Sawa Mitoma has officially lived every high school girl's dream by breathing in limited-edition Sohma cottage air and landing a date with a Sohma heartthrob. That is, until she's thrust face-to-face with a disturbing truth...
...that threatens to revert her back to her past self. The last thing she wants is for the Sohmas to get involved, but it turns out there's more to the truth than she remembers... Don't miss the grand finale of Fruits Basket Another!
Natsuki Takaya (高屋奈月, real name Naka Hatake) is the penname of a Japanese manga artist best-known for creating the series Fruits Basket. She was born on July 7, 1973; (Tanabata). Takaya is left-handed and once revealed that she wanted to be a mangaka since first grade, when her sister started drawing.
She was born in Shizuoka, Japan, but was raised in Tokyo, where she made her debut in 1992. She enjoys video games such as the Final Fantasy series or Sakura Wars, or working on her different manga series, such as Fruits Basket, which is the second best-selling shōjo manga ever in Japan, and the top selling shōjo manga in North America. Fruits Basket has also been adapted into a twenty-six-episode anime series.
In 2001, Takaya received a Kodansha Manga Award for shōjo manga for Fruits Basket.
According to Takaya (in a sidebar of a Fruits Basket manga volume), she enjoys drawing girls (girly ones) more than she does boys. Takaya also enjoys electronics and music, but dislikes talking about herself. Also revealed in a sidebar of Fruits Basket, Takaya broke her drawing arm (left) after Fruits Basket volume six was published. She had to go into surgery, and as a result, had put Fruits Basket on a brief hiatus. Takaya made a full recovery, but complains that her handwriting had gotten uglier, due to the surgery. During her hospital stay, she gained an interest in baseball.
It kind of hurts to write this, until I remember that by the end of Furuba the series as a whole is more of a three star for me after it being so very good in the first half. I didn't have the same expectations of Furubana. My reviews for vols 1 and 2 show how...conflicted I feel over this sequel series set two decades (or so) after Furuba featuring the children of our original Sohmas.
Mitoma as is an uncharismatic main character to follow; she spends half the series as anxious as Ritsu. Constantly apologizing, constantly holding her tongue. Not the same way Tohru would, Mitoma was much more of a "I don't deserve to exist" sort of way. We learn this is largely her mother's fault and for a time Mitoma seems to come out of her shell, especially in regards to Shiki (Shigure and Akito's child who bears a lot of abuse from his grandmother and the older resentful Sohmas in general).
I think maybe because Takaya didn't mean for this to go on as long as it did, she didn't pace revelations vs. nostalgia story bites very well. The issues Mitoma faces in volume 3 would have been better served starting in volume 2 as this.volume's plot is bookended by a carefree opening at the Sohma beach house and a largrly carefree ending at a school festival. The issues Mitoma had to live with weren't truly resolved - merely having people in your life telling you that you can overcome something while dealing with that abuse isn't a resolution. Mitoma didn't come to a plan beyond "wait it out". It cheapened the fact she was urging Shiki out of his shell in a gentle way.
Plus I'll be honest I cared way more for the fact Shigure apparently still was THE WORST and somehow Hatori's daughter Kinu wound up being Ayame's daughter Hibiki's keeper (much like Hari was to Ayame).
Sadly the old crew doesn't make any real appearances so :shrug: in the end a mildly interesting if unfocused sequel.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
2.5⭐️ I’m interested in these characters but it’s as if there’s no real story line? We get introduced to them and get hints as to who their parents are and then it stops there. I wish we got more because I feel like the next generation has so much potential! I will say we got a little more here, but again it was a carbon copy of the original and SUPER random? It felt like it didn’t make sense/have real meaning. It’s just kinda bland and I’m disappointed
This is the third and final volume of Fruits Basket Another, and it is by far the best. I finally get to give it a full four stars! The story truly comes into it’s own here. We finally get an explanation for everything that’s confusing about the first two volumes. And yes, it’s just as heartbreaking as you would expect from Takaya. And yes, I did cry. Shiki, Shigure and Akito’s son, gets a lot of character development, and I loved his relationship with Sawa. Oh, and I reiterate that Sawa’s mother is awful. She makes Yuki and Ayame’s mom look warm and fuzzy. Honestly, I think she’s about on par with Ren Sohma, so you know it’s bad.
