What do you think?
Rate this book
The Root of Magic
A deeply felt sibling story set in a town where people have a mysterious magical power and one girl is determined to discover what it is, for readers of Lauren Myracle and Ingrid Law. Willow knows the unknown is scary. Especially when your little brother has been sick for a long time and nobody has been able to figure out why. All Willow wants is for her brother to get better and for her her life to go back to normal. But after a bad stroke of luck, Willow and her family find themselves stranded in an unusual town in the middle of nowhere and their life begins to change in the most unexpected way. Willow soon discovers that the town isn't just unusual—it's magical—and the truth is more exciting that she ever imagined.Will Willow find that this could be the secret to saving her family—or discover that the root of magic could lead them to something greater?
216 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 11, 2019
20 people are currently reading
247 people want to read
About the author
Kathleen Benner Duble
13 books56 followersKathleen Benner Duble had sixteen car accidents before she was twenty-one. Being an at-home writer keeps her from hitting the road (or anyone else)! She is the author of eight books for children. Kathleen loves digging for unique historical fiction plotlines and encouraging students and lovers of books to look for great stories right in their own backyard!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews
March 18, 2019
I received this book through NetGalley.
This thought-provoking middle grade book is about fate and the power of choice. Willow has become a miniature adult in her family. Her younger brother is deathly sick and undiagnosed despite endless tests; their mom is obsessed with curing the boy, with Willow ignored; and their dad has moved out, unable to handle anything. In the thick one of snowstorm, Willow, her mom, and brother wreck their car but find themselves promptly rescued by people from a small town. But Willow is soon unnerved by the weird way townsfolk predict what she will do. It’s like... magic.
I really enjoyed this book, and I really would have loved it as a kid. Willow is easy to relate to—smart, complicated, and nosy about the town secrets. Her family dynamics felt realistic. The moral dilemma presented by the book is handled well, too. It would open up opportunities for deep discussions between kids and adults about what they would choose and why.
This thought-provoking middle grade book is about fate and the power of choice. Willow has become a miniature adult in her family. Her younger brother is deathly sick and undiagnosed despite endless tests; their mom is obsessed with curing the boy, with Willow ignored; and their dad has moved out, unable to handle anything. In the thick one of snowstorm, Willow, her mom, and brother wreck their car but find themselves promptly rescued by people from a small town. But Willow is soon unnerved by the weird way townsfolk predict what she will do. It’s like... magic.
I really enjoyed this book, and I really would have loved it as a kid. Willow is easy to relate to—smart, complicated, and nosy about the town secrets. Her family dynamics felt realistic. The moral dilemma presented by the book is handled well, too. It would open up opportunities for deep discussions between kids and adults about what they would choose and why.
February 8, 2021
I was so happy to win this title from a blog giveaway hosted by Nicole at Bluestocking Thinking. I started reading it with my kiddos last year, but then when we began packing to move, we completely lost our place. So we started all over again at the end of January 2021.
Twelve-year-old Willow knows her parents are struggling to get along, but they’ll do whatever it takes to make sure her little brother, Wisp, gets the medical attention he needs. Some days are better than others, but he’s very sick and they don’t know what to do next. One night while returning home from Willow’s hockey game, their car goes over the edge of a secluded bridge. They are rescued just before the car falls to its doom, and when they enter the tiny village of Kismet, things begin to get eery. But the good news is that Wisp seems to be feeling better. In fact, Willow’s mom is in a much happier mood, too. The only problem is, why does Willow getting the feeling they may never leave? The story is mysterious and magical with lots of good discussion about fate and free will. It was a very successful read aloud and the writing was quite beautiful and touching. ❤
For more children's literature, middle grade literature, and YA literature reviews, feel free to visit my personal blog at The Miller Memo!!
----------------------
This was a surprisingly good read with so much to think about and discuss! The last 20ish pages had me on the edge of my seat and bumped it from 4 to 5 stars, for me. I read this one aloud with my children over 8 mornings. Full review to come soon...
Twelve-year-old Willow knows her parents are struggling to get along, but they’ll do whatever it takes to make sure her little brother, Wisp, gets the medical attention he needs. Some days are better than others, but he’s very sick and they don’t know what to do next. One night while returning home from Willow’s hockey game, their car goes over the edge of a secluded bridge. They are rescued just before the car falls to its doom, and when they enter the tiny village of Kismet, things begin to get eery. But the good news is that Wisp seems to be feeling better. In fact, Willow’s mom is in a much happier mood, too. The only problem is, why does Willow getting the feeling they may never leave? The story is mysterious and magical with lots of good discussion about fate and free will. It was a very successful read aloud and the writing was quite beautiful and touching. ❤
For more children's literature, middle grade literature, and YA literature reviews, feel free to visit my personal blog at The Miller Memo!!
----------------------
This was a surprisingly good read with so much to think about and discuss! The last 20ish pages had me on the edge of my seat and bumped it from 4 to 5 stars, for me. I read this one aloud with my children over 8 mornings. Full review to come soon...
Read
June 20, 2019This fantastically creative coming of age story is snowy, full of magic and intrigue, and dives into the power of choice over fate.
It's the perfect read for upper elementary school and middle school kids. -Megan G.
It's the perfect read for upper elementary school and middle school kids. -Megan G.
June 26, 2019
I had the opportunity to read a NetGalley digital ARC of this middle grade fantasy novel in exchange for a review. Navigating the rough waters of adolescence is tough, especially when you’re also faced with a health crisis in your family and the resulting strains on relationships. Willow’s younger brother, Wisp, has a rare, mysterious illness that affects his ability to eat and also makes him weak and tired much of the time. Willow’s mom is consumed with worry as she seeks out a cure from health care professionals, nutritionists, and any other promising source.
When an unexpected New England winter storm leaves the three of them stranded in Kismet, Maine with only the clothes they’re wearing, they have to rely on the kindness and generosity of the mysterious townspeople. Willow feels very uncomfortable with how much everyone seems to know about her and her family, even though they’ve never met. When a doctor in the town’s hospital seems to have a promising treatment for Wisp’s condition, Willow’s mom decides to stay in Kismet indefinitely.
