What do you think?
Rate this book


336 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 1, 2004


This volume has its ups and downs, but it also has the debut of Ultimate Black Cat, and Black Cat = automatic 5 stars.
There are two moments in this volume that I especially liked. The first is the Aunt May issue, showing May pouring out her heart to her psychiatrist. I can see where that would've been a disappointment for readers who were going through the series issue-by-issue, but in the context of this collected volume, it's really good. I enjoy how Brian Michael Bendis is bringing more depth to Aunt May. The second moment that stands out in Volume 4 is when J. Jonah Jameson opens up to Peter about why he is so harsh toward Spider-Man. As always, such moments would be better if Bendis didn't write all dialogue as though it's spoken by a slow-witted, stuttering teenager. But the J. Jonah moment is still really nice.
The poorer aspects of Volume 4 include the introduction of a new sort-of villain, Geldof. And, connected to that story, the introduction (though some of them have appeared previously, in cameo roles) of the Ultimate X-men, who look terrible (what was Mark Bagley thinking?) and act brainless. Geldof strikes me as a failed attempt, and the X-men deserve much better than how they're presented here.
As in previous volumes, Bendis raises some intriguing issues for Peter to struggle with. The writing is never going to delve very far into those issues, but I'm glad they're there. The big issue of this collection is society's willingness to look the other way when a person's crimes seem to be balanced out by his "good works"--or when the person has enough money to buy his continued freedom.
As a side note: I was amazed at how many times the word "shenanigans" appears in these stories.