So, I just lost my whole review by accidentally swiping down fml. I guess I’ll try to rewrite it?
~
Probably closer to 3.5 stars.
I actually finished a book club book with two days to spare! W o w. (Maybe now I’ll move on to my other book club book? Time will tell.)
Things I loved:
- The magical realism which brought the Met to life. Secret passageways, ghosts, objects telling their own stories... Amazing.
- I’m now realizing that the book’s treatment of objects is meant to be parallel to the people discussed — both are a part of the collection. The president’s remark in the last chapter made me think of this, when she said that she’d been there so long she needed her own accession number. The chapters at the beginning and end — with differing interpretations of who “we” are — also point to this conclusion.
- Some of the stories are standout. As is some of the writing. I loved the different perspectives and especially the indulgent people watching.
Things I didn’t love:
- Rampant yet half-hidden elitism. The higher-ups are not outright critiqued for their odd entitled eccentricity, but rather are only laughed at behind a hand and discretely pointed at. I just think the ‘average’ people were almost more strange and meant to be pitied? (Like, oh, wow, look at them, enjoying art! Love of art is universal, even for them.) Maybe it’s also that this book was obviously not meant for an ‘emerging museum professional’ like me (I REALLY don’t like that term and I can’t even quite explain why, but alas, I suppose the shoe fits). Like, she’s not setting out to critique her workplace for over a quarter of a century. (Besides, if she made it, why couldn’t any lowly person — like the character Melvin that melts into a sofa in a depression, but dies (?) happy among art?!)
- Weird treatment of topics like death, age, body image, sex, etc. I don’t know. Some of it just didn’t sit right with me.
- No cohesion in the stories. Some were too long (often the ones I didn’t like due to being bored!). Others were really good but ended abruptly... They also didn’t connect too much. The last story didn’t feel like the right conclusion (despite it being about death...)
Things I would love to see:
- A Canadian version (at the ROM?) that includes lowly summer students and post-grad interns instead of the Development Office and the Mezz Girls.
- More from the perspective of the visitors, including locals rather than silly tourists. And not just the rich donor types, either.
- Also, perhaps something from the perspective of the education department? (They’re more or less scorned in one of the first few chapters iirc)
- More time-bending and magical realism!
- More critiques, but I guess that’s obvious by my rant above.
I suppose I may have more to add after discussing the book! I may also include some of my favourite stories, once I have another flip through and look at my notes from earlier in the month.