Willow meets some of the other kids her age that live in Kismet, and what she learns about the town’s magic only leads to more questions. She becomes romantically close to Topher, who is about to turn thirteen. When kids in this town turn thirteen, they are required to either accept the magic of the town or leave forever. This story will have readers wondering if they would prefer the assurance of always knowing what is going to happen next (even if you’re bound to accept the fate that has been shown to you) or enjoying the surprises that come your way and somehow finding the courage to face life head on in the face of the unknown.
The story moves along pretty quickly, and I think that readers who enjoy a little romance with their magical situations will enjoy this book. The romance is written appropriately for middle grade students (grades 5-8) with hand holding, hugging, and a kiss or two. The book has a good climax in which readers will really want to find out what the characters will decide. It could also generate some good discussions for groups or pairs that read the book together.
When an unexpected New England winter storm leaves the three of them stranded in Kismet, Maine with only the clothes they’re wearing, they have to rely on the kindness and generosity of the mysterious townspeople. Willow feels very uncomfortable with how much everyone seems to know about her and her family, even though they’ve never met. When a doctor in the town’s hospital seems to have a promising treatment for Wisp’s condition, Willow’s mom decides to stay in Kismet indefinitely.
Willow meets some of the other kids her age that live in Kismet, and what she learns about the town’s magic only leads to more questions. She becomes romantically close to Topher, who is about to turn thirteen. When kids in this town turn thirteen, they are required to either accept the magic of the town or leave forever. This story will have readers wondering if they would prefer the assurance of always knowing what is going to happen next (even if you’re bound to accept the fate that has been shown to you) or enjoying the surprises that come your way and somehow finding the courage to face life head on in the face of the unknown.
The story moves along pretty quickly, and I think that readers who enjoy a little romance with their magical situations will enjoy this book. The romance is written appropriately for middle grade students (grades 5-8) with hand holding, hugging, and a kiss or two. The book has a good climax in which readers will really want to find out what the characters will decide. It could also generate some good discussions for groups or pairs that read the book together.
April 19, 2019
@kidlitexchange #partner: The Root of Magic by Kathleen Benner Duble. Releases June 11th, 2019.
—————
The Root of Magic is written in third-person present-tense. If you can get used to that, you’ll have no problem. I had to get used to it, but it still in no way distracted me from the plot.
In The Root of Magic, a small family finds themselves stranded by a snowstorm in a town where right away, everything feels “off.” In fact, to me, before I knew what was going on, it felt downright sinister, but maybe I’ve read too much dark YA lately. Everyone acts weird and no one will explain what’s going on. Willow, our young main character, ultimately discovers the truth: the town itself is magic, with a supernatural mind and will of its own, and everyone age 13 and up must make a decision. They can stay, trapped forever by the town, and gain the ability to see into the future one day at a time—or they can leave and never see their families again.
The Root of Magic raises the complex issues of our predetermined destinies, our free will, and how on earth the two can ever coexist. On June 11, you can enter this troubling town of secrets and dark magic yourself. Thank you @kidlitexchange and @randomhousekids for the review copy—all opinions are my own.
—————
The Root of Magic is written in third-person present-tense. If you can get used to that, you’ll have no problem. I had to get used to it, but it still in no way distracted me from the plot.
In The Root of Magic, a small family finds themselves stranded by a snowstorm in a town where right away, everything feels “off.” In fact, to me, before I knew what was going on, it felt downright sinister, but maybe I’ve read too much dark YA lately. Everyone acts weird and no one will explain what’s going on. Willow, our young main character, ultimately discovers the truth: the town itself is magic, with a supernatural mind and will of its own, and everyone age 13 and up must make a decision. They can stay, trapped forever by the town, and gain the ability to see into the future one day at a time—or they can leave and never see their families again.
The Root of Magic raises the complex issues of our predetermined destinies, our free will, and how on earth the two can ever coexist. On June 11, you can enter this troubling town of secrets and dark magic yourself. Thank you @kidlitexchange and @randomhousekids for the review copy—all opinions are my own.
July 3, 2019
I received a free review copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
THE ROOT OF MAGIC is an interesting middle grade book about fate, free will, and family. The writing was well done and I was engaged enough to keep reading. I wanted to discover the source of the magic in the mysterious town of Kismet.
While I enjoyed the book thematically, I cannot recommend it to young readers. Here's why: there are basically two mean girl characters in this book. One is described as "girl next door" -- what does that mean to you? To most readers, it will mean white and probably blonde.
The other is described as "exotic" -- what does that mean to you? The "exotic" character is later revealed to be dark-skinned and is the only character in the book whose skin tone is noted at all. She turns out to be the meaner of the two...no positive side of her character is ever revealed.
It is well documented that people of color are insulted by being labeled as "exotic," the definition of which is "originating from a foreign country" and is often used to describe plants and animals (not humans). And to have the only obvious person of color in the book be the villain is just...it's not OK.
This was a relatively minor plot point in the book, but there is really no excuse for these types of ignorant references to race in children's literature in 2019. It's really a shame because it could have easily been spotted and edited out, and the author would have had a fine book.
THE ROOT OF MAGIC is an interesting middle grade book about fate, free will, and family. The writing was well done and I was engaged enough to keep reading. I wanted to discover the source of the magic in the mysterious town of Kismet.
While I enjoyed the book thematically, I cannot recommend it to young readers. Here's why: there are basically two mean girl characters in this book. One is described as "girl next door" -- what does that mean to you? To most readers, it will mean white and probably blonde.
The other is described as "exotic" -- what does that mean to you? The "exotic" character is later revealed to be dark-skinned and is the only character in the book whose skin tone is noted at all. She turns out to be the meaner of the two...no positive side of her character is ever revealed.
It is well documented that people of color are insulted by being labeled as "exotic," the definition of which is "originating from a foreign country" and is often used to describe plants and animals (not humans). And to have the only obvious person of color in the book be the villain is just...it's not OK.
This was a relatively minor plot point in the book, but there is really no excuse for these types of ignorant references to race in children's literature in 2019. It's really a shame because it could have easily been spotted and edited out, and the author would have had a fine book.
March 12, 2023
Required reading for my son. We both thought it was okay. It definitely got a lot more interesting at the end of the book, but was kind of dragging before then.
