I loved this book.
I've rarely heard anyone talk about why mathematics is important, about why people care to use it. In primary and secondary schools, teachers (at least the ones I and most other people seem to have had) emphasize techniques and only occasionally do they give explanations about the technique's source. Techniques are taught like they're eternal truths and that if you don't 'get' it there must be something wrong with your brain.
I'd argue that this book is about more than just mathematics, it's about the scientific enterprise in general.
By explaining the sources and the thought processes of some of the greatest scientists (Newton, Galileo, Decartes, Maxwell, and Gauss among others), this books shows and tells at the same time.
What's the deal with all the math symbols?
- "The use of special symbols enables one to write mathematical statements concisely and precisely. The symbolism also contributes to clarity. The same statements in ordinary words would often be long, complicated sentences, too difficult for the mind to grasp..." and later, "There is no doubt that language of algebra is enormously effective in recording and in operating with mathematical concepts. Nevertheless, many people complain about the need to learn this special language. These people would be more justified, however, in complaining that the French people insist on using their own language and the Germans, theirs... Certainly insofar as the language of algebra is concerned, no subsititute serves the purposes so well... On the other hand there are some legitimate objections to the language of algebra and of mathematics generally... There is no doubt, too, that mathematicians are generally overzealous about conciseness, and in their passion for brevity indulge in symbols even where these seem no better than a familiar English word or phrase. A faulty judgment has caused mathematicians to equate elegance and conciseness at the cost of intelligibility."
Why do people use math to study the world?
- "To confine our activity entirely to the physical investigations or observations may lead to getting lost in a jungle of physical facts; it may require traversing impassable territory, as in measuring the size of the earth; it may involve climbing mountains so high that the atmosphere becomse too rare to support physical activity; or it may mean the at present [1959] impossible task of getting to the moon...
"The mathematician... with concepts and axioms in mind, whether solely mathematical or a combination of physical and mathematical ones, the mathematician retires to a corner and deduces new conclusions about the physical world... [The conclusions] yield such knowledge as the distance to the sun and sometimes such totaly unexpected phenomea as the existence of radio waves."
Why is the world explained by math?
- "Mathematics is commonly regarded as highly abstract and remote from the real world... but every abstraction that even the greatest mathematician has introduced is ultimately derived from and is therefore understandable in terms of intuitively meaningful objects or phenomena...
"[Man] has one more means at his disposial to make his mathematics fit the physical world. If his theorems do not fit, he is free to change his axioms. This recources seems farfetched, but scientists have adopted this procedure in our time."
_____
Once again, this is a fantasic book. Now I just need some friends or strangers (I'm not picky!) to recommend this to.