I think the most interesting thing about this series for me is how it looks at generational trauma. Even though this is the next generation, the consequences of the Zodiac curse still affect them. It doesn’t stop just because the curse is broken; there are years worth of trauma, hurt, and hate that keep existing. And even though our original cast has clearly grown into loving parents, it’s inevitable that some of this will reach the kids. Shiki takes a lot of abuse from his grandmother and some of the older Sohmas because of his mother’s actions. The knowledge of the past weighs heavy on Hajime and Mutsuki. But we also get to see the trauma slowly healing. I just think it’s really beautiful. (And yes, I’m crying as I write this review. Leave me alone. I have a lot of feelings.)
The biggest problem is that the series ends here. As I said, this is the volume where it finally becomes it’s own story. It stops feeling like a watered down rehash of the original series and develops it’s own storyline. And then it’s over. I wish the first two volumes had spent less time on the fanservice stuff so we could see more of these characters’ story.
Overall, Fruits Basket Another doesn’t match the original series in brilliance. It was never going to. And that’s okay. It’s still a fun and emotional ride, and I’m looking forward to the one-shots about these characters Takaya is planning.
I think another reviewer said it best: This sequel series lacks all of the charm that I loved about the original series and really doubles down on the flaws.
Volume 1 was rough. So many characters were introduced in rapid succession and two volumes later I still haven’t figured out who any of the Sohmas are. They just blur together. But I wanted to give the series a chance to get better. And it hasn’t. Mitoma is a really painful main character and I’m sad this is turning out to be a straight slice-of-life manga instead of the quirky fantasy slice-of-life I enjoyed before.
Bye, kids! I’m going back to Fruits Basket where my heart is.
Sigh, before staring this series I knew it would be nothing like the original but I didn’t think it would be this bland. One of the things that I think made Furuba special is the comedy that somehow fits in with the rly deep sad parts. Furubana had none of that, it didn’t even have a plot. I honestly don’t know what the author was going for, she made it so someone who hasn’t read Furuba will still be able to enjoy it but I think they would just very confused. Anyways I still loved seeing the characters from furuba’s kids even though their personalities are kinda repeat I love them! Especially Momoji’s child!
I can't believe that I have reached the end of Fruits Basket Another. As always I loved this volume. I want/need more Fruits Basket related content. I still need to watch the anime and hope to do so soon.
⭐️⭐️⭐️3.5 "Fruits Basket Another Volume 3" takes readers on an emotional rollercoaster, offering a bittersweet yet heartwarming continuation of Natsuki Takaya's beloved "Fruits Basket" universe. While I enjoyed the characters and the sense of found family, the ending left me with mixed feelings.
One of the strongest aspects of this manga series is the depth and complexity of its characters. Takaya skillfully breathes life into each one, and in this volume, we see them continue to grow and evolve. The protagonists, Sawa and the Sohma family members, face their own internal struggles and past traumas, making them feel authentic and relatable. Their journey towards healing and self-acceptance is both touching and beautifully depicted.
The theme of found family is a cornerstone of "Fruits Basket Another," and it shines brightly in this volume. The bonds between the Sohma clan and their friends, new and old, deepen as they support and care for each other. It's heartening to witness these connections forming and strengthening throughout the story. Takaya's exploration of these relationships is a testament to the enduring power of love and friendship.
However, my main qualm with this volume is the ending. While I appreciate the emotional complexity and the ambiguity that Takaya often incorporates into her narratives, the conclusion of "Fruits Basket Another Volume 3" left me feeling somewhat unsatisfied. I was left with unanswered questions and a desire for more closure regarding certain character arcs. It seemed like there were loose ends that could have been tied up more neatly.