May 29, 2019
One of the big questions posed by The Root of Magic is the difference between fate and free will. Fate being that your life is preplanned, already decided versus the free will of choosing your own path, having the ability to change things yourself. The characters in the story are given an opportunity to know what each day has in store for them, the knowledge of everything that is to happen tomorrow and the time to prepare for it. A life that is predictable, ordered, knowing what to expect, with less of the stress of the unknown. Yet, although it may bring peace of mind, what do you give up in the process? What about being spontaneous, the joy of surprising someone? What are you loosing with knowing tomorrow? This is the dilemma that faces Willow when she enters the town of Kismet. Something she isn't really fully aware of until she meets Topher. Willow's mom's decision seems to be clear, she wants the knowledge of tomorrow, but in the end, its Willow that has to make the choice whether this is a future that she wants. Even though Wisp is so ill and she longs for the familiar way things used to be before, maybe Willow's also ready to deal with the pain of the unknown. I really enjoyed The Root of Magic, it gives you a lot to ponder and I always enjoy mysterious towns, especially during the winter.
*Review copy provided by BlueSlip Media in exchange for an honest review*
*Review copy provided by BlueSlip Media in exchange for an honest review*
July 21, 2019
I loved this book! This is a middle grade novel you won't want to miss.
It's a quiet book with a quiet cover. It wasn't released with a ton of fanfare, so I could see how most people would pass over this book in favor of something with a bright, colorful cover or a book with a ton of hype around it. But that would be a mistake. This book is beautiful. A delight. It's a genuine story with a deeper message.
It's about Willow, her brother Wisp, and their mother. They're traveling home from a hockey game when they get caught in a blizzard and nearly plunge into a river. They are saved by some kind souls and taken to a B&B in a small town called Kismet. While they wait out the storm and get to know the townspeople better, Willow and her family realize that there is something strange about the town.
This book is a little bit spooky in a few spots, but it's not scary. I loved the story. I loved Willow and her new friend Topher. I loved her bravery and her courage. She has deep thoughts for a twelve-year-old and she fights hard to save herself and her family.
The story raises questions about fate, choices, magic, family, and free will. It would be fantastic for a middle school book club, family book club, or classroom discussion.
This isn't a long book. It's just over 200 pages, so if you want something short, magical, and completely heartfelt, pick this one up. It's a quiet gem and it's 100% worth the read. I highly recommend it!
Content: one innocent kiss (male/female).
Source: The publisher sent me a copy of this book.
It's a quiet book with a quiet cover. It wasn't released with a ton of fanfare, so I could see how most people would pass over this book in favor of something with a bright, colorful cover or a book with a ton of hype around it. But that would be a mistake. This book is beautiful. A delight. It's a genuine story with a deeper message.
It's about Willow, her brother Wisp, and their mother. They're traveling home from a hockey game when they get caught in a blizzard and nearly plunge into a river. They are saved by some kind souls and taken to a B&B in a small town called Kismet. While they wait out the storm and get to know the townspeople better, Willow and her family realize that there is something strange about the town.
This book is a little bit spooky in a few spots, but it's not scary. I loved the story. I loved Willow and her new friend Topher. I loved her bravery and her courage. She has deep thoughts for a twelve-year-old and she fights hard to save herself and her family.
The story raises questions about fate, choices, magic, family, and free will. It would be fantastic for a middle school book club, family book club, or classroom discussion.
This isn't a long book. It's just over 200 pages, so if you want something short, magical, and completely heartfelt, pick this one up. It's a quiet gem and it's 100% worth the read. I highly recommend it!
Content: one innocent kiss (male/female).
Source: The publisher sent me a copy of this book.
January 16, 2023
3.75 stars!
What originally drew me to this book was the winter setting paired with a magical town. I love cozy middle grades and I’m always on the hunt for stories set in winter that aren’t about Christmas. This fit the bill in that regard perfectly. Willow and her little brother Wisp find themselves along with their mom in an unusual town after they get lost and slide off the road in the middle of a blizzard. Willow suspects there is something off about the town of Kismet right away but when their mom wakes up one morning acting completely relaxed and stress-free Willow is certain something is wrong. Ever since her little brother Wisp became ill with an undiagnosed condition their mom has cared about little else and rarely even smiles. It would take a miracle to make her mom relaxed and happy like she used to be but even those come with a cost.
My first impression of this book was that it wasn’t as cozy as I was hoping for. In the opening chapters we learn that Willow’s little brother Wisp has a mysterious illness, their parents have divorced over disagreements regarding his illness, and they’ve just had a car accident after getting lost in a blizzard. Pretty heavy stuff for the first couple of chapters of a middle grade book. I have no qualms with heavy topics in novels targeted for this age group it just wasn’t giving the vibes I was hoping for when I purchased this book. As the story progressed I found myself getting a bit annoyed with Willow. While I understand her point of view regarding her brother’s sickness and her mom’s behavior in the wake of it I felt it could have been done with a bit more sensitivity. I think Willow’s personality was a bit abrasive. The same viewpoints could have been shared in a more palatable way that didn’t involve the disrespect and disregard of her mother’s choices and reasoning. I realize I’m viewing this through a mothers lens- and I have two teenage daughters that would never approach me the way Willow does her mom so I have a biased opinion here. I’m sure the 12-year-old kids this narrative is targeted towards would relate more with Willow than I did but with that in mind I also think the author should have taken the opportunity to provide a good example for said readers.
Topher is a great character. He remains upbeat and respectful even though it’s clear that he isn’t as happy as everyone else about the things going on in Kismet. He definitely displays the behavior I was hoping to see in Willow but I also appreciate the individualism present in all the characters. In Willows case I do think she displays some points of view that are a bit odd for a child of her age- the types of ideas you expect from an adult who has some life experience under their belt. I agreed with her thoughts but felt they were a bit weird for a young girl.
The magic present in the story is definitely unique- I’ve not seen anything like it in any other books I’ve read so I always appreciate that. Although I have seen a similar idea in a hallmark movie I once saw and funnily enough the town’s name in this book is also a word found in the title of this hallmark Christmas movie that I’m referring to.. so there’s a little hint for you- the premise of the magic in that movie is very similar. It makes me wonder if the author took inspiration from that movie or vice versa.
The nature of the magic in this book offers a legitimate conflict which is important for my enjoyment of the story. A weak conflict or the use of miscommunication to further a plot annoys me to no end. But the elements in The Root of Magic force you to choose between two seemingly impossible things and when I considered what I’d have chosen I was genuinely torn. This meant the ending of the book had more of an impact and I really liked the direction that it went and how the conclusion to the story played into the themes present in the rest of the novel.
