Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

All That Belongs

Rate this book
Catherine, an archivist, has spent decades committed to conserving the pasts of others, only to find her own resurfacing on the eve of her retirement. Carefully, she mines the failing memories of her aging mother to revive a mysterious Uncle and relive the tragic downfall of her brother. Catherine remembers, and in the process, discovers darker family secrets, long silenced, and their devastating aftermath. Spanning decades between rural Alberta and Winnipeg, All That Belongs is an elegant examination of our own ephemeral histories, the consequences of religious fanaticism, and the startling familial ties--and shame--that bind us.

333 pages, Paperback

Published September 15, 2019

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Dora Dueck

11 books12 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
15 (37%)
4 stars
10 (25%)
3 stars
12 (30%)
2 stars
2 (5%)
1 star
1 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews
Profile Image for Gabriele Goldstone.
Author 8 books47 followers
January 4, 2020
The introspective main character, a retired archivist, explores her memories of growing up with a strange uncle and a now deceased brother. It’s a gentle book—nuanced and finely crafted—filled with the kind of heartfelt, poignant sharing that women of a certain age do over coffee. For the most part, I connected with the first person narrator—perhaps many will do the same.

I’ve looked forward to reading Dora Dueck’s new book, All That Belongs, and was not disappointed. Her careful use of language is insightful and oft times sensual. For example, near the end, she describes our Winnipeg sun as “a glowing apricot” (pg. 329). Love it. And yes, the book’s set mostly in Winnipeg, with other chapters set in small town Alberta. While the setting is local, the issues are universal— mental illness, religion, trauma, aging, and coupledom—all examined through the lens of time and memory.
Profile Image for MaryLou Driedger.
Author 2 books9 followers
September 2, 2020
One of the ways a good book engages you is that you are able to make some kind of personal connection with one or more of the characters.  While I was reading Dora Dueck's new book All That Belongs I was making so many connections with her protagonist Catherine that I started jotting down a list of things we had in common.  When I got to twenty I stopped, but I could have easily continued.

When reading All That Belongs the phrase 'gentle reader' kept coming into my head. It is a kind of old fashioned way writers like Charlotte Bronte or Jane Austen address their reading audience directly.  I felt like Dora was talking directly to me in this book and she had some important things to say, but she did so in such a gentle and measured way that I felt a sense of comfort and goodness as I read.  

Profile Image for Kathryn.
241 reviews4 followers
March 7, 2020
I bought this book, looking forward to a plot that combined many of my interests; Mennonite background, family dynamics, and an archivist's viewpoint. Instead, I felt like I was slogging my way through this book as it focused on center characters in the attempt to flesh out the nuances of relationships as the protagonist attempted to make sense of her family and its secrets. While it did "wrap the threads up at the end", it was difficult to read this book at times as I remember saying "move on already!"

This is the story of Catherine, a newly retired archivist, who is looking forward to spending retirement her spouse, Jim, a music teacher. Jim has been asked to continue in the field for another year and so she finds that she has time on her hands that Catherine hadn't expected. At her husband's suggestion, she begins to review her life and details about her family that she previously hadn't looked at. I found it odd, an archivist who wasn't interested in studying her own family until she was bored.

So she begins by remembering her childhood. Her father, Jacob, and his brother, Gerhard, came from Prussia. Her mother was not Mennonite but "endured" her brother in law as he and Jacob farmed together. For some reason, the uncle had the nickname "Uncle Must", given by our protagonist, and he was a bit odd. Known for eccentric behavior and fanatical preaching on street corners, this uncle was a puzzle. When a strange woman showed up one rainy night, this uncle frantically left his house and stayed in the house with his brother and family. This woman, Susan, ended up living in Uncle Must's house for up to 2 years.
As Catherine remembers these events, she picks the threads to understand the secrets/mysteries about the uncle's behaviors, and his mysterious death, and in so doing, confronts the secrets of her family. She learns that her father's mother witnessed the murder of her own mother at the hand of her father. Catherine explores the family secret of her brother and his time in, what I assume was the 60's, and how his drug use had a profound effect on his family. The story ends with Catherine meeting with Susan in an attempt to understand who she was and why Susan decided to stay with Uncle Must.

While the threads come together at the end of the book, the plot spent a lot of time setting the background. I think that it was hard to read as I, the reader, was confused and had questions about the uncle's odd behavior and the influence of this mystery woman. Because it was hard to reconcile, I think that is why I started to get bored with the book early on. The writing style is good, but the complexity of the plot with little foreshadowing had me restart the book at least 2x.

5 reviews
July 24, 2021
I am not normally a fan of reading books on Kindle because I like the “feel” of a proper book, but I needed a book to read and didn’t want to wait for it to be delivered, so I chose the Kindle copy and was glad I did.

I really enjoyed reading this book, mainly because I am interested in family history and also because I worked in a lawyers’ office before I retired and loved looking at old handwritten documents, maps and plans although we never had to wear gloves!

I found the book a little slow to start with, but it soon picked up - however, because I am a “skimmer” when I read, and also because the book goes back and forth from the present to the past, I had to go back several times and re-read things that I had read quickly earlier, in order to get them set in my mind. I enjoyed the author’s descriptions not only of places but also of people and having recently nursed an aged mother, could relate to many of these, particularly the times when Catherine visited her ageing mother in a care home.

The author’s use of similes were wonderful - I have highlighted many of them in the book, which is one of the great things about having the Kindle edition, and many of them resonated with me - things I have seen and done like “There’d been no warning, nothing unusual that Sunday, no fuss rising in advance like foam when a meat bone simmers in a pot.” “A holding-hands row of a family like I used to cut out of folded paper” and “When a person dies, she said, everything essential about them dies as well.”

