recently released from prison, is the prime suspect. Then if one (two) high-crimes isn’t enough, during renovations of the old Windsholme mansion a previously unknown “sealed” room is uncovered along with an intriguing diary from 1898 providing more angst than delight.
Brilliant! Barbara Ross’s eighth book is filled with mystery, mystery, and more mystery. Using a first-person narrative from Julia’s perspective gave me a vicarious role in the drama. Her vivid descriptions paint the beautiful northeast island setting along with characters’ looks and mannerisms; she also helps set tone and emotions, a bit of humor, and illustrate personalities with expressive dialogue. The mysteries and the family dramas are complicated keeping me engaged, guessing, and quickly turning the page for solutions. A pet peeve of mine is the expectation of realism, so I was pleased with character reactions, responses, and the role of law enforcement...I like that. There were dramas carried over from previous books, but it didn’t take long to catch up and enjoy the story. “Recipes Included” always gets me excited, and these easy-to-follow recipes are truly delicious, although chops and pot roast at a clambake? Enjoy Greek Style Lamb Chops Sous Vide, Halibut Pizzaiola, Slow Cooker Cioppino, Olga’s Brownies, and Ma’s Pot Roast. I love this series, and am eager to read more!
Disclosure: I received an ARC from Kensington thru NetGalley. My review is voluntary with honest insights and comments.
October 14, 2020
I love this series. I love the setting and the characters and the way it is written. Every time I pick up a book in this series, I never want to put it down. (Darn it, being a responsible adult gets in the way of that.)
What I liked about Sealed Off:
A double mystery - In addition to the rambling list in my brief opening, there is always a mystery to be solved (I mean, *obviously*, given the genre, right?). This one had two and they never competed for your attention or your brain space. They were each presented in their own way and followed their own path. I was kept guessing about both, and though I had some suspicion about one mystery (I was wrong), I hadn't a clue what to make of the other, but they both resolved in a satisfying manner.
Character growth - I have established that I love the characters in this series. I also thoroughly enjoy the way they are developed. For being "just" a cozy mystery series, these characters have so much depth. (I have found that many in this genre are goofy and caricature-like. That is *not* the case with the Maine Clambake Mysteries.) And it isn't only the characters but their relationships with one another. I have read many books one might, as a reader, expect to have more substance than a "mere cozy mystery" and have fallen far short of the characters Ms Ross has gifted us in this series.
A visit with some favorite peripheral characters - Marguerite and Tallulah!! Oh, I enjoyed exploring Windsholme with them.
What I didn't care for:
As per usual, my complaint column is virtually bare. A couple of minor editing issues in the edition I read, but beyond that, I cannot think of a single issue I had with this book.
I have just one holiday novella left until I am current in this series and will have to wait for more time in Busman's Harbor. I could weep just at the thought!
What I liked about Sealed Off:
A double mystery - In addition to the rambling list in my brief opening, there is always a mystery to be solved (I mean, *obviously*, given the genre, right?). This one had two and they never competed for your attention or your brain space. They were each presented in their own way and followed their own path. I was kept guessing about both, and though I had some suspicion about one mystery (I was wrong), I hadn't a clue what to make of the other, but they both resolved in a satisfying manner.
Character growth - I have established that I love the characters in this series. I also thoroughly enjoy the way they are developed. For being "just" a cozy mystery series, these characters have so much depth. (I have found that many in this genre are goofy and caricature-like. That is *not* the case with the Maine Clambake Mysteries.) And it isn't only the characters but their relationships with one another. I have read many books one might, as a reader, expect to have more substance than a "mere cozy mystery" and have fallen far short of the characters Ms Ross has gifted us in this series.
A visit with some favorite peripheral characters - Marguerite and Tallulah!! Oh, I enjoyed exploring Windsholme with them.
What I didn't care for:
As per usual, my complaint column is virtually bare. A couple of minor editing issues in the edition I read, but beyond that, I cannot think of a single issue I had with this book.
I have just one holiday novella left until I am current in this series and will have to wait for more time in Busman's Harbor. I could weep just at the thought!
December 18, 2019
Sealed Off is the eighth book in Barbara Ross’ Maine Clambake Mystery series. There is sufficient background information provided to allow this book to be read as a standalone. This is a well-plotted murder mystery with a great cast of characters. The story moves at a steady pace, with two mysteries to keep the reader engaged.