What originally drew me to this book was the winter setting paired with a magical town. I love cozy middle grades and I’m always on the hunt for stories set in winter that aren’t about Christmas. This fit the bill in that regard perfectly. Willow and her little brother Wisp find themselves along with their mom in an unusual town after they get lost and slide off the road in the middle of a blizzard. Willow suspects there is something off about the town of Kismet right away but when their mom wakes up one morning acting completely relaxed and stress-free Willow is certain something is wrong. Ever since her little brother Wisp became ill with an undiagnosed condition their mom has cared about little else and rarely even smiles. It would take a miracle to make her mom relaxed and happy like she used to be but even those come with a cost.
My first impression of this book was that it wasn’t as cozy as I was hoping for. In the opening chapters we learn that Willow’s little brother Wisp has a mysterious illness, their parents have divorced over disagreements regarding his illness, and they’ve just had a car accident after getting lost in a blizzard. Pretty heavy stuff for the first couple of chapters of a middle grade book. I have no qualms with heavy topics in novels targeted for this age group it just wasn’t giving the vibes I was hoping for when I purchased this book. As the story progressed I found myself getting a bit annoyed with Willow. While I understand her point of view regarding her brother’s sickness and her mom’s behavior in the wake of it I felt it could have been done with a bit more sensitivity. I think Willow’s personality was a bit abrasive. The same viewpoints could have been shared in a more palatable way that didn’t involve the disrespect and disregard of her mother’s choices and reasoning. I realize I’m viewing this through a mothers lens- and I have two teenage daughters that would never approach me the way Willow does her mom so I have a biased opinion here. I’m sure the 12-year-old kids this narrative is targeted towards would relate more with Willow than I did but with that in mind I also think the author should have taken the opportunity to provide a good example for said readers.
Topher is a great character. He remains upbeat and respectful even though it’s clear that he isn’t as happy as everyone else about the things going on in Kismet. He definitely displays the behavior I was hoping to see in Willow but I also appreciate the individualism present in all the characters. In Willows case I do think she displays some points of view that are a bit odd for a child of her age- the types of ideas you expect from an adult who has some life experience under their belt. I agreed with her thoughts but felt they were a bit weird for a young girl.
The magic present in the story is definitely unique- I’ve not seen anything like it in any other books I’ve read so I always appreciate that. Although I have seen a similar idea in a hallmark movie I once saw and funnily enough the town’s name in this book is also a word found in the title of this hallmark Christmas movie that I’m referring to.. so there’s a little hint for you- the premise of the magic in that movie is very similar. It makes me wonder if the author took inspiration from that movie or vice versa.
The nature of the magic in this book offers a legitimate conflict which is important for my enjoyment of the story. A weak conflict or the use of miscommunication to further a plot annoys me to no end. But the elements in The Root of Magic force you to choose between two seemingly impossible things and when I considered what I’d have chosen I was genuinely torn. This meant the ending of the book had more of an impact and I really liked the direction that it went and how the conclusion to the story played into the themes present in the rest of the novel.
October 3, 2025
2.8 stars
i have a soft spot for this type of supernatural/slice-of-life/mystery middle grade, but this story fell a bit flat in its execution; almost completely failing in its mystery and atmosphere, mostly due to overtly clear and repetitive writing.
this book lacks something that i feel makes books like this good, or at least better; an "establishing of the mundane". i would say it should go something more like: "Welcome to our town! Yes it is weird, but it is normal to us (a mundane, you could say), and it might even be better than your normal!" while this book tries to do: "Welcome to out town! Yes it is weird, we have a secret and you cant know it, but it makes life here so much better!" they may seem similar but are night and day when reading.
most of the first half is meant to be a mystery - i think, but most of it is simply being told in very clear-cut and repetitive writing *about* the fact there is a mystery. in the FIRST conversation Willow has with the boy with two colour eyes, he mentions very obviously the fact that there is something here to hide. people constantly tell Willow in conversations to her face, that there is a secret, but just flat out ignore her when she questions more. all this "mystery" is, is Willow rumination back and forth on what it MIGHT be, and making a mental list over and over and over and over about all the weird things that have happened, and people flat out saying that there is a mystery but refusing to elaborate. very engaging stuff.
the second half, after the whole 'mystery' Band-Aid is ripped off, becomes more of a moral debate. this is somewhat better, thank god, but still not quite good. again most of it is very repetitive listing pros and cons and such, debating and discussing futures and morals and the like, mainly relating to the magic system and leaving or staying in the town. i thought that the impact of not being able to change your future after you saw it, to be such a larger problem then having days be boring because of have to live them twice, which just made the moral discussions seem stupid and juvenile to me.
the characters and dialogue are inconsistent enough to be noticeable. at one point Willow's 8 year old brother, Wisp, gives her 10/11 year old sister a motivational pep talk with a moral discussion on the side and not a hind of hurt feelings after overhearing himself talked about as a nuisance. it was completely unrealistic that it took me out of the book full stop. however, one point about the characters i really enjoyed was the inclusion of the troubled family dynamics; Wisp's sickness. the divorced parents because of arguments over treatments. uprooting Willows life because of the illness. Wisp losing people around him who don't want to be friends with a sick kid. it is all-around very respectful on all parts!
did i enjoy it? -in parts
would i read it again? -no
would i have read it knowing what i do after? -no
i have a soft spot for this type of supernatural/slice-of-life/mystery middle grade, but this story fell a bit flat in its execution; almost completely failing in its mystery and atmosphere, mostly due to overtly clear and repetitive writing.
this book lacks something that i feel makes books like this good, or at least better; an "establishing of the mundane". i would say it should go something more like: "Welcome to our town! Yes it is weird, but it is normal to us (a mundane, you could say), and it might even be better than your normal!" while this book tries to do: "Welcome to out town! Yes it is weird, we have a secret and you cant know it, but it makes life here so much better!" they may seem similar but are night and day when reading.
most of the first half is meant to be a mystery - i think, but most of it is simply being told in very clear-cut and repetitive writing *about* the fact there is a mystery. in the FIRST conversation Willow has with the boy with two colour eyes, he mentions very obviously the fact that there is something here to hide. people constantly tell Willow in conversations to her face, that there is a secret, but just flat out ignore her when she questions more. all this "mystery" is, is Willow rumination back and forth on what it MIGHT be, and making a mental list over and over and over and over about all the weird things that have happened, and people flat out saying that there is a mystery but refusing to elaborate. very engaging stuff.
