Thanks to St. Martin's Press for my galley copy.
Because this is an uncorrected proof, Keegan-Michael Key's preface, "On Being an Indignant Brown Girl," and "Making the Green New Deal the Real Deal" are not included in the copy I reviewed.
I'm going to state off the bat that I am not an entirely unbiased reviewer. I tend to think AOC is pretty great. However, I'm going to try to be as unbiased as possible.
This is a collection of essays, so I'm going to treat it as such. Like any anthology, they're of varying quality, but they're generally good, painting a picture not just of AOC but of the movements, people, and ideas that shaped her and of the writers themselves. Usually the effusive praise is grounded in something, so even if you aren't a fan of the congresswoman, there's a lot of interesting observations about, say, Latinas in the world of finance, although there are a few times where the essay could be a little longer or the praise seems to be hyperbole. The progression overall creates a decent sense of unity, beginning with an open letter to the congresswoman that is both full of heart and witty and progressing to a short, snappy biography of AOC before moving on to the main body of the essays.
My favorite sections were the ones written as short memoirs, particularly Natalia Sylvester's "In No Uncertain Terms," since I consider myself to be a language nerd and love how she talks about the politics of language. Tracey Ross' "A Just Society" is probably the most unique of all of these, as it's essentially a policy proposal, standing out among other essays for its particular format. Yet all of them, whether short history, memoir, or analyses, have something to offer. Some of them are written specifically for Latina women of color, some have a more general goal, but all of them paint a multifaceted portrait of the congresswoman, her world, and the forces that shaped her.
If you're an open-minded conservative or libertarian, you'll probably seldom agree with the authors, but you still might like it overall, since it's not just about AOC or her accomplishments, but also about how AOC fits into more general topics, like the history of socialism or Puerto Rican activism. Ultimately, though this does cater to people of a particular political leaning, I think it can be appreciated by anyone. It's not just non-stop cheerleading for 240 pages, it's a thoughtfully crafted body of writings which seeks to articulate who AOC is and place her in a definite context.