Would you give to someone who desperately needed it, that which you could live without?
Keely is the epitome of a self-made woman, her ability to make the right choices her superpower. She doesn’t believe in looking back and has the drive, ambition, and financial means to create the exact life she wants to live—regardless of what her kids and her husband, Andrew, want or need. Michelle lives in stark contrast to Keely’s life. She believes she was doomed from the start with a heartbreaking, poverty-stricken childhood. A string of bad choices in adulthood only intensifies her lack of faith in herself. With her daughter safely away at college, she is left alone with her abusive husband, Ray. As the days drag on, she struggles to find a reason to continue. Until she meets Andrew.
The two women’s worlds eventually collide, courtesy of their daughters, and both are forced to contemplate a time-worn question: is the comfort of a familiar self-constructed prison safer than the risk of trying to live a life of true freedom and potentially failing?
Cake asks how much the world has really changed for women—and for which women—by evaluating the progress of modern feminism. This novel examines privilege, the haves and have-nots, the ideals we choose to embrace, and the facts we forcefully decide to not see. This story entices the reader to contemplate whether our material and emotional conditions arise from childhood environments, personal choice, systemic inequality, or a combination of them all.
Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This was a page turning domestic drama for me. It was about a few members of two different families that were intertwined for kind of unbelievable reasons (think soap opera) but nonetheless that made it interesting. I thought the characters were well developed and there were some good points about being a woman and having limited options when you make certain lifestyle choices.
My favourite part of this book was loving characters you were meant to hate! So many relationships to explore, while they unravel and rebuild. You will not be able to put this book down.
Many novels are written to a formula, variations on a theme; change the characters, create some different crises, but end on a similar and familiar note. Many readers are comfortable with such familiarity and predictability.
This is not that. There are ‘in your face’ messages in this book, the points are made in spades. Be prepared to become frustrated, angered, surprised, but most of all, I hope, sympathetic and empathetic.
The story is told through first person narratives of the primary characters, four women (the men play supporting roles only - one the caricature of the worst male characteristics; the other of the best). The reader comes to understand the characters, both good and bad traits, through their thoughts and conversations.
By far the most important issue dealt with is domestic violence against women. Michelle believes that, for whatever reason, she was born to suffer in this world. Her husband keeps her under control through a combination of brutal physical abuse, intimidation and the always present threat he presents to his step daughter. Michelle believes her only purpose in life is to protect her daughter. Even as she is successful in raising her daughter to become a caring, self confident young woman, she feels there is no escaping her situation, she is thoroughly and completely under his rule and command. Even when others offer alternatives she cannot risk the ever-present threat he presents to her beloved daughter. She comes to believe there is only one path of escape and comes very close to ending it all.
This is also a story of redemption. An overachiever, fitness nut, and successful business woman, Keely has always believed that the most important relationship she has is the one with herself. Husband and daughter are neglected and are secondary to maintaining personal beauty and her physical fitness business. She associates only with women of similar minds. But the future will reveal the huge fault in her belief system.
I was not entirely satisfied with the one-dimensionality of the characters. The dialogue failed to fully explore the character's personalities.
A story reflecting today’s world and attitudes it is valuable for its insights and attitudes. ‘Enjoy’ is not really an appropriate descriptor - perhaps ‘revelatory’ and satisfying are better words to describe my feelings having read this book.
I began reading Cake by Nicole Brooks with some trepidation but I would have missed out big-style, had I not followed my instincts and read it anyway! I found the book to be most compelling and engaging.
Cake is told from several different perspectives, allowing the reader to gain an insight into the minds of various cast members, thus enhancing the story. As a result, I couldn't wait to turn to the next page to see how the characters' lives were progressing, either positively or otherwise. Nicole’s writing style is a good fit for me; easy-to-read, clear and with subtle dashes of humour, whilst delivering a rich portrayal of certain key characters. In Cake there is sadness by the bucket-load, along with some awe and shocks throughout, and this could have been a rather melancholic and sombre novel. However, Nicole Brooks cleverly levelled the equilibrium with some well-placed lighter, comedic moments. The themes at the core of this book are timely and relevant and this novel beautifully highlights concepts of violence, sexual identity, self-esteem, body image, and the need for acceptance. Definitely a provocative, fulfilling read.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel at my request from BooksGoSocial via NetGalley and this review is my unbiased opinion.