Despite my reservations about the ending, "Fruits Basket Another Volume 3" is a worthwhile addition to the series for fans who have followed the Sohma family's journey over the years. It continues to explore the themes of love, acceptance, and the resilience of the human spirit. The artwork remains stunning, capturing the characters' emotions with great detail.
In conclusion, this volume of "Fruits Basket Another" may not have provided the resolution I hoped for, but it still offers an emotionally charged and thought-provoking experience. If you've grown attached to the characters and the world of "Fruits Basket," you'll find plenty to love in this installment, even if it leaves you with a few lingering questions.
Overall, I'm just not sure what the point of this series was. I got a very strong vibe from this volume that the author didn't really have her heart in it but was forced to end it. There's a few story beats repeated from the original Fruits Basket (going to the lakehouse and going to a haunted house) and then a reveal at the end that I was just like...ok?? And for what's a blatant fanservice series, we never get to see any of the original cast except for very minor flashbacks that only show them from the neck down. I'm really happy for everyone that they had kids and they're all happy but ultimately this story was about who ended up breeding.
The new MC was just not interesting to me at all! I'm sorry! I tried to like her and my heart aches for her, but I know nothing about her personality still. And the second primary character ended up being Akito/Shigure's son which also...I do not give a shit about, to be plain. I guess I'm glad that he beat the odds and managed to not be self-centered jag considering his parents.
Overall, just...eh. This didn't need to be 3 volumes if it wasn't going to actually do anything with the story. However, it is nice to see how much Natsuki Takaya's art has improved - it was always good, but she's really honed her art skills and they're so impressive.
Trigger warnings/squicks: extreme emotional abuse, parent gaslighting their child Representation: Author/artist and main characters are Japanese, one of the main characters has an unspecified chronic illness
This was probably the best of the three for me, but I'm still tragically disappointed.
There are just too many Sohmas for a 3-volume series. Too many to keep track of, and you never really get to know any of them. I think it was a gratuitous offering and Fruits Basket honestly deserved better.
I did really feel something a bit more with this one, because Sawa's mum is actually the WORST. But still, there's no explanation of why? Or anything more about her really except that she's awful? I wanted more layers than I got.
I wanted so much to love this mini series but it broke my heart more than anything.
I'll just stick to re-reading the original, I think.
A slow climb to a rating slightly higher than it's predecessor, Fruits Basket Another, Volume 3 gets a modest 4.1 stars.
Highlights of this volume, as it compares to the last two of it's kind, are that we glean a bit more backstory for Mitoma, and, in the revelation about who her mother truly is — in verifiable fact from others, and not just Mitoma's fractured, uncertain memories and impression. The more we explore Mitoma's history, the more the story diverges from the tropes and trappings of the original Furuba, and the more the characters feel distinct, real, and deep.
We also learn more about Shiki's past in this volume, and how he's become the person he is, and how the other characters care both about and for him. Because this care is so active and actionable, it helps better define not only Shiki, but those characters around him, which I greatly enjoy.
A final highlight, and I think the deeper through line and connecting story beat that I have been searching for this whole Fruits Basket Another journey, is the narrative exploring, however briefly, the different consequences and affects of the generational trauma springloaded in the Sohma family curse. Yes, we did break the curse in the original Fruits Basket, but it's entire being didn't just go away, slipping quietly into the night. Even though we might hope foolishly that the trauma ended with the curse and the heaviness has left, there is still much of it that lingers — both in the characters of the original series (now parents), and the children that they have since had, who see shadow and occasionally grapple with individuals not yet healed, and who are affected by it, still. It's nice to see that this heaviness wasn't simply erased, but that it is gently being healed, and that everyone helps with that, in their own way. This second generation doesn't escape what the curse meant: . They are working through it, however, and there is hope in that. And acceptance.
Moving forward, I would still like more by way of story, and I still would like to see more deviation from the formula that worked so well for the original Fruits Basket — worked, because it had more space to do more than these sequel volumes, and worked because it had a greater meta narrative to tell. I have always enjoyed Furuba's slice of life story telling style because it was taking us through a fantastical tragic story in a safe, near mundane way. The charm and strength of the series was in that juxtaposition. Because this sequel series lacks the latter half of that formula, it leaves me wanting. The story meanders and lacks something ephemeral to keep it cohesive and strong.
