I really don't like to beat up on art. It's difficult to create. But this one was nominated for the highest award in horror, the Bram Stoker Award, and it's received many positive reviews with superlative compliments.
Plainly, I think this book is stupid. I don't know how else to say it. To me, it was just silly. Largely, this is because the main character, Andi, is given very little background. And her personality is underexplored. The entire story is told from her point of view. OK, but the problem is that her point of view sounds like a high school freshman who spent too much time on /r/NoSleep, jacked up on Mountain Dew and Creepy Pastas.
SPOILERS: Here's the plot. A young woman, Andi, breaks up a marriage, and she starts a relationship with the woman from that marriage, Luna. She then creeps out her girlfriend, and her girlfriend tries to help her get therapy and treatment for her traumatic past. Andi, though, starts to fantasize about becoming a vulture and eating dead things. She starts to think extra spooky, scary, tWisTED thoughts about what things would be like dead and devoured by her. This escalates whenever she breaks into her neighbor farmer's barn and steals a piglet, which she kills and eats raw. She does this again. And then she kills the farmer. Andi's girlfriend's ex-husband becomes worried about not seeing Luna around, so he checks at Andi's house. Andi eventually takes him to a spot in the wilderness, where it's revealed that her therapist is actually a field-dressed deer (Dr. FAWNing, get it?) and Luna, the girlfriend, has been bled and assaulted but is still alive. The divorced couple escapes.
Honestly, the plot is pretty good. It's just the execution that's bad. Andi's traumatic life is hinted at, but it's not really explored. There could've been so much more done with this. What ends up happening as a result is that the reader doesn't sympathize at all with the main character. So, for me, it was a struggle to finish even this short novella. So much of the character building was Andi going on these weird tangents in an angsty way, a sorta horror Holden Caufield thinking about how phony the world is and how much she wants to eat dead things.
I know a lot of reviewers found the prose beautiful, but I didn't. I found it overwrought. For me, the best poetry doesn't just use big words. Tantlinger has a solid vocabulary, after all. Poetry also commands its imagery and metaphors intentionally, not just protractedly. Poetry also has at its core some insight, some way of mystifying the mundane or awakening something in us. Poetry has substance just as much as style. And there's no substance to this story, largely because the characters are underdeveloped and the plot aims at shock.
Is the story a comment on mental illness? No, not really. Andi is just crazy, but her trauma or diagnosis isn't explored. Nor is the idea that it's tough to have a mental illness in North America or in relationships.
Is the story a comment on stifling heteronormativity, since Andi is a gay and Luna is bi? No, not really. Andi is actually a horrible girlfriend, and the ex-husband seems like a decent guy. (Also, something that irked me is that Andi was mad at her neighbor for calling Luna "Princess Jasmine" but Andi referred to Luna by racialized traits, such as calling Luna her tiger. I don't like Andi, so it worked to reinforce that. So, maybe there's a comment on hypocrisy here?)
Is the story groundbreaking in its transgressiveness? Hardly. It's been 200 years since de Sade wrote *120 Days of Sodom*, which takes the cake when it comes to depravity. If we go for more queer authors with gore, it's been over 30 years since Clive Barker experimented with BDSM, violence, and queerness. The author isn't breaking any new ground given the history of horror, extreme horror, and transgressive literature. I mean, the first chapter starts with Andi giving a gift of bug wings sewn together to Luna and Luna being creeped out. Toward the middle of the book, Andi bullies Luna into sex when Luna is on her period, and Andi goes down on her, and Luna freaks out when Andi enjoys the blood. I mean, if the best you have, as a transgressive writer, is bugs and period sex, there's a lot left to be desired.
So what is this story doing? I honestly have no clue.
The story's cute, I guess. And it's adept, in the sense that the curveball about the therapist was unexpected and well done. And I'm glad that Luna survived. But the whole story just felt forced and cringeworthy. Whatever. Maybe we all either die based or live long enough to become cringe. And given that I'm approaching middle age, maybe I should just embrace the cringe like this story did. Maybe I should listen to my gurgling stomach and find something to be devoured ...