the second half, after the whole 'mystery' Band-Aid is ripped off, becomes more of a moral debate. this is somewhat better, thank god, but still not quite good. again most of it is very repetitive listing pros and cons and such, debating and discussing futures and morals and the like, mainly relating to the magic system and leaving or staying in the town. i thought that the impact of not being able to change your future after you saw it, to be such a larger problem then having days be boring because of have to live them twice, which just made the moral discussions seem stupid and juvenile to me.
the characters and dialogue are inconsistent enough to be noticeable. at one point Willow's 8 year old brother, Wisp, gives her 10/11 year old sister a motivational pep talk with a moral discussion on the side and not a hind of hurt feelings after overhearing himself talked about as a nuisance. it was completely unrealistic that it took me out of the book full stop. however, one point about the characters i really enjoyed was the inclusion of the troubled family dynamics; Wisp's sickness. the divorced parents because of arguments over treatments. uprooting Willows life because of the illness. Wisp losing people around him who don't want to be friends with a sick kid. it is all-around very respectful on all parts!
did i enjoy it? -in parts
would i read it again? -no
would i have read it knowing what i do after? -no
June 11, 2019
"The true magic of life lies in those days that are not yet known."
There is power in choice, but how does it relate to fate. A fun thought to discuss. This short middle grade fiction has a creative storyline, magic, intrigue, a strong protagonist, family/sibling relationship, and topics that are hard but kids can relate to. Willow's brother Wisp is sick, and the doctors can't solve it. The impact his sickness has on his friendships, sibling relationship, and on his parents is well written. This book would make a great bibliotherapy book for kids with a sick sibling.
To be honest, the story for an adult is a bit predictable, but I actually didn't mind the predictability, b/c there was enough intrigue. I doubt many kids will be able to predict the storyline.
Rating: 4/5 stars
Best For: 9-12 years old, 3rd through 6th grade girls
# of Pages: 212
Clean Read: Yes.
Worth a Check Out: Yes.
Buy It or Not: Maybe. If you're looking for a great story to read with your children or class.
Read Aloud: Yes. It could be a great read aloud for 3rd-6th grade. The chapters are shorter, but the intrigue is there. There would be a lot of things you could discuss and talk about. With a girl as a main character, boys won't pick this book up themselves. However, I think they'd enjoy the story.
Some favorite quotes:
"Anger and sorrow fill her, like baking soda and vinegar thrown together in a glass and about to fizz over. Willow doesn't know what to do about these feelings." pg 19
"Battles are usually unexpected. And I don't like being unprepared." pg30
"Nobody promised you fair when you came into this world, girl," Cora says. "And nobody promised you fair on how or when you go out. The best you can do is to be prepared." pg50
"But maybe, she things, loving someone who is ill means finding the courage to face the pain you know will be yours if the unthinkable should happen." pg101
Thank you Blue Slip Media for the book to read. All thoughts and opinions are mine.
There is power in choice, but how does it relate to fate. A fun thought to discuss. This short middle grade fiction has a creative storyline, magic, intrigue, a strong protagonist, family/sibling relationship, and topics that are hard but kids can relate to. Willow's brother Wisp is sick, and the doctors can't solve it. The impact his sickness has on his friendships, sibling relationship, and on his parents is well written. This book would make a great bibliotherapy book for kids with a sick sibling.
To be honest, the story for an adult is a bit predictable, but I actually didn't mind the predictability, b/c there was enough intrigue. I doubt many kids will be able to predict the storyline.
Rating: 4/5 stars
Best For: 9-12 years old, 3rd through 6th grade girls
# of Pages: 212
Clean Read: Yes.
Worth a Check Out: Yes.
Buy It or Not: Maybe. If you're looking for a great story to read with your children or class.
Read Aloud: Yes. It could be a great read aloud for 3rd-6th grade. The chapters are shorter, but the intrigue is there. There would be a lot of things you could discuss and talk about. With a girl as a main character, boys won't pick this book up themselves. However, I think they'd enjoy the story.
Some favorite quotes:
"Anger and sorrow fill her, like baking soda and vinegar thrown together in a glass and about to fizz over. Willow doesn't know what to do about these feelings." pg 19
"Battles are usually unexpected. And I don't like being unprepared." pg30
"Nobody promised you fair when you came into this world, girl," Cora says. "And nobody promised you fair on how or when you go out. The best you can do is to be prepared." pg50
"But maybe, she things, loving someone who is ill means finding the courage to face the pain you know will be yours if the unthinkable should happen." pg101
Thank you Blue Slip Media for the book to read. All thoughts and opinions are mine.
August 5, 2019
@kidlitexchange #partner “Thanks to the @kidlitexchange network for the
review copy of this book - all opinions are my own.”
Think you want to know the future? Even for a day at a time? Even if you know you can’t change it? In The Root of Magic, Kathleen Benner Duble explores this kind of magic in the town of Kismet. It’s an enchanted tale of magic, friendship, loyalty, family, and hope - and quite a delightful tale at that!
Precocious Willow DuChard’s world has been turned upside down due to her brother, Wisp’s, illness. (Yes, Willow and Wisp! Name choice is explained eventually, and it’s a cute explanation)! Now everything in her life is put on the back burner - including hockey - as her mother seeks treatment, doing anything and everything possible to find a cure for Wisp’s mysterious illness. When the three of them land in Kismet, things start to change. But Willow knows that something odd is happening and she cannot keep her mother from getting pulled in by the magic of it all. Out of necessity, Willow becomes the voice of reason and assumes the role of the adult in the family as her mother gets swept into the prospect of finding a cure.
There’s plenty going on in this story to keep it engaging. Willow’s character is well-developed and likable. She gives up a lot as any sibling does when a family member faces health concerns, and most times it is willingly, even though you can sense her frustration with all the attention given Wisp. Her friendship with Topher is believable, and the bullying from the other girls seems plausible. Overall, an enjoyable read...probably best for the 5th-7th grade classroom but a good lesson for anyone pondering fate vs free will. For “the true magic of life lies in those days that are not yet known.”
review copy of this book - all opinions are my own.”
Think you want to know the future? Even for a day at a time? Even if you know you can’t change it? In The Root of Magic, Kathleen Benner Duble explores this kind of magic in the town of Kismet. It’s an enchanted tale of magic, friendship, loyalty, family, and hope - and quite a delightful tale at that!