But I'll be finishing, anyway. I would like to see these characters happy, and mixture of nostalgia bait and comforting relationship dynamics is just enough to keep me hanging on.
I think it's a really interesting concept that all of the Sohma kids are coming from well-adjusted parents who love each other and their children, and now seek to help out a girl with an abusive parent. I just wish it was done in a bit of a more organic way I guess? Like, we don't get a ton of like the build-up or even resolution.
Which, on the one hand, makes sense if this is a limited series. But then why write this? It was also predictably disappointing to not see any of the old main cast. But the bonus manga about how every first snow, Yuki and Machi take their son out to stomp around is too precious and I loved it so much T____T
I have to say that I enjoyed this one the most out of all three volumes so far. Now, it's still a bit all over the place and I've given up on trying to pair the kids with the parents. But we learned some secrets and I can get a better understanding for why they befriended Sawa. I'm getting a vibe from Sawa and Shiki and I'm all for it if it turns into a relationship. I know he's younger than her, but their interactions are pretty cute.
This volume ends saying that it's the final one but since then, the author announced they are releasing a volume four in December. As we know, I'm going to pick it up.
i just do love these books. i love seeing the Sohma kids grow into wholeness. i love seeing them reach out and embrace Sawa. i love seeing Sawa grow into a whole person who can stand and look up, and i love that she’s bringing her other sad self along as she grows.
i see that this was planned as three volumes, yet i have four. Looking forward to seeing what Takaya does with these sweet kids next.
Une fin un peu plate et précipitée. En tournant la dernière page, je me suis dit « hein ? ça se termine comme ça ? 😕 » À croire que la mangaka avait prévu plus de tomes que ça, mais qu’elle a dû raccourcir son histoire ? Bref, c’était une jolie série, bien qu’il n’y ait pas vraiment d’histoire… Un peu déçue de ne pas voir les anciens personnages mais bon !
Wouldn’t be Fruits Basket without some ✨trauma✨ I really appreciated seeing Sawa and Shiki’s connection and diving deeper into their pasts. But ummm it gave me romantic vibes and it was cute until I realized their age gap. Soooo I hope that doesn’t become a thing.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This book comes to a bittersweet ending as our main character learns the secret of her past and learns she can face any future with the help of friends.
"Thank you for staying with us 'til the very end. ..... or so I would say, but I also think it would be nice if I could draw more of this story." ‼️⚠️🤞👀 pleaseee I love all these characters... and I need to see the original fruba adults happily living their lives!!!
Again, this is probably closer to a 3-3.5, but I rounded up because there were some very sweet and heartwarming moments. It’s a shame that this series is wrapping up with only three volumes, but to be totally honest, it never quite had the same allure for me as the original series. Given the shortness, there’s so much less time to delve into the tragic backstories and the deeply rooted personal issues that so many of these characters are burdened with.
This volumes introduces the reason for the tension between Sawa and the Sohmas, but because it’s close to the end of the story, we don’t get to delve too deeply into it. The original series had 23 whole volumes to introduce characters, establish a story, then pepper in the darker aspects, slowly evolving the story. Here, we don’t get that luxury, and I do feel like a lot of time is spent introducing the huge cast of characters (many of whom don’t factor in majorly to the story) that could instead be spent with more interior moments. A lot of my brain power was spent keeping track of everyone’s names, remembering who was related to who, instead of really getting inside Sawa’s head, which we don’t quite get until the very end. Her painful history with the Sohmas finally comes out, but I didn’t quite feel like enough seeds had been planted for the reveal to feel fully shocking. Also, I do wish we could have seen Sawa confront her mother one last time, but her resolve to move forward and not let her toxicity drag her down is a great lesson for kids who may not know that can draw back from these kinds of situations. Her budding relationship with Shiki is very sweet, which ended the story on a nice note.