Although I thorough enjoyed Nicole's first novel--Just Because We Can--I found Cake to be more engaging. I couldn't wait to turn to the next page or arrive at the next chapter to see how each of the character's lives was evolving. This book will challenge your values, ideals and pre-conceived notions on how even the most perfectly planned life can go awry. At times it hedged around the old "nature vs nurture" argument when trying to determine what has more influence upon one's life. The book touches on how often, small choices made early in life can manifest into more complex issues and dilemmas as one grows older. Nicole’s writing style allows for the story to be told from several different perspectives. Everyone who reads this will see either a little of themselves or someone that they know in at least one of the characters. You will applaud Cassie and Emerson for their maturity and compassion as young adult women, while they attempt to encourage and guide their own mothers through complex relationships. No doubt, you will cheer on all of these women as the author helps sift through each layer of their lives so that they may finally blossom into their true selves. This was an enjoyable and fairly quick read. For anyone that wants to be encouraged to be and live as your authentic self, then this is it! It’s a must to take on your trip to the beach this summer!
I was trying to make this review a little more open-minded because I didn't like this book and I tried to understand why. And the more I think on it, the angrier I get about it! Ha-ha!
That said, to some small degree, this book challenged how I think about the topics it was trying to address and for that I give it 2 stars. Otherwise, it was too full of over-the-top cliches and a plot that kept getting all the more insane. It felt like someone combined a Hallmark movie with a Lifetime movie into a book, added a dash of stereotypical feminism and lesbianism, and called it a day.
To be clear I have no problem with feminism, lesbianism, or a novel examination of each. But I would prefer it to be less hokey than this book is. Oh, and **slight spoiler alert** it would be nice if the whole "man saves the day" bit toward the end had been left out all together. A book that touches on feminism in such an exaggerated way isn't helping its case by including a scene where the emotionally needy father/husband/secret lover literally bursts in to a room to save the women-folk from the abusive, sexist male antagonist.
Lastly, am I the only one who feels weird about Cassie and Em/ Michelle and Andrew quasi incest bit? I know there is a joke to be made about Canadians here, but as someone from the deep south who deals with the same kind of jokes from time to time, I'll give them a break.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I received a free copy of this book via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Cake is the novel that asks us to look at ourselves and decide how much is too much. How selfish is too selfish, should we keep giving from ourselves until we have nothing left?
Michelle gives her entire self. She gives herself to her daughter as a loving mother who protects her in every way she can. She is even willing to suffer if she believes it is for her daughters benefit. She gives herself to her abusive husband as his obedient housewife in exchange for financial security. Keely gives nothing. She was a stay home mom when he kids were small, but found it didn't make her happy so she changed her life. Her main priorities are her body, her fitness competitions and her gym. She gave away enough of her life and now she wants what makes her happy. When the two women's lives collide in more ways than one, can each learn a little about give and take for their own lives? Or are they stuck on the path they've been travelling forever?
I flew threw the first (approx.) 75% of this novel and then I found it got so cliche and stereotypical. After that it slowed down for me. I also found the ending to be rushed and everyone's problems seemed to be solved with the snap of a finger in the most TV wrapped predictable way possible.
The characters were one dimensional. Each character was simply all one thing. Keely was self obsessed with no softer moments. Michelle was an obedient woman with no good days or bad days, just sad obedient days with her abusive husband. She has one or two moments where she seems to be standing up for herself but then she's only fine when she's rescued by the man.
I did like that the book addressed certain issues, although I'm still unsure how I feel about the way they were addressed. I hate that Michelle was 'saved' by someone other than herself. I found that aspect to be quite disappointing as she never really learned to stand up for herself.
Overall, it wasn't a bad read. It's quick enough where even if you didn't like the story it doesn't feel like you wasted a lot of time on it. Would I recommend it? Yes, because despite the flaws I still think this book has some things that you can take away from it.
