3.5/5 Stars
*I was provided with a copy of this book by the publisher, in exchange for my honest opinion.
I’m sure that the majority of us have read Alice in Wonderland at some point, or at least are familiar with the story. It has been a while though since I’ve read it, but it’s always been a story that fascinated me and I love the different interpretations of it in both book and film, so this anthology piqued my interest a lot. These stories were very original and were a very eclectic mix and it’s probably one of the most diverse anthologies I’ve read, most notably in the genres explored. As it’s such a mix of interpretations, writing styles and genres, everyone will probably respond to this anthology very differently from the next person. And as is probably expected, there were some stories that I enjoyed more than others.
Every single contribution in this anthology is of course, inspired by Alice in Wonderland. However, with some of the stories it is a bit harder to pinpoint the connection to Wonderland and so with a couple of them, although I enjoyed the story in itself, it was a bit disappointing to not be able to see a clear connection with Alice. I didn’t expect them to be an exact copy, I’m actually glad that none of them were, but it would’ve been nice if the Alice influence was a bit clearer. Some had elements of the original story in them like going down the rabbit hole, the growing and shrinking and the slaying of the Jabberwocky. Whereas some just had characters with similar names to the original characters, with one being spelt Alise. Others didn’t have connections that I could pinpoint as easily and I didn’t mind when the story in itself was interesting enough, but some of the concepts were harder to grasp and I just couldn’t get into them as much.
I wish I’d have taken my time with this, and stepped away after each story, because I feel like it would of allowed each story to fully make its mark on me, before I dived into another. Some of the stories have overlapped a bit in my memory because there are quite a few of them, and naturally, I remember the ones that I enjoyed more, compare to the ones I didn’t. There were quite a lot of stories that I did enjoy though and I found myself faced with one of the downsides to anthologies, where you read a good story and desperately want it to be a bit longer. For the most part, I felt that the author’s did a really good job with the length of their stories, they didn’t seem too long or too short, but when you’re enjoying something, you always want a bit more. There were actually also two poems in the book, one opened the anthology and another closed it, which was a quite nice use of structure. Both of the poems were done by the same author, but I really liked the last poem the best, it, paired with the last story, felt the perfect way to end the anthology. Both offerings seemed to jolt the reader back into the harsh realities of life, such as the fact that Alice couldn’t stay in Wonderland forever and in my opinion, the horrific truth of what would of happened to Wonderland had it been discovered by adults.
The ones that I wasn’t too fond of, like I said, didn’t really feel connected to Wonderland or just didn’t pull me in enough. I feel like some of the stories were too abstract in their connection and general plot, that I couldn’t enjoy them as much as the others. I completely love how weird and wacky the world of Wonderland is, but some of the stories just didn’t make sense to me and I was confused the whole time. I felt like I couldn’t find something to hold on to in those stories and so when that happened, I was searching for the connection to Alice instead and then when I didn’t find it, I was at a loss. Therefore, I couldn’t appreciate them as their own story or through their connection to Wonderland.
Lastly I want to just praise the ones that I loved. These tended to be the ones that had a more realistic approach to Wonderland, covered in magical realism. Magical realism tends to be a favourite of mine and so it doesn’t surprise me that these were my favourite type of stories. I’m not sure why, but I just found these more inventive than the others. There was one where Alice had come out of Wonderland, found the world a changed place and had to assimilate into everyday mundane life, it was sad but a really interesting read. There was another story that was a bit harder to swallow in terms of subject matter and looked at what Alice could of been escaping from by going to Wonderland. A lot of the stories had quite dark undertones, but one that was incredibly sweet was where Alice had to come to terms with the fact that the things from her childhood, such as Wonderland, were suffering due to her no longer paying attention to them and she made it her responsibility to fix it. One of my favourites and the last story, looked at Alice reflecting on her life and what happens to those who experienced so much magic as a child and the longing to go back instead of facing reality. It even incorporated Peter Pan, which I thought was a nice touch.
Overall, this was a unique anthology filled with inventive stories that I’ve never seen before as interpretations of Wonderland. Although some were more to my liking than others, I was able to appreciate the amount of creativity displayed, I mean we saw an injection of Japanese folklore, Alice hunting Mr. Rabbit and even consideration of the controversy surrounding Carroll. I would definitely recommend this as I’m sure that there’s something for everyone in this wide range of stories.