Fans of Fruits Basket will likely be able to find something to like about this series, but it does still feel more like an extended one-shot to me as opposed to its own real series. Those looking for a recreation of all that made the original great will likely be disappointed (especially as there’s much less, if no, romance in these three volumes.) The upside is that Takaya’s art looks really gorgeous, and all the finely wrought expressions that make her characters lovable are on full display here.
And I can’t be too sad because I still have the whole new anime adaptation to hold me over. :)
I want so, so much more of these characters! I didn’t feel that way as much with the first two volumes, but I’m sad now to leave this new cast behind...
It seems like a lot of the reviews rating this short series poorly focus on it not being what was wanted or expected - mostly a yearning to see what the original cast is up to - rather than based on what it actually is. I would've liked to see the original cast make cameos, too, but that's not what this story is about and it was never meant to be a lengthy, in-depth continuation. I've enjoyed this stroll through the lives of the Sohma's next generation, although I would love to see a family tree because it's been a long time since I read Fruits Basket. At long last, vol 3 throws Sawa's trauma wide open and it's heartbreaking. But, in true form, the Sohmas rally around her and lift her spirits as much as they can. I wish they could have done more for her, but they are forced to accept their limited roles. And I think that shows what we really learn from this series. The original group took in Tohru and changed her life as much as she changed theirs, and that changed the family dynamics. She broke the curse. But here, we learn that it's not always that easy and that problems can't be fixed overnight - in fact, some problems persist for the originals. Sometimes life really sucks and, while some people are kind, others are horrid, and often we must endure and choose to live. The story delves just deep enough to prod the reader into thinking further and it's not a bad path to follow because one person's really crappy life affects more than them. It may chase away friends and lead to isolation or bring others closer and offer a respite to see more than pain in life. It's easy to runaway. The hard part is sticking it out and being stronger for it
Liked it, didn’t love it. I enjoyed reading about the festivities at the summer vacation home. We also learn more about Sawa’s troubles with her mother and the story of how she fell down the stairs and Shiki found her.
At the summer vacation home, they have a BBQ,
Another moment reminiscent of the original Fruits Basket is when Chizuru mentions that “Kinu is the only one that can control (or calm) Hibika who has the personality of Ayame which is just like Hatori being able to control Ayame, which makes sense because Kinu is Hatori’s daughter after all.
The next morning, Sawa wakes up to find Shiki having breakfast with the others.
I think the family knows that Shiki likes Sawa and Sawa has become friends with Shiki, so Mina convinces Shiki to go with Sawa.Sawa is worried about roping in Shiki to go with her to the aquarium (even though it was Mina’s suggestion), luckily, Shiki tells Sawa he had been to that aquarium before when he was little and recalls watching the stingrays, the two then happen to see a big stingray gliding by and Shiki is happy. Sawa and Shiki have a good time together.
Meanwhile Hinata, Mina, and Chizuru talk about Shiki and how his dad, Shigure was teasing him about traveling Shiki about being anxious to get on the road to the vacation home. Chizuru mentions that Shigure always “jumps at the chance to tease people.” And that’s why Shiki doesn’t like him. As a throwback to Shigure’s playful and immature personality, I can see that Shigure hasn’t changed much. Regardless, I still love Shigure, even if he is a butt.
To finish the summer vacation on a good note, the Sohmas and Sawa have some fun with sparklers and fireworks. Before they leave the summer vacation home, Shiki thanks Mutsuki for inviting him and realizes he is never really alone with Mutsuki and the others always looking out for him, but recalls the day he found Sawa on the stairs and believes that’s true loneliness.
When the gang go back home, they get excited for the school’s cultural festival, in which each class hosts an event or showcases talent, Sawa recalls Shiki teaching her the game “Go” at the Sohma vacation home and Shiki tells Sawa he will play with her anytime while blushing. It’s clear he likes her.
On her way back, a girl finds Sawa with Shiki and asks if Shiki and the Sohmas were her friends, and then oddly states “I guess that means your mother hasn’t gotten around to trash-talking them yet.”
The girl then confronts her about her past, reminding Sawa about how they used to be friends in the past and would play together and then all of a sudden they didn’t want to play with her anymoe. She tells Sawa to really think about why they didn’t want to play with her anymore. She tells Sawa that her mother met with the girls the day before they stopped playing with Sawa and started insulting the girls and bad mouthing them. Sawa had no idea this whole time and is shocked her mother would do that to her and then pick on Sawa about having no friends anymore and really putting her down.
Then the girl asks what we are all thinking… “What is wrong with your mother?” I’ve been wondering this very same thing the whole time I’ve been reading this series. Is Sawa’s mother, bipolar, just a bully, or did something darker happen to where she started acting in this despicable way to her own daughter.
I used to think Yuki’s mom was bad, but this is on the level of Kyo’s biological father bad! Poor Sawa is furious and very sad when she learned the truth about why her friends stopped playing with her.
On Mutsuki and Hajime’s way back to their house, they find a shaking and crying Sawa who asks them if her mother ever did anything to the Sohma family. Mutsuki then tells the story of the time when Shiki had found Sawa all alone injured at the bottom of the stairs when her mother had left her all alone abandoned that day.
Even though it was an accident and Sawa’s mother’s fault for not being there to prevent it, her mother blamed Shiki saying “he pushed her” and sued Shiki just to get money out of the Sohma family who her mother knew were rich. Everything had been settled, the Sohma boys weren’t sure how and didn’t know the details, but the damage was already done and both boys reminded Sawa she did nothing wrong so as not to worry her.
Sawa then has a huge mental breakdown and starts bawling, truly realizing how miserable she has made Sawa’s life. Kinu sees all this, invites Sawa in who falls asleep from mental exhaustion and watches over her for the night. Sawa finds out that Kinu and the Sohma family already knew who sh was because of the whole ordeal with her mother and Shiki.
Sawa feels guilty and bad about the whole situation, but Kinu gives her some wise advice about no point in dwelling on it now, because her mother would just take advantage of her feelings. Kinu gives her further wisdom by telling Sawa her life is her own and no one has the right to it, not even her parents. She also tells her to protect herself. Sawa then decides to talk to Shiki about the whole situation.
After talking to Kinu about her awful mother and the mention of Shiki, Sawa’s memory is triggered and she finally remembers the incident. Sawa’s mother made plans to take her out when she was young only to abandon her for some guy and leaves her alone for 6 hours in the snow, Sawa then slips on the snowy, slick stairs, falls all the way down and breaks or injuries her arm. That’s when Shiki finds her unconscious on the ground from hitting her head.
A bit later Shiki comes over with Mutsuki. Sawa is surprised to see him, but Shiki wanted to come when he heard from Kinu that she wanted to speak to him. Mutsuki suggests they go on a walk together with Hajime jokingly says “What are you, a matchmaker?” Sawa tells Shiki she finally remembers him and the incident. She profusely apologizes to him for not remembering before and for her mother’s actions.
Shockingly, Shiki apologizes to Sawa, mentioning that he saw her earlier that day by herself on the stairs and noticed she was still there on the way back. He also noticed she was crying the whole time, so when he got home, he ran straight back to check on her and that’s when he found her at the bottom of the stairs injured.he went back home and had Shigure call the ambulance.
It’s clear that Shiki is a good boy with a heart of gold having been very concerned for Sawa when he could have just been a bystander and do nothing but stay home. I thought that was so sweet.
Shiki then mentions that he always thought and worried about her ever since then, so he was very happy when he saw her happy. Sawa, overcome by several emotions at once, anger at her mom, then gratefulness for Shiki, so she thanks Shiki for caring about her and finding her.
Overall I enjoyed this series, but I didn’t love it. I was super disappointed we never got to see Tohru and Kyo’s daughter. I also wished they original characters would have had more appearances or even just popped in at the end to see the school festival or just to visit their own kids. I think this is why I felt that this series was trying to be Fruits Basket and another totally different series at the same time.