4*+ ARC Review – Compelling Book that Requires a Group Discussion I read a lot of books as part of ARC groups but this one made me wish it was part of a book club or class discussion. This ARC was provided by Hidden Gems in exchange for an honest review, and this copy contained discussion questions. This is the story of two women and how their very different lives become intertwined. The book examines many societal issues including economic inequity, social media and domestic violence. Michelle is a downtrodden woman whose life is a series of desperate situations and has finally gotten to a point that something must change. Although her daughter, Cassie wants to help her leave her abusive husband, she seems to hesitate both between his abuse and the psychological trauma she has suffered. Also, she has met a man that might be able to help her out of the situation, but it is hard for her to trust and believe in him. At times, she is in a desperate situation that does not have an answer. The other woman, Keely, is the complete opposite to Michelle. She is fitness and social media obsessed woman who is living a seemingly perfect life with a handsome, successful husband and children. Although her life looks good from the outside, once examined we learn that she is more concerned about her gym and appearance than she is what is happening with her family. Her marriage is ending, and she waffles back and forth between wanting the trappings of her former life and being able to do whatever she wants on her own. It is so hard to describe this book. The way the characters come together is masterful but at times a little too easy, and they did make the “small world” comment as explanation. There is so much going on and at times I dislike most of the main characters. The author does a great job of showing these lives in a way that even when they annoy you, there is still a desire to see where it will go. One of the best parts for me is when Cassie grapples with her mother’s inability to leave her abusive husband. It reflected a lot of my feelings about Michelle and her situation. As much as I understand why she will not leave a part of me is mad at her for not just doing it. Also, as the story around Cassie emerges, I got a little exasperated by her youthful, simplistic view of the world. Although she wants to help people, she felt a little too idealistic to take seriously.
Wow! I actually had to create a whole new set of shelves for this book simply because it's not usually the type of book I read. This was recommended to me by a friend who is in love with this book and has been trying to get us all to read it, and she finally managed to convince this firmly fantasy-oriented reader!
It's incredibly tough to review this book, because it was just so different from what I normally read. I wouldn't necessarily say I "enjoyed myself" while reading this, because the topics were so heavy, but it was so well-written and well done that the reader feels as if they're experiencing these emotions. When I finished this book, I actually had to just sit for a while and think about what I had just read, because I had so many thoughts and emotions going through my mind regarding these characters and their thoughts and feelings.
My main nitpick, and the reason I gave it 4 instead of 5 stars, is the fact that some of the plot contrivances were a bit of a stretch, and the characters did feel a bit one-dimensional at times. However, you could argue that in order to drive home the message the author was trying to express, the characters needed to be one-dimensional archetypes to avoid convoluting the message. I can also imagine that if the author wrote the abusive husband as more of well-rounded character, the reader may begin to feel more sympathetic for him, rather than focusing on Michelle's plight and really feeling her desperation and hopeless situation.
Overall, a well-written book that made me feel far more emotions than I was prepared to feel, lol.
CAKE is a fable, shaped like a contemporary romance, set in modern Canada. The juxtaposition of the two main characters, women of middle age but different economic levels, is quite enough by itself to lend contrast. Then not only does the husband shift from one of them to the other, their two children fall in love... it's much more neat and tidy than real life, unless it was an operetta, not a novel about domestic violence and prejudice.
Both these women are ensnared by illusions. Michelle is in the millennia-old trap of a downtrodden sex object, unused to love and thinking she deserves nothing. Keely has fallen for the consumer media generated projections of what success and happiness look like, but refuses the real thing when it threatens to break that illusion and ends up starved and alone. Both are so wrong!
Helpful side characters continually offer escape to them both. The happy ending is when they each manage to take it. And the big symbolic denouement is to 'let them eat cake'.
The major characters in the book are all amazingly realistic, pitch-perfect. I didn't resent the way everything worked into a Happily ever after until the end when I read through the 'study guide ' appendix. Only then did I realize I'd been ambushed by 'romance mode'. Very crafty, Brooks.
I need to preface the following review with the fact that this was not the book for me. I may seem to be stating this often of late, but I think it counts as a bias that needs to be taken into account when reading a review because it indicates the slant of the review itself.
Cake is a book which includes different types of cheating, to the extent that it made me uncomfortable despite all the background information providing us with reasons why it was so. Cheating oneself, a spouse and general public in the form of social presence are all the prominent parts of the tale. We have two main women, as poles apart from each other as upbringings could make them. then we have two other women, daughters of the other women with a life struggling to understand the choices their mothers make on a daily basis. It has fodder that can be dissected to the smallest fraction because of all these instances and the way each character responds, staying true to their image on the whole.
I did not enjoy the book in the sense of the word but I think it threw up contradictions in daily lives of almost average people and would appeal widely to the right audience. I received an ARC thanks to Netgalley and the publishers but the review (as you can see) is completely based on my reading experience.
While reading Just Because We Can, I fell in love with Nicole's writing style. I genuinely felt connected to her and the characters she brought to life. With so much rawness and honesty displayed in her first novel, I was very excited to hear that her second was in the works. Cake caught me off guard in the most amazing way. It was so different from Nicole’s first novel and brought me in to a terrifying world of domestic abuse, love, sadness, hope and the courage to finally be free. Free from a lifetime of constant abuse versus free from a privileged lifestyle, hiding one’s true identity. Telling this story from 4 different points of view made it extremely thought provoking and emotional. Again, I felt very connected to the characters and found myself deeply reflecting on realities that are so different than my own. I love Cake's message and how beautifully it was told. Thank you for another 5 star read Nicole! Choosing me to be one of your first readers is an honor. I can't wait to hear about what's next!
My favorite fiction books are ones that deal with contemporary social issues and make me think. Beyond that, they need to be well written and have a beginning that draws me in rapidly. Cake does all of this and much more and I liked it right from the beginning. The book is the story of two intertwined families and the struggles that the women have in knowing and accepting who they are or need to be. They are from very different backgrounds and are challenged to deal with problems including parenting, domestic abuse, motherhood, their sexuality and the impact of class has on their lives. If it has a shortcoming it could be that the plot requires a stretch of the imagine; but, to be honest, this did not hinder my enjoyment of the book. The book challenges the reader to examine where they stand on important issues and to look at their values, priorities, and prejudices. It would be a good choice for stimulating conversations in a book club. I am looking forward to future books by Ms.Brooks. I received this book free in exchange for an honest review.
This book is my favorite type of read, people working through real life challenges to grasp a better understanding of themselves and what truly defines happiness. I love Nicole’s writing style, she infuses her novels with a subtle sense of humor and delivers a deep portrayal of each character. The story introduces several characters - each representing different walks of life, diverse motivators, and unique ways of defining fulfillment and success. Through the evolution of the story we are reminded how people may have very different paths but ultimately yearn for similar, and often simple things in life to be happy and how difficult this discovery can be. There was laughter and sadness, along with some shock and awe throughout the novel, which kept Cake a page turner. In the end, as always with Nicole’s novels, the enjoyable read provided me with entertaining escape, but moreover some personal reflection on my own life.
Nicole has done it again... She ignites awareness to issues that women face day to day that lead to insecurities, doubt and question our worthiness. Cake gives us two strong women who overcompensate focusing on upholding societies "rules", silence who they are, and cling to their false self identity. The fear and strength to be vulnerable is what sets them free and oh my don't we all need that reminder. Nicole's characterization of these ladies made them feel so real I saw bits and pieces of each woman in myself and my friends creating empathy to situations I did not prior understand. This book challenges you to face prejudices and see the real person and also take a look at what you are forcing into the world as your persona; are you being real or putting on an act to protect your hurts and fears. Read this with friends and enjoy a slice of cake and the great discussion that this book will bring up.
Two women with very different lives. One has the picture perfect Instagram reel life. The other believes her lot in life is nothing more than an abusive relationship and a child she dearly loves. Both women are stuck in their own way and both find their way out in the end. But how are these two polar opposite lives interwoven? You have to read to find out - I won't do spoilers here. I will say I really, really disliked Keeley (the insta-perfect character). At the same time, she perfectly illustrated everything about privilege and how completely out of touch one can be to real suffering going on around you. I really enjoyed this book even though I tend toward more of the thriller/horror genre. Definitely a great read.
* I received a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. *
I received an ARC of this book with thanks to BooksGoSocial via NetGalley
A story about two women, how their lives intertwine and how remarkably different their worlds are. The subject matters at the core of this book are both urgent and relevant. I was gripped by the story and read it quicker than I anticipated. However the writing wasn't exceptional. Brooks has created a great narrative with such potential but it is missing the expressive and gritty vocabulary that I crave to read. I wanted to feel a deeper connection to the characters and I wanted more depth in both the writing and the character development. I read another review that suggested this book has a very YA feel to it. And with that I entirely agree. It had potential to be something breathtaking and visceral but just fell short.
Nicole Brooks' new novel Cake describes the intertwined lives of two women as they are discovering who they are. It's a cliche story about "finding" themselves but Nicole Brooks has successfully done this in a way that engages the reader. The reader can relate with each of the characters who has created an public persona while they deal with their inner struggles of success, failure, sexuality, love and purpose. Nicole Brooks created realistic and relatable characters with understable struggles. My only negative comment is the use of the anatomical terms on a couple of occasions in the story. These felt a little unnatural in the context and left me wondering what the purpose of this was.
I enjoyed this book and look forward to more from Nicole.