Precocious Willow DuChard’s world has been turned upside down due to her brother, Wisp’s, illness. (Yes, Willow and Wisp! Name choice is explained eventually, and it’s a cute explanation)! Now everything in her life is put on the back burner - including hockey - as her mother seeks treatment, doing anything and everything possible to find a cure for Wisp’s mysterious illness. When the three of them land in Kismet, things start to change. But Willow knows that something odd is happening and she cannot keep her mother from getting pulled in by the magic of it all. Out of necessity, Willow becomes the voice of reason and assumes the role of the adult in the family as her mother gets swept into the prospect of finding a cure.
There’s plenty going on in this story to keep it engaging. Willow’s character is well-developed and likable. She gives up a lot as any sibling does when a family member faces health concerns, and most times it is willingly, even though you can sense her frustration with all the attention given Wisp. Her friendship with Topher is believable, and the bullying from the other girls seems plausible. Overall, an enjoyable read...probably best for the 5th-7th grade classroom but a good lesson for anyone pondering fate vs free will. For “the true magic of life lies in those days that are not yet known.”
June 29, 2019
@kidlitexchange # partner
Thank you to the #kidlitexchange network and the publisher for the advance copy of The Root of Magic by Kathleen Benner Duble. This book was released on June 11, 2019.
Two years ago things changed for Willow when her brother fell ill. He has a mysterious illness that doctors haven't been able to figure out. In those two years, her parents separated as they had differing views of how to care for Wisp, Willow's brother. The separation is bitter and Willow's mom seems to despise her father and blames him for them being caught in a snow storm. During the snow storm, their car crashes on a bridge and Wisp, Willow, and their mom are saved just before their car topples into the icy river below. Their rescuers take them to a very small Canadian town called Kismet. Willow soon realizes that there is something odd about Kismet and its residents. Soon, she realizes that the town is magic, but the magic comes with a choice; one that Willow doesn't know if she's willing, or even capable, of making.
This was an intriguing concept for a book that deals with an important topic: free will. Willow has a lot on her shoulders and is a character that some readers will connect strongly to. Though she loves her brother, she feels as if her mom's world revolves solely around Wisp and his illness meaning that she often gets forgotten. She raises some great questions about motivation and why we do what we do (whether it is for ourselves or someone else). She also questions whether one person has the right to make a decision for another and whether or not free will outweighs fate. The story has mystery and magic and is sure to pull in a middle grade reader.
Thank you to the #kidlitexchange network and the publisher for the advance copy of The Root of Magic by Kathleen Benner Duble. This book was released on June 11, 2019.
Two years ago things changed for Willow when her brother fell ill. He has a mysterious illness that doctors haven't been able to figure out. In those two years, her parents separated as they had differing views of how to care for Wisp, Willow's brother. The separation is bitter and Willow's mom seems to despise her father and blames him for them being caught in a snow storm. During the snow storm, their car crashes on a bridge and Wisp, Willow, and their mom are saved just before their car topples into the icy river below. Their rescuers take them to a very small Canadian town called Kismet. Willow soon realizes that there is something odd about Kismet and its residents. Soon, she realizes that the town is magic, but the magic comes with a choice; one that Willow doesn't know if she's willing, or even capable, of making.
This was an intriguing concept for a book that deals with an important topic: free will. Willow has a lot on her shoulders and is a character that some readers will connect strongly to. Though she loves her brother, she feels as if her mom's world revolves solely around Wisp and his illness meaning that she often gets forgotten. She raises some great questions about motivation and why we do what we do (whether it is for ourselves or someone else). She also questions whether one person has the right to make a decision for another and whether or not free will outweighs fate. The story has mystery and magic and is sure to pull in a middle grade reader.
June 8, 2019
Thank you to Blue Slip Media for a review copy. All opinions are my own.
Willow and her family (sans father) find themselves in Kismet, Vermont after nearly going off a bridge during a snowstorm. Willow's younger brother is very sick, though the doctors can't figure out what is actually wrong with him. While their mother initially wants to get back on the road as quickly as possible, there is a magical undertone to the town that is luring her in.
Willow knows that something is off about the town the moment they get there. Cora, the woman who owns the B&B, makes up a room for 3, including a roll-away bed with a bucket next to it in case Wisp gets sick. In the morning, Cora gets Willow grapefruit juice, an unusual choice, before she even asks for it. Somehow everyone is always one step ahead of them. Willow tries to go along with it and gets enjoyment out of a friendship with young Topher, whose mother is the town doctor and who is trying to help Wisp.
When the truth comes out, Willow faces the question of whether knowing what the next day holds is a good thing or a bad thing. Should we follow what is out "fate" or should we be able to have free will over our own lives? Both Willow and Topher struggle with the question and the painful choice that if they don't want to adhere to the town secret, they must leave and never see their families again.
The story is somewhat dark, but engaging just the same. For 8-12 year olds who enjoy a little bit of magic with their stories, this is a good choice.
Willow and her family (sans father) find themselves in Kismet, Vermont after nearly going off a bridge during a snowstorm. Willow's younger brother is very sick, though the doctors can't figure out what is actually wrong with him. While their mother initially wants to get back on the road as quickly as possible, there is a magical undertone to the town that is luring her in.
Willow knows that something is off about the town the moment they get there. Cora, the woman who owns the B&B, makes up a room for 3, including a roll-away bed with a bucket next to it in case Wisp gets sick. In the morning, Cora gets Willow grapefruit juice, an unusual choice, before she even asks for it. Somehow everyone is always one step ahead of them. Willow tries to go along with it and gets enjoyment out of a friendship with young Topher, whose mother is the town doctor and who is trying to help Wisp.
When the truth comes out, Willow faces the question of whether knowing what the next day holds is a good thing or a bad thing. Should we follow what is out "fate" or should we be able to have free will over our own lives? Both Willow and Topher struggle with the question and the painful choice that if they don't want to adhere to the town secret, they must leave and never see their families again.
The story is somewhat dark, but engaging just the same. For 8-12 year olds who enjoy a little bit of magic with their stories, this is a good choice.
