I'm gonna be very honest here. This was a very weird book in a very non-weird way. I read Sailor's short story The Ugly Post and I was looking forward to another book by her because I believe she's got a mature voice. And you know what, it kind delivered? Throughout the book (or the first 60% which I read avidly), the writing was very introspective and wise-like which was a good change I was looking for.
But this is the case of a good writing brought down by a really really bad setting. From the first moment I realised where this was going, it just didn't sit right with me. Sometimes, authors go to lengths to make unusual pairings in MM romance which I quite honestly dig. But this one, boy where do I start? It's not even truly a rich guy meets a poor guy trope because of all the constant hiding that he's rich. Then there's the logistics of it! I hate it when writing gets so critically descriptive of every moment in their lives, "he's crossing this street", "this is visible to him so he will see me", "I have to take this spot cos it's good for hiding" but they loose the bigger picture?
Ummm, if they'd been living together for four months in a shack, why hadn't Tobias ever questioned that Arthur refer him to his temp agency for a job? They didn't share numbers because they were saving money on calling and people don't talk on temp jobs? Seriously??? Then there is living together for so long, and what do they even talk about when Arthur is literally hiding his whole past from Tobias?
You know those books, where it literally says "They talk and talk for hours" and "And then they fall in love", yeah this happened here. Literally at 30% of the book. I was surprised that a writer would take that risk without even giving that much dynamic development between the characters up until that point and just straight up, "Oh, I love you and you're the one", and when the whole story boiled down to that ending, I just wasn't buying this shit. So yeah, with this book you'll find yourself in a place if you're willing to do the whole make-believe thing. I still think the writing is strong in some parts where they introspect on their power dynamic and I loved some bits but bitch, the constant nagging of how it was all possible just wasn't going away!!!