Written by an ownvoices author, this was extremely perceptive about topics I hadn’t even considered thinking about. It’s a smart tale that reminds us the past really isn’t that important. What’s important is that you accept your mistakes, and find a better way.
CJ wouldn’t call herself ambitious, compared to her pursuing family. She simply enjoys working in the family’s flower shop, where her aunt aligns with her customers’ hearts with her ‘flower magic’. CJ is usually talentless, but she does seem to have a skill for arranging bouquets, and she’s proud of it. When her mother decides to sell the shop to the wealthy McAllisters, her world falls apart. The McAllisters are known for winning over property when Japanese Americans were thrown in internment camps by the government during World War II. It’s only a shop, and yet this sale can threaten her family and the whole community of Northern California with it. And this time, CJ refuses to remain passive: it’s time for action.
Sugiura neatly describes a wide array of important subjects, like the aftermath of poverty, complex family dynamics, the racism preceded by Pearl Harbor, drug abuse, teen pregnancy, abortion and cancer. Coming from a pink floral, delightful cover and the sweet synopsis, I never would have thought for those things to be mentioned. Better yet, there’s so much valid information in this novel that doesn’t get dumbed down. She fluently educates her readers on subjects that are usually deemed sensitive and unworthy to be put into contemporaries, and waves it into the plot with no effort. With a poignant, frank writing style, Sugiura also managed to make me laugh at various times.
CJ deeply cares about the feud harbored in her family, even though she doesn’t own the same persistence as her ancestors. She loves the personality of each flower in her hands, all taught to her by her eccentric aunt Hannah. CJ is used to disappointing people, so she yearns from the validation and pride she gets from her exceptional bouquet arrangements. Her family doesn’t score so great at romance either, so she has chosen not to believe in it. She can’t seem to find her vision in life, and it’s that what makes her incredibly authentic. She tends to judge easily, and to focus on her personal grudges and issues. That’s what teenagers do, and it merely showed vulnerability. She seems flawed and messy, but still honest.
Identity, race and sexuality were explored in detail in these characters. Unlike some novels, they didn’t get swooped to the back. Instead, they took over the plot. Owen might is a skinny history nerd who excels at trivia. He’s a little dramatic, but that’s what makes him charming. As someone who prefers sincerity, he refuses to be negative or demotivating most of the time. If anything, he brims with hope and optimism on several aspects, although there is some fear hidden there. He’s passionate, and based his life on principles, and was, in fact, a complete cinnamon roll. Emily is CJ’s best friend who has her own patisserie shop named after her. She isn’t afraid to speak the truth, and is open to forgiveness and acceptance. As a fiercely loyal out queer teen, her emotional depth was exceptionally layered. There were so many flavored characters that it was hard to pinpoint favorite ones, even though Hannah, Brynn and even Shane came close.
What I personally enjoyed most is that it didn’t shame the act of abortion. Most books tend to make the character stress too much about it, and subconsciously villainize the deed. Here, the character was very clear about it, and it’s shown that it’s okay not to be ready to raise a child. This novel well deserves the 4.5 stars. The only minor complaint I have about it is that it was hard to get into, and it didn’t really require 400 pages. Still, the book has some grand elements. The growth of each character became a gradual, believable improvement that fitted the authenticity of their roles perfectly. Especially CJ’s developing thought process was incredibly insightful. The inserted love triangle wasn’t annoying either, but necessary for CJ to come to terms with some things and herself. If anything, This Time Will Be Different had an important lesson that while clichéd remains one of my favorite quotes. Everyone is fighting a battle you know nothing about. Be kind, always.