9 books in and I was hoping to have changed my mind about the main character Ember. Nope, I still do not like her. I keep reading the series because I enjoy the story lines, the town of Starry Hollow and most of the other characters in the series. Ember is snarky and sarcastic, two characteristics that I normally enjoy and identify with. Unfortunately for her, she just comes off as immature and annoying. She is 29 years old and is less mature than her 11 year old daughter. She makes the excuse that she had her daughter young, ok that is fine for when you are 18-25 but now you are 29, time to grow up and be more serious. I also do not understand the pairing the author made between her and Alec the stuffy vampire. Where she is uncouth, he is refined, classy and boring. I felt Sheriff Nash was a better fit for her, he is down to earth, casual and loyal. Ember's daughter Marley was more taken with Alec and I feel it was because he is a vampire and mysterious, plus he is more of an intellectual which Marley identifies with completely. He writes books, Marley's joy. Nash is more fun and down and dirty, a man's man if you will (he is a shifter), Marley is not used to that. Marley's 11th birthday arrives and presents were presented by both men, Alec dedicates his latest book to Marley and Nash gives her a locket with the picture of her mom and dad in the locket and yet Ember finds Alec's gift more endearing and causes her to melt more. She appreciated the gift that the Sheriff gave Marley but she was more keen to Alec, I believe Ember chose Alec because of her daughter. For me, the deal would have been sealed with Nash, that was a personal gift and took thought and heart. Ember ends up breaking Nash's heart, she strung him along and used him until Alec came around to tell her he felt the same. Now that they are together she is more pretentious and keeps thinking that Nash is doing things to sabotage their relationship. She gets indignant and starts to threaten with the fact that she is a Rose, everything she at first abhorred. Then she gets upset because her aunt sends her lawyer to have them sign a paper declaring their relationship at the business, this is normal practice any time there are relationships between bosses and subordinates, and yet she feels it was wrong and gets angered about it. Insert big eye roll here. Marley has been having issues with her magic as well and starts to doubt herself, Ember knows that it is something to do with the wand, but rather than tell her daughter she continues to allow her daughter to feel depressed and doubt her magical abilities. She found out that the wand harbored negative energy from the previous owner who was an ancestor. The simple solution was to speak to her aunt about the history and to tell her daughter it needs to be checked and get her a loaner wand in the meantime. Instead she decides to do her own research and come up with nothing. If she invested more time in her daughter's needs and her own magical training, she would be a more likeable character, instead she spends time getting involved in the Sherriff's investigations where again she is almost killed and trying to find a therapist for couple's therapy for her and Alec so they can start out on the right foot of the relationship. It seems to me that if you need to start out with couple's therapy, maybe you should take a step back from being a couple work on individual therapy and then try being in a relationship. The whole thing is odd. There also was a couple that appeared that apparently Alec and Ember met somewhere before on a trip, I don't know what story they first appeared in, I couldn't find a short story that I had missed so that was out of left field for me. There could be a story somewhere, but I did not find one. I liked this book the least of the series, I will continue because I do like most of the other characters and I hope that Sheriff Nash finds someone who appreciates him for his roughness, I have lost hope that Ember will become likeable.