Julia Snowden and her boyfriend, Chris Durand, live in Busman’s Harbor, Maine. During the off-season, they operate their fine dining restaurant and bar. During the summer months, Julia helps with her family’s business, the Snowden Family Clambake, which provides boat tours and authentic clambakes on Morrow Island, their private island. The season is winding down, and there will only be a handful of clambakes before winter sets in and Julie and Chris re-open their restaurant for the winter months. Between the clambakes, a Russian demolition crew working on Windsholme to prepare it for renovation in the spring, disagreements between a few employees, and a visit from her mother’s ninety-six-year-old distant cousin, Marguerite Morales, who grew up in Windsholme, Julie has her hands full. The last thing Julie needs is to find the body of Jason Caraway, a longtime member of the fire pit crew, and a sealed-off room along with a journal that was written by Lilly Smythe, a governess, in 1898 that contained some disturbing entries. When Chris’ brother, Terry Durand, who was recently released from prison, becomes the prime suspect, Chris asks Julie to look into matters and prove his innocence.
I received an Advance Reader Copy of this book from NetGalley and voluntarily reviewed it.
Julia Snowden and her boyfriend, Chris Durand, live in Busman’s Harbor, Maine. During the off-season, they operate their fine dining restaurant and bar. During the summer months, Julia helps with her family’s business, the Snowden Family Clambake, which provides boat tours and authentic clambakes on Morrow Island, their private island. The season is winding down, and there will only be a handful of clambakes before winter sets in and Julie and Chris re-open their restaurant for the winter months. Between the clambakes, a Russian demolition crew working on Windsholme to prepare it for renovation in the spring, disagreements between a few employees, and a visit from her mother’s ninety-six-year-old distant cousin, Marguerite Morales, who grew up in Windsholme, Julie has her hands full. The last thing Julie needs is to find the body of Jason Caraway, a longtime member of the fire pit crew, and a sealed-off room along with a journal that was written by Lilly Smythe, a governess, in 1898 that contained some disturbing entries. When Chris’ brother, Terry Durand, who was recently released from prison, becomes the prime suspect, Chris asks Julie to look into matters and prove his innocence.
I received an Advance Reader Copy of this book from NetGalley and voluntarily reviewed it.
February 5, 2020
I will admit I'm some what biased when it comes to this series because I have visited Boothbay Harbor (the town this is based on) countless times and love it. I'm inclined to love a book that has so many places that I can identify, even if the names have changed--Squirrel Island has become Chipmunk Island.
That being said, I enjoy the series for other reasons as well. The characters are down-to-earth and realistic. Relationships continue to evolve (and sometimes devolve) and a love of family is at the heart of this series. It is fun to see how things change from book to book. Ross often uses plots that are very relevant to the place and time of a tourist dependent Maine coast town instead of generic plot that can and has be used in any number cozy series where the only change is the trappings of location.
Another murder on the Snowden family island drives the mystery plot in this book. There are plenty of possible suspects and red herrings to keep it interesting. While I guessed the culprit before the end I hadn't figured out all the twists and turns of why and how.
I loved the diary extracts of the governess on the island when it was being used as a summer residence for Snowden family in the late 1890s. It gives some details about the glamorous summer residences of the rich families during their heyday that dot the Maine coast. It also shows that things weren't always as rosy as one imagines in those "romantic" times. But it was nice to find out what happened to the governess at the end of the book.
I look forward to visiting Busman's Harbor in the next book.
That being said, I enjoy the series for other reasons as well. The characters are down-to-earth and realistic. Relationships continue to evolve (and sometimes devolve) and a love of family is at the heart of this series. It is fun to see how things change from book to book. Ross often uses plots that are very relevant to the place and time of a tourist dependent Maine coast town instead of generic plot that can and has be used in any number cozy series where the only change is the trappings of location.
Another murder on the Snowden family island drives the mystery plot in this book. There are plenty of possible suspects and red herrings to keep it interesting. While I guessed the culprit before the end I hadn't figured out all the twists and turns of why and how.
I loved the diary extracts of the governess on the island when it was being used as a summer residence for Snowden family in the late 1890s. It gives some details about the glamorous summer residences of the rich families during their heyday that dot the Maine coast. It also shows that things weren't always as rosy as one imagines in those "romantic" times. But it was nice to find out what happened to the governess at the end of the book.
I look forward to visiting Busman's Harbor in the next book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 237 reviews