June 16, 2019
Willow is returning from a hockey game when a sudden snowstorm appears and causes an accident. An accident that could had been deadly if someone hadn’t shown up in time to rescue them. Willow ‘s mom is always worried about Willow’s little brother Wisp—a very sick boy. When they are rescued they are taken to a bed and breakfast in Kismet, Maine. Kismet is a very small town — less than 200 people. The people are all very friendly but strange. They seem to know what is going to happen before it does. It spooks Willow. Why? Her mom who has been constantly worried about Wisp, but suddenly stops in Kismet. Why? Willow gets a friend who gives mysterious hints about Kismet, which only frustrates her more. When the kids of Kismet turn 13, they must make a decision to live in Kismet forever or leave. If they decide to leave, they can never go back to Kismet. Why? How can a 13 year old make that type of decision?
It is an engaging mysterious story with a secret that isn’t told to outsiders. The hints given in this mystery kept me intrigue in this well written book. I hated to have it end. The characters are well developed and described. The plot of the story is excellent. It gave me a question that made me think what my answer would be.
Disclaimer: I received an arc of this book from the author/publisher from Netgalley. I wasn’t obligated to write a favorable review or any review at all. The opinions expressed are strictly my own.
It is an engaging mysterious story with a secret that isn’t told to outsiders. The hints given in this mystery kept me intrigue in this well written book. I hated to have it end. The characters are well developed and described. The plot of the story is excellent. It gave me a question that made me think what my answer would be.
Disclaimer: I received an arc of this book from the author/publisher from Netgalley. I wasn’t obligated to write a favorable review or any review at all. The opinions expressed are strictly my own.
July 22, 2019
The Root of Magic is a beautiful novel about family and making hard choices. Willow, her mother and little brother Wisp are in a car accident which leads them to a small town which has a secret. Wisp is always sick and Willow only wants him to get better. When her mother decides they maybe should stay in the strange town, she knows something odd is going on. There’s only one phone in the whole town at the bed and breakfast they are staying at and no one seems to leave the town.
When Willow learns the truth, she decides to do something dramatic, something no one can predict.
I really enjoyed this novel, about a girl who has been given a choice and knows what she wants in life. This book is about making that choice a reality even when obstacles stand in her way. The magical aspect of the book was quite interesting, I wasn’t quite sure what was going to be discovered. I thought there may be a bit more conflict towards the end, but it was more mild than I expected.
I also enjoyed the slight romance between Willow and Topher, a boy from the town who I was sort of worried would make her think of staying. Topher is a kind and responsible boy who seems a bit different from the other kids in the town. I like their interactions together and the little romantic moments they share – definitely an appropriate romance for a MG novel.
Verdict:
A great novel about making choices and standing your ground all with a twist of magic.
When Willow learns the truth, she decides to do something dramatic, something no one can predict.
I really enjoyed this novel, about a girl who has been given a choice and knows what she wants in life. This book is about making that choice a reality even when obstacles stand in her way. The magical aspect of the book was quite interesting, I wasn’t quite sure what was going to be discovered. I thought there may be a bit more conflict towards the end, but it was more mild than I expected.
I also enjoyed the slight romance between Willow and Topher, a boy from the town who I was sort of worried would make her think of staying. Topher is a kind and responsible boy who seems a bit different from the other kids in the town. I like their interactions together and the little romantic moments they share – definitely an appropriate romance for a MG novel.
Verdict:
A great novel about making choices and standing your ground all with a twist of magic.
August 22, 2019
While traveling home from an ice hockey game with her mother and little brother Wisp, twelve-year-old Willow DuChard stumbles upon a strange village. The family almost perishes in an accident in a blinding snowstorm, and the residents quickly rescue them. The townspeople are friendly enough, but Willow becomes increasingly certain that there's something odd about the villagers and how they seem almost able to read her mind or predict future action. Willow can't wait for the storm to abate so she can return home to her familiar surroundings, but her mother seems increasingly caught up in the magic of the town. Because Wisp suffers from an unknown illness, their mother worries constantly. Staying in the town offers her a respite from those worries. But as Willow comes to realize, there is a price to be paid for certainty and predictability. Readers will find the bond between the siblings realistic and enjoy watching the budding romance between Willow and Topher, soon to be 13 and on the verge of making a very important decision that will mean all the difference in the world in how he lives the rest of his life. I never doubted that Willow herself would make the decision she did, but I wasn't sure about Topher.
January 20, 2022
This was… interesting. Super reminiscent of Tuck Everlasting. I would have given it three stars myself, but my kids really enjoyed it as a read aloud. I’ll try to give a brief review without spoiling anything.
The big, terrible secret of the town of Kismet, Maine was pretty easy to figure out. Like, not just easy for the reader but should have been painfully obvious to the main character. There were many places, actually, where the MC had an “aha!!” moment that didn’t make much sense because it seemed like she would have already understood that revelation.
That said, it was a cute story all the way through. The townspeople were represented well, as in not bad people per se but people who had their reasons for wanting things to remain as they were. I also thought the blossoming relationship between the MC and the boy, Topher, was sweet and tastefully written.
Parent warnings: There is a scene where MC gives him a kiss, like a sweet first kiss. There is also a scene where they sneak off in the morning for a day spent “ice boating.” Innocent, but sneaky, and there were consequences for this decision. Not that I have a problem with these things, I just like to mention things like this in case it is reason to skip this book with your own kids.
The big, terrible secret of the town of Kismet, Maine was pretty easy to figure out. Like, not just easy for the reader but should have been painfully obvious to the main character. There were many places, actually, where the MC had an “aha!!” moment that didn’t make much sense because it seemed like she would have already understood that revelation.
That said, it was a cute story all the way through. The townspeople were represented well, as in not bad people per se but people who had their reasons for wanting things to remain as they were. I also thought the blossoming relationship between the MC and the boy, Topher, was sweet and tastefully written.
Parent warnings: There is a scene where MC gives him a kiss, like a sweet first kiss. There is also a scene where they sneak off in the morning for a day spent “ice boating.” Innocent, but sneaky, and there were consequences for this decision. Not that I have a problem with these things, I just like to mention things like this in case it is reason to skip this book with your own kids.
June 21, 2019
-Thanks to the @kidlitexchange network for the review copy of this book— all opinions are my own-
____
The Root of magic by Kathleen Benner Duble is a book about discovering who you truly want to be even in the face of rejection.
