(Zero spoiler review)
I had no idea this existed until I stumbled upon it at the library. One quick flip through, and its main (possibly only) was obvious. The exquisite Marini art enthrals and captivates in a way that few other American superhero stories have. Sure, we've been blessed with thousands of immensely talented artists on various titles over the years, although the European style is a wholly separate and undeniably beautiful beast, and I wish there was more if it making its way over to the West. His drawn out aerial shots of Gotham are sublime, and show Gotham in a way that many comic artists, and basically every film director has failed to bring to life. If this book was nothing but Gotham city concept art, I would be a very happy camper. But the dynamism of his characters, the choice of colours, the framing of his panels, the man is a master of his craft when it comes to putting pictures on a page.
Sadly, and this is a very big, very loud sadly, the man's talent comes to a grinding halt when it comes to the words accompanying his drawings. I suppose it would be criminally unfair for a man to be overtly talented in both fields, but I could live with the inferiority complex (as I can barely draw stick figures) if it meant we got something equally as enthralling to read about here. I've never read a thing of his before this, but something tells me people accept, or suffer through his stories just to look at the pretty pictures. The man's obvious enthusiasm in his foreword about writing a Batman story was palpable, although even there, you could see the limits of his vernacular, his stilted language coming to the fore. Quite why artists so often feel compelled to write, when they clearly aren't that talented is a mystery to me. Envy? Ego? Ignorance? Maybe they just want to have their work over and done with in a matter of days, rather than weeks. So then does editorial smile, pat them on the head and let them have at it, as long as they keep drawing books for chump change? I feel editorial have a lot to answer for here, as the man's characterisation of some of Gotham's favourites, particularly my girl Selina, is almost unforgiveable. His dialogue is frequently stale and occasionally cringey. That said, every now and then, he'll nail an exchange, or even an individual line. Then again, a broken clock is right twice a day. If someone had the balls to pull him up on some of his poorer choices, or better yet, give him a better writer to work with, though I doubt he would've done the book if he didn't get to write it. The story itself is fine, but its execution page to page is amateurish. The common curse of the comic rears its head again. A really skilled editor could have dramatically improved it without the author knowing, thinking it had all been his idea. Everybody wins. Unfortunately, this is modern DC, and there are no talented editors. Maybe they could release a version of this with empty word bubbles, so I could fill them in myself. Or even a version with no dialogue at all. That way I don't feel drawn to read the unfortunate words tarnishing the beautiful drawings. Great to look at, but not much else. 3/5
OmniBen.