Wow - Why haven't I heard of Audrey Howard before? She writes so so well and her characters are so realistic and even complex. The story telling is rich with detail and historical context. This was definitely historical fiction and not historical romance. It was really more about the changes in society in the early 1900's and how all the youth of every class were breaking free of the restrictive rules their parents grew up with and the book really addresses the pain that causes for their mothers, as they watch their children make "unacceptable" choices. The main characters were compelling, and I loved their stories, although they kept making some really bad choices - all the choices were in line with their characters personalities and desires. It was very realistic. The ending is definitely not a romance genre ending. It ends happily for some and not happily for others. I learned a lot about the history of the time while reading this. Very very worth reading. It did have more sexual content than I like or expected, and I don't give 5 stars to books where I didn't love the ending, no matter how well written.