Willow is a strong, caring character who finds herself feeling alone due to her brother’s illness. Her brother, Wisp, has taken over their mom’s attention due to medical conditions that cannot be explained. In a trip, Willow and her family find themselves stranded in an odd town. The people there seem to know what will happen before it happens, and there is a secret that no one is willing to share. Willow’s mom begins embracing the town but Willow just wishes to go back to her normal life.
Filled with mystery, character building, and suspense, this book is unique and captivating in its tale. Willow grows the most as a character and has to come to terms with what she wants for her life versus what her family wants.
I loved the mystery of it and discovery the magical element to the town pushed the story forward! I recommend this book for fantasy and mystery lovers! Best for 3rd grade and up! @randomhouse
____
The Root of magic by Kathleen Benner Duble is a book about discovering who you truly want to be even in the face of rejection.
Willow is a strong, caring character who finds herself feeling alone due to her brother’s illness. Her brother, Wisp, has taken over their mom’s attention due to medical conditions that cannot be explained. In a trip, Willow and her family find themselves stranded in an odd town. The people there seem to know what will happen before it happens, and there is a secret that no one is willing to share. Willow’s mom begins embracing the town but Willow just wishes to go back to her normal life.
Filled with mystery, character building, and suspense, this book is unique and captivating in its tale. Willow grows the most as a character and has to come to terms with what she wants for her life versus what her family wants.
I loved the mystery of it and discovery the magical element to the town pushed the story forward! I recommend this book for fantasy and mystery lovers! Best for 3rd grade and up! @randomhouse
March 11, 2019
The Root of Magic
by Kathleen Benner Duble
A young adult book with a different spin. A young girl, her brother and mother are lost in a snow storm after her winning hockey game. It is where they find themselves that is remarkable. A small town, but not an ordinary small town. The people seem to be mind readers, able to predict things before they occur. Like the tow truck driver and his wife that pull them out of their car before it goes over the bridge causing their death. It is the root of magic that may be the source of power in this town. But the question is being able to know your future is it worth the cost.
It’s a great book about noticing the details, and understanding the human spirit. A book for young readers to understand the magic in the world.
January 3, 2020
Willow's family has fractured due to difficulties in handling her younger brother's diagnosed illness. Willow feels caught in the middle as she is navigating the new family rules. On their way back from a hockey tournament, Willow, her mother, and brother are involved in a car accident. They lose their phones and belongings in the river. They are found and brought to the town of Kismet, ME. The residents there are very helpful but a little different. There is no mail, only one phone in the town, and no one ever seems to leave. Willow must figure out what secrets Kismet is hiding and figure out how they will effect her life. This title deals with family difficulties, and the definitions of fate and free will. It would be a solid addition to most public libraries.
July 12, 2019
Would you want to know what each day would bring before it happened? This is the question Willow must answer when a terrifying accident brings her and her family to Kismet, Maine.
The Root of Magic is a story filled with the wonders of magic, love, and acceptance of yourself and others.
Appropriate for children of ages 8 - 12. There is no foul language and no sex (a first kiss only). It would make a great read-aloud for families. Discussions will abound.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher, Random House Children's Publishing, through NetGalley. Any and all opinions expressed in the above review are entirely my own.
The Root of Magic is a story filled with the wonders of magic, love, and acceptance of yourself and others.
Appropriate for children of ages 8 - 12. There is no foul language and no sex (a first kiss only). It would make a great read-aloud for families. Discussions will abound.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher, Random House Children's Publishing, through NetGalley. Any and all opinions expressed in the above review are entirely my own.
Read
July 25, 2019As a medically trained adult, the deadly, undiagnosable illness as a plot contrivance drives me bonkers. As a kid, I would've eaten it up. So setting that aside, this was a suspenseful present-tense read featuring a fierce little girl caught in the middle of one terrible problem, followed by another and then another. The dreamy, otherworldly setting is quite believable and the main characters are interesting. Young readers who like magic and thinking about fate vs. free will will love this book.
October 4, 2019
Willow's little brother is sick with an unexplained illness, her mother is perpetually worried about him, and her father is checked out with fear. When Willow, her brother, and mother are stranded in a small Maine town during a snow storm, she realizes there is magic that lures people in and doesn't allow them to leave, but she must fight for her freedom of choice. This novel is creepy, twisted, and surreal with great reveals and a snowy setting. Willow makes some tough choices, and readers will feel for her whole family. A cool concept in this middle grade novel.
October 21, 2019
My daughter recommended that I read this and so I did. It is a great little, self-contained story with a powerful and satisfying conclusion. The themes are straightforward, but well done. The magic was a little fuzzy in its rules, but concrete enough to enable the story to resolve. The characters were deep enough (although I think the dad's arc could have used some more details), but nothing over the top. Of course, this is a children's book, so all of the above are enough for a good, enjoyable, quick read.
March 3, 2023
A great fantasy book for 5th-8th graders. I'm an educator and this is the second year I've read this book with a small group of on-level and/or above-level 5th graders.
They really enjoyed it and it was a great opportunity to introduce them to some philosophical questions about fate and free choice. It is also a great book to use to help them practice with making predictions. They had some really interesting theories as to what was causing the mysterious happenings in Kismet.
I, as a grown-up who loves the fantasy genre, also enjoyed this book.
They really enjoyed it and it was a great opportunity to introduce them to some philosophical questions about fate and free choice. It is also a great book to use to help them practice with making predictions. They had some really interesting theories as to what was causing the mysterious happenings in Kismet.
I, as a grown-up who loves the fantasy genre, also enjoyed this book.
July 19, 2019
This seemed like it might have been my type of book, but not exactly. I think , though, kids 5th grade to maybe 7th will enjoy it. As an adult I found it a bit of a stretch in some ways. I liked the characters; most seemed true to life, especially Willow and her family. I've seen families torn apart by a child's illness. Not a bad read really for it's marketed age group.
I received a Kindle arc from Netgalley in exchange for a fair review.
I received a Kindle arc from Netgalley in exchange for a fair review.
August 15, 2019
This book gave off Jacob Two Two vibes, though it was quite a bit more magical feeling.
It was very cute, magical, and even thrilling at times. It really explores the meaning of pain and joy, fate and charge, family and friends, in a way that I think would be easy for kids to digest.
It was very cute, magical, and even thrilling at times. It really explores the meaning of pain and joy, fate and charge, family and friends, in a way that I think would be easy for kids to digest.
March 16, 2019
Preductible but would have enjoyed as a kid/pre-teen
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews