Sword Art Online volume 17- Alicization Awakening
Gotta say that I have mixed feelings about this one. There are several reasons for this but I’ll only list the main one here, plus a single secondary one. There are more but this review was already taking too long.
I think the author has too many balls in the air this time. Too many plotlines with too many characters in too many places: it’s not confusing, it’s annoying. I can keep track of it all just fine, but the pacing is far too slow. Each plotline moves at a rate of one event per appearance, and much of that appearance is about re-establishing what is going on and has been going since the previous appearance. Any one of these would have been great to focus on:
* Gabriel as Vecta abducting Alice and being pursued by Bercouli.
* Leafa as Terraria befriending, Lilpillin the leader of the orcs who, as a result, possibly becomes the first darkworlder to break the Seal of the Right Eye.
*Asuna’s struggle against the legions of mass-produced players brought in by Critter.
*The budding battlefield romance of Sheyta and Ishkahn.
*The continuing effort to restore Kazuto’s fluctlight.
*Sinon’s re-match against Subtilizer (and the implications of him being the same as Vecta and Gabriel)
*The viewpoints of converted accounts and mass-produced accounts encountering the reality of the Underworld.
Look at all that. I’m not even sure I listed all of them. Over 200 pages for all of that. On their own, they are all interesting, well-written, and deserving of further exploration. Stuffing them all together like this, they feel rushed, underdeveloped and a waste of potential. It’s gets boring, at times. Though, I am glad that I read it.
The anime doesn’t cover everything, because there is a lot. One of the most interesting of the above, in my opinion, is this short interlude of a random Alfheim online player, who converts to Underworld in a state of apathy, is overwhelmed by the intensity of the combat, but finds new resolve after a brief conversation with this Underworld girl who gives him battlefield healing. It’s a classic Call to Adventure. I wanted to see more of this kid, and how this experienced impacted him.
Also,
Sinon as Solus is basically wasted potential. I know hindsight is 20/20, and the decisions made by her and her allies make sense at the time they are made, but still, it rankles. If Sinon had gone literally anywhere else, she would have made a bigger impact on the plot, and didn’t really buy any time for Alice, since she was going to the same place that Vecta wanted to take her too. And what’s up with the Subtilizer account being able to generate some flying creature immediately after conversion? I was hoping the light novel would have some kind of explanation for that.
Trickster Eric Novels gives Sword Art Online volume 17- Alicization Awakening a B