I did find it difficult at first not having speech marks for the conversations, but I soon got used to that although again, I had to re-read certain passages to ensure I understood what was being said.

I was disappointed when the book finished, as I wanted it to go on so that I could find out more about how Catherine and Jim, her husband, coped once he had “properly” retired.

Having recently found out more about my own family through my research, I liked the book cover too, and originally thought it was just the colourful head and shoulders of a nameless woman. However, when I looked closely I realised that the woman’s hair was made up of photographs of those who had gone before and who were in her mind - from a painting by Agatha Fast. I must admit that my head feels like that sometimes. Definitely a good read and I’m sure I will read it again.

PS Sadly the book cover on Goodreads is NOT up to date - as it is on Amazon. Is it possible to update this please?
152 reviews4 followers
October 12, 2019
I'm not a professional archivist, but I'm drawn to Catherine's aspirations: “…the entire archival enterprise was premised on a contrary hope—the hope that something essential, something weighty, did in fact remain. Something true.
Every morning, the professionals showed up at their temperature-and-humidity-controlled, document-packed rooms and could not betray their confidence that the papers they guarded had the fullest capacity to embody the essential.
And I was a card-carrying member of that school.”

Since the story happens mostly in two different Canadian provinces I feel as though I've been there. Especially here in the driving trip that Catherine makes between her adult and childhood homes I see the landscape and feel how it mentors:

“Homeward, downward, from Alberta’s foothills to the flats of the former seabed where Winnipeg sprawls, and once again I found myself in the meditative state of long distance driving.
…Over the border into Saskatchewan, I rounded a curve that brought me to the top of a rise and before me, an endless vista of budding green, bashful tufts of trees, the highway through it straight and like a welt, the glint of roofs of houses and barns. The sun was partially blocked by a large, low cloud, casting half the scene in shadow while the other half shone. If prairie artist William Kurlek were alive and travelling with me, with his canvases and paints, he would know exactly how to render this immense and generous world, its deeper concerns snugged into ditches at the corners and almost invisible. And then I was down the hill and crossing the view, remembering the most abiding conundrum of our childlessness, that the very notion of memory required offspring. Didn’t it?”

What a luscious book that makes me want to listen more closely to the fragments I have of family history.

Profile Image for MaryAnne.
75 reviews
Read
December 27, 2019
Dora Dueck takes us on simultaneous journeys--of memory, of discovery, and eventually of coming to terms with one's own history and therefore one's own self. Catherine, an archivist, on retiring, discovers a need to understand her odd Uncle Must. As she slowly peels off layers of mystery, she allows herself to remember and to mourn her brother, 13 months older than her, who died so sadly in his mid 20s, and allows herself to face again and integrate her childlessness.
Dora is an observer who "if she lived in a thesaurus would take up residence in the adjectives."

"What was the point of re-visiting, keeping, recording, telling saving, if the nub on the genealogy tree wouldn't open, branch out? Daniel Jute at the archives centre asking in his ponderous voice, For whom are we saving this? The question was rhetorical. For the children, of course. For the unruly, amorphous mass of the next generation, those who partook of us.
Who would, we all hoped, be interested someday....
I realized again what I'd realized before but kept forgetting or hesitated to trust: children--what one sent downstream, that is--weren't the point. not the main one at least. There were always people to love, to funnel stories to.
The point was love. Lateral. in the moment. Ephemeral, too. It could never be adequately described or sung or archived. Had to be --constantly--renewed, given, received. Composed into another song. I slowed to slightly less than the speed limint and savoured the timeworn matter of love. Like a bronze saint's toe kissed over and over again and worn to a sheen. Which is not to say I found it entirely easy to cast off my feeling tha the profession I practiced for decades was lesser than it would have been if I'd had children who could be proud of my accomplishments. But, whatever.
Profile Image for Lypenner.
54 reviews
December 30, 2020
This is my fourth book by Dora Dueck, lent to me by my sister. Over the years, I've found that Dora's characters have a staying power in my imagination, probably because her strength as a writer is really developing the inner life of the protagonist. Her books for me are often a slow read, but worth it as you take a deep dive into the person's inner world. The downside of this is that this wasn't a page-turner, but perhaps that's fitting for a book about someone in second half of life. Being a retired person like Catherine in the novel, I understood her journey of wrestling with questions of vocation, identity and purpose. I hope that like her, I will be drawn deeper and come to greater peace.
Profile Image for Melanie Springer Mock.
390 reviews20 followers
January 8, 2020
Beautifully written. I resonated with the protagonist in so many ways, her own narration drawing me back to reflection on my own past as a Mennonite preacher's daughter. But so much more, too, about how the past is carried within us, a part of the stories we write, for good or for ill.
Profile Image for Nicole Fernz.
58 reviews3 followers
February 4, 2020
I think some people might have trouble with the pacing of this novel, but I quite enjoyed the simplicity of it as well as the overarching themes of family, the past, and memory.
Profile Image for Monica.
350 reviews1 follower
February 9, 2020
Snooze fest. Pretty much sums it up. Books to fall asleep by. I was bored to tears.
Profile Image for Samuel.
Author 7 books25 followers
December 18, 2019
This was slow starting; at times it felt like too many words that did not move the story forward. It did pick up for me in the send half of the book. The plot was engaging, recounting how a retired archivist sorted through her own family's history as she tried to understand a "strange" uncle and the death of her brother.

I'm not a fan of fiction that doesn't use punctuation to signify conversation. It makes the reading more difficult and adds nothing. This made me drop the rating to a 3.
Profile Image for Jacquie.
371 reviews1 follower
January 6, 2020
This book made me evaluate my growing up years as we also had an "uncle." Every family has stories and this one was well written.
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews