Rating: 3.8 / 5
I confess that, between this book and the first, The Wizard's Ward is my preferred one out of the series. Despite both books following an interesting storyline and involving the same characters and overall fantasy world, for some reason, the sequel and concluding book of the series just fell flat for me on a few key points. Namely:
The risks weren't as high
Technically speaking, the protagonists have an entire army against them rather than just a few individuals this time, but the fact that they literally have an army of their own behind them, as well as the fact that they're a bit more experienced with taking on an enemy, makes it feel like it's less risky for them personally to be fighting. As well, the descriptions of the violence aren't as vivid this time around, so even when the characters are technically in danger, I don't feel that same sense of apprehension that I felt for the first novel. (As well as the fact that, now that I think about it, I don't think that Maura or Rath ever really get physically hurt in this novel, as they did in the first.)
Even though there are more twists and turns for this book, the characters don't deal with them as well
By this I mean (and without going into too much spoiler territory) that whenever they're confronted with a problem, both Rath and Maura are both held back by their personal misgivings. For Rath, it's jealousy and the constant fear of losing Maura, whereas for her, it becomes a secret of her past. They're both fearful and uncertain of the future, and so Rath lets himself be controlled by someone else, whom, for a while, ends up controlling Maura as well. Now, I hate this character a lot, and really hate how the author made both protagonists let this person carry on as they have for such a long time out of a feeling of "necessity". By the end of the book, I really didn't get what their purpose was, other than to toss in an extra complication to make the conflict more interesting. Instead of making things interesting, though, this just made me feel like Maura and Rath lost some of the good points of their characters from the first book.
There's no more of "the witch and wolf"
That was actually the selling point of the first novel that I was really drawn to: that Rath and Maura were both outcasts who had only each other to rely on in tough situations, taking from what was strongest from each of them. From Rath, it was strength and survival skills, and from Maura, it was healing and resourcefulness in both body and mind. Now though, in the second novel, no one treats them as outlaws anymore, as they take on new roles that they somewhat accept, but in different ways. So, yeah, the charm of my favourite aspect of the first novel was essentially nonexistent in this one.
Well, these were the drawbacks for me in the sequel, but I still gave it a high rating overall. The reasons for this are actually pretty good as well:
+ The writing style was still exactly the same, so I could tell that it was the same fantasy world, the same characters, and the same conflict at hand. It was encouraging to know that the writer was still able to keep her established world intact.
+ The events taking place were still interesting, even though I didn't feel that the risks were as high as before. Mistakes still had consequences, so at least it wasn't easy for the protagonists to go through everything.
+ There was still an equal balance of it being both Maura and Rath's story. Like in the first novel, both of their points of view were described, in third person via the events and emotions that they were going through in the absence of the other.
+ A great twist for Maura's side of the story. I did not see it coming, and I was actually pretty happy with how it all tied in without being too messy or cluttered or anything.
+ The ending. Just knowing that, after a month's delay of getting the book, I was able to finish the story and know how things ended was really satisfying.
All in all, a good enough read, and a suited sequel to the first novel. Now, on to the next read!