With its interesting premise, vivid prose, and moving characters, Brooks' highly engrossing story resonates deeply in today's progressive world. Ambitious and determined Keely has nothing in common with meek, compliant Michelle. But when the two women’s worlds collide, Keely is forced to confront her inner demons, something she has common with the other woman: her inability to break free of a self-constructed prison and live a life of true freedom.
Brooks perfectly captures her characters’ inner turmoil and emotional upheaval as circumstances introduce them to life outside of their small existences. Unconventional and genuinely captivating, Brooks’ tale is a beautiful exploration of how a person’s choices affect their life in the long run.
I was absolutely captivated by the characters. Even though they were all faulty in their own ways, they each had innate qualities that I was drawn to and couldn't help but like them or sympathize with them. With Ray, it wasn't so much sympathizing as the sad reflection that so any children today don't stand a chance in hell of becoming decent human beings thanks to the homes they are growing up in. Oftentimes, I read a book and once done, move on to the next with little additional thought, however with this one, the characters and themes have stuck in my mind long after I've finished reading it.
Cake is one of those novels that pulls you in and you feel like each character is someone you know personally. Each character is so thoughtfully created in each chapter and you can’t help reflect on similarities in ones own life. This Canadian author brings familiarity to us fellow Canadians which I love! The web of connections between the characters in each chapter keeps the pages turning. Ray is my least favourite character, but another reviewer said it well, as much as you dislike the guy, Nicole’s writing allows for a small piece of empathy to come through for Ray. Amazing book! Can’t wait for the next one.
This novel reminds us that there is always a reason why a person is acting and reacting in the manner they are. The world is a difficult place, and we are all struggling to survive, no matter what mask we put on in the morning. It is a reminder to be kind to the people we come across, even when their behaviours evoke a negative response within us. It is these people that help us learn the most about ourselves, and force us to change and grow. I would recommend this to anyone who has ever had trouble understanding the sometimes difficult behaviours of others.
Cake: a Novel was a great read. It was a wonderful story told from the perspective of four very different yet intertwined women who shared common human needs, although that does not reveal itself until later. I found myself invested in each of their lives. I could feel what they felt and question a lot of the choices that they made. I was both cheering for and against each of the female characters. The only downside I found was that the book wasn't longer. Once I was finished I was wanting more, longing to dive in even deeper into their lives.
Choice or luck? The lives we lead are complex and this novel brings into the light matters of belonging, self-worth, body image, relational violence, and sexual identity.
Fabulous character development and detailed descriptions allow you to navigate through the tangled story line with ease. Truly a page turner- in that you want to know what’s happens next.
This book is wonderful! I found myself relating with many of the characters, disliking some, seeing my history in others. I enjoy how well written each of the characters is, it allows you to see their perspectives and what they bring to the storyline clearly. I found(find) myself thinking of the characters when I couldn’t read the story(darn tiny humans) and wondering what was next! Can’t wait for Nicole’s next novel!
From the first page to the last, I was on an emotional roller-coaster. I found myself so invested in Keely, Michelle, Cassie and Emerson. I judged them; I cheered for them; and then I cried for them. How can you not love a book that elicits such strong emotion? They say you can't have your Cake and eat it too.... well, I devoured this novel. I can't wait to see what this author has in store for her readers.
You just never know what’s going on with someone in their life!!! Everything may look good from the outside but the inside is a different story!!! Nicole explores two women that couldn’t be in such different situations in their lives but still have similarities to the strength they need to overcome the struggles in their lives. Makes you think, what you have, what you don’t, what you should be thankful for...
I found the first half of the book rather slow but the second half improved as things began to come together in the storyline. Keely is clearly a rather nasty self-obsessed character, but other than Michelle, for me, the rest of the cast of characters were too slight. I felt that Andrew was not complex enough for his role in the story. I also got bored at the 80% mark and kipped to the last chapter as I wanted to end the book.
I received this novel via ARC from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you to Netgalley.
Two womens lives, a world apart, collide when Michelle, a downtrodden middle-aged woman, who has known only neglect and abuse from men, meets Andrew and falls in love. This will change forever, not only her lives, but the lives of those around her.
Thought provoking, this novel alternatively shocked and saddened me, but never bored me.
It will make you sit back and ask yourself, what would make me happy.
After the first few chapters I wasn't sure this was intended for men to read but I let myself get to know the characters and enjoy how they look at themselves and at life. In the end I was entertainment and reassured that too many people forget to be themselves, if